Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0605038 · Physical Review A

Evolution of additional (hidden) quantum variables in the interference of Bose-Einstein condensates

William J. Mullin, Robert V. Krotkov, Franck Laloë

Published Aug 18, 2006• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Additional variables (also often called ``hidden variables'') are sometimes added to standard quantum mechanics in order to remove its indeterminism or ``incompleteness'' and to make the measurement process look more classical. Here we discuss a case in which an additional variable arises almost spontaneously from the quantum formalism: the emergence of a relative phase between two highly populated Fock-state Bose-Einstein condensates. The model simulated here involves the interference of two Bose condensates, one with all up spins and the other with down spins, along a $z$ axis. With the clouds overlapping, we consider the results of measuring spins in a transverse plane (the general direction is studied in an appendix). The determination of the previously ``hidden'' phase becomes progressively more definite as additional measurements are made. We also provide an analysis of a recent and closely related experiment.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.74.023610

Related papers

The origin of the phase in the interference of Bose-Einstein condensates

William J. Mullin, Robert V. Krotkov, Franck Laloë

We consider the interference of two overlapping ideal Bose-Einstein condensates. The usual description of this phenomenon involves the introduction of a condensate wave function with a definite phase. We investigate the origin of this phase and the theoretical basis of treating interference. It is possible to construct a phase state for which the particle number is uncertain, but the phase is known. How such a state would be prepared before an experiment is not obvious. We show that a phase can also arise from experiments using condensates with known particle numbers. The analysis of measurements in such states also gives us a prescription for preparing phase states. The connection of this procedure to questions of spontaneously broken gauge symmetry and to hidden variables is discussed.

arXiv:cond-mat/0604371•American Journal of Physics•Sep 12, 2006•30 citations

Classical phases and quantum angles in the description of interfering Bose-Einstein condensates

William J. Mullin, Franck Laloë

The interference of two Bose-Einstein condensates, initially in Fock states, can be described in terms of their relative phase, treated as a random unknown variable. This phase can be understood either as emerging from the measurements or pre-existing to them; in the latter case, the originating states could be phase states with unknown phases, so an average over all their possible values is taken. Both points of view lead to a description of probabilities of results of experiments in terms of a phase angle, which plays the role of a classical variable. Nevertheless, in some situations, this description is not sufficient: another variable, which we call the ``quantum angle,'' emerges from the theory. This article studies various manifestations of the quantum angle. We first introduce the quantum angle by expressing two Fock states crossing a beam splitter in terms of phase states and relate the quantum angle to off-diagonal matrix elements in the phase representation. Then we consider an experiment with two beam splitters, where two experimenters make dichotomic measurements with two interferometers and detectors that are far apart; the results lead to violations of the Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality (valid for local-realistic theories, including classical descriptions of the phase). Finally, we discuss an experiment where particles from each of two sources are either deviated via a beam splitter to a side collector or proceed to the point of interference. For a given interference result, we find ``population oscillations'' in the distributions of the deviated particles, which are entirely controlled by the quantum angle. Various versions of population oscillation experiments are discussed, with two or three independent condensates.

arXiv:0908.3012•Physical Review A•Jul 14, 2010•8 citations

Interference between Bose-Einstein condensates: quantum non-local effects

WJ Mullin, Franck Laloë

Quantum systems in Fock states do not have a phase. When two or more Bose-Einstein condensates are sent into interferometers, they nevertheless acquire a relative phase under the effect of quantum measurements. The usual explanation relies on spontaneous symmetry breaking, where phases are ascribed to all condensates and treated as unknown classical quantities. However, this image is not always sufficient: when all particles are measured, quantum mechanics predicts probabilities that are sometimes in contradiction with it, as illustrated by quantum violations of local realism. In this letter, we show that interferometers can be used to demonstrate a large variety of violations with an arbitrarily large number of particles. With two independent condensates, we find violations of the BCHSH inequalities, as well as new N-body Hardy impossibilities. With three condensates, we obtain new GHZ (Greenberger, Horne and Zeilinger) type contradictions.

•May 1, 2008•0 citations

Interference of Bose-Einstein condensates: Quantum nonlocal effects

William J. Mullin, Franck Laloë

Quantum systems in Fock states do not have a phase. When two or more Bose-Einstein condensates are sent into interferometers, they nevertheless acquire a relative phase under the effect of quantum measurements. The usual explanation relies on spontaneous symmetry breaking, where phases are ascribed to all condensates and treated as unknown classical quantities. However, this image is not always sufficient: when all particles are measured, quantum mechanics predicts probabilities that are sometimes in contradiction with it, as illustrated by quantum violations of local realism. In this Rapid communication, we show that interferometers can be used to demonstrate a large variety of violations with an arbitrarily large number of particles. With two independent condensates, we find violations of the Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequalities, as well as $N$-body Hardy impossibilities. With three condensates, we obtain Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger-type contradictions.

arXiv:0805.0105•Physical Review A•Dec 15, 2008•16 citations

Simultaneous Measurement in the Bohm-Bub Hidden-Variable Theory

J. H. Tutsch

A recently proposed theory of measurement for nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, due to Bohm and Bub, is generalized, and a mathematical analysis of the theory is presented. The fact that there are always theories of the Bohm-Bub type, given the standard formulation of quantum mechanics, is discussed. The phenomenological coefficient $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ of the original theory is defined to be the absolute value of the energy change of the system during measurement divided by $\ensuremath{\hbar}$. This definition leads to a Heisenberg-like relation between the average energy change of the system during the measurement process and the collapse time, but the new relation depends on the so-called hidden variables, and hence could lead to non-quantum-mechanical effects. The time dependence of the hidden variables is considered, and they are then assumed to be constant for each individual system. An experiment is proposed which would test this assumption. A positive result would disagree significantly with the quantum-mechanical prediction. The question of whether or not the new variables must remain unobservable is analyzed mathematically. A rigorous definition of simultaneous measurement is made, and the resulting interference is given a mathematical description.

Physical Review•Jul 25, 1969•13 citations

Nonlocal Quantum Effects with Bose-Einstein Condensates

Franck Laloë, William J. Mullin

We study theoretically the properties of two Bose-Einstein condensates in different spin states, represented by a double Fock state. Individual measurements of the spins of the particles are performed in transverse directions, giving access to the relative phase of the condensates. Initially, this phase is completely undefined, and the first measurements provide random results. But a fixed value of this phase rapidly emerges under the effect of the successive quantum measurements, giving rise to a quasiclassical situation where all spins have parallel transverse orientations. If the number of measurements reaches its maximum (the number of particles), quantum effects show up again, giving rise to violations of Bell type inequalities. The violation of Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequalities with an arbitrarily large number of spins may be comparable (or even equal) to that obtained with two spins.

arXiv:0704.0386•Physical Review Letters•Oct 8, 2007•56 citations
Additional variables (also often called hidden variables'') are sometimes added to standard quantum mechanics in order to remove its indeterminism or incompleteness'' and to make the measurement process look more classical. Here we discuss a case in which an additional variable arises almost spontaneously from the quantum formalism: the emergence of a relative phase between two highly populated Fock-state Bose-Einstein condensates. The model simulated here involves the interference of two Bose condensates, one with all up spins and the other with down spins, along a zzz axis. With the clouds overlapping, we consider the results of measuring spins in a transverse plane (the general direction is studied in an appendix). The determination of the previously ``hidden'' phase becomes progressively more definite as additional measurements are made. We also provide an analysis of a recent and closely related experiment.
We consider the interference of two overlapping ideal Bose-Einstein condensates. The usual description of this phenomenon involves the introduction of a condensate wave function with a definite phase. We investigate the origin of this phase and the theoretical basis of treating interference. It is possible to construct a phase state for which the particle number is uncertain, but the phase is known. How such a state would be prepared before an experiment is not obvious. We show that a phase can also arise from experiments using condensates with known particle numbers. The analysis of measurements in such states also gives us a prescription for preparing phase states. The connection of this procedure to questions of spontaneously broken gauge symmetry and to hidden variables is discussed.
The interference of two Bose-Einstein condensates, initially in Fock states, can be described in terms of their relative phase, treated as a random unknown variable. This phase can be understood either as emerging from the measurements or pre-existing to them; in the latter case, the originating states could be phase states with unknown phases, so an average over all their possible values is taken. Both points of view lead to a description of probabilities of results of experiments in terms of a phase angle, which plays the role of a classical variable. Nevertheless, in some situations, this description is not sufficient: another variable, which we call the ``quantum angle,'' emerges from the theory. This article studies various manifestations of the quantum angle. We first introduce the quantum angle by expressing two Fock states crossing a beam splitter in terms of phase states and relate the quantum angle to off-diagonal matrix elements in the phase representation. Then we consider an experiment with two beam splitters, where two experimenters make dichotomic measurements with two interferometers and detectors that are far apart; the results lead to violations of the Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality (valid for local-realistic theories, including classical descriptions of the phase). Finally, we discuss an experiment where particles from each of two sources are either deviated via a beam splitter to a side collector or proceed to the point of interference. For a given interference result, we find ``population oscillations'' in the distributions of the deviated particles, which are entirely controlled by the quantum angle. Various versions of population oscillation experiments are discussed, with two or three independent condensates.
Quantum systems in Fock states do not have a phase. When two or more Bose-Einstein condensates are sent into interferometers, they nevertheless acquire a relative phase under the effect of quantum measurements. The usual explanation relies on spontaneous symmetry breaking, where phases are ascribed to all condensates and treated as unknown classical quantities. However, this image is not always sufficient: when all particles are measured, quantum mechanics predicts probabilities that are sometimes in contradiction with it, as illustrated by quantum violations of local realism. In this letter, we show that interferometers can be used to demonstrate a large variety of violations with an arbitrarily large number of particles. With two independent condensates, we find violations of the BCHSH inequalities, as well as new N-body Hardy impossibilities. With three condensates, we obtain new GHZ (Greenberger, Horne and Zeilinger) type contradictions.
Quantum systems in Fock states do not have a phase. When two or more Bose-Einstein condensates are sent into interferometers, they nevertheless acquire a relative phase under the effect of quantum measurements. The usual explanation relies on spontaneous symmetry breaking, where phases are ascribed to all condensates and treated as unknown classical quantities. However, this image is not always sufficient: when all particles are measured, quantum mechanics predicts probabilities that are sometimes in contradiction with it, as illustrated by quantum violations of local realism. In this Rapid communication, we show that interferometers can be used to demonstrate a large variety of violations with an arbitrarily large number of particles. With two independent condensates, we find violations of the Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequalities, as well as NNN-body Hardy impossibilities. With three condensates, we obtain Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger-type contradictions.
A recently proposed theory of measurement for nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, due to Bohm and Bub, is generalized, and a mathematical analysis of the theory is presented. The fact that there are always theories of the Bohm-Bub type, given the standard formulation of quantum mechanics, is discussed. The phenomenological coefficient $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ of the original theory is defined to be the absolute value of the energy change of the system during measurement divided by $\ensuremath{\hbar}$. This definition leads to a Heisenberg-like relation between the average energy change of the system during the measurement process and the collapse time, but the new relation depends on the so-called hidden variables, and hence could lead to non-quantum-mechanical effects. The time dependence of the hidden variables is considered, and they are then assumed to be constant for each individual system. An experiment is proposed which would test this assumption. A positive result would disagree significantly with the quantum-mechanical prediction. The question of whether or not the new variables must remain unobservable is analyzed mathematically. A rigorous definition of simultaneous measurement is made, and the resulting interference is given a mathematical description.
We study theoretically the properties of two Bose-Einstein condensates in different spin states, represented by a double Fock state. Individual measurements of the spins of the particles are performed in transverse directions, giving access to the relative phase of the condensates. Initially, this phase is completely undefined, and the first measurements provide random results. But a fixed value of this phase rapidly emerges under the effect of the successive quantum measurements, giving rise to a quasiclassical situation where all spins have parallel transverse orientations. If the number of measurements reaches its maximum (the number of particles), quantum effects show up again, giving rise to violations of Bell type inequalities. The violation of Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequalities with an arbitrarily large number of spins may be comparable (or even equal) to that obtained with two spins.