Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:hep-ph/0505141 · Physics Letters B

Quantum theory of neutrino oscillations for pedestrians: simple answers to confusing questions

Harry J. Lipkin

Published Oct 6, 2006• 48 citations
arXivHTMLPDF
DOI
10.1016/j.physletb.2006.09.054

Related papers

Trade-off relations of quantum resource theory in neutrino oscillations

Yuwen Li, Lijuan Li, Xue‐Ke Song +1 more

arXiv:2212.09320•The European Physical Journal Plus•Nov 21, 2022•11 citations

When the wavepacket is unnecessary

Leo Stodolsky

We point out that many wavepacket discussions for the coherence properties of particle beams are unnecessary since they deal with stationary sources; and when the problem is stationary, essentially all information is in the energy spectrum. This recognition allows a simple answer to a number of long-debated points, usually framed in terms of the``length of the wavepacket.'' In particular we discuss neutrino oscillations, and some issues in neutron physics. The question as to whether two simple beams with the same energy spectrum are distinguishable is answered negatively for stationary situations. The question as to whether neutrino oscillations should be thought of as taking place between states of the same energy or the same momentum is answered in favor of energy for stationary situations. The consequences for proposals involving the ${}^{7}\mathrm{Be}$ neutrino line of the Sun, the observation of oscillations in supernova neutrinos, and wavepacket studies with neutrons are briefly discussed, as well as the connection with the coherence notions of quantum optics.

arXiv:hep-ph/9802387•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jul 9, 1998•122 citations

Quantum Simulating Neutrino Oscillations [Poster]

Alisha Roberts

N/A•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

Neutrino Oscillations: Entanglement, Energy-Momentum Conservation and QFT

E. Kh. Akhmedov, A. Yu. Smirnov

arXiv:1008.2077•Foundations of Physics•Feb 24, 2011•75 citations

What is coherent in neutrino oscillations

Harry J. Lipkin

Simple rigorous quantum mechanics with no hand waving nor loopholes clarifies the confusion between three contradictory descriptions of the coherence between different neutrino mass eigenstates that can give rise to oscillations: (1) The standard textbook description of oscillations in time produced by coherence between states with different masses and different energies. (2) Stodolsky's proof that interference between states having different energies cannot be observed in realistic experiments. (3) The description of a pion decay at rest into an observed muon and unobserved neutrino as a “missing mass” experiment where coherence between different neutrino mass eigenstates is not observable. The known position in space of all realistic detectors is rigorously shown to provide the quantum-mechanical ignorance of the neutrino momentum needed to produce coherence between amplitudes from neutrino states with the same energy and different masses. Conditions are precisely formulated for the loss of coherence when mass eigenstate wave packets moving with different velocities separate. The example of Bragg scattering shows how quantum-mechanically imposed ignorance produces coherence.

arXiv:hep-ph/0304187•Physics Letters B•Dec 6, 2003•40 citations

Entangled neutrino states in a toy model QFT

Jarah Markar Evslin, Hosam Mohammed, Emilio Ciuffoli +1 more

It has been claimed that wave packets must be covariant and also that decohered neutrino oscillations are always revived during measurement. These conjectures are supported by general arguments which are not specific to the electroweak theory, and so if they are true for neutrinos they will also be true for simplified models. In this paper we produce such a simplified model in which the neutrino wave function, including its entanglement with the source particle and the environment, can be calculated explicitly in quantum field theory. It exhibits neutrino oscillation, which is reduced at late times by decoherence due to interactions of the source with the environment. One simple lesson from this model is that only the difference between the environmental interactions before and after neutrino emission can reduce the amplitude of neutrino oscillations. The model will be used to test the conjectures in a companion paper.

arXiv:1902.03934•The European Physical Journal C•Jun 1, 2019•10 citations
We point out that many wavepacket discussions for the coherence properties of particle beams are unnecessary since they deal with stationary sources; and when the problem is stationary, essentially all information is in the energy spectrum. This recognition allows a simple answer to a number of long-debated points, usually framed in terms of the``length of the wavepacket.'' In particular we discuss neutrino oscillations, and some issues in neutron physics. The question as to whether two simple beams with the same energy spectrum are distinguishable is answered negatively for stationary situations. The question as to whether neutrino oscillations should be thought of as taking place between states of the same energy or the same momentum is answered in favor of energy for stationary situations. The consequences for proposals involving the 7Be{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}7Be neutrino line of the Sun, the observation of oscillations in supernova neutrinos, and wavepacket studies with neutrons are briefly discussed, as well as the connection with the coherence notions of quantum optics.
Simple rigorous quantum mechanics with no hand waving nor loopholes clarifies the confusion between three contradictory descriptions of the coherence between different neutrino mass eigenstates that can give rise to oscillations: (1) The standard textbook description of oscillations in time produced by coherence between states with different masses and different energies. (2) Stodolsky's proof that interference between states having different energies cannot be observed in realistic experiments. (3) The description of a pion decay at rest into an observed muon and unobserved neutrino as a “missing mass” experiment where coherence between different neutrino mass eigenstates is not observable. The known position in space of all realistic detectors is rigorously shown to provide the quantum-mechanical ignorance of the neutrino momentum needed to produce coherence between amplitudes from neutrino states with the same energy and different masses. Conditions are precisely formulated for the loss of coherence when mass eigenstate wave packets moving with different velocities separate. The example of Bragg scattering shows how quantum-mechanically imposed ignorance produces coherence.
It has been claimed that wave packets must be covariant and also that decohered neutrino oscillations are always revived during measurement. These conjectures are supported by general arguments which are not specific to the electroweak theory, and so if they are true for neutrinos they will also be true for simplified models. In this paper we produce such a simplified model in which the neutrino wave function, including its entanglement with the source particle and the environment, can be calculated explicitly in quantum field theory. It exhibits neutrino oscillation, which is reduced at late times by decoherence due to interactions of the source with the environment. One simple lesson from this model is that only the difference between the environmental interactions before and after neutrino emission can reduce the amplitude of neutrino oscillations. The model will be used to test the conjectures in a companion paper.