Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:math-ph/0007002

Is Schroedinger equation consistent with information theory?

Venkataraman, R. P.

Published Jul 3, 2000• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is shown that Schroedinger equation is not consistent with information theory. From the modified form of information which ensures that the most probable density function it yields tallies with a general form of continuous Riemann integrable density function that has real or imaginary zeros or singularities at end points of $[a,b] εR$, a new variational formulation for quantum mechanics is proposed that yields a system of Euler-Lagrange equations that are non-linear. It is proved that the solutions of this system are unique, orthonormal and complete. One dimensional harmonic oscillator has been solved.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.math-ph/0007002

Related papers

Discrete-to-Continuum Limit of Causal Chains in the Kähler Reconstruction

Jean-François Rigollet

Discrete-to-Continuum Limit of Causal Chains in the Kähler Reconstruction Previous paper (Causal Reconstruction: Elementary Succession and the Planck Energy) proposed that the Schrödinger equation should arise as the continuum limit of discrete causal chains. Article 18 establishes this result under explicit regularity assumptions, completing the bridge between elementary causal succession and continuous quantum dynamics. Purpose The reconstruction programme contains two distinct transitions: Discrete causal chain → continuum reconstructive action → Madelung–Schrödinger dynamics. The second step was already established in Article 5. The purpose of this paper is to prove the first step: that discrete causal chains converge to the continuous reconstructive action in a mathematically controlled way. Main Idea The reconstructive cost between two states is interpreted as a discrete Lagrangian in the sense of variational integrator theory. A causal chain therefore becomes a discrete variational system whose dynamics is governed by discrete Euler–Lagrange equations. The key observation is that the discrete action SN = Σ C(ρk,ρk+1) plays exactly the role of a discrete Lagrangian approximation of the reconstructive action Srec. Main Results Discrete Lagrangian formulation. The reconstructive cost is shown to define a discrete Lagrangian under suitable regularity conditions. Discrete Euler–Lagrange equations. Critical causal chains satisfy discrete Euler–Lagrange equations expressing momentum continuity across each causal node. Γ-convergence. The discrete action SN Γ-converges to the continuous reconstructive action Srec as the elementary action quantum tends to zero while total duration remains fixed. Convergence of solutions. Solutions of the discrete causal-chain equations converge to solutions of the continuous Madelung equations. Preservation of Kähler structure. The discrete symplectic structure converges to the canonical Kähler symplectic form of the reconstruction phase space. Recovery of Schrödinger dynamics. Combining the present result with Article 5 yields a complete chain from discrete causal succession to the Schrödinger equation. Regularity Analysis A significant contribution of the paper is the analysis of the Fisher information functional in alternative coordinates. In the density variable ρ, Fisher information becomes singular as ρ approaches zero. In the amplitude variable u = √ρ, Fisher information becomes exactly a Dirichlet energy: I(ρ) = 4||∇u||². In the wavefunction variable ψ = √ρ exp(iS/ℏ), the reconstructive action becomes smooth on the natural Hilbert space H¹(M,C). This shows that the apparent singularities of Fisher information are coordinate artefacts rather than genuine obstructions. The Three Operative Conditions The continuum limit ultimately depends on three explicit conditions: C1 — Tightness: minimising sequences remain precompact. C2 — Small-step regime: elementary causal transitions remain inside the injectivity radius. C3 — Non-degeneracy: the second variation of the reconstructive action remains positive, excluding conjugate points and ensuring local uniqueness. Condition C2 becomes automatic in the continuum limit. Conditions C1 and C3 remain the principal analytical assumptions. Conceptual Significance The paper transforms the causal-chain picture from a heuristic interpretation into a variational approximation theorem. Discrete causal succession is no longer merely compatible with quantum dynamics; it converges to it. In this view, a quantum trajectory is not a fundamental continuous object. It is the continuum limit of a chain of elementary reconstructive transitions, each carrying one action quantum. Conclusion This paper completes the mathematical bridge between the causal layer and the quantum layer of the reconstruction programme. Under explicit regularity assumptions, discrete causal chains converge to the reconstructive action, the reconstructive action yields the Madelung equations, and the Madelung formulation is equivalent to Schrödinger dynamics. The resulting picture is a fully variational route from elementary causal succession to quantum mechanics.

•Jun 16, 2026•0 citations

Why is Quantum Mechanics Sometimes Formulated in Terms of Fisher Information?

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In (1) the Schrodinger equation is derived using the extremization of Fisher information in a certain way formulated in (2) i.e. Extreme Physical Information. Fisher information, however, is defined in terms of P(x) which in quantum mechanics is W*(x)W(x) where W(x) is the wavefunction. As a result, the Schrodinger equation is derived in terms of P(x) and then the mathematical substitution P(x)=W(x)W(x) for a bound state “simplifies” the form of the equation. Otherwise there would be no need to introduce the wavefunction. Furthermore P(x) = constant for a quantum free particle which is also a solution of the Schrodinger equation. For P(x)=constant, however, one would normally not consider using the Fisher information. We further note that in a physical example, namely that of the reflection/refraction of light from an interface of media one is forced to introduce the concept of a wavefunction i.e. the square root of flux, otherwise the problem cannot be solved. Thus in this situation one does not solve the problem in terms of P(x) and then introduce W(x) to simplify the form. In particular, if one considers a single photon moving to the right, it either reflects or refracts (with probability), but the ensuing equations involve the weight of the square root fluxes (wavefunctions) of all three. How can this be unless there is uncertainty in time and space which allows one to have all three together? Thus the reflection/refraction problem depends on square root probability or flux and introduces the idea of uncertainty in x, t. Given the translational invariance in the problem, it is natural to introduce the translation operator d/dx. In fact, one may define the uncertainty in x such that one has an eigenfunction of -id/dx i.e. exp(ipx). This is complex and so its modulus respects P(x)=constant which would yield a Fisher’s information of 0, meaning that there is no probability and hence no need for Fisher’s information. There is, however, probability in x, but a different level than the deterministic x=vt where v=constant. Thus we argue that one may obtain exp(ipx) strictly from the notion of translational invariance. In other words, Fisher information is not required to find this form and the quantum physics associated with it. Nevertheless Fisher information and EPI (Extreme physical Information) may be used to derive the Schrodinger equation (applied to a bound state) and one may deduce exp(ipx) from this. We note, however, that Fisher information makes use of d/dx which is the translational generator and so the idea of translational invariance and Fisher’s information/EPI may be linked.

•Mar 3, 2023•0 citations

Schrödinger's equation as a diffusion equation

Katsunori Mita

Schrödinger's equation can be considered as a diffusion equation with a diffusion coefficient β2=ℏ/2m. In this article, we explore the implications of this view. Rewriting the wave function in a polar form and transforming Schrödinger's equation into two real equations, we show that one of them reduces to the continuity equation, and the other, a nonlinear dynamical equation for the probability density. Considering these two equations as if they were the basic equations of quantum mechanics, we apply them to several one-dimensional quantum systems. We show the dispersive properties in the probability densities of stationary states of a particle in a rigid box and in harmonic potential; quasi-classical Gaussian probability densities of a free particle; and coherent states and squeezed states of the harmonic oscillator. We also present the soliton as a quantum mechanical representation of a free particle. We discuss the meaning of the diffusion coefficient β2 for each quantum system using a density plot.

American Journal of Physics•Apr 21, 2021•26 citations

A regularisation method to obtain analytical solutions to the de Broglie Bohm wave equation

Anand Aruna Kumar, S. K. Srivatsa, Rajesh Tengli

We develop a variational regularisation framework that enables analytical solutions of the stationary de~Broglie--Bohm wave equation. The formulation begins with a Fisher-information-augmented action functional for the probability density and phase fields, yielding the Madelung (Hamilton--Jacobi and continuity) equations and, upon complex recombination, a Schrödinger-type equation with a parametric information coupling $μ$. Beyond this density-based formulation, we introduce a variational regularisation scheme for the de~Broglie--Bohm equations that combines a global Fisher-information regularisation at the level of the action functional with a shell-level regularisation arising from stationary flux closure. This reduction isolates the regularisation mechanism in the spatial momentum flow and yields constrained Euler--Lagrange equations governing admissible amplitude configurations. The resulting first integral possesses an elliptic structure whose admissible asymptotic branch enforces a universal canonical relation $p(x)x \to μ/2$ near amplitude zeros. The framework yields closed-form analytical solutions for standard potentials and reveals a systematic inverse-square regularising term in the effective potential. The associated elliptic discriminant defines a geometric length scale that, for $μ=\hbar$, naturally reduces to the reduced Compton wavelength. Canonical Bohmian regularisation therefore appears as a variational admissibility condition on density dynamics, producing structurally stable analytical branches and modified yet consistent energy spectra within stationary dBB mechanics.

quant-pharXiv:2512.18555•Dec 23, 2025•0 citations

Variational Information Principles to Unveil Physical Laws

David Bernal‐Casas, Josep Maria Oller

This article demonstrates that the application of the variation method to purely information-theoretic models can lead to the discovery of fundamental equations in physics, such as Schrödinger’s equation. Our solution, expressed in terms of information parameters rather than physical quantities, suggests a profound implication—Schrödinger’s equation can be viewed as a unique physical expression of a more profound informational formalism, inspiring new avenues of research.

Mathematics•Dec 14, 2024•8 citations

On the quantization of a theory arising from a variational principle for multiple integrals with application to born's electrodynamics

P. Weiss

Abstract The transition from classical mechanics to quantum mechanics has been formulated in various ways. But all these ways have the common feature that they use as starting point mechanics not in its Newtonian form, but in the form which it was given by Lagrange and Hamilton. The essence of this form consists in the fact that the differential equations are represented as Euler equations of a variational principle for v functions, the generalized coordinates, of one variable, the time. In its purely mathematical aspect the quantization method may, therefore, be regarded as a mode of taking certain notions and certain relations arising from a variational principle for several dependent and one independent variable and of giving them a new meaning.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences•Aug 1, 1936•20 citations
It is shown that Schroedinger equation is not consistent with information theory. From the modified form of information which ensures that the most probable density function it yields tallies with a general form of continuous Riemann integrable density function that has real or imaginary zeros or singularities at end points of [a,b]εR[a,b] εR[a,b]εR, a new variational formulation for quantum mechanics is proposed that yields a system of Euler-Lagrange equations that are non-linear. It is proved that the solutions of this system are unique, orthonormal and complete. One dimensional harmonic oscillator has been solved.
Discrete-to-Continuum Limit of Causal Chains in the Kähler Reconstruction Previous paper (Causal Reconstruction: Elementary Succession and the Planck Energy) proposed that the Schrödinger equation should arise as the continuum limit of discrete causal chains. Article 18 establishes this result under explicit regularity assumptions, completing the bridge between elementary causal succession and continuous quantum dynamics. Purpose The reconstruction programme contains two distinct transitions: Discrete causal chain → continuum reconstructive action → Madelung–Schrödinger dynamics. The second step was already established in Article 5. The purpose of this paper is to prove the first step: that discrete causal chains converge to the continuous reconstructive action in a mathematically controlled way. Main Idea The reconstructive cost between two states is interpreted as a discrete Lagrangian in the sense of variational integrator theory. A causal chain therefore becomes a discrete variational system whose dynamics is governed by discrete Euler–Lagrange equations. The key observation is that the discrete action SN = Σ C(ρk,ρk+1) plays exactly the role of a discrete Lagrangian approximation of the reconstructive action Srec. Main Results Discrete Lagrangian formulation. The reconstructive cost is shown to define a discrete Lagrangian under suitable regularity conditions. Discrete Euler–Lagrange equations. Critical causal chains satisfy discrete Euler–Lagrange equations expressing momentum continuity across each causal node. Γ-convergence. The discrete action SN Γ-converges to the continuous reconstructive action Srec as the elementary action quantum tends to zero while total duration remains fixed. Convergence of solutions. Solutions of the discrete causal-chain equations converge to solutions of the continuous Madelung equations. Preservation of Kähler structure. The discrete symplectic structure converges to the canonical Kähler symplectic form of the reconstruction phase space. Recovery of Schrödinger dynamics. Combining the present result with Article 5 yields a complete chain from discrete causal succession to the Schrödinger equation. Regularity Analysis A significant contribution of the paper is the analysis of the Fisher information functional in alternative coordinates. In the density variable ρ, Fisher information becomes singular as ρ approaches zero. In the amplitude variable u = √ρ, Fisher information becomes exactly a Dirichlet energy: I(ρ) = 4||∇u||². In the wavefunction variable ψ = √ρ exp(iS/ℏ), the reconstructive action becomes smooth on the natural Hilbert space H¹(M,C). This shows that the apparent singularities of Fisher information are coordinate artefacts rather than genuine obstructions. The Three Operative Conditions The continuum limit ultimately depends on three explicit conditions: C1 — Tightness: minimising sequences remain precompact. C2 — Small-step regime: elementary causal transitions remain inside the injectivity radius. C3 — Non-degeneracy: the second variation of the reconstructive action remains positive, excluding conjugate points and ensuring local uniqueness. Condition C2 becomes automatic in the continuum limit. Conditions C1 and C3 remain the principal analytical assumptions. Conceptual Significance The paper transforms the causal-chain picture from a heuristic interpretation into a variational approximation theorem. Discrete causal succession is no longer merely compatible with quantum dynamics; it converges to it. In this view, a quantum trajectory is not a fundamental continuous object. It is the continuum limit of a chain of elementary reconstructive transitions, each carrying one action quantum. Conclusion This paper completes the mathematical bridge between the causal layer and the quantum layer of the reconstruction programme. Under explicit regularity assumptions, discrete causal chains converge to the reconstructive action, the reconstructive action yields the Madelung equations, and the Madelung formulation is equivalent to Schrödinger dynamics. The resulting picture is a fully variational route from elementary causal succession to quantum mechanics.
In (1) the Schrodinger equation is derived using the extremization of Fisher information in a certain way formulated in (2) i.e. Extreme Physical Information. Fisher information, however, is defined in terms of P(x) which in quantum mechanics is W*(x)W(x) where W(x) is the wavefunction. As a result, the Schrodinger equation is derived in terms of P(x) and then the mathematical substitution P(x)=W(x)W(x) for a bound state “simplifies” the form of the equation. Otherwise there would be no need to introduce the wavefunction. Furthermore P(x) = constant for a quantum free particle which is also a solution of the Schrodinger equation. For P(x)=constant, however, one would normally not consider using the Fisher information. We further note that in a physical example, namely that of the reflection/refraction of light from an interface of media one is forced to introduce the concept of a wavefunction i.e. the square root of flux, otherwise the problem cannot be solved. Thus in this situation one does not solve the problem in terms of P(x) and then introduce W(x) to simplify the form. In particular, if one considers a single photon moving to the right, it either reflects or refracts (with probability), but the ensuing equations involve the weight of the square root fluxes (wavefunctions) of all three. How can this be unless there is uncertainty in time and space which allows one to have all three together? Thus the reflection/refraction problem depends on square root probability or flux and introduces the idea of uncertainty in x, t. Given the translational invariance in the problem, it is natural to introduce the translation operator d/dx. In fact, one may define the uncertainty in x such that one has an eigenfunction of -id/dx i.e. exp(ipx). This is complex and so its modulus respects P(x)=constant which would yield a Fisher’s information of 0, meaning that there is no probability and hence no need for Fisher’s information. There is, however, probability in x, but a different level than the deterministic x=vt where v=constant. Thus we argue that one may obtain exp(ipx) strictly from the notion of translational invariance. In other words, Fisher information is not required to find this form and the quantum physics associated with it. Nevertheless Fisher information and EPI (Extreme physical Information) may be used to derive the Schrodinger equation (applied to a bound state) and one may deduce exp(ipx) from this. We note, however, that Fisher information makes use of d/dx which is the translational generator and so the idea of translational invariance and Fisher’s information/EPI may be linked.
Schrödinger's equation can be considered as a diffusion equation with a diffusion coefficient β2=ℏ/2m. In this article, we explore the implications of this view. Rewriting the wave function in a polar form and transforming Schrödinger's equation into two real equations, we show that one of them reduces to the continuity equation, and the other, a nonlinear dynamical equation for the probability density. Considering these two equations as if they were the basic equations of quantum mechanics, we apply them to several one-dimensional quantum systems. We show the dispersive properties in the probability densities of stationary states of a particle in a rigid box and in harmonic potential; quasi-classical Gaussian probability densities of a free particle; and coherent states and squeezed states of the harmonic oscillator. We also present the soliton as a quantum mechanical representation of a free particle. We discuss the meaning of the diffusion coefficient β2 for each quantum system using a density plot.
We develop a variational regularisation framework that enables analytical solutions of the stationary de~Broglie--Bohm wave equation. The formulation begins with a Fisher-information-augmented action functional for the probability density and phase fields, yielding the Madelung (Hamilton--Jacobi and continuity) equations and, upon complex recombination, a Schrödinger-type equation with a parametric information coupling μμμ. Beyond this density-based formulation, we introduce a variational regularisation scheme for the de~Broglie--Bohm equations that combines a global Fisher-information regularisation at the level of the action functional with a shell-level regularisation arising from stationary flux closure. This reduction isolates the regularisation mechanism in the spatial momentum flow and yields constrained Euler--Lagrange equations governing admissible amplitude configurations. The resulting first integral possesses an elliptic structure whose admissible asymptotic branch enforces a universal canonical relation p(x)x→μ/2p(x)x \to μ/2p(x)x→μ/2 near amplitude zeros. The framework yields closed-form analytical solutions for standard potentials and reveals a systematic inverse-square regularising term in the effective potential. The associated elliptic discriminant defines a geometric length scale that, for μ=ℏμ=\hbarμ=ℏ, naturally reduces to the reduced Compton wavelength. Canonical Bohmian regularisation therefore appears as a variational admissibility condition on density dynamics, producing structurally stable analytical branches and modified yet consistent energy spectra within stationary dBB mechanics.
Abstract The transition from classical mechanics to quantum mechanics has been formulated in various ways. But all these ways have the common feature that they use as starting point mechanics not in its Newtonian form, but in the form which it was given by Lagrange and Hamilton. The essence of this form consists in the fact that the differential equations are represented as Euler equations of a variational principle for v functions, the generalized coordinates, of one variable, the time. In its purely mathematical aspect the quantization method may, therefore, be regarded as a mode of taking certain notions and certain relations arising from a variational principle for several dependent and one independent variable and of giving them a new meaning.