Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/9312089

Spin-gap formation in cuprates: gauge theory

Menke U. Ubbens, Patrick A. Lee

Published Dec 22, 1993• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We analyze the phase diagram of single and bi-layer cuprates using the gauge-field description of the t-J model. For $T>T_{\text{BE}}$ the in-plane fermion-pairing order parameter $Δ_{\scriptscriptstyle\parallel}$ is eliminated by gauge field fluctuations, leading us to predict the absence of a spin-gap phase in single-layer cuprates. For bi-layer cuprates the inter-layer order parameter $Δ_\perp$ is enhanced by spin correlations, and is less affected by gauge fluctuations. We believe that the spin gap in bi-layer materials is due to inter-layer fermion pairing, and that for these underdoped samples the superconducting gap may be nodeless.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.cond-mat/9312089

Related papers

The superconducting phase diagram of the t-J model

Menke U. Ubbens

In this thesis I present a microscopic model for the high-To cuprates, and analyze the phase diagram predicted by this model.The model is based on the t-J Hamiltonian, which describes the physics of a single copper-oxide plane.An important feature of the t-J model is that close to half filling the motion of the electrons is controlled by the empty sites in the system.This leads to spin-charge separation, which I take into account using the slave-boson formalism.In this approach the electrons are split into spinons and holons, which carry, respectively, the spin and the charge degrees of freedom of the electrons.Superconductivity will occur when the spinons form Cooper pairs and the bosons are Bose condensed.I first analyze the model in the mean-field approximation.Novel flux phases are found at low doping, indicating that the system tries to simulate a Nel ordered state to minimize its magnetic energy.At intermediate doping the mean-field analysis predicts a superconducting gap with a d-wave symmetry.7 A drawback of the mean-field analysis is that it grossly overestimates the superconducting transition temperature, especially at low doping.One can improve on the mean-field results by including a fluctuating gauge field in the analysis.This gauge field mediates the interactions between the spinons and the holons, which are strongly coupled.I show in Chapter 3 that the fluctuating gauge field suppresses the tendency of the holons to Bose condense.8 In order to obtain this result I developed a new technique based on a summation over Feynman paths which is a very convenient approach in the strong-coupling limit t > J.Chapter 4 focuses on the pair-breaking effects of the gauge field, which can be analyzed by studying the contribution of the gauge field to the total free energy.I show that there is a significant reduction of free energy due to gauge field fluctuations, which 7 M.

•Jan 1, 1994•0 citations

Aspects of spin-charge separation in high Tc cuprates

Don H. Kim

High Tc, cuprates have a number of features that are anomalous from the point of view of the conventional theory of metals, i.e. the Fermi liquid theory. These include the high Tc itself, the linear resistivity in optimally doped cuprates, the "spin gap" phenomena, and antiferromagnetic fluctuations. Some of the basic features of the high Tc, phase diagram can be readily understood from slave boson mean field theories of the t-J model that yield a variety of phases like the uRVB phase (strange metal), d-wave RVB phase (spin gap), and the superconducting phase. This thesis is concerned with improving this picture by considering important fluctuations around the mean fields. This leads to certain gauge theories in which neutral spin 1/2 fermions ("spinons") and charged spinless bosons ("holons") are coupled to gauge fields. If the gauge field is not "confining", the spin and charge degrees of freedom are separated to some extent, and an unconventional picture for transport and magnetic properties is expected. Following an introduction and overview, the first half of the main body of this thesis analyzes a simple model of a degenerate two-dimensional Bose liquid interacting with a fluctuating gauge field, with the goal of studying the charge degree of freedom in the cuprates. It is shown that the fluctuating gauge field efficiently destroys superfluidity even in the Bose degenerate regime. The nature of the resulting normal state is discussed in terms of the geometric properties of the imaginary-time paths of the bosons. Charge response functions are studied numerically (by path integral Monte Carlo methods); it is found that the transport scattering rate behaves as ... , consistent with the experiments on the cuprates in the normal state, and that the density correlations of our model resemble the charge correlations of the t-J model. The second half considers the magnetic properties of cuprates from the point of view of a gauge theory of spinons, with emphasis on the underdoped regime. Despite the spin gap, there is a substantial antiferromagnetic correlation in the underdoped cuprates, as evidenced by the q-space scan of Neutron scattering cross section and different temperature dependences of the Copper and Oxygen site relaxation rates, features which are not captured well by mean field theories. As a concrete illustration of the gauge-fluctuation restoration of the antiferromangetic correlation and the feasibility of the 1/N perturbation theory, a U(1) gauge theory of id Heisenberg spin chain is worked out exactly, and then perturbatively. The difference between the behavior of uniform and staggerd spin correlation functions is discussed in terms of conserved and nonconserved currents. The 1/N-perturbative treatment of the gauge theory in 2+1D (which can be motivated from the mean field Flux phase of the Heisnberg model) leads to a dynamical mass generation corresponding to an antiferromagnetic ordering, but it is argued that in a similar gauge theory with an additional coupling to a Bose (holon) field, symmetry breaking does not occur, but antiferromagnetic correlations are improved, which is the situation in the underdoped cuprates.

•Jan 1, 1998•0 citations

Spin-gap phase of strongly correlated fermions

Pascal Lederer, Elihu Abrahams

We discuss the possible existence of a ``spin-gap'' phase in the low-doping regime of strongly correlated two-dimensional (2D) electrons within the gauge field description of the t-J model. The spin-gap phase was recently shown by \"Ubbens and Lee to be destroyed by gauge field quantum fluctuations for a single-layer 2D system in the absence of disorder and for a full gap. We show that the same conclusion applies both in the dirty limit and for the case of a gapless spinon condensate. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

arXiv:cond-mat/9511096•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Apr 15, 1996•3 citations

U(1) × SU (2) Gauge theory of underdoped high TC cuprates via Chern-simons bosonization

P. A. Marchetti

We outline the basic ideas involved in a recently proposed [17] derivation of a gauge theory for underdoped cuprates in the “spin gap phase”, performed essentially step by step starting from the t — J model, considered as a model Hamiltonian for the CuO2 layers. The basic tool is the U(1) x SU(2) Chern-Simons bosonization, to which it is dedicated a somewhat detailed discussion. The basic output is a “spingap” not vanishing in any direction and an antiferromagnetic correlation length proportional to the inverse square root of doping concentration, in agreement with data deduced from the neutron experiments. The model also exhibits a small half-pocket Fermi surface around (±π/2, ±π/2) and a linear in temperature dependence of in-plane resistivity in certain temperature range.

arXiv:cond-mat/9812251•Ferroelectrics•Aug 1, 2000•2 citations

Massless Dirac Fermions, Gauge Fields, and Underdoped Cuprates

Don H. Kim, Patrick A. Lee, Xiao-Gang Wen

We study $2+1$ dimensional massless Dirac fermions and bosons coupled to a U(1) gauge field as a model for underdoped cuprates. We find that the uniform susceptibility and the specific heat coefficient are logarithmically enhanced (compared to linear-in- $T$ behavior) due to the fluctuation of a transverse gauge field which is the only massless mode at finite boson density. We analyze existing data, and find good agreement in the spin gap phase. Within our picture, the drop of the susceptibility below the superconducting ${T}_{c}$ arises from the suppression of gauge fluctuations.

arXiv:cond-mat/9702218•Physical Review Letters•Sep 15, 1997•59 citations

Quantum-disordered slave-boson theory of underdoped cuprates

Yong Baek Kim, Ziqiang Wang

We study the stability of the spin gap phase in the U (1) slave-boson theory of the t - J model in connection with the underdoped cuprates. We approach the spin gap phase from the superconducting state and consider the quantum phase transition of the slave bosons at zero temperature by introducing vortices in the boson superfluid. At finite temperatures, the properties of the bosons are different from those in the strange-metal phase and lead to modified gauge field fluctuations. As a result, the spin gap phase can be stabilized in the quantum-critical (QC) and quantum-disordered (QD) regime of the boson system. We also show that the regime of QD bosons with the paired fermions can be regarded as a strong-coupling version of the recently proposed nodal liquid theory.

arXiv:cond-mat/9901003•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Jun 1, 2000•8 citations
We analyze the phase diagram of single and bi-layer cuprates using the gauge-field description of the t-J model. For T>TBET>T_{\text{BE}}T>TBE​ the in-plane fermion-pairing order parameter Δ∥Δ_{\scriptscriptstyle\parallel}Δ∥​ is eliminated by gauge field fluctuations, leading us to predict the absence of a spin-gap phase in single-layer cuprates. For bi-layer cuprates the inter-layer order parameter Δ⊥Δ_\perpΔ⊥​ is enhanced by spin correlations, and is less affected by gauge fluctuations. We believe that the spin gap in bi-layer materials is due to inter-layer fermion pairing, and that for these underdoped samples the superconducting gap may be nodeless.
In this thesis I present a microscopic model for the high-To cuprates, and analyze the phase diagram predicted by this model.The model is based on the t-J Hamiltonian, which describes the physics of a single copper-oxide plane.An important feature of the t-J model is that close to half filling the motion of the electrons is controlled by the empty sites in the system.This leads to spin-charge separation, which I take into account using the slave-boson formalism.In this approach the electrons are split into spinons and holons, which carry, respectively, the spin and the charge degrees of freedom of the electrons.Superconductivity will occur when the spinons form Cooper pairs and the bosons are Bose condensed.I first analyze the model in the mean-field approximation.Novel flux phases are found at low doping, indicating that the system tries to simulate a Nel ordered state to minimize its magnetic energy.At intermediate doping the mean-field analysis predicts a superconducting gap with a d-wave symmetry.7 A drawback of the mean-field analysis is that it grossly overestimates the superconducting transition temperature, especially at low doping.One can improve on the mean-field results by including a fluctuating gauge field in the analysis.This gauge field mediates the interactions between the spinons and the holons, which are strongly coupled.I show in Chapter 3 that the fluctuating gauge field suppresses the tendency of the holons to Bose condense.8 In order to obtain this result I developed a new technique based on a summation over Feynman paths which is a very convenient approach in the strong-coupling limit t > J.Chapter 4 focuses on the pair-breaking effects of the gauge field, which can be analyzed by studying the contribution of the gauge field to the total free energy.I show that there is a significant reduction of free energy due to gauge field fluctuations, which 7 M.
High Tc, cuprates have a number of features that are anomalous from the point of view of the conventional theory of metals, i.e. the Fermi liquid theory. These include the high Tc itself, the linear resistivity in optimally doped cuprates, the "spin gap" phenomena, and antiferromagnetic fluctuations. Some of the basic features of the high Tc, phase diagram can be readily understood from slave boson mean field theories of the t-J model that yield a variety of phases like the uRVB phase (strange metal), d-wave RVB phase (spin gap), and the superconducting phase. This thesis is concerned with improving this picture by considering important fluctuations around the mean fields. This leads to certain gauge theories in which neutral spin 1/2 fermions ("spinons") and charged spinless bosons ("holons") are coupled to gauge fields. If the gauge field is not "confining", the spin and charge degrees of freedom are separated to some extent, and an unconventional picture for transport and magnetic properties is expected. Following an introduction and overview, the first half of the main body of this thesis analyzes a simple model of a degenerate two-dimensional Bose liquid interacting with a fluctuating gauge field, with the goal of studying the charge degree of freedom in the cuprates. It is shown that the fluctuating gauge field efficiently destroys superfluidity even in the Bose degenerate regime. The nature of the resulting normal state is discussed in terms of the geometric properties of the imaginary-time paths of the bosons. Charge response functions are studied numerically (by path integral Monte Carlo methods); it is found that the transport scattering rate behaves as ... , consistent with the experiments on the cuprates in the normal state, and that the density correlations of our model resemble the charge correlations of the t-J model. The second half considers the magnetic properties of cuprates from the point of view of a gauge theory of spinons, with emphasis on the underdoped regime. Despite the spin gap, there is a substantial antiferromagnetic correlation in the underdoped cuprates, as evidenced by the q-space scan of Neutron scattering cross section and different temperature dependences of the Copper and Oxygen site relaxation rates, features which are not captured well by mean field theories. As a concrete illustration of the gauge-fluctuation restoration of the antiferromangetic correlation and the feasibility of the 1/N perturbation theory, a U(1) gauge theory of id Heisenberg spin chain is worked out exactly, and then perturbatively. The difference between the behavior of uniform and staggerd spin correlation functions is discussed in terms of conserved and nonconserved currents. The 1/N-perturbative treatment of the gauge theory in 2+1D (which can be motivated from the mean field Flux phase of the Heisnberg model) leads to a dynamical mass generation corresponding to an antiferromagnetic ordering, but it is argued that in a similar gauge theory with an additional coupling to a Bose (holon) field, symmetry breaking does not occur, but antiferromagnetic correlations are improved, which is the situation in the underdoped cuprates.
We discuss the possible existence of a ``spin-gap'' phase in the low-doping regime of strongly correlated two-dimensional (2D) electrons within the gauge field description of the t-J model. The spin-gap phase was recently shown by \"Ubbens and Lee to be destroyed by gauge field quantum fluctuations for a single-layer 2D system in the absence of disorder and for a full gap. We show that the same conclusion applies both in the dirty limit and for the case of a gapless spinon condensate. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
We outline the basic ideas involved in a recently proposed [17] derivation of a gauge theory for underdoped cuprates in the “spin gap phase”, performed essentially step by step starting from the t — J model, considered as a model Hamiltonian for the CuO2 layers. The basic tool is the U(1) x SU(2) Chern-Simons bosonization, to which it is dedicated a somewhat detailed discussion. The basic output is a “spingap” not vanishing in any direction and an antiferromagnetic correlation length proportional to the inverse square root of doping concentration, in agreement with data deduced from the neutron experiments. The model also exhibits a small half-pocket Fermi surface around (±π/2, ±π/2) and a linear in temperature dependence of in-plane resistivity in certain temperature range.
We study 2+12+12+1 dimensional massless Dirac fermions and bosons coupled to a U(1) gauge field as a model for underdoped cuprates. We find that the uniform susceptibility and the specific heat coefficient are logarithmically enhanced (compared to linear-in- TTT behavior) due to the fluctuation of a transverse gauge field which is the only massless mode at finite boson density. We analyze existing data, and find good agreement in the spin gap phase. Within our picture, the drop of the susceptibility below the superconducting Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ arises from the suppression of gauge fluctuations.
We study the stability of the spin gap phase in the U (1) slave-boson theory of the t - J model in connection with the underdoped cuprates. We approach the spin gap phase from the superconducting state and consider the quantum phase transition of the slave bosons at zero temperature by introducing vortices in the boson superfluid. At finite temperatures, the properties of the bosons are different from those in the strange-metal phase and lead to modified gauge field fluctuations. As a result, the spin gap phase can be stabilized in the quantum-critical (QC) and quantum-disordered (QD) regime of the boson system. We also show that the regime of QD bosons with the paired fermions can be regarded as a strong-coupling version of the recently proposed nodal liquid theory.