We provide a precise definition and analysis of quantum causal histories (QCHs). A QCH consists of a discrete, locally finite, causal pre-spacetime with matrix algebras encoding the quantum structure at each event. The evolution of quantum states and observables is described by completely positive maps between the algebras at causally related events. We show that this local description of evolution is sufficient and that unitary evolution can be recovered wherever it should actually be expected. This formalism may describe a quantum cosmology without an assumption of global hyperbolicity; it is thus more general than the Wheeler–De Witt approach. The structure of a QCH is also closely related to quantum information theory and algebraic quantum field theory on a causal set.
We provide a precise definition and analysis of quantum causal histories (QCHs). A QCH consists of a discrete, locally finite, causal pre-spacetime with matrix algebras encoding the quantum structure at each event. The evolution of quantum states and observables is described by completely positive maps between the algebras at causally related events. We show that this local description of evolution is sufficient and that unitary evolution can be recovered wherever it should actually be expected. This formalism may describe a quantum cosmology without an assumption of global hyperbolicity; it is thus more general than the Wheeler–De Witt approach. The structure of a QCH is also closely related to quantum information theory and algebraic quantum field theory on a causal set.
Abstract In this paper, we construct a tensor network representation of quantum causal histories, as a step towards directly representing states in quantum gravity via bulk tensor networks. Quantum causal histories are quantum extensions of causal sets in the sense that on each event in a causal set is assigned a Hilbert space of quantum states, and the local causal evolutions between events are modeled by completely positive and trace-preserving maps. Here we utilize the channel-state duality of completely positive and trace-preserving maps to transform the causal evolutions to bipartite entangled states. We construct the matrix product state for a single quantum causal history by projecting the obtained bipartite states onto the physical states on the events. We also construct the two dimensional tensor network states for entangled quantum causal histories in a restricted case with compatible causal orders. The possible holographic tensor networks are explored by mapping the quantum causal histories in a way analogous to the exact holographic mapping. The constructed tensor networks for quantum causal histories are exemplified by the non-unitary local time evolution moves in a quantum system on temporally varying discretizations, and these non-unitary evolution moves are shown to be necessary for defining a bulk causal structure and a quantum black hole. Finally, we comment on the limitations of the constructed tensor networks, and discuss some directions for further studies aiming at applications in quantum gravity.
The Causal Set hypothesis for Quantum Gravity asserts that the smooth Lorentzian spacetime manifold of General Relativity is only an approximation to a fundamental microscopic discrete structure: a locally-finite partially-ordered set. The points of this set are akin to the point-events of the spacetime manifold, and the order-relations among these points are akin to the causal-relations among these point-events. The local-finiteness condition implies a fundamental discreteness and provides an important [conformal] factor needed for the continuum approximations. In this dissertation, we address two aspects toward the formulation of a quantum dynamics for causal sets. The first aspect concerns the dynamics of a zero-mass classical scalar field on a background causal set, Poisson-sampled from an Alexandrov interval in (1 + 1)-dimensional Minkowski spacetime. Our numerical simulations suggest that actions can be defined for such a scalar field, expressed solely in terms of the causal set and the scalar field, which approximates the corresponding classical action on the continuum Minkowski spacetime. This result may help us describe matter and gauge fields in a local and Lorentz-invariant way on a causal set, a discrete structure now being considered as the arena for spacetime physics. More importantly, it may help us formulate an action for the causal set itself, which would be used in a sum-over-histories approach to describe the quantum dynamics of causal sets. The second aspect concerns Quantum Measure Theory, a new approach to quantum dynamics inspired by the sum-over-histories approach, which is better suited to formulating the dynamics of causal sets and of other alternative structures for spacetime. To better understand the mathematical structure underlying this new approach, we derive some algebraic identities involving the sum-rules of the Quantum Measure and its generalizations. We conclude with a discussion on possible applications and open problems concerning these aspects.
In general relativity, the causal structure between events is dynamical, but it is definite and observer-independent; events are point-like and the membership of an event A in the future or past light-cone of an event B is an observer-independent statement. When events are defined with respect to quantum systems however, nothing guarantees that the causal relationship between A and B is definite. We propose to associate a causal reference frame corresponding to each event, which can be interpreted as an observer-dependent time according to which an observer describes the evolution of quantum systems. In the causal reference frame of one event, this particular event is always localised, but other events can be ‘smeared out’ in the future and in the past. We do not impose a predefined causal order between the events, but only require that descriptions from different reference frames obey a global consistency condition. We show that our new formalism is equivalent to the pure process matrix formalism (Araújo et al 2017 Quantum 1 10). The latter is known to predict certain multipartite correlations, which are incompatible with the assumption of a causal ordering of the events—these correlations violate causal inequalities. We show how the causal reference frame description can be used to gain insight into the question of realisability of such strongly non-causal processes in laboratory experiments. As another application, we use causal reference frames to revisit a thought experiment Zych et al (arXiv: 1708.00248 ) where the gravitational time dilation due to a massive object in a quantum superposition of positions leads to a superposition of the causal ordering of two events.
The process-matrix formalism describes quantum processes without assuming a fixed global causal order, but the physical meaning of indefinite causal order remains open. We address this question within histories theory, where temporal ordering and dynamical evolution are distinct structures. We show that the decoherence functional admits coherent superpositions of dynamics. In measurement settings, under suitable factorization conditions, these generate process matrices. In the bipartite setting considered here, process-matrix indefinite causal order is thereby identified as an operationally restricted realization of the more general phenomenon of superposition of dynamics. Histories theory also admits a distinct kinematical notion of indefinite order, in which the ordering of physical events is itself a history observable. The resulting distinction between event order and intervention order clarifies the relation between indefinite causal order, quantum dynamics, and spacetime structure.
We use techniques of quantum information theory to analyze the quantum causal histories approach to quantum gravity. While it is consistent to introduce closed timelike curves (CTCs), they cannot generically carry independent degrees of freedom. Moreover, if the effective dynamics of the chronology-respecting part of the system is linear, it should be completely decoupled from the CTCs. In the absence of a CTC, not all causal structures admit the introduction of quantum mechanics. It is possible for those and only those causal structures that can be represented as quantum computational networks. Dynamics of the subsystems should not be unitary or even completely positive. However, we show that other commonly made assumptions ensure the complete positivity of the reduced dynamics.
This paper establishes the structural inevitability of quantum-theoretical description within the framework of Causal Update Cosmology (CUC I–IX). Rather than deriving quantum-mechanical equations or advocating a specific interpretation of quantum theory, the present work adopts an exclusion-based structural approach. Starting from the completed formulation of CUC and the concept of the central regime, it demonstrates that classical deterministic description is structurally impossible in causal update systems that have not yet reached or cannot maintain the central regime. Below the central regime, causal path competition remains immature, history indistinguishability is unsaturated, and self-averaging does not operate. Under these conditions, states cannot be uniquely defined, deterministic temporal evolution cannot be constructed, and observation cannot be treated as a passive readout. These failures are not due to epistemic limitations or insufficient information, but follow directly from the causal update structure itself. The paper shows that while probabilistic description becomes unavoidable once determinism is excluded, classical probability theory is insufficient, because probability in such systems is intrinsically coupled to the update process and competing causal histories are structurally non-independent. As a result, quantum-theoretical description emerges as the minimal and only consistent remaining framework. Observation is reinterpreted as an irreversible causal update rather than a measurement of a pre-existing state. This provides a structural resolution of the measurement problem and explains why quantum systems consistently appear on the initial side of the central regime upon observation: not because they are fundamentally incapable of reaching the central regime, but because observational updates disrupt the conditions required to maintain it in systems with limited causal redundancy. Classical description, determinism, and decoherence are shown to arise only as derived and conditional features once the central regime is reached and stably maintained. In this sense, classical theory is not fundamental but emergent. The conclusions of this paper are structurally symmetric to those obtained in the analysis of relativistic inevitability within CUC. Just as relativistic spacetime structure is unavoidable in central-regime–admitting systems, quantum theory is unavoidable below the central regime. Both are thus positioned as necessary descriptive frameworks selected by causal structure, rather than as exceptional postulates. This work represents a key step in extending Causal Update Cosmology beyond relativistic structure to the foundations of quantum theory, and sets the stage for a unified structural treatment of gravity and spacetime curvature in future studies. Note on AI Use This work also explores the broader question of whether new physical theories can emerge through collaboration with AI systems. ChatGPT (OpenAI) was used extensively in the generation and structuring of theoretical ideas and manuscript text, beyond simple editing or polishing. All numerical experiments and scientific validation were performed by the human author.