Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cs/0111062 · SIAM Journal on Computing

One-Way Communication Complexity and the Nečiporuk Lower Bound on Formula Size

Hartmut Klauck

Published Jan 1, 2007• 36 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper the Nečiporuk method for proving lower bounds on the size of Boolean formulas is reformulated in terms of one-way communication complexity. We investigate the settings of probabilistic formulas, nondeterministic formulas, and quantum formulas. In all cases we can use results about one-way communication complexity to prove lower bounds on formula size. The main results regarding formula size are as follows: We show a polynomial size gap between probabilistic/quantum and deterministic formulas, a near-quadratic gap between the sizes of nondeterministic formulas with limited access to nondeterministic bits and nondeterministic formulas with access to slightly more such bits, and a near-quadratic lower bound on quantum formula size. Furthermore we give a polynomial separation between the sizes of quantum formulas with and without multiple read random inputs. The lower bound methods for quantum and probabilistic formulas employ a variant of the Nečiporuk bound in terms of the Vapnik–Chervonenkis dimension. To establish our lower bounds we show optimal separations between one-way and two-way protocols for limited nondeterministic and quantum communication complexity, and we show that zero-error quantum one-way communication complexity asymptotically equals deterministic one-way communication complexity for total functions.

DOI
10.1137/s009753970140004x

Related papers

On quantum and probabilistic communication: Las Vegas and one-way protocols

Hartmut Klauck

We investigate the power of quantum communication protocols compared to classical probabilistic protocols.In our first result we describe a total Boolean function that has a quantum Las Vegas protocol communicating at most O(N 1°/11+~) qubits for all e > 0, while any classical probabilistic protocol (with bounded error) needs ~(N/log N) bits.Then we investigate quantum one-way communication complexity.First we show that the VC-dimension lower bound on one-way probabilistic communication of [26] holds for quantum protocols, too.Then we prove that for oneway protocols computing total functions quantum Las Vegas communication is asymptotically as efficient as exact quantum communication, which is exactly as efficient as deterministic communication.We describe applications of the lower bounds for one-way communication complexity to quantum finite automata and quantum formulae.

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•May 1, 2000•76 citations

Lower Bounds for Quantum Communication Complexity

Hartmut Klauck

We prove lower bounds on the bounded error quantum communication complexity. Our methods are based on the Fourier transform of the considered functions. First we generalize a method for proving classical communication complexity lower bounds developed by Raz [Comput. Complexity, 5 (1995), pp. 205–221] to the quantum case. Applying this method, we give an exponential separation between bounded error quantum communication complexity and nondeterministic quantum communication complexity. We develop several other lower bound methods based on the Fourier transform, notably showing that $\sqrt{\bar{s}(f)/\log n}$, for the average sensitivity $\bar{s}(f)$ of a function f, yields a lower bound on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of $f((x \wedge y)\oplus z)$, where x is a Boolean word held by Alice and $y,z$ are Boolean words held by Bob. We then prove the first large lower bounds on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of functions, for which a polynomial quantum speedup is possible. For all the functions we investigate, the only previously applied general lower bound method based on discrepancy yields bounds that are $O(\log n)$.

arXiv:quant-ph/0106160•SIAM Journal on Computing•Jan 1, 2007•127 citations

Lower Bounds on Quantum Multiparty Communication Complexity

Troy Lee, Gideon Schechtman, Adi Shraibman

A major open question in communication complexity is if randomized and quantum communication are polynomially related for all total functions. So far, no gap larger than a power of two is known, despite significant efforts. We examine this question in the number-on-the-forehead model of multiparty communication complexity. We show that essentially all lower bounds known on randomized complexity in this model also hold for quantum communication. This includes bounds of size Omega(n/2k) for the k-party complexity of explicit functions, bounds for the generalized inner product function, and recent work on the multiparty complexity of disjointness. To the best of our knowledge, these are the first lower bounds of any kind on quantum communication in the general number-on-the-forehead model. We show this result in the following way. In the two-party case, there is a lower bound on quantum communication complexity in terms of a norm gamma2, which is known to subsume nearly all other techniques in the literature. For randomized complexity there is another natural bound in terms of a different norm mu which is also one of the strongest techniques available. A deep theorem in functional analysis, Grothendieck's inequality, implies that gamma2and mu are equivalent up to a constant factor. This connection is one of the major obstacles to showing a larger gap between randomized and quantum communication complexity in the two-party case. The lower bound technique in terms of the norm mu was recently extended to the multiparty number-on-the-forehead model. Here we show how the gamma2norm can be also extended to lower bound quantum multiparty complexity. Surprisingly, even in this general setting the two lower bounds, on quantum and classical communication, are still very closely related. This implies that separating quantum and classical communication in this setting will require the development of new techniques. The relation between these extensions of mu and gamma2is proved by a multi-dimensional version of Grothendieck's inequality.

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Jul 1, 2009•22 citations

Lower bounds for quantum communication complexity

Hartmut Klauck

We prove new lower bounds for bounded error quantum communication complexity. Our methods are based on the Fourier transform of the considered functions. First we generalize a method for proving classical communication complexity lower bounds developed by R. Raz (1995) to the quantum case. Applying this method we give an exponential separation between bounded error quantum communication complexity and nondeterministic quantum communication complexity. We develop several other Fourier based lower bound methods, notably showing that /spl radic/(s~(f)/log n) n, for the average sensitivity s~(f) of a function f, yields a lower bound on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of f (x/spl and/y/spl oplus/yz), where x is a Boolean word held by Alice and y, z are Boolean words held by Bob. We then prove the first large lower bounds on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of functions, for which a polynomial quantum speedup is possible. For all the functions we investigate, only the previously applied general lower bound method based on discrepancy yields bounds that are O(log n).

Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science•Jan 1, 2001•40 citations

Fooling One-Sided Quantum Protocols

Hartmut Klauck, Ronald de Wolf

We use the venerable "fooling set" method to prove new lower bounds on the quantum communication complexity of various functions. Let f:X x Y-->{0,1} be a Boolean function, fool^1(f) its maximal fooling set size among 1-inputs, Q_1^*(f) its one-sided error quantum communication complexity with prior entanglement, and NQ(f) its nondeterministic quantum communication complexity (without prior entanglement; this model is trivial with shared randomness or entanglement). Our main results are the following, where logs are to base 2: * If the maximal fooling set is "upper triangular" (which is for instance the case for the equality, disjointness, and greater-than functions), then we have Q_1^*(f)>=(1/2)log fool^1(f) - 1/2, which is essentially optimal by superdense coding. No super-constant lower bound for equality seems to follow from earlier techniques. * For all f we have Q_1^*(f)>=(1/4)log fool^1(f) - 1/2, which is optimal up to a factor of 2. * NQ(f)>=log \fool^1(f)/2 + 1. We do not know if the factor 1/2 is needed in this result, but it cannot be replaced by 1: we give an example where NQ(f)~0.613 log fool^1(f).

arXiv:1204.4619•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Apr 20, 2012•12 citations

One-Way Communication Complexity and Non-Adaptive Decision Trees

Nikhil S. Mande, Swagato Sanyal, Suhail Sherif

We study the relationship between various one-way communication complexity measures of a composed function with the analogous decision tree complexity of the outer function. We consider two gadgets: the AND function on 2 inputs, and the Inner Product on a constant number of inputs. More generally, we show the following when the gadget is Inner Product on 2b input bits for all b ≥ 2, denoted IP. - If f is a total Boolean function that depends on all of its n input bits, then the bounded-error one-way quantum communication complexity of f∘IP equals Ω(n(b-1)). - If f is a partial Boolean function, then the deterministic one-way communication complexity of f∘IP is at least Ω(b ⋅ 𝖣_{dt}^ → (f)), where 𝖣_{dt}^ → (f) denotes non-adaptive decision tree complexity of f. To prove our quantum lower bound, we first show a lower bound on the VC-dimension of f∘IP. We then appeal to a result of Klauck [STOC'00], which immediately yields our quantum lower bound. Our deterministic lower bound relies on a combinatorial result independently proven by Ahlswede and Khachatrian [Adv. Appl. Math.'98], and Frankl and Tokushige [Comb.'99]. It is known due to a result of Montanaro and Osborne [arXiv'09] that the deterministic one-way communication complexity of f∘XOR equals the non-adaptive parity decision tree complexity of f. In contrast, we show the following when the inner gadget is the AND function on 2 input bits. - There exists a function for which even the quantum non-adaptive AND decision tree complexity of f is exponentially large in the deterministic one-way communication complexity of f∘AND. - However, for symmetric functions f, the non-adaptive AND decision tree complexity of f is at most quadratic in the (even two-way) communication complexity of f∘AND. In view of the first bullet, a lower bound on non-adaptive AND decision tree complexity of f does not lift to a lower bound on one-way communication complexity of f∘AND. The proof of the first bullet above uses the well-studied Odd-Max-Bit function. For the second bullet, we first observe a connection between the one-way communication complexity of f and the Möbius sparsity of f, and then give a lower bound on the Möbius sparsity of symmetric functions. An upper bound on the non-adaptive AND decision tree complexity of symmetric functions follows implicitly from prior work on combinatorial group testing; for the sake of completeness, we include a proof of this result. It is well known that the rank of the communication matrix of a function F is an upper bound on its deterministic one-way communication complexity. This bound is known to be tight for some F. However, in our final result we show that this is not the case when F = f∘AND. More precisely we show that for all f, the deterministic one-way communication complexity of F = f∘AND is at most (rank(M_{F}))(1 - Ω(1)), where M_{F} denotes the communication matrix of F.

arXiv:2105.01963•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•May 5, 2021•1 citation
In this paper the Nečiporuk method for proving lower bounds on the size of Boolean formulas is reformulated in terms of one-way communication complexity. We investigate the settings of probabilistic formulas, nondeterministic formulas, and quantum formulas. In all cases we can use results about one-way communication complexity to prove lower bounds on formula size. The main results regarding formula size are as follows: We show a polynomial size gap between probabilistic/quantum and deterministic formulas, a near-quadratic gap between the sizes of nondeterministic formulas with limited access to nondeterministic bits and nondeterministic formulas with access to slightly more such bits, and a near-quadratic lower bound on quantum formula size. Furthermore we give a polynomial separation between the sizes of quantum formulas with and without multiple read random inputs. The lower bound methods for quantum and probabilistic formulas employ a variant of the Nečiporuk bound in terms of the Vapnik–Chervonenkis dimension. To establish our lower bounds we show optimal separations between one-way and two-way protocols for limited nondeterministic and quantum communication complexity, and we show that zero-error quantum one-way communication complexity asymptotically equals deterministic one-way communication complexity for total functions.
We investigate the power of quantum communication protocols compared to classical probabilistic protocols.In our first result we describe a total Boolean function that has a quantum Las Vegas protocol communicating at most O(N 1°/11+~) qubits for all e > 0, while any classical probabilistic protocol (with bounded error) needs ~(N/log N) bits.Then we investigate quantum one-way communication complexity.First we show that the VC-dimension lower bound on one-way probabilistic communication of [26] holds for quantum protocols, too.Then we prove that for oneway protocols computing total functions quantum Las Vegas communication is asymptotically as efficient as exact quantum communication, which is exactly as efficient as deterministic communication.We describe applications of the lower bounds for one-way communication complexity to quantum finite automata and quantum formulae.
We prove lower bounds on the bounded error quantum communication complexity. Our methods are based on the Fourier transform of the considered functions. First we generalize a method for proving classical communication complexity lower bounds developed by Raz [Comput. Complexity, 5 (1995), pp. 205–221] to the quantum case. Applying this method, we give an exponential separation between bounded error quantum communication complexity and nondeterministic quantum communication complexity. We develop several other lower bound methods based on the Fourier transform, notably showing that sˉ(f)/log⁡n\sqrt{\bar{s}(f)/\log n}sˉ(f)/logn​, for the average sensitivity sˉ(f)\bar{s}(f)sˉ(f) of a function f, yields a lower bound on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of f((x∧y)⊕z)f((x \wedge y)\oplus z)f((x∧y)⊕z), where x is a Boolean word held by Alice and y,zy,zy,z are Boolean words held by Bob. We then prove the first large lower bounds on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of functions, for which a polynomial quantum speedup is possible. For all the functions we investigate, the only previously applied general lower bound method based on discrepancy yields bounds that are O(log⁡n)O(\log n)O(logn).
A major open question in communication complexity is if randomized and quantum communication are polynomially related for all total functions. So far, no gap larger than a power of two is known, despite significant efforts. We examine this question in the number-on-the-forehead model of multiparty communication complexity. We show that essentially all lower bounds known on randomized complexity in this model also hold for quantum communication. This includes bounds of size Omega(n/2k) for the k-party complexity of explicit functions, bounds for the generalized inner product function, and recent work on the multiparty complexity of disjointness. To the best of our knowledge, these are the first lower bounds of any kind on quantum communication in the general number-on-the-forehead model. We show this result in the following way. In the two-party case, there is a lower bound on quantum communication complexity in terms of a norm gamma2, which is known to subsume nearly all other techniques in the literature. For randomized complexity there is another natural bound in terms of a different norm mu which is also one of the strongest techniques available. A deep theorem in functional analysis, Grothendieck's inequality, implies that gamma2and mu are equivalent up to a constant factor. This connection is one of the major obstacles to showing a larger gap between randomized and quantum communication complexity in the two-party case. The lower bound technique in terms of the norm mu was recently extended to the multiparty number-on-the-forehead model. Here we show how the gamma2norm can be also extended to lower bound quantum multiparty complexity. Surprisingly, even in this general setting the two lower bounds, on quantum and classical communication, are still very closely related. This implies that separating quantum and classical communication in this setting will require the development of new techniques. The relation between these extensions of mu and gamma2is proved by a multi-dimensional version of Grothendieck's inequality.
We prove new lower bounds for bounded error quantum communication complexity. Our methods are based on the Fourier transform of the considered functions. First we generalize a method for proving classical communication complexity lower bounds developed by R. Raz (1995) to the quantum case. Applying this method we give an exponential separation between bounded error quantum communication complexity and nondeterministic quantum communication complexity. We develop several other Fourier based lower bound methods, notably showing that /spl radic/(s~(f)/log n) n, for the average sensitivity s~(f) of a function f, yields a lower bound on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of f (x/spl and/y/spl oplus/yz), where x is a Boolean word held by Alice and y, z are Boolean words held by Bob. We then prove the first large lower bounds on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of functions, for which a polynomial quantum speedup is possible. For all the functions we investigate, only the previously applied general lower bound method based on discrepancy yields bounds that are O(log n).
We use the venerable "fooling set" method to prove new lower bounds on the quantum communication complexity of various functions. Let f:X x Y-->{0,1} be a Boolean function, fool^1(f) its maximal fooling set size among 1-inputs, Q_1^*(f) its one-sided error quantum communication complexity with prior entanglement, and NQ(f) its nondeterministic quantum communication complexity (without prior entanglement; this model is trivial with shared randomness or entanglement). Our main results are the following, where logs are to base 2: * If the maximal fooling set is "upper triangular" (which is for instance the case for the equality, disjointness, and greater-than functions), then we have Q_1^*(f)>=(1/2)log fool^1(f) - 1/2, which is essentially optimal by superdense coding. No super-constant lower bound for equality seems to follow from earlier techniques. * For all f we have Q_1^*(f)>=(1/4)log fool^1(f) - 1/2, which is optimal up to a factor of 2. * NQ(f)>=log \fool^1(f)/2 + 1. We do not know if the factor 1/2 is needed in this result, but it cannot be replaced by 1: we give an example where NQ(f)~0.613 log fool^1(f).
We study the relationship between various one-way communication complexity measures of a composed function with the analogous decision tree complexity of the outer function. We consider two gadgets: the AND function on 2 inputs, and the Inner Product on a constant number of inputs. More generally, we show the following when the gadget is Inner Product on 2b input bits for all b ≥ 2, denoted IP. - If f is a total Boolean function that depends on all of its n input bits, then the bounded-error one-way quantum communication complexity of f∘IP equals Ω(n(b-1)). - If f is a partial Boolean function, then the deterministic one-way communication complexity of f∘IP is at least Ω(b ⋅ 𝖣_{dt}^ → (f)), where 𝖣_{dt}^ → (f) denotes non-adaptive decision tree complexity of f. To prove our quantum lower bound, we first show a lower bound on the VC-dimension of f∘IP. We then appeal to a result of Klauck [STOC'00], which immediately yields our quantum lower bound. Our deterministic lower bound relies on a combinatorial result independently proven by Ahlswede and Khachatrian [Adv. Appl. Math.'98], and Frankl and Tokushige [Comb.'99]. It is known due to a result of Montanaro and Osborne [arXiv'09] that the deterministic one-way communication complexity of f∘XOR equals the non-adaptive parity decision tree complexity of f. In contrast, we show the following when the inner gadget is the AND function on 2 input bits. - There exists a function for which even the quantum non-adaptive AND decision tree complexity of f is exponentially large in the deterministic one-way communication complexity of f∘AND. - However, for symmetric functions f, the non-adaptive AND decision tree complexity of f is at most quadratic in the (even two-way) communication complexity of f∘AND. In view of the first bullet, a lower bound on non-adaptive AND decision tree complexity of f does not lift to a lower bound on one-way communication complexity of f∘AND. The proof of the first bullet above uses the well-studied Odd-Max-Bit function. For the second bullet, we first observe a connection between the one-way communication complexity of f and the Möbius sparsity of f, and then give a lower bound on the Möbius sparsity of symmetric functions. An upper bound on the non-adaptive AND decision tree complexity of symmetric functions follows implicitly from prior work on combinatorial group testing; for the sake of completeness, we include a proof of this result. It is well known that the rank of the communication matrix of a function F is an upper bound on its deterministic one-way communication complexity. This bound is known to be tight for some F. However, in our final result we show that this is not the case when F = f∘AND. More precisely we show that for all f, the deterministic one-way communication complexity of F = f∘AND is at most (rank(M_{F}))(1 - Ω(1)), where M_{F} denotes the communication matrix of F.