Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/9910333 · Physical Review Letters

Houdayer and Martin Reply:

J. Houdayer, Olivier Martin

Published Jan 31, 2000• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The problem of the survival of a spin glass phase in the presence of a field has been a challenging one for a long time. To date, all attempts using equilibrium Monte Carlo methods have been unconclusive. In their comment to our paper, Marinari, Parisi and Zuliani use out-of-equilibrium measurements to test for an Almeida-Thouless line. In our view such a dynamic approach is not based on very solid foundations in finite dimensional systems and so cannot be as compelling as equilibrium approaches. Nevertheless, the results of those authors suggests that there is a critical field near B=0.4 at zero temperature. In view of this quite small value (compared to the mean field value), we have reanalyzed our data. We find that if finite size scaling is to distinguish between that small field and a zero field, we would need to go to lattice sizes of about 20x20x20.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.84.1057

Related papers

Comment on “Ising Spin Glasses in a Magnetic Field”

Enzo Marinari, Giorgio Parisi A, Francesco Zuliani

In ref. cond-mat/9811419 Houdayer and Martin analyze the T=0 3d EA spin glass with a magnetic field $B$. By using a new, powerful method, they determine an effective critical field $B_c$ as a function of the lattice size $L$. They use their results to deduce that the model is behaving like in the droplet approach and not like the mean-field theory. We show here, by using some unpublished data, that this very interesting method and numerical results are completely compatible with the behavior implied by the Replica Symmetry Breaking theory.

arXiv:cond-mat/9812401•Physical Review Letters•Jan 31, 2000•17 citations

Critical point scaling of Ising spin glasses in a magnetic field

Joonhyun Yeo, M A Moore

Critical point scaling in a field $H$ applies for the limits $t\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ (where $t=T/{T}_{c}\ensuremath{-}1)$ and $H\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ but with the ratio $R=t/{H}^{2/\ensuremath{\Delta}}$ finite. $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ is a critical exponent of the zero-field transition. We study the replicon correlation length $\ensuremath{\xi}$ and from it the crossover scaling function $f(R)$ defined via $1/(\ensuremath{\xi}{H}^{4/(d+2\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\eta})})\ensuremath{\sim}f(R)$. We have calculated analytically $f(R)$ for the mean-field limit of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model. In dimension $d=3$, we have determined the exponents and the critical scaling function $f(R)$ within two versions of the Migdal-Kadanoff (MK) renormalization group procedure. One of the MK versions gives results for $f(R)$ in $d=3$ in reasonable agreement with those of the Monte Carlo simulations at the values of $R$ for which they can be compared. If there were a de Almeida-Thouless (AT) line for $d\ensuremath{\le}6$, it would appear as a zero of the function $f(R)$ at some negative value of $R$, but there is no evidence for such behavior. This is consistent with the arguments that there should be no AT line for $d\ensuremath{\le}6$, which we review.

arXiv:1412.2448•Physical Review B•Mar 30, 2015•11 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Critical point scaling of Ising spin glasses in a magnetic field’ ”

Joonhyun Yeo, M A Moore

In his Comment, Temesv\'ari objects to a remark in our paper [Phys. Rev. B 91, 104432 (2015)] that his result for the form of the Almeida-Thouless (AT) line obtained in an earlier paper by Parisi and Temev\'ari [Nucl. Phys. B 858, 293 (2012)] in six dimensions can be obtained by taking the limit of $d\ensuremath{\rightarrow}6$ in the equations valid for $d>6$ but that this violated one of the inequalities needed for their validity. He is just pointing out that they gave a derivation of the form of the AT line in six dimensions in Parisi and Temev\'ari [Nucl. Phys. B 858, 293 (2012)] which avoided this difficulty. However, it is still a perturbative approach and does not deal with the lack of a perturbative fixed point found by Bray and Roberts [J. Phys. C 13, 5405 (1980)] long ago.

arXiv:1610.05764•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 1, 2016•1 citation

Numerical Simulations and Replica Symmetry Breaking

Víctor Martín-Mayor, Juan Jesus Ruiz-Lorenzo, Beatriz Seoane +1 more

Use of dedicated computers in spin glass simulations allows one to equilibrate very large samples (of size as large as $L=32$) and to carry out "computer experiments" that can be compared to (and analyzed in combination with) laboratory experiments on spin-glass samples. In the absence of a magnetic field, the most economic conclusion of the combined analysis of equilibrium and non-equilibrium simulations is that an RSB spin glass phase is present in three spatial dimensions. However, in the presence of a field, the lower critical dimension for the de Almeida-Thouless transition seems to be larger than three.

arXiv:2205.14089•WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 1, 2023•6 citations

Comment on “Critical point scaling of Ising spin glasses in a magnetic field”

T. Temesvári

In a section of a recent paper [Phys. Rev. B 91, 104432 (2015)], the authors discuss some of the arguments in the paper by Parisi and Temesv\'ari [Nucl. Phys. B 858, 293 (2012)]. In this Comment, it is shown how these arguments are misinterpreted and the existence of the Almeida-Thouless transition $\mathit{in}$ the upper critical dimension six reasserted.

arXiv:1610.04747•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 1, 2016•3 citations

Finite-size critical scaling in Ising spin glasses in the mean-field regime

Timo Aspelmeier, Helmut G. Katzgraber, Derek Larson +3 more

We study in Ising spin glasses the finite-size effects near the spin-glass transition in zero field and at the de Almeida-Thouless transition in a field by Monte Carlo methods and by analytical approximations. In zero field, the finite-size scaling function associated with the spin-glass susceptibility of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick mean-field spin-glass model is of the same form as that of one-dimensional spin-glass models with power-law long-range interactions in the regime where they can be a proxy for the Edwards-Anderson short-range spin-glass model above the upper critical dimension. We also calculate a simple analytical approximation for the spin-glass susceptibility crossover function. The behavior of the spin-glass susceptibility near the de Almeida-Thouless transition line has also been studied, but here we have only been able to obtain analytically its behavior in the asymptotic limit above and below the transition. We have also simulated the one-dimensional system in a field in the non-mean-field regime to illustrate that when the Imry-Ma droplet length scale exceeds the system size one can then be erroneously lead to conclude that there is a de Almeida-Thouless transition even though it is absent.

arXiv:1509.05372•Physical review. E•Mar 14, 2016•22 citations
The problem of the survival of a spin glass phase in the presence of a field has been a challenging one for a long time. To date, all attempts using equilibrium Monte Carlo methods have been unconclusive. In their comment to our paper, Marinari, Parisi and Zuliani use out-of-equilibrium measurements to test for an Almeida-Thouless line. In our view such a dynamic approach is not based on very solid foundations in finite dimensional systems and so cannot be as compelling as equilibrium approaches. Nevertheless, the results of those authors suggests that there is a critical field near B=0.4 at zero temperature. In view of this quite small value (compared to the mean field value), we have reanalyzed our data. We find that if finite size scaling is to distinguish between that small field and a zero field, we would need to go to lattice sizes of about 20x20x20.
In ref. cond-mat/9811419 Houdayer and Martin analyze the T=0 3d EA spin glass with a magnetic field BBB. By using a new, powerful method, they determine an effective critical field BcB_cBc​ as a function of the lattice size LLL. They use their results to deduce that the model is behaving like in the droplet approach and not like the mean-field theory. We show here, by using some unpublished data, that this very interesting method and numerical results are completely compatible with the behavior implied by the Replica Symmetry Breaking theory.
Critical point scaling in a field HHH applies for the limits $t\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ (where $t=T/{T}_{c}\ensuremath{-}1)$ and $H\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ but with the ratio $R=t/{H}^{2/\ensuremath{\Delta}}$ finite. $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ is a critical exponent of the zero-field transition. We study the replicon correlation length $\ensuremath{\xi}$ and from it the crossover scaling function f(R)f(R)f(R) defined via $1/(\ensuremath{\xi}{H}^{4/(d+2\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\eta})})\ensuremath{\sim}f(R)$. We have calculated analytically f(R)f(R)f(R) for the mean-field limit of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model. In dimension d=3d=3d=3, we have determined the exponents and the critical scaling function f(R)f(R)f(R) within two versions of the Migdal-Kadanoff (MK) renormalization group procedure. One of the MK versions gives results for f(R)f(R)f(R) in d=3d=3d=3 in reasonable agreement with those of the Monte Carlo simulations at the values of RRR for which they can be compared. If there were a de Almeida-Thouless (AT) line for $d\ensuremath{\le}6$, it would appear as a zero of the function f(R)f(R)f(R) at some negative value of RRR, but there is no evidence for such behavior. This is consistent with the arguments that there should be no AT line for $d\ensuremath{\le}6$, which we review.
In his Comment, Temesv\'ari objects to a remark in our paper [Phys. Rev. B 91, 104432 (2015)] that his result for the form of the Almeida-Thouless (AT) line obtained in an earlier paper by Parisi and Temev\'ari [Nucl. Phys. B 858, 293 (2012)] in six dimensions can be obtained by taking the limit of $d\ensuremath{\rightarrow}6$ in the equations valid for d>6d>6d>6 but that this violated one of the inequalities needed for their validity. He is just pointing out that they gave a derivation of the form of the AT line in six dimensions in Parisi and Temev\'ari [Nucl. Phys. B 858, 293 (2012)] which avoided this difficulty. However, it is still a perturbative approach and does not deal with the lack of a perturbative fixed point found by Bray and Roberts [J. Phys. C 13, 5405 (1980)] long ago.
Use of dedicated computers in spin glass simulations allows one to equilibrate very large samples (of size as large as L=32L=32L=32) and to carry out "computer experiments" that can be compared to (and analyzed in combination with) laboratory experiments on spin-glass samples. In the absence of a magnetic field, the most economic conclusion of the combined analysis of equilibrium and non-equilibrium simulations is that an RSB spin glass phase is present in three spatial dimensions. However, in the presence of a field, the lower critical dimension for the de Almeida-Thouless transition seems to be larger than three.
In a section of a recent paper [Phys. Rev. B 91, 104432 (2015)], the authors discuss some of the arguments in the paper by Parisi and Temesv\'ari [Nucl. Phys. B 858, 293 (2012)]. In this Comment, it is shown how these arguments are misinterpreted and the existence of the Almeida-Thouless transition in\mathit{in}in the upper critical dimension six reasserted.
We study in Ising spin glasses the finite-size effects near the spin-glass transition in zero field and at the de Almeida-Thouless transition in a field by Monte Carlo methods and by analytical approximations. In zero field, the finite-size scaling function associated with the spin-glass susceptibility of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick mean-field spin-glass model is of the same form as that of one-dimensional spin-glass models with power-law long-range interactions in the regime where they can be a proxy for the Edwards-Anderson short-range spin-glass model above the upper critical dimension. We also calculate a simple analytical approximation for the spin-glass susceptibility crossover function. The behavior of the spin-glass susceptibility near the de Almeida-Thouless transition line has also been studied, but here we have only been able to obtain analytically its behavior in the asymptotic limit above and below the transition. We have also simulated the one-dimensional system in a field in the non-mean-field regime to illustrate that when the Imry-Ma droplet length scale exceeds the system size one can then be erroneously lead to conclude that there is a de Almeida-Thouless transition even though it is absent.