Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/9809029 · Physical Review Letters

Comment on “Critical Behavior in Disordered Quantum Systems Modified by Broken Time-Reversal Symmetry”

Martin Janßen, Boris Shapiro, Imre Varga

Published Oct 5, 1998• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In a recent Letter [Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 1003 (1998)] Hussein and Pato employed the maximum entropy principle (MEP) in order to derive interpolating ensembles between any pair of universality classes in random matrix theory. They apply their formalism also to the transition from random matrix to Poisson statistics of spectra that is observed for the case of the Anderson-type metal-insulator transition. We point out the problems with the latter procedure.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.81.3048

Related papers

Critical Behavior in Disordered Quantum Systems Modified by Broken Time-Reversal Symmetry

Mahir Saleh Hussein, Mauricio Porto Pato

It is shown that the maximum entropy principle provides a natural basis for construction of an interpolating ensemble between any pair of the universality classes of random matrix theory. As an application, the Gaussian unitary ensemble to Gaussian orthogonal ensemble transition is worked out in detail. Transitions from these two ensembles to a Poisson distribution, of relevance to the metal-insulator transition in disordered metals, is also discussed in detail and the ``universal critical ensemble'' was found to depend on the time-reversal symmetry.

Physical Review Letters•Feb 2, 1998•21 citations

Universal Critical Exponent in Class D Superconductors

V. Kagalovsky, Demitry Nemirovsky

We study a physical system consisting of noninteracting quasiparticles in disordered superconductors that have neither time-reversal nor spin-rotation invariance. This system belongs to class D within the recent classification scheme of random matrix ensembles, and its phase diagram contains three different phases: metallic and two distinct localized phases with different quantized thermal Hall conductances. We find that critical exponents describing different transitions (insulator-to-insulator and insulator-to-metal) are identical within the error of numerical calculations and also find that critical disorder of the insulator-to-metal transition is energy-independent.

arXiv:0806.2744•Physical Review Letters•Sep 16, 2008•13 citations

Universal relation between spectral and wavefunction properties at criticality

Simon Jiricek, Miroslav Hopjan, V. E. Kravtsov +2 more

Quantum-chaotic systems exhibit several universal properties, ranging from level repulsion in the energy spectrum to wavefunction delocalization. On the other hand, if wavefunctions are localized, the energy levels exhibit no level repulsion and their statistics is Poisson. At the boundary between quantum chaos and localization, however, one observes critical behavior, not complying with any of those characteristics. An outstanding open question is whether there exists yet another type of universality, which is genuine for the critical point. Previous work suggested that there may exist a relation between the global characteristics of the energy spectrum, such as the spectral compressibility χ , and the degree of wavefunction delocalization, expressed via the fractal dimension D 1 of the Shannon–von Neumann entropy in a preferred (e.g., real-space) basis. Here, we study physical systems subject to local and nonlocal hopping, both with and without time-reversal symmetry, with the Anderson models in dimensions three to five being representatives of the first class, and the random banded matrices as representatives of the second class. Our thorough numerical analysis supports the validity of the simple relation χ + D 1 = 1 in all systems under investigation. Hence, we conjecture that it represents a universal property of a broad class of critical models. Moreover, we test and confirm the accuracy of our surmise for a closed-form expression of the spectral compressibility in the one-parameter critical manifold of random banded matrices. Based on these findings, we derive a universal function D 1 ( r ) of the averaged level spacing ratio r , which is valid for a broad class of critical systems.

arXiv:2506.11675•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Feb 6, 2026•4 citations

Quantum criticality at the Anderson transition: A typical medium theory perspective

Samiyeh Mahmoudian, Shao Hui Tang, V. Dobrosavljević

We present a complete analytical and numerical solution of the typical medium theory (TMT) for the Anderson metal-insulator transition. This approach self-consistently calculates the typical amplitude of the electronic wave functions, thus representing the conceptually simplest order-parameter theory for the Anderson transition. We identify all possible universality classes for the critical behavior, which can be found within such a mean-field approach. This provides insights into how interaction-induced renormalizations of the disorder potential may produce qualitative modifications of the critical behavior. We also formulate a simplified description of the leading critical behavior, thus obtaining an effective Landau theory for Anderson localization.

arXiv:1411.4558•Physical Review B•Oct 30, 2015•9 citations

Comment on “Disorder Induced Quantum Phase Transition in Random-Exchange Spin- 1/2 Chains”

Nicolas Laflorencie, Heiko Rieger

We reconsider the random bond antiferromagnetic spin-1/2 chain for weak disorder and demonstrate the existence of crossover length scale x_W that diverges with decreasing strength of the disorder. Recent DMRG calculations [Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 127202 (2002); cond-mat/0111027] claimed to have found evidence for a non-universal behavior in this model and found no indications of a universal infinite randomness fixed point (IRFP) scenario. We show that these data are not in the asymptotic regime since the system sizes that have been considered are of the same order of magnitude or much smaller than the crossover length x_W. We give a scaling form for the xx-spin-correlation function that takes this crossover length into account and that is compatible with the IRFP scenario and a random singlet phase.

arXiv:cond-mat/0212099•Physical Review Letters•Nov 26, 2003•17 citations

Symmetry relations for multifractal spectra at random critical points

Cécile Monthus, Bertrand Berche, Christophe Chatelain

Random critical points are generically characterized by multifractal properties. In the field of Anderson localization, Mirlin, Fyodorov, Mildenberger and Evers [Phys. Rev. Lett 97, 046803 (2006)] have proposed that the singularity spectrum $f(α)$ of eigenfunctions satisfies the exact symmetry $f(2d-α)=f(α)+d-α$ at any Anderson transition. In the present paper, we analyse the physical origin of this symmetry in relation with the Gallavotti-Cohen fluctuation relations of large deviation functions that are well-known in the field of non-equilibrium dynamics: the multifractal spectrum of the disordered model corresponds to the large deviation function of the rescaling exponent $γ=(α-d)$ along a renormalization trajectory in the effective time $t=\ln L$. We conclude that the symmetry discovered on the specific example of Anderson transitions should actually be satisfied at many other random critical points after an appropriate translation. For many-body random phase transitions, where the critical properties are usually analyzed in terms of the multifractal spectrum $H(a)$ and of the moments exponents X(N) of two-point correlation function [A. Ludwig, Nucl. Phys. B330, 639 (1990)], the symmetry becomes $H(2X(1) -a)= H(a) + a-X(1)$, or equivalently $Δ(N)=Δ(1-N)$ for the anomalous parts $Δ(N) \equiv X(N)-NX(1)$. We present numerical tests in favor of this symmetry for the 2D random $Q-$state Potts model with various $Q$.

arXiv:0909.0584•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Dec 3, 2009•27 citations
In a recent Letter [Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 1003 (1998)] Hussein and Pato employed the maximum entropy principle (MEP) in order to derive interpolating ensembles between any pair of universality classes in random matrix theory. They apply their formalism also to the transition from random matrix to Poisson statistics of spectra that is observed for the case of the Anderson-type metal-insulator transition. We point out the problems with the latter procedure.
It is shown that the maximum entropy principle provides a natural basis for construction of an interpolating ensemble between any pair of the universality classes of random matrix theory. As an application, the Gaussian unitary ensemble to Gaussian orthogonal ensemble transition is worked out in detail. Transitions from these two ensembles to a Poisson distribution, of relevance to the metal-insulator transition in disordered metals, is also discussed in detail and the ``universal critical ensemble'' was found to depend on the time-reversal symmetry.
We study a physical system consisting of noninteracting quasiparticles in disordered superconductors that have neither time-reversal nor spin-rotation invariance. This system belongs to class D within the recent classification scheme of random matrix ensembles, and its phase diagram contains three different phases: metallic and two distinct localized phases with different quantized thermal Hall conductances. We find that critical exponents describing different transitions (insulator-to-insulator and insulator-to-metal) are identical within the error of numerical calculations and also find that critical disorder of the insulator-to-metal transition is energy-independent.
Quantum-chaotic systems exhibit several universal properties, ranging from level repulsion in the energy spectrum to wavefunction delocalization. On the other hand, if wavefunctions are localized, the energy levels exhibit no level repulsion and their statistics is Poisson. At the boundary between quantum chaos and localization, however, one observes critical behavior, not complying with any of those characteristics. An outstanding open question is whether there exists yet another type of universality, which is genuine for the critical point. Previous work suggested that there may exist a relation between the global characteristics of the energy spectrum, such as the spectral compressibility χ , and the degree of wavefunction delocalization, expressed via the fractal dimension D 1 of the Shannon–von Neumann entropy in a preferred (e.g., real-space) basis. Here, we study physical systems subject to local and nonlocal hopping, both with and without time-reversal symmetry, with the Anderson models in dimensions three to five being representatives of the first class, and the random banded matrices as representatives of the second class. Our thorough numerical analysis supports the validity of the simple relation χ + D 1 = 1 in all systems under investigation. Hence, we conjecture that it represents a universal property of a broad class of critical models. Moreover, we test and confirm the accuracy of our surmise for a closed-form expression of the spectral compressibility in the one-parameter critical manifold of random banded matrices. Based on these findings, we derive a universal function D 1 ( r ) of the averaged level spacing ratio r , which is valid for a broad class of critical systems.
We present a complete analytical and numerical solution of the typical medium theory (TMT) for the Anderson metal-insulator transition. This approach self-consistently calculates the typical amplitude of the electronic wave functions, thus representing the conceptually simplest order-parameter theory for the Anderson transition. We identify all possible universality classes for the critical behavior, which can be found within such a mean-field approach. This provides insights into how interaction-induced renormalizations of the disorder potential may produce qualitative modifications of the critical behavior. We also formulate a simplified description of the leading critical behavior, thus obtaining an effective Landau theory for Anderson localization.
We reconsider the random bond antiferromagnetic spin-1/2 chain for weak disorder and demonstrate the existence of crossover length scale x_W that diverges with decreasing strength of the disorder. Recent DMRG calculations [Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 127202 (2002); cond-mat/0111027] claimed to have found evidence for a non-universal behavior in this model and found no indications of a universal infinite randomness fixed point (IRFP) scenario. We show that these data are not in the asymptotic regime since the system sizes that have been considered are of the same order of magnitude or much smaller than the crossover length x_W. We give a scaling form for the xx-spin-correlation function that takes this crossover length into account and that is compatible with the IRFP scenario and a random singlet phase.
Random critical points are generically characterized by multifractal properties. In the field of Anderson localization, Mirlin, Fyodorov, Mildenberger and Evers [Phys. Rev. Lett 97, 046803 (2006)] have proposed that the singularity spectrum f(α)f(α)f(α) of eigenfunctions satisfies the exact symmetry f(2d−α)=f(α)+d−αf(2d-α)=f(α)+d-αf(2d−α)=f(α)+d−α at any Anderson transition. In the present paper, we analyse the physical origin of this symmetry in relation with the Gallavotti-Cohen fluctuation relations of large deviation functions that are well-known in the field of non-equilibrium dynamics: the multifractal spectrum of the disordered model corresponds to the large deviation function of the rescaling exponent γ=(α−d)γ=(α-d)γ=(α−d) along a renormalization trajectory in the effective time t=ln⁡Lt=\ln Lt=lnL. We conclude that the symmetry discovered on the specific example of Anderson transitions should actually be satisfied at many other random critical points after an appropriate translation. For many-body random phase transitions, where the critical properties are usually analyzed in terms of the multifractal spectrum H(a)H(a)H(a) and of the moments exponents X(N) of two-point correlation function [A. Ludwig, Nucl. Phys. B330, 639 (1990)], the symmetry becomes H(2X(1)−a)=H(a)+a−X(1)H(2X(1) -a)= H(a) + a-X(1)H(2X(1)−a)=H(a)+a−X(1), or equivalently Δ(N)=Δ(1−N)Δ(N)=Δ(1-N)Δ(N)=Δ(1−N) for the anomalous parts Δ(N)≡X(N)−NX(1)Δ(N) \equiv X(N)-NX(1)Δ(N)≡X(N)−NX(1). We present numerical tests in favor of this symmetry for the 2D random Q−Q-Q−state Potts model with various QQQ.