Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:hep-th/9509089 · Physical Review A

Absence of classical and quantum mixing

L. L. Salcedo

Published Oct 1, 1996• 54 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is shown, under mild assumptions, that classical degrees of freedom dynamically coupled to quantum ones do not inherit their quantum fluctuations. It is further shown that if the assumptions are strengthened by imposing the existence of a canonical structure, only purely classical or purely quantum dynamics is allowed. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.54.3657

Related papers

Impediments to mixing classical and quantum dynamics

José Caro, L. L. Salcedo

The dynamics of systems composed of a classical sector plus a quantum sector is studied. We show that, even in the simplest cases, (i) the existence of a consistent canonical description for such mixed systems is incompatible with very basic requirements related to the time evolution of the two sectors when they are decoupled, (ii) the classical sector cannot inherit quantum fluctuations from the quantum sector, and (iii) a coupling among the two sectors is incompatible with the requirement of physical positivity of the theory, i.e., there would be positive observables with a nonpositive expectation value.

arXiv:quant-ph/9812046•Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1999•111 citations

Sampling the time evolution of mixed quantum-classical systems

Alessandro Sergi

Quantum mechanics is not logically closed with respect to the classical world.Its formalism unfolds as the quantization of a sub-set of classical Hamiltonians.The interpretation of quantum theory in terms of the measurement process inevitably requires to deal with systems composed by a mixture of both classical and quantum degrees of freedom.Moreover, when energy can flow between the quantum and classical degrees of freedom (i.e., in the case of nonadiabatic dynamics), there are more theoretical difficulties in order to obtain a fully consistent quantum-classical formalism.In order to perform calculations, one can renounce to the usual Lie algebraic structure of well-established physical theories, adopt non-Hamiltonian brackets, and obtain a formalism for the dynamics and statistics of quantum-classical systems that has an affordable computational complexity.Recent progress in the algorithms for the sampling of nonadiabatic dynamics of quantum-classical systems at long time is reviewed here.

Atti della Accademia Peloritana dei Pericolanti. Classe di Scienze Fisiche, Matematiche e Naturali/Atti della Accademia Peloritana dei Pericolanti, Classe di Scienze Fisiche, Matematiche e Naturali•May 1, 2011•1 citation

Quantum physical systems as classical systems

Antonio Cassa

A physical system showing a classical (deterministic) behavior to an observer can appear to be a quantum system to another observer unable to distinguish between some distinct states.

arXiv:quant-ph/0111070•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Nov 1, 2001•3 citations

Maximally non-Markovian quantum dynamics without environment-to-system backflow of information

Adrián A. Budini

The degree of non-Markovianity allows one to characterize quantum evolutions that depart from a Markovian regime in a similar way as the Schmidt number measures the degree of entanglement of pure states. Maximally non-Markovian dynamics are analogous to maximally entangled states [D. Chru\ifmmode \acute{s}\else \'{s}\fi{}ci\ifmmode \acute{n}\else \'{n}\fi{}ski and S. Maniscalco, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 120404 (2014)]. Here we demonstrate that there exists a class of maximally non-Markovian quantum evolutions where the associated environment (degrees of freedom not belonging to the system) obeys a Markovian (memoryless) dynamics, which in turn is unperturbed by the system state or dynamics. These properties imply the absence of any ``physical environment-to-system backflow of information.'' Non-Markovian features (as usual in quantum systems coupled to dissipative classical degrees of freedom) arise from a unidirectional dependence of the system dynamics on the reservoir states.

arXiv:1804.03305•Physical Review A•May 31, 2018•24 citations

How many degrees of freedom describe a quantum N-particle state?

Matthew J. Lake, Marek L. Miller

In Newtonian spacetime, the canonical description of a classical $N$-particle system requires $3N$ degrees of freedom. Not all of these are physical, however, since the conservation of the net momentum implies that only $3(N-1)$ accelerations are independent. Hence, three constraints can be used to eliminate the unphysical centre-of-mass variables, at the level of the Lagrangian, leaving only the subset of observable displacements and momenta, which are relational. Imposing the constraints does not change the dynamics of these variables, at the classical level, and is analogous to a gauge-fixing procedure, which removes redundancy in the description of the system. In classical physics, therefore, the number of physical degrees of freedom equals the number of independent relational degrees of freedom. Here, we show that this is not the case in quantum mechanics. While an operator-analogue of the classical net momentum exists, it cannot be used to impose constraints that restrict the degrees of freedom in the theory, without a loss of physical information. This means that all $3N$ canonical degrees of freedom are physical, even though only $3(N-1)$ of them are relational. We explore the physical consequences of the non-relational variables and show that they give rise to generalised uncertainty relations (GURs), for the relational quantities that define the quantum reference frame (QRF). Hence, it is shown that the non-relational degrees of freedom refer to the frame itself and that the non-Heisenberg terms in the GURs define its Galilean-invariant spreads, in both real space and momentum space. The implications of this result for recent work on relational models, including the ``perspective neutral'' framework for QRFs, are discussed. Its implications for the wider relational program, and, in particular, the relevance of the latter to quantum gravity research, are also critically assessed

quant-pharXiv:2607.16988•Jul 21, 2026•0 citations

Mixing quantum and classical mechanics

Oleg V. Prezhdo, Vladimir V. Kisil

Quantum-classical mixing is studied by a group-theoretical approach, and a quantum-classical equation of motion is derived. The quantum-classical bracket entering the equation preserves the Lie algebra structure of quantum and classical mechanics, and, therefore, leads to a natural description of interaction between quantum and classical degrees of freedom. The exact formalism is applied to coupled quantum and classical oscillators. Various approximations, such as the mean-field and the multiconfiguration mean-field approaches, which are of great utility in studying realistic multidimensional systems, are derived. Based on the formulation, a natural classification of the previously suggested quantum-classical equations of motion arises, and several problems from earlier works are resolved.

arXiv:quant-ph/9610016•Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1997•207 citations
It is shown, under mild assumptions, that classical degrees of freedom dynamically coupled to quantum ones do not inherit their quantum fluctuations. It is further shown that if the assumptions are strengthened by imposing the existence of a canonical structure, only purely classical or purely quantum dynamics is allowed. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
The dynamics of systems composed of a classical sector plus a quantum sector is studied. We show that, even in the simplest cases, (i) the existence of a consistent canonical description for such mixed systems is incompatible with very basic requirements related to the time evolution of the two sectors when they are decoupled, (ii) the classical sector cannot inherit quantum fluctuations from the quantum sector, and (iii) a coupling among the two sectors is incompatible with the requirement of physical positivity of the theory, i.e., there would be positive observables with a nonpositive expectation value.
Quantum mechanics is not logically closed with respect to the classical world.Its formalism unfolds as the quantization of a sub-set of classical Hamiltonians.The interpretation of quantum theory in terms of the measurement process inevitably requires to deal with systems composed by a mixture of both classical and quantum degrees of freedom.Moreover, when energy can flow between the quantum and classical degrees of freedom (i.e., in the case of nonadiabatic dynamics), there are more theoretical difficulties in order to obtain a fully consistent quantum-classical formalism.In order to perform calculations, one can renounce to the usual Lie algebraic structure of well-established physical theories, adopt non-Hamiltonian brackets, and obtain a formalism for the dynamics and statistics of quantum-classical systems that has an affordable computational complexity.Recent progress in the algorithms for the sampling of nonadiabatic dynamics of quantum-classical systems at long time is reviewed here.
The degree of non-Markovianity allows one to characterize quantum evolutions that depart from a Markovian regime in a similar way as the Schmidt number measures the degree of entanglement of pure states. Maximally non-Markovian dynamics are analogous to maximally entangled states [D. Chru\ifmmode \acute{s}\else \'{s}\fi{}ci\ifmmode \acute{n}\else \'{n}\fi{}ski and S. Maniscalco, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 120404 (2014)]. Here we demonstrate that there exists a class of maximally non-Markovian quantum evolutions where the associated environment (degrees of freedom not belonging to the system) obeys a Markovian (memoryless) dynamics, which in turn is unperturbed by the system state or dynamics. These properties imply the absence of any ``physical environment-to-system backflow of information.'' Non-Markovian features (as usual in quantum systems coupled to dissipative classical degrees of freedom) arise from a unidirectional dependence of the system dynamics on the reservoir states.
In Newtonian spacetime, the canonical description of a classical NNN-particle system requires 3N3N3N degrees of freedom. Not all of these are physical, however, since the conservation of the net momentum implies that only 3(N−1)3(N-1)3(N−1) accelerations are independent. Hence, three constraints can be used to eliminate the unphysical centre-of-mass variables, at the level of the Lagrangian, leaving only the subset of observable displacements and momenta, which are relational. Imposing the constraints does not change the dynamics of these variables, at the classical level, and is analogous to a gauge-fixing procedure, which removes redundancy in the description of the system. In classical physics, therefore, the number of physical degrees of freedom equals the number of independent relational degrees of freedom. Here, we show that this is not the case in quantum mechanics. While an operator-analogue of the classical net momentum exists, it cannot be used to impose constraints that restrict the degrees of freedom in the theory, without a loss of physical information. This means that all 3N3N3N canonical degrees of freedom are physical, even though only 3(N−1)3(N-1)3(N−1) of them are relational. We explore the physical consequences of the non-relational variables and show that they give rise to generalised uncertainty relations (GURs), for the relational quantities that define the quantum reference frame (QRF). Hence, it is shown that the non-relational degrees of freedom refer to the frame itself and that the non-Heisenberg terms in the GURs define its Galilean-invariant spreads, in both real space and momentum space. The implications of this result for recent work on relational models, including the ``perspective neutral'' framework for QRFs, are discussed. Its implications for the wider relational program, and, in particular, the relevance of the latter to quantum gravity research, are also critically assessed
Quantum-classical mixing is studied by a group-theoretical approach, and a quantum-classical equation of motion is derived. The quantum-classical bracket entering the equation preserves the Lie algebra structure of quantum and classical mechanics, and, therefore, leads to a natural description of interaction between quantum and classical degrees of freedom. The exact formalism is applied to coupled quantum and classical oscillators. Various approximations, such as the mean-field and the multiconfiguration mean-field approaches, which are of great utility in studying realistic multidimensional systems, are derived. Based on the formulation, a natural classification of the previously suggested quantum-classical equations of motion arises, and several problems from earlier works are resolved.