Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0508205 · Physical Review B

Anomalous superconductivity and its competition with antiferromagnetism in doped Mott insulators

S. S. Kancharla, Bumsoo Kyung, David Sénéchal, Marcello Civelli, Massimo Capone, Gabriel Kotliar, A.–M. S. Tremblay

Published May 23, 2008• 205 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Proximity to a Mott insulating phase is likely to be an important physical ingredient of a theory that aims to describe high-temperature superconductivity in the cuprates. Quantum cluster methods are well suited to describe the Mott phase. Hence, as a step toward a quantitative theory of the competition between antiferromagnetism and $d$-wave superconductivity in the cuprates, we use cellular dynamical mean-field theory to compute zero-temperature properties of the two-dimensional square lattice Hubbard model. The $d$-wave order parameter is found to scale like the superexchange coupling $J$ for on-site interaction $U$ comparable to or larger than the bandwidth. The order parameter also assumes a dome shape as a function of doping, while, by contrast, the gap in the single-particle density of states decreases monotonically with increasing doping. In the presence of a finite second neighbor hopping ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$, the zero-temperature phase diagram displays the electron-hole asymmetric competition between antiferromagnetism and superconductivity that is observed experimentally in the cuprates. Adding realistic third neighbor hopping ${t}^{\ensuremath{''}}$ improves the overall agreement with the experimental phase diagram. Since band parameters can vary depending on the specific cuprate considered, the sensitivity of the theoretical phase diagram to band parameters challenges the commonly held assumption that the doping vs ${T}_{c}∕{T}_{c}^{\mathit{max}}$ phase diagram of the cuprates is universal. The calculated angle-resolved photoemission spectrum displays the observed electron-hole asymmetry. The tendency to homogeneous coexistence of the superconducting and antiferromagnetic order parameters is stronger than observed in most experiments but consistent with many theoretical results and with experiments in some layered high-temperature superconductors. Clearly, our calculations reproduce important features of $d$-wave superconductivity in the cuprates that would otherwise be considered anomalous from the point of view of the standard Bardeen--Cooper--Schrieffer approach. At strong coupling, $d$-wave superconductivity and antiferromagnetism naturally appear as two equally important competing instabilities of the normal phase of the same underlying Hamiltonian.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.77.184516

Related papers

Competition between Antiferromagnetism and Superconductivity in High- T c Cuprates

David Sénéchal, Pierre-Luc Lavertu, M.-A. Marois +1 more

Using variational cluster perturbation theory we study the competition between $d$-wave superconductivity ($d\mathrm{SC}$) and antiferromagnetism (AF) in the $t\mathrm{\text{\ensuremath{-}}}{t}^{\ensuremath{'}}\mathrm{\text{\ensuremath{-}}}{t}^{\ensuremath{'}\ensuremath{'}}\mathrm{\text{\ensuremath{-}}}U$ Hubbard model. Large scale computer calculations reproduce the overall ground-state phase diagram of the high-temperature superconductors as well as the one-particle excitation spectra for both hole and electron doping. We identify clear signatures of the Mott gap as well as of AF and of $d\mathrm{SC}$ that should be observable in photoemission experiments.

arXiv:cond-mat/0410162•Physical Review Letters•Apr 20, 2005•235 citations

Antiferromagnetic to superconducting phase transition in the hole- and electron-doped Hubbard model at zero temperature

Markus Aichhorn, Enrico Arrigoni, Michael Potthoff +1 more

The competition between $d$-wave superconductivity (SC) and antiferromagnetism (AF) in the high-${T}_{c}$ cuprates is investigated by studying the hole- and electron-doped two-dimensional Hubbard model with a recently proposed variational quantum-cluster theory. The approach is shown to provide a thermodynamically consistent determination of the particle number, provided that an overall shift of the on-site energies is treated as a variational parameter. The consequences for the single-particle excitation spectra and for the phase diagram are explored. By comparing the single-particle spectra with quantum Monte Carlo and experimental data, we verify that the low-energy excitations in a strongly correlated electronic system are described appropriately. The cluster calculations also reproduce the overall ground-state phase diagram of the high-temperature superconductors. In particular, they include salient features such as the enhanced robustness of the antiferromagnetic state as a function of electron doping and the tendency towards phase separation into a mixed antiferromagnetic-superconducting phase at low doping and a pure superconducting phase at high (both hole and electron) doping.

arXiv:cond-mat/0511460•Physical Review B•Jul 13, 2006•161 citations

Phase separation and competition of superconductivity and magnetism in the two-dimensional Hubbard model: From strong to weak coupling

Markus Aichhorn, Enrico Arrigoni, Michael Potthoff +1 more

Cooperation and competition between the antiferromagnetic, $d$-wave superconducting, and Mott-insulating states are explored for the two-dimensional Hubbard model including nearest and next-nearest-neighbor hoppings at zero temperature. Using the variational cluster approach with clusters of different shapes and sizes up to 10 sites, it is found that the doping-driven transition from a phase with microscopic coexistence of antiferromagnetism and superconductivity to a purely superconducting phase is discontinuous for strong interaction and accompanied by phase separation. At half-filling the system is in an antiferromagnetic Mott-insulating state with vanishing charge compressibility. Upon decreasing the interaction strength $U$ below a certain critical value of roughly ${U}_{c}\ensuremath{\sim}4$ (in units of the nearest-neighbor hopping), however, the filling-dependent magnetic transition changes its character and becomes continuous. Phase separation or, more carefully, the tendency towards the formation of inhomogeneous states disappears. This critical value is in contrast to previous studies, where a much larger value was obtained. Moreover, we find that the system at half-filling undergoes the Mott transition from an insulator to a state with a finite charge compressibility at essentially the same value. The weakly correlated state at half-filling exhibits superconductivity microscopically admixed to the antiferromagnetic order. This scenario suggests a close relation between phase separation and the Mott-insulator physics.

arXiv:0707.3557•Physical Review B•Dec 11, 2007•64 citations

Particle-hole asymmetry and a fluctuating pair-density-wave state in a lightly doped Mott insulator on the square lattice

Hao-Xin Wang, Zheng-Yuan Yue, Wen-Yuan Liu +1 more

Whether a lightly doped Mott insulator on the square lattice supports robust $d$-wave superconductivity remains a central question in strongly correlated physics and in the microscopic theory of cuprate superconductivity. Experiments and numerical studies reveal a pronounced particle-hole asymmetry, pointing to a delicate competition among $d$-wave superconductivity, pair-density wave (PDW), stripe, charge-density wave (CDW), and antiferromagnetic correlations. Here we combine large-scale DMRG and finite-size PEPS to study the square-lattice $t$-$J$ model at low doping, $δ\leq 0.1$, while tuning the next-nearest-neighbor hopping $t'$ from the electron-like ($t'>0$) to the hole-like ($t'<0$) regime. The electron-like side supports robust, nearly uniform $d$-wave pairing, whereas decreasing $t'$ induces a period-two plaquette modulation and ultimately produces, on the hole-like side, a charge-dominated state with a strongly suppressed static pairing amplitude. DMRG calculations on open strips and squares, together with PEPS calculations on open squares up to $16\times16$ sites, support this evolution. On squares with $C_4$-symmetric Hamiltonians, both methods find that the pair correlations of the hole-like state select the plaquette momenta $(π,0)$ and $(0,π)$ and decay within a few lattice spacings, while the dominant charge-density modulation forms a bidirectional checkerboard whose period extrapolates to about $4a_0$, close to that observed in lightly doped Bi-2201. These observations establish a fluctuating plaquette PDW in the lightly doped hole-like regime, in which local pairs carry finite momentum but lack phase coherence. Our results firmly establish particle-hole asymmetry as a central organizing principle for competing pairing tendencies in the lightly doped $t$-$J$ model.

arXiv:2611.14101•Nov 10, 2026•0 citations

Superconductivity of bad fermions and the origin of two gaps in cuprates

E. A. Stepanov, Sergei Iskakov, Mikhail I. Katsnelson +1 more

Abstract The spectral properties of the doped t – t ’ Hubbard model, using parameters typical for high-temperature cuprate superconductors, and the mechanism of d-wave pairing remain among the longstanding problems of many-body fermionic materials. We used a strong-coupling Green’s function expansion around a correlated reference system, namely a particle-hole-symmetric undoped Hubbard lattice with $${t}^{{\prime} }=0$$ t ′ = 0 , which can be treated numerically exactly using sign-problem-free lattice Quantum Monte Carlo calculations. This reference system exhibits a large antiferromagnetic Mott-Hubbard-Slater gap in the electronic spectrum. We investigate how the Mott-like spectrum is reconstructed under finite doping and nonzero $${t}^{{\prime} }$$ t ′ using a dual-fermion-inspired perturbation expansion. For a large next-nearest-neighbor hopping $${t}^{{\prime} }=-0.3t$$ t ′ = − 0.3 t , characteristic of cuprate families with T c around 100 K, the electronic spectral function reveals a strongly renormalized flat-band feature with a pseudogap near the antinodal point. The superconducting response of this system to a small $${d}_{{x}^{2}-{y}^{2}}$$ d x 2 − y 2 -like external field shows a pseudogap at the antinodal point in the normal part of the Nambu Green’s function, associated with “bad-fermion” behavior in the normal phase. At the same time, the anomalous Green’s function exhibits a d-wave-like structure with zero response at the nodal point of the Brillouin zone.

arXiv:2502.08635•Communications Physics•Feb 12, 2026•9 citations

Crossover between BCS Superconductor and Doped Mott Insulator of d -Wave Pairing State in Two-Dimensional Hubbard Model

Hisatoshi Yokoyama, Masao Ogata, Yukio Tanaka +2 more

With high-Tc cuprates in mind, properties of correlated dx2-y2-wave superconducting (SC) and antiferromagnetic (AF) states are studied for the Hubbard (t-t'-U) model on square lattices, using a variational Monte Carlo method. We employ simple trial wave functions including only crucial parameters, such as a doublon-holon binding factor indispensable to describe correlated SC and normal states as doped Mott insulators. U/t, t'/t and δ(doping rate) dependence of relevant quantities are systematically calculated. As U/t increases, a sharp crossover of SC properties occurs at U_co/t \sim 10 from a conventional BCS type to a kinetic-energy-driven type for any t'/t. As δdecreases, U_co/t is smoothly connected to the Mott transition point at half filling. For U/t\lsim 5, steady superconductivity corresponding to the cuprates is not found, whereas the d-wave SC correlation function Pd^\infty rapidly increases for U/t\gsim 6 and becomes maximum at U=U_co. Comparing the δdependence of Pd^\infty with experimentally observed dome-shaped Tc and condensation energy, we find that the effective value of $U$ for the cuprates should be larger than the band width, for which the t-J model is valid. Analyzing the kinetic energy, we reveal that for U>U_co only doped holes (electrons) become charge carriers, which will make a small Fermi surface (hole pocket), but for UU_co is determined by two factors, i.e., the AF spin correlation, which creates singlet pairs (pseudogap), and the charge mobility dominated by Mott physics.

arXiv:1208.1102•Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Jan 15, 2013•101 citations
Proximity to a Mott insulating phase is likely to be an important physical ingredient of a theory that aims to describe high-temperature superconductivity in the cuprates. Quantum cluster methods are well suited to describe the Mott phase. Hence, as a step toward a quantitative theory of the competition between antiferromagnetism and ddd-wave superconductivity in the cuprates, we use cellular dynamical mean-field theory to compute zero-temperature properties of the two-dimensional square lattice Hubbard model. The ddd-wave order parameter is found to scale like the superexchange coupling JJJ for on-site interaction UUU comparable to or larger than the bandwidth. The order parameter also assumes a dome shape as a function of doping, while, by contrast, the gap in the single-particle density of states decreases monotonically with increasing doping. In the presence of a finite second neighbor hopping t\ensuremath′{t}^{\ensuremath{'}}t\ensuremath′, the zero-temperature phase diagram displays the electron-hole asymmetric competition between antiferromagnetism and superconductivity that is observed experimentally in the cuprates. Adding realistic third neighbor hopping t\ensuremath′′{t}^{\ensuremath{''}}t\ensuremath′′ improves the overall agreement with the experimental phase diagram. Since band parameters can vary depending on the specific cuprate considered, the sensitivity of the theoretical phase diagram to band parameters challenges the commonly held assumption that the doping vs Tc∕Tcmax{T}_{c}∕{T}_{c}^{\mathit{max}}Tc​∕Tcmax​ phase diagram of the cuprates is universal. The calculated angle-resolved photoemission spectrum displays the observed electron-hole asymmetry. The tendency to homogeneous coexistence of the superconducting and antiferromagnetic order parameters is stronger than observed in most experiments but consistent with many theoretical results and with experiments in some layered high-temperature superconductors. Clearly, our calculations reproduce important features of ddd-wave superconductivity in the cuprates that would otherwise be considered anomalous from the point of view of the standard Bardeen--Cooper--Schrieffer approach. At strong coupling, ddd-wave superconductivity and antiferromagnetism naturally appear as two equally important competing instabilities of the normal phase of the same underlying Hamiltonian.
Using variational cluster perturbation theory we study the competition between ddd-wave superconductivity (dSCd\mathrm{SC}dSC) and antiferromagnetism (AF) in the $t\mathrm{\text{\ensuremath{-}}}{t}^{\ensuremath{'}}\mathrm{\text{\ensuremath{-}}}{t}^{\ensuremath{'}\ensuremath{'}}\mathrm{\text{\ensuremath{-}}}U$ Hubbard model. Large scale computer calculations reproduce the overall ground-state phase diagram of the high-temperature superconductors as well as the one-particle excitation spectra for both hole and electron doping. We identify clear signatures of the Mott gap as well as of AF and of dSCd\mathrm{SC}dSC that should be observable in photoemission experiments.
The competition between ddd-wave superconductivity (SC) and antiferromagnetism (AF) in the high-Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ cuprates is investigated by studying the hole- and electron-doped two-dimensional Hubbard model with a recently proposed variational quantum-cluster theory. The approach is shown to provide a thermodynamically consistent determination of the particle number, provided that an overall shift of the on-site energies is treated as a variational parameter. The consequences for the single-particle excitation spectra and for the phase diagram are explored. By comparing the single-particle spectra with quantum Monte Carlo and experimental data, we verify that the low-energy excitations in a strongly correlated electronic system are described appropriately. The cluster calculations also reproduce the overall ground-state phase diagram of the high-temperature superconductors. In particular, they include salient features such as the enhanced robustness of the antiferromagnetic state as a function of electron doping and the tendency towards phase separation into a mixed antiferromagnetic-superconducting phase at low doping and a pure superconducting phase at high (both hole and electron) doping.
Cooperation and competition between the antiferromagnetic, ddd-wave superconducting, and Mott-insulating states are explored for the two-dimensional Hubbard model including nearest and next-nearest-neighbor hoppings at zero temperature. Using the variational cluster approach with clusters of different shapes and sizes up to 10 sites, it is found that the doping-driven transition from a phase with microscopic coexistence of antiferromagnetism and superconductivity to a purely superconducting phase is discontinuous for strong interaction and accompanied by phase separation. At half-filling the system is in an antiferromagnetic Mott-insulating state with vanishing charge compressibility. Upon decreasing the interaction strength UUU below a certain critical value of roughly ${U}_{c}\ensuremath{\sim}4$ (in units of the nearest-neighbor hopping), however, the filling-dependent magnetic transition changes its character and becomes continuous. Phase separation or, more carefully, the tendency towards the formation of inhomogeneous states disappears. This critical value is in contrast to previous studies, where a much larger value was obtained. Moreover, we find that the system at half-filling undergoes the Mott transition from an insulator to a state with a finite charge compressibility at essentially the same value. The weakly correlated state at half-filling exhibits superconductivity microscopically admixed to the antiferromagnetic order. This scenario suggests a close relation between phase separation and the Mott-insulator physics.
Whether a lightly doped Mott insulator on the square lattice supports robust ddd-wave superconductivity remains a central question in strongly correlated physics and in the microscopic theory of cuprate superconductivity. Experiments and numerical studies reveal a pronounced particle-hole asymmetry, pointing to a delicate competition among ddd-wave superconductivity, pair-density wave (PDW), stripe, charge-density wave (CDW), and antiferromagnetic correlations. Here we combine large-scale DMRG and finite-size PEPS to study the square-lattice ttt-JJJ model at low doping, δ≤0.1δ\leq 0.1δ≤0.1, while tuning the next-nearest-neighbor hopping t′t't′ from the electron-like (t′>0t'>0t′>0) to the hole-like (t′<0t'<0t′<0) regime. The electron-like side supports robust, nearly uniform ddd-wave pairing, whereas decreasing t′t't′ induces a period-two plaquette modulation and ultimately produces, on the hole-like side, a charge-dominated state with a strongly suppressed static pairing amplitude. DMRG calculations on open strips and squares, together with PEPS calculations on open squares up to 16×1616\times1616×16 sites, support this evolution. On squares with C4C_4C4​-symmetric Hamiltonians, both methods find that the pair correlations of the hole-like state select the plaquette momenta (π,0)(π,0)(π,0) and (0,π)(0,π)(0,π) and decay within a few lattice spacings, while the dominant charge-density modulation forms a bidirectional checkerboard whose period extrapolates to about 4a04a_04a0​, close to that observed in lightly doped Bi-2201. These observations establish a fluctuating plaquette PDW in the lightly doped hole-like regime, in which local pairs carry finite momentum but lack phase coherence. Our results firmly establish particle-hole asymmetry as a central organizing principle for competing pairing tendencies in the lightly doped ttt-JJJ model.
Abstract The spectral properties of the doped t – t ’ Hubbard model, using parameters typical for high-temperature cuprate superconductors, and the mechanism of d-wave pairing remain among the longstanding problems of many-body fermionic materials. We used a strong-coupling Green’s function expansion around a correlated reference system, namely a particle-hole-symmetric undoped Hubbard lattice with t′=0{t}^{{\prime} }=0t′=0 t ′ = 0 , which can be treated numerically exactly using sign-problem-free lattice Quantum Monte Carlo calculations. This reference system exhibits a large antiferromagnetic Mott-Hubbard-Slater gap in the electronic spectrum. We investigate how the Mott-like spectrum is reconstructed under finite doping and nonzero t′{t}^{{\prime} }t′ t ′ using a dual-fermion-inspired perturbation expansion. For a large next-nearest-neighbor hopping t′=−0.3t{t}^{{\prime} }=-0.3tt′=−0.3t t ′ = − 0.3 t , characteristic of cuprate families with T c around 100 K, the electronic spectral function reveals a strongly renormalized flat-band feature with a pseudogap near the antinodal point. The superconducting response of this system to a small dx2−y2{d}_{{x}^{2}-{y}^{2}}dx2−y2​ d x 2 − y 2 -like external field shows a pseudogap at the antinodal point in the normal part of the Nambu Green’s function, associated with “bad-fermion” behavior in the normal phase. At the same time, the anomalous Green’s function exhibits a d-wave-like structure with zero response at the nodal point of the Brillouin zone.
With high-Tc cuprates in mind, properties of correlated dx2-y2-wave superconducting (SC) and antiferromagnetic (AF) states are studied for the Hubbard (t-t'-U) model on square lattices, using a variational Monte Carlo method. We employ simple trial wave functions including only crucial parameters, such as a doublon-holon binding factor indispensable to describe correlated SC and normal states as doped Mott insulators. U/t, t'/t and δ(doping rate) dependence of relevant quantities are systematically calculated. As U/t increases, a sharp crossover of SC properties occurs at U_co/t \sim 10 from a conventional BCS type to a kinetic-energy-driven type for any t'/t. As δdecreases, U_co/t is smoothly connected to the Mott transition point at half filling. For U/t\lsim 5, steady superconductivity corresponding to the cuprates is not found, whereas the d-wave SC correlation function Pd^\infty rapidly increases for U/t\gsim 6 and becomes maximum at U=U_co. Comparing the δdependence of Pd^\infty with experimentally observed dome-shaped Tc and condensation energy, we find that the effective value of UUU for the cuprates should be larger than the band width, for which the t-J model is valid. Analyzing the kinetic energy, we reveal that for U>U_co only doped holes (electrons) become charge carriers, which will make a small Fermi surface (hole pocket), but for UU_co is determined by two factors, i.e., the AF spin correlation, which creates singlet pairs (pseudogap), and the charge mobility dominated by Mott physics.