In references cond-mat/9907171 and cond-mat/9606206 (Phys.Rev.B.53, 4927 (1996)) by You-Quan Li and Bin Chen, was considered a mesoscopic LC circuit with charge discreteness. So, it was proposed a finite difference Schroedinger equation for the charge time behavior. In this comment, we generalize the corresponding mesoscopic Hamiltonian in order to taken into account the dissipative effects (resistance R). Namely, a quantum term RI, proportional to the current, is added to the mesoscopic LC circuit equation. This is carried-out in analogy with the theory of Caldirola-Kanai for quantum one particle damping.
In a recent paper \cite{EH} Eriksen and Hedegard (EH) claimed that they ``clarified'' our path integral calculation \cite{GZ1} and found an error in our analysis. Here we will demonstrate that this claim is based on mathematically incorrect and physically meaningless procedure invented by the authors \cite{EH}. The main problem in the EH analysis is due to their erroneous calculation of Gaussian path integrals and has nothing to do with the momentum recoil of a particle interacting with an external bath.