Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:hep-ph/0405059 · Physical Review Letters

Stability Criteria for Breached-Pair Superfluidity

Michael McNeil Forbes, Elena Gubankova, W. Vincent Liu, Frank A. Wilczek

Published Jan 5, 2005• 180 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present simple, concrete, two-fermion models that exhibit thermodynamically stable isotropic translationally invariant gapless superfluid states (breached-pair superfluidity). The mass ratio between the components and the momentum structure of the interaction are crucial for determining the stability of such states: idealized, momentum-independent ("contact") interactions are insufficient.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.94.017001

Related papers

Gapless surfaces in anisotropic superfluids

Elena Gubankova, Eugene G. Mishchenko, Frank A. Wilczek

We demonstrate when p-wave pairing occurs between species whose free Fermi surfaces are mismatched the gap generally vanishes over a two-dimensional surface. We present detailed calculations of condensation energy, superfluid density (Meissner mass) and specific heat for such states. We also consider stability against separation into mixed phases. According to several independent criteria that can be checked at weak coupling, the resulting ``breached'' state appears to be stable over a substantial range of parameters. The simple models we consider are homogeneous in position space, and break rotation symmetry spontaneously. They should be realizable in cold atom systems.

arXiv:cond-mat/0411238•Physical Review B•Nov 13, 2006•14 citations

Breached Superfluidity via p -Wave Coupling

Elena Gubankova, Eugene G. Mishchenko, Frank A. Wilczek

Anisotropic pairing between fermion species with different Fermi momenta opens two-dimensional areas of gapless excitations, thus producing a spatially homogeneous state with coexisting superfluid and normal fluids. This breached pairing state is stable and robust for arbitrarily small mismatch and weak p-wave coupling.

arXiv:cond-mat/0409088•Physical Review Letters•Mar 22, 2005•38 citations

Stability conditions and Fermi surface topologies in a superconductor

Elena Gubankova, Andreas Schmitt, Frank A. Wilczek

Candidate homogeneous, isotropic superfluid or superconducting states of paired fermion species with different chemical potentials, can lead to quasiparticle excitation energies that vanish at either 0, 1, or 2 spheres in momentum space. With no zeros, we have a conventional BCS superconductor. The other two cases, ``gapless'' superconductors, appear in mean- field theory for sufficiently large mismatches and/or sufficiently large coupling strengths. Here we examine several stability criteria for those candidate phases. Positivity of number susceptibility appears to provide the most powerful constraint, and renders all the two-zero states that we have examined mechanically unstable. Our results should apply directly to ultracold fermionic atom systems.

arXiv:cond-mat/0603603•Physical Review B•Aug 11, 2006•52 citations

STABILITY CONDITIONS IN GAPLESS SUPERCONDUCTORS

Elena Gubankova

Gapless superconductivity can arise when pairing occurs between fermion species with different Fermi surface sizes, provided there is a sufficiently large mismatch between Fermi surfaces and/or at sufficiently large coupling constant. In gapless states, secondary Fermi surfaces appear where quasiparticle excitation energy vanishes. This work focuses on homogeneous and isotropic superfluids in the s-wave channel, with either zero (conventional superconductor), one, or two spherical Fermi surfaces. The stability conditions for these candidate phases are analyzed. It is found that gapless states with one Fermi surface are stable in the BEC region, while gapless states with two Fermi surfaces are unstable in all parameter space. The results can be applied to ultracold fermionic atom systems.

arXiv:cond-mat/0608041•Continuous Advances in QCD•Mar 1, 2007•0 citations

Stability of the breached pair state for a two-species fermionic system in the presence of Feshbach resonance

Raka Dasgupta

We investigate the phenomenon of fermionic pairing with mismatched Fermi surfaces in a two-species system in the presence of Feshbach resonance, where the resonantly paired fermions combine to form bosonic molecules. We observe that the Feshbach parameters control the critical temperature of the gapped BCS superfluid state, and also determine the range over which a gapless breached pair state may exist. Demanding the positivity of the superfluid density, it is shown that although a breached pair state with two Fermi surfaces is always unstable, its single Fermi-surface counterpart can be stable if the chemical potentials of the two pairing species have opposite signs. This condition is satisfied only over a narrow region in the BEC side, characterized by an upper and a lower limit for the magnetic field. We estimate these limits for a mixture of two hyperfine states of $^{6}\text{L}\text{i}$ using recent experimental data.

arXiv:0812.5028•Physical Review A•Dec 15, 2009•5 citations

LOFF pairing vs breached pairing in asymmetric fermion superfluids

Lianyi He, Meng Jin, Pengfei Zhuang

A general analysis for the competition between breached pairing (BP) and LOFF pairing mechanisms in asymmetric fermion superfluids is presented in the frame of a four fermion interaction model. Two physical conditions which can induce mismatched Fermi surfaces are considered: (1) fixed chemical potential asymmetry $\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\mu}$ and (2) fixed fermion number asymmetry $\ensuremath{\alpha}$. In case (1), the BP state is ruled out because of Sarma instability, and the LOFF state is thermodynamically stable in a narrow window of $\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\mu}$. In case (2), while the Sarma instability can be avoided and both the BP and LOFF states can survive provided $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ is less than the corresponding critical value, the BP state suffers magnetic instability and the LOFF state is always thermodynamically stable. While the LOFF window in case (2) is much larger than the one in the conventional case (1), the longitudinal superfluid density of the LOFF state is negative for small $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ and it suffers magnetic instability too.

arXiv:cond-mat/0601147•Physical Review B•Jun 29, 2006•75 citations
We present simple, concrete, two-fermion models that exhibit thermodynamically stable isotropic translationally invariant gapless superfluid states (breached-pair superfluidity). The mass ratio between the components and the momentum structure of the interaction are crucial for determining the stability of such states: idealized, momentum-independent ("contact") interactions are insufficient.
We demonstrate when p-wave pairing occurs between species whose free Fermi surfaces are mismatched the gap generally vanishes over a two-dimensional surface. We present detailed calculations of condensation energy, superfluid density (Meissner mass) and specific heat for such states. We also consider stability against separation into mixed phases. According to several independent criteria that can be checked at weak coupling, the resulting ``breached'' state appears to be stable over a substantial range of parameters. The simple models we consider are homogeneous in position space, and break rotation symmetry spontaneously. They should be realizable in cold atom systems.
Candidate homogeneous, isotropic superfluid or superconducting states of paired fermion species with different chemical potentials, can lead to quasiparticle excitation energies that vanish at either 0, 1, or 2 spheres in momentum space. With no zeros, we have a conventional BCS superconductor. The other two cases, ``gapless'' superconductors, appear in mean- field theory for sufficiently large mismatches and/or sufficiently large coupling strengths. Here we examine several stability criteria for those candidate phases. Positivity of number susceptibility appears to provide the most powerful constraint, and renders all the two-zero states that we have examined mechanically unstable. Our results should apply directly to ultracold fermionic atom systems.
Gapless superconductivity can arise when pairing occurs between fermion species with different Fermi surface sizes, provided there is a sufficiently large mismatch between Fermi surfaces and/or at sufficiently large coupling constant. In gapless states, secondary Fermi surfaces appear where quasiparticle excitation energy vanishes. This work focuses on homogeneous and isotropic superfluids in the s-wave channel, with either zero (conventional superconductor), one, or two spherical Fermi surfaces. The stability conditions for these candidate phases are analyzed. It is found that gapless states with one Fermi surface are stable in the BEC region, while gapless states with two Fermi surfaces are unstable in all parameter space. The results can be applied to ultracold fermionic atom systems.
We investigate the phenomenon of fermionic pairing with mismatched Fermi surfaces in a two-species system in the presence of Feshbach resonance, where the resonantly paired fermions combine to form bosonic molecules. We observe that the Feshbach parameters control the critical temperature of the gapped BCS superfluid state, and also determine the range over which a gapless breached pair state may exist. Demanding the positivity of the superfluid density, it is shown that although a breached pair state with two Fermi surfaces is always unstable, its single Fermi-surface counterpart can be stable if the chemical potentials of the two pairing species have opposite signs. This condition is satisfied only over a narrow region in the BEC side, characterized by an upper and a lower limit for the magnetic field. We estimate these limits for a mixture of two hyperfine states of 6Li^{6}\text{L}\text{i}6Li using recent experimental data.
A general analysis for the competition between breached pairing (BP) and LOFF pairing mechanisms in asymmetric fermion superfluids is presented in the frame of a four fermion interaction model. Two physical conditions which can induce mismatched Fermi surfaces are considered: (1) fixed chemical potential asymmetry $\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\mu}$ and (2) fixed fermion number asymmetry $\ensuremath{\alpha}$. In case (1), the BP state is ruled out because of Sarma instability, and the LOFF state is thermodynamically stable in a narrow window of $\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\mu}$. In case (2), while the Sarma instability can be avoided and both the BP and LOFF states can survive provided $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ is less than the corresponding critical value, the BP state suffers magnetic instability and the LOFF state is always thermodynamically stable. While the LOFF window in case (2) is much larger than the one in the conventional case (1), the longitudinal superfluid density of the LOFF state is negative for small $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ and it suffers magnetic instability too.