Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/9707323 · Physical Review Letters

Superfluidity in Sympathetic Cooling with Atomic Bose-Einstein Condensates

Eddy Timmermans, Robin Côté

Published Apr 20, 1998• 84 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The dynamical structure of an atomic Bose-Einstein condensate limits the efficiency of the condensate in cooling slow impurity atoms. To illustrate the point, we show that an impurity atom moving in a homogeneous zero-temperature condensate is not scattered incoherently if its velocity is lower than the condensate sound velocity $c$, limiting cooling to velocities $v\ensuremath{\ge}c$. This striking effect is an expression of superfluidity and provides a direct means to detect the fundamental property of superfluidity in atomic condensates. Furthermore, we show that the fermionic lithium isotope, ${}^{6}\mathrm{Li}$, is a reasonable candidate for sympathetic cooling by a ${}^{23}\mathrm{Na}$ condensate.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.80.3419

Related papers

Bose-Einstein condensation of Sr88 through sympathetic cooling with Sr87

Pascal G. Mickelson, Y. N. Martinez de Escobar, Mi Yan +2 more

We report Bose-Einstein condensation of $^{88}\mathrm{Sr}$, which has a small, negative $s$-wave scattering length (${a}_{88}=\ensuremath{-}2{a}_{0}$). We overcome the poor evaporative cooling characteristics of this isotope by sympathetic cooling with $^{87}\mathrm{Sr}$ atoms. $^{87}\mathrm{Sr}$ is effective in this role despite the fact that it is a fermion because of the large ground-state degeneracy arising from a nuclear spin of $I=9/2$, which reduces the impact of Pauli blocking of collisions. We observe a limited number of atoms in the condensate (${N}_{\mathrm{max}}\ensuremath{\approx}{10}^{4}$) that is consistent with the value of ${a}_{88}$ and the optical dipole trap parameters.

arXiv:1003.3867•Physical Review A•May 5, 2010•61 citations

Beyond superfluidity in non-equilibrium Bose–Einstein condensates

Florian Pinsker

The phenomenon of superfluidity in open Bose–Einstein condensates (BEC) is analysed numerically and analytically. It is found that a superfluid phase is feasible above the speed of sound, when forces due to inhomogeneous non-equilibrium processes oppose the contributions of homogeneous processes. Furthermore a regime of accelerating impurities can be observed for particular pumping/decay strategies. All findings are derived within the complex Gross–Pitaevskii (GP) theory extended to include creation and annihilation terms. Utilising this framework the effective force acting on an impurity as it moves with velocity v through the open condensate can be calculated. The result shows that the drag force is continuously increasing with increasing velocity starting from the state of zero motion at v = 0, a property that can be traced down to the additional homogeneous annihilation/creation term in the extended GP model. For very large velocities however we observe a reversion of the drag force. Our findings stand in stark contrast to the concept of a topological phase transition to frictionless flow below a critical velocity as observed for equilibrium BEC analytically (Astrakharchik and Pitaevskii 2004 Phys. Rev. A 70 013608; Pinsker 2017 Physica B 521 36–42), numerically (Winiecki et al 1999 Phys. Rev. Lett. 82 26) and for trapped atoms experimentally (Desbuquois et al 2012 Nat. Phys. 8 645; Zwierlein et al 2006 Nature 442 54–58).

arXiv:1611.03430•New Journal of Physics•Oct 23, 2017•4 citations

SYMPATHETIC COOLING OF FERMIONIC LITHIUM VIA A BOSONIC RUBIDIUM GAS

S. Günther, C. SILBER, C. Marzok +3 more

The Pauli exclusion principle inhibits s-wave collisions between fermionic 6 Li atoms and renders thermalization and evaporative cooling at low temperatures inefficient. A way around this problem is sympathetic cooling by a different actively cooled atomic species. With this technique, using bosonic 87 Rb as cooling agent, we obtain a mixture of quantum-degenerate gases, where the Rb cloud is colder than the critical temperature for Bose-Einstein condensation and the Li cloud colder than the Fermi temperature. From measurements of the thermalization velocity we estimate the interspecies s-wave triplet scattering length .

Laser Spectroscopy•Dec 1, 2005•0 citations

Experiments with Ultracold Quantum-degenerate Fermionic Lithium Atoms

Wolfgang Ketterle

Experimental methods of laser and evaporative cooling, used in the production of atomic Bose-Einstein condensates have recently been extended to realize quantum degeneracy in trapped Fermi gases. Fermi gases are a new rich system to explore the implications of Pauli exclusion on scattering properties of the system, and ultimately fermionic superfluidity. We have produced a new macroscopic quantum system, in which a degenerate Li-6 Fermi gas coexists with a large and stable Na-23 BEC. This was accomplished using inter-species sympathetic cooling of fermionic 6Li in a thermal bath of bosonic Na-23. We have achieved high numbers of both fermions (less than 10(exp 5) and bosons (less than 10(exp 6), and Li-6 quantum degeneracy corresponding to one half of the Fermi temperature. This is the first time that a Fermi sea was produced with a condensate as a "refrigerator".

•Jan 1, 2003•0 citations

Quantum Degenerate Bosonic and Fermionic Gases: A 7 Li Bose-Einstein Condensate Immersed in a 6 Li Fermi Sea

Lev Khaykovich, Florian Schreck, Kristan L. Corwin +4 more

Using sympathetic cooling between fermionic and bosonic lithium atoms in a magnetic trap, we have reached quantum degeneracy for both species 1 . In a first set of experiments we trap both isotopes in their upper hyperfine states where bosonic 7 Li atoms have a negative scattering length. We observe a common temperature of T ∼ 1μ K , which corresponds to the Bose-Einstein condensation critical temperature T C while T/T F = 0.22(5) where T F is the Fermi temperature of 6 Li . In the second set of experiments both isotopes are trapped in their lower hyperfine states. We produce a stable 7 Li condensate because of the positive scattering length in this state. With a very small fraction of thermal atoms, the condensate is quasi-pure and coexists with the 6 Li Fermi sea. The lowest common temperature is 0.28 μ K ≃ 0.2(1) T C = 0.2(1) T F . The 7 Li condensate has a one-dimensional character.

Laser Spectroscopy•Jun 1, 2002•0 citations

Superfluids and superfluid mixtures in atom traps

Eddy Timmermans

Superfluidity has become a topic of active interest in the field of atom trap Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs). We motivate this line of research by placing the BEC developments against the general backdrop of the theory of superfluidity and by highlighting the advantages offered by the atom trap technology. We review the standard description of the BEC dynamics, as well as basic concepts of superfluidity and we present theoretical arguments for expecting the BECs to exhibit superfluid behaviour. In atom traps, as in condensed and nuclear matter, superfluidity can manifest itself in a manifold of guises. Moreover, some of its manifestations can even be undesirable, as we illustrate by the poignant example of sympathetic cooling with condensates. We also review recent experimental evidence for superfluid BEC behaviour and we suggest further experiments to probe superfluidity in atom traps. The low densities of the BECs allow optical imaging and imply that the relevant physics occurs on time and length scales that are much slower and larger than in the traditional 4He superfluid. Consequently, BEC experiments can study known superfluid phenomena and structures in a different and, perhaps, more detailed manner. In addition, the flexibility offered by existing techniques in atomic, molecular and optical physics is unprecedented in the field of low-temperature physics and suggests the prospect of creating superfluids of fundamentally novel structures. Finally, it is conceivable that new applications of superfluidity may arise from these studies.

Contemporary Physics•Jan 1, 2001•10 citations
The dynamical structure of an atomic Bose-Einstein condensate limits the efficiency of the condensate in cooling slow impurity atoms. To illustrate the point, we show that an impurity atom moving in a homogeneous zero-temperature condensate is not scattered incoherently if its velocity is lower than the condensate sound velocity ccc, limiting cooling to velocities v\ensuremath≥cv\ensuremath{\ge}cv\ensuremath≥c. This striking effect is an expression of superfluidity and provides a direct means to detect the fundamental property of superfluidity in atomic condensates. Furthermore, we show that the fermionic lithium isotope, 6Li{}^{6}\mathrm{Li}6Li, is a reasonable candidate for sympathetic cooling by a 23Na{}^{23}\mathrm{Na}23Na condensate.
We report Bose-Einstein condensation of 88Sr^{88}\mathrm{Sr}88Sr, which has a small, negative sss-wave scattering length (${a}_{88}=\ensuremath{-}2{a}_{0}$). We overcome the poor evaporative cooling characteristics of this isotope by sympathetic cooling with 87Sr^{87}\mathrm{Sr}87Sr atoms. 87Sr^{87}\mathrm{Sr}87Sr is effective in this role despite the fact that it is a fermion because of the large ground-state degeneracy arising from a nuclear spin of I=9/2I=9/2I=9/2, which reduces the impact of Pauli blocking of collisions. We observe a limited number of atoms in the condensate (${N}_{\mathrm{max}}\ensuremath{\approx}{10}^{4}$) that is consistent with the value of a88{a}_{88}a88​ and the optical dipole trap parameters.
The phenomenon of superfluidity in open Bose–Einstein condensates (BEC) is analysed numerically and analytically. It is found that a superfluid phase is feasible above the speed of sound, when forces due to inhomogeneous non-equilibrium processes oppose the contributions of homogeneous processes. Furthermore a regime of accelerating impurities can be observed for particular pumping/decay strategies. All findings are derived within the complex Gross–Pitaevskii (GP) theory extended to include creation and annihilation terms. Utilising this framework the effective force acting on an impurity as it moves with velocity v through the open condensate can be calculated. The result shows that the drag force is continuously increasing with increasing velocity starting from the state of zero motion at v = 0, a property that can be traced down to the additional homogeneous annihilation/creation term in the extended GP model. For very large velocities however we observe a reversion of the drag force. Our findings stand in stark contrast to the concept of a topological phase transition to frictionless flow below a critical velocity as observed for equilibrium BEC analytically (Astrakharchik and Pitaevskii 2004 Phys. Rev. A 70 013608; Pinsker 2017 Physica B 521 36–42), numerically (Winiecki et al 1999 Phys. Rev. Lett. 82 26) and for trapped atoms experimentally (Desbuquois et al 2012 Nat. Phys. 8 645; Zwierlein et al 2006 Nature 442 54–58).
The Pauli exclusion principle inhibits s-wave collisions between fermionic 6 Li atoms and renders thermalization and evaporative cooling at low temperatures inefficient. A way around this problem is sympathetic cooling by a different actively cooled atomic species. With this technique, using bosonic 87 Rb as cooling agent, we obtain a mixture of quantum-degenerate gases, where the Rb cloud is colder than the critical temperature for Bose-Einstein condensation and the Li cloud colder than the Fermi temperature. From measurements of the thermalization velocity we estimate the interspecies s-wave triplet scattering length .
Experimental methods of laser and evaporative cooling, used in the production of atomic Bose-Einstein condensates have recently been extended to realize quantum degeneracy in trapped Fermi gases. Fermi gases are a new rich system to explore the implications of Pauli exclusion on scattering properties of the system, and ultimately fermionic superfluidity. We have produced a new macroscopic quantum system, in which a degenerate Li-6 Fermi gas coexists with a large and stable Na-23 BEC. This was accomplished using inter-species sympathetic cooling of fermionic 6Li in a thermal bath of bosonic Na-23. We have achieved high numbers of both fermions (less than 10(exp 5) and bosons (less than 10(exp 6), and Li-6 quantum degeneracy corresponding to one half of the Fermi temperature. This is the first time that a Fermi sea was produced with a condensate as a "refrigerator".
Using sympathetic cooling between fermionic and bosonic lithium atoms in a magnetic trap, we have reached quantum degeneracy for both species 1 . In a first set of experiments we trap both isotopes in their upper hyperfine states where bosonic 7 Li atoms have a negative scattering length. We observe a common temperature of T ∼ 1μ K , which corresponds to the Bose-Einstein condensation critical temperature T C while T/T F = 0.22(5) where T F is the Fermi temperature of 6 Li . In the second set of experiments both isotopes are trapped in their lower hyperfine states. We produce a stable 7 Li condensate because of the positive scattering length in this state. With a very small fraction of thermal atoms, the condensate is quasi-pure and coexists with the 6 Li Fermi sea. The lowest common temperature is 0.28 μ K ≃ 0.2(1) T C = 0.2(1) T F . The 7 Li condensate has a one-dimensional character.
Superfluidity has become a topic of active interest in the field of atom trap Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs). We motivate this line of research by placing the BEC developments against the general backdrop of the theory of superfluidity and by highlighting the advantages offered by the atom trap technology. We review the standard description of the BEC dynamics, as well as basic concepts of superfluidity and we present theoretical arguments for expecting the BECs to exhibit superfluid behaviour. In atom traps, as in condensed and nuclear matter, superfluidity can manifest itself in a manifold of guises. Moreover, some of its manifestations can even be undesirable, as we illustrate by the poignant example of sympathetic cooling with condensates. We also review recent experimental evidence for superfluid BEC behaviour and we suggest further experiments to probe superfluidity in atom traps. The low densities of the BECs allow optical imaging and imply that the relevant physics occurs on time and length scales that are much slower and larger than in the traditional 4He superfluid. Consequently, BEC experiments can study known superfluid phenomena and structures in a different and, perhaps, more detailed manner. In addition, the flexibility offered by existing techniques in atomic, molecular and optical physics is unprecedented in the field of low-temperature physics and suggests the prospect of creating superfluids of fundamentally novel structures. Finally, it is conceivable that new applications of superfluidity may arise from these studies.