The ferromagnetic q-states Potts model on a square lattice is analysed, for q > 4, through an elaborate version of the operatorial variational method. In the variational approach proposed in this paper, the duality relations are exactly satisfied, involving at a more fundamental level, a duality relationship between variational parameters. Besides some exact predictions, the approach is very effective in the numerical estimates over a wide range of temperature and can be systematically improved.
A phenomenological approach to the ferromagnetic two-dimensional (2D) Potts model on square lattice is proposed. Our goal is to present a simple functional form that obeys the known properties possessed by the free energy of the q-state Potts model. The duality symmetry of the 2D Potts model together with the known results on its critical exponent α allows us to fix consistently the details of the proposed expression for the free energy. The agreement of the analytic ansatz with numerical data in the q=3 case is very good at high and low temperatures as well as at the critical point. It is shown that the q>4 cases naturally fit into the same scheme and that one should also expect a good agreement with numerical data. The limiting q=4 case is shortly discussed.
The q-state Potts model on a square lattice is transformed into a staggered ice model. A variational principle for the largest eigenvalue of the transfer matrix of this model is used to develop a set of matrix equations. In the limit of these matrices becoming infinite, the equations determine the partition function and order parameter of the Potts model exactly. We have solved the equations numerically for finite matrices, obtaining estimates of these quantities and, as a result, the critical exponent β.
The phase transition temperature T c of the q-state Potts model with ferromagnetic interactions J x and antiferromagnetic ones J y in the two respective directions of a 2D lattice is calculated by the high-temperature series expansion (HTSE) of the appropriate staggered susceptibility as well a by the cluster variate approximation (CVA). For q=3 the HTSE result in the range of mod J y mod /J x <or approximately=1.5 shows a good coincidence with the Kosterlitz-Thouless-type phase transition temperature calculated on the prescription by Ostlund which is given by 1/16 pi =exp(-2 beta c J x ) coth(- beta c J y /2), beta =1/kT c . The CVA result shows similar behaviour of T c to that of the Migdal-Kadanoff renormalisation group method obtained by Kinzel et al, but it is considered to be less reliable than the HTSE result.
We report some results on the complex-temperature (CT) singularities of
q-state Potts models on the square lattice. We concentrate on the problematic region
Re(a)<0 (where
a=eK) in which CT zeros of the partition function are sensitive to finite lattice artifacts. From analyses of low-temperature series expansions for
3< q< 8, we establish the existence, in this region, of complex-conjugate CT singularities at which the magnetization and susceptibility diverge. From calculations of zeros of the partition function, we obtain evidence consistent with the inference that these singularities occur at endpoints
ae,
ae∗ of arcs protruding into the (complex-temperature extension of the) ferromagnetic phase. Exponents for these singularities are determined; e.g., for
q=3, we find ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{e}=\ensuremath{-}0.125(1)$, consistent with ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{e}=\ensuremath{-}\frac{1}{8}$. By duality, these results also imply associated arcs extending into the (CT extension of the) symmetric paramagnetic phase. Analytic expressions are suggested for the positions of some of these singularities; e.g., for
q=5, our finding is consistent with the exact value
ae, ${a}_{e}^{*}=2(\ensuremath{-}1\ensuremath{\mp}i)$. Further discussions of complex-temperature phase diagrams are given.