Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:math-ph/0602011

Alternative linear structures associated with regular Lagrangians. Weyl quantization and the Von Neumann uniqueness theorem

Elisa Ercolessi, Alberto Ibort, Giuseppe Marmo, G. Morandi

Published Feb 3, 2006• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We discuss how the existence of a regular Lagrangian description on the tangent bundle $TQ$ of some configuration space $Q$ allows for the construction of a linear structure on $TQ$ that can be considered as "adapted" to the given dynamical system. The fact then that many dynamical systems admit alternative Lagrangian descriptions opens the possibility to use the Weyl scheme to quantize the system in different non equivalent ways, "evading", so to speak, the von Neumann uniqueness theorem.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.math-ph/0602011

Related papers

Quantization Methods

The tremendous experimental success of Quantum Mechanics (QM) makes it a cornerstone of our present knowledge of the physical world. The basic paradigm of QM is here revised. We will first introduce the notion of Hilbert space of states and then we discuss the standard procedure to quantize a dynamical system owing to the classical to quantum correspondence (Poisson brackets vs. commutators). We will discuss the dynamics in both the Schrödinger and Heisenberg representations and we provide the tools to realize semiclassical states. Then, we present the generalization of the canonical quantization procedure by introducing Weyl algebra and GNS construction. The former can be seen as the “exponentiated” version of the commutation relations, while the latter allows to construct the Hilbert space directly from the algebra. Under some hypotheses it is possible to probe how the GNS construction applied to the Weyl algebra leads to the Schrödinger representation (Stone-Von Neumann theorem). However, if some of these hypotheses are relaxed, one finds new inequivalent quantum representations of the Weyl algebra. We will discuss one of this new representations, namely the polymer representation, which has the property to set up naturally a minimum length scale. Finally we will return back to the canonical quantization procedure and we will outline the issues one encounters when quantizing some relevant constrained physical systems.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jun 3, 2014•0 citations

The Basic Formalism of Field Theory

A.N. Vasiliev

The classical system is usually quantized using the canonical formalism, i.e., in the language of coordinates and momenta. In addition to this “purely algebraic” ambiguity, there is also an ambiguity in the choice of realization of the operators p^ and q^: the commutation relations do not determine it uniquely, but up to a unitary equivalence (the well known uniqueness theorem of von Neumann pertains only to the Weyl form of the commutation relations). The realization must be chosen on the basis of additional considerations regarding the nature of the canonical variables p and q. In this book the term “theory” is used in various ways: in a broad sense (quantum field theory, relativistic theory) and in a narrow sense, to refer to a particular system or class of systems with certain dynamics. In quantum theory there are also systems whose operators corresponding to canonical variables satisfy not commutation relations, but anticommutation relations.

Routledge eBooks•Jan 22, 2019•0 citations

QUANTUM GROUPS AND VON NEUMANN THEOREM

Alfredo Iorio, Giuseppe Vitiello

We discuss the q-deformation of Weyl-Heisenberg algebra in connection with the von Neumann theorem in quantum mechanics. We show that the q-deformation parameter labels the Weyl systems in quantum mechanics and the unitarily inequivalent representations of the canonical commutation relations in quantum field theory.

arXiv:math-ph/0009035•Modern Physics Letters B•Feb 20, 1994•17 citations

A quantum route to the classical Lagrangian formalism

Florio M. Ciaglia, Fabio Di Cosmo, Alberto Ibort +3 more

Using the recently developed groupoidal description of Schwinger’s picture of Quantum Mechanics, a new approach to Dirac’s fundamental question on the role of the Lagrangian in Quantum Mechanics is provided. It is shown that a function [Formula: see text] on the groupoid of configurations (or kinematical groupoid) of a quantum system determines a state on the von Neumann algebra of the histories of the system. This function, which we call q-Lagrangian, can be described in terms of a new function [Formula: see text] on the Lie algebroid of the theory. When the kinematical groupoid is the pair groupoid of a smooth manifold M, the quadratic expansion of [Formula: see text] will reproduce the standard Lagrangians on TM used to describe the classical dynamics of particles.

arXiv:2106.00998•Modern Physics Letters A•Apr 30, 2021•9 citations

Finite-Resolution Limits on Quantum Uniqueness

Seramika Ariwahjoedi, Sameer Ahmad Mir, Mir Faizal

The Stone-von Neumann theorem makes canonical quantization unique only after one imposes strong continuity of the Weyl translation groups. We show that this continuity assumption cannot be certified by any finite-resolution interrogation of the Weyl relations. A finite protocol probes only finitely many phase-space displacements and bounded expectation values, thereby determining a protocol algebra \(C_S\) generated by a finitely generated subgroup of Weyl translations, but not the regularity of an extension to the full Weyl algebra. Using the polymer representation as a canonical non-regular representation, we prove that for every regular Weyl representation, every normal state, and every finite family of bounded protocol observables, a polymer state reproduces the same expectation values to arbitrary prescribed accuracy. Thus finite agreement with Schrödinger quantum mechanics does not operationally certify the regularity hypothesis entering uniqueness. The result does not assert physical equivalence between regular and polymer quantizations, it identifies where additional input, such as Hamiltonian dynamics, energy regularity, semiclassicality, or a continuum limit, is required to distinguish or select representations. In this precise sense, non-regular polymer kinematics are not excluded by finite Weyl data alone, a point of direct relevance to quantum-gravity motivated quantizations.

quant-pharXiv:2608.22001•Physics Letters B•Aug 25, 2026•0 citations

Lagrangian description of Heisenberg and Landau–von Neumann equations of motion

Florio M. Ciaglia, Fabio Di Cosmo, Alberto Ibort +3 more

An explicit Lagrangian description is given for the Heisenberg equation on the algebra of operators of a quantum system, and for the Landau–von Neumann equation on the manifold of quantum states which are isospectral with respect to a fixed reference quantum state.

arXiv:2005.01876•Modern Physics Letters A•Apr 27, 2020•3 citations
We discuss how the existence of a regular Lagrangian description on the tangent bundle TQTQTQ of some configuration space QQQ allows for the construction of a linear structure on TQTQTQ that can be considered as "adapted" to the given dynamical system. The fact then that many dynamical systems admit alternative Lagrangian descriptions opens the possibility to use the Weyl scheme to quantize the system in different non equivalent ways, "evading", so to speak, the von Neumann uniqueness theorem.
The tremendous experimental success of Quantum Mechanics (QM) makes it a cornerstone of our present knowledge of the physical world. The basic paradigm of QM is here revised. We will first introduce the notion of Hilbert space of states and then we discuss the standard procedure to quantize a dynamical system owing to the classical to quantum correspondence (Poisson brackets vs. commutators). We will discuss the dynamics in both the Schrödinger and Heisenberg representations and we provide the tools to realize semiclassical states. Then, we present the generalization of the canonical quantization procedure by introducing Weyl algebra and GNS construction. The former can be seen as the “exponentiated” version of the commutation relations, while the latter allows to construct the Hilbert space directly from the algebra. Under some hypotheses it is possible to probe how the GNS construction applied to the Weyl algebra leads to the Schrödinger representation (Stone-Von Neumann theorem). However, if some of these hypotheses are relaxed, one finds new inequivalent quantum representations of the Weyl algebra. We will discuss one of this new representations, namely the polymer representation, which has the property to set up naturally a minimum length scale. Finally we will return back to the canonical quantization procedure and we will outline the issues one encounters when quantizing some relevant constrained physical systems.
The classical system is usually quantized using the canonical formalism, i.e., in the language of coordinates and momenta. In addition to this “purely algebraic” ambiguity, there is also an ambiguity in the choice of realization of the operators p^ and q^: the commutation relations do not determine it uniquely, but up to a unitary equivalence (the well known uniqueness theorem of von Neumann pertains only to the Weyl form of the commutation relations). The realization must be chosen on the basis of additional considerations regarding the nature of the canonical variables p and q. In this book the term “theory” is used in various ways: in a broad sense (quantum field theory, relativistic theory) and in a narrow sense, to refer to a particular system or class of systems with certain dynamics. In quantum theory there are also systems whose operators corresponding to canonical variables satisfy not commutation relations, but anticommutation relations.
Using the recently developed groupoidal description of Schwinger’s picture of Quantum Mechanics, a new approach to Dirac’s fundamental question on the role of the Lagrangian in Quantum Mechanics is provided. It is shown that a function [Formula: see text] on the groupoid of configurations (or kinematical groupoid) of a quantum system determines a state on the von Neumann algebra of the histories of the system. This function, which we call q-Lagrangian, can be described in terms of a new function [Formula: see text] on the Lie algebroid of the theory. When the kinematical groupoid is the pair groupoid of a smooth manifold M, the quadratic expansion of [Formula: see text] will reproduce the standard Lagrangians on TM used to describe the classical dynamics of particles.
The Stone-von Neumann theorem makes canonical quantization unique only after one imposes strong continuity of the Weyl translation groups. We show that this continuity assumption cannot be certified by any finite-resolution interrogation of the Weyl relations. A finite protocol probes only finitely many phase-space displacements and bounded expectation values, thereby determining a protocol algebra CSC_SCS​ generated by a finitely generated subgroup of Weyl translations, but not the regularity of an extension to the full Weyl algebra. Using the polymer representation as a canonical non-regular representation, we prove that for every regular Weyl representation, every normal state, and every finite family of bounded protocol observables, a polymer state reproduces the same expectation values to arbitrary prescribed accuracy. Thus finite agreement with Schrödinger quantum mechanics does not operationally certify the regularity hypothesis entering uniqueness. The result does not assert physical equivalence between regular and polymer quantizations, it identifies where additional input, such as Hamiltonian dynamics, energy regularity, semiclassicality, or a continuum limit, is required to distinguish or select representations. In this precise sense, non-regular polymer kinematics are not excluded by finite Weyl data alone, a point of direct relevance to quantum-gravity motivated quantizations.