Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0411039 · Physical Review B

Ward identities for strongly coupled Eliashberg theories

Andrey V. Chubukov

Published Aug 8, 2005• 31 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We discuss Ward identities for strongly interacting fermion systems described by Eliashberg-type theories. We show that Ward identities are not in conflict with the Migdal theorem and derive diagrammatically a Ward identity for a charge vertex both in a Fermi liquid and when a Fermi liquid is destroyed at quantum criticality. We argue that a Ward identity for the spin vertex cannot be obtained within the Eliashberg theory.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.72.085113

Related papers

Ward Identity as Exact Transport Equation

Yamane Yoko, M. Itoh

We show that the exact transport equation of interacting fermions is nothing but an alternative form of the Ward identity. It is close to that derived diagrammatically by Éliashberg, but along with the complete collision integral and full renormalizations. We further discuss the hidden divergence in conductivity in the conventional microscopic Fermi liquid theory. The exact transport equation does not bring this divergence, incorporating the particle-particle and hole-hole excitations.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Oct 1, 2012•0 citations

From Ward Identity to Exact Transport Equation: complements to Éliashberg's derivation and beyond

Yoko Yamane, Masaki Itoh

Transport equation of interacting fermions is re-considered in the light of the conservation law. We show that the exact equation for the particle-hole excitation is derived directly from the Ward identity, by simply transforming it. It is almost identical to that derived diagrammatically by Éliashberg, but the collision integral is written in the symmetric form. We further discuss the hidden ultraviolet divergence in the both treatments, claiming that the microscopic justification of the Landau-Silin equation has not yet been completed. The divergence is removed by incorporating the particle-particle and hole-hole pairs of excitations, without sacrificing the rigour. This requires re-identification of the distribution function, but does not alter the basic structure of the fermi liquid theory.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Dec 17, 2012•0 citations

Fermi liquid near a q = 0 charge quantum critical point

R. David Mayrhofer, Andrey V. Chubukov, P. Wölfle

We analyze the quasiparticle interaction function (the fully dressed and antisymmetrized interaction between fermions) for a two-dimensional Fermi liquid at zero temperature close to a q=0 charge quantum critical point (QCP) in the $s\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{wave}$ channel (the one leading to phase separation). By the Ward identities, this vertex function must be related to quasiparticle residue $Z$, which can be obtained independently from the fermionic self-energy. We show that to satisfy these Ward identities, one needs to go beyond the standard diagrammatic formulation of Fermi-liquid theory and include a series of additional contributions to the vertex function. These contributions are not present in a conventional Fermi liquid, but do emerge near a QCP, where the effective 4-fermion interaction is mediated by a soft dynamical boson. We demonstrate explicitly that including these terms restores the Ward identity. Our analysis is built on previous studies of the vertex function near an antiferromag netic QCP [Phys. Rev. B 89, 045108 (2014)] and a $d$-wave charge-nematic QCP [Phys. Rev. B 81, 045110 (2010)]. We show th at for $s\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{wave}$ charge QCP the analysis is more straightforward and allows one to obtain the full quasiparticle interaction function (the Landau function) near a QCP. We show that all partial components of this function (Landau parameters) diverge near a QCP, in the same way as the effective mass ${m}^{*}$, except for the $s$-wave charge component, which approaches $\ensuremath{-}1$. Consequently, the susceptibilities in all channels, except for the critical one, remain finite at a QCP, as they should.

arXiv:2403.09835•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 6, 2024•6 citations

Applicability of Eliashberg theory for systems with electron-phonon and electron-electron interaction: A comparative analysis

Shang-Shun Zhang, Zachary M. Raines, Andrey V. Chubukov

The applicability of Eliashberg theory, for fermions interacting with fluctuations of a soft collective boson near a quantum-critical point (QCP) in two dimensions, remains a subject of debate. The velocity of the soft boson is comparable to the Fermi velocity. Hence, Migdal's justification of Eliashberg theory is formally not applicable. The authors argue here that some elements of Migdal's reasoning remain valid because the collective boson is overdamped, yet vertex corrections to Eliashberg theory are $O$(1). At the same time, they show that these corrections are numerically small, at least near an Ising-nematic QCP.

arXiv:2404.11820•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 24, 2024•13 citations

Quantum Critical Eliashberg Theory

Ilya Esterlis, Jörg Schmalian

Quantum criticality plays a central role in understanding non-Fermi liquid behavior and unconventional superconductivity in strongly correlated systems. In this review, we explore the quantum critical Eliashberg theory, which extends conventional Eliashberg approaches to non-Fermi liquid regimes governed by critical fluctuations. We discuss the theoretical foundations and recent developments in the field, focusing on the interplay between electronic interactions and bosonic modes near quantum phase transitions as described in the Yukawa-coupled version of the Sachdev–Ye–Kitaev model. Special emphasis is placed on the breakdown of quasiparticle coherence, anomalous scaling behavior, Cooper pairing without quasiparticles, and emergent universality in different physical settings. Starting from a zero-dimensional quantum dot model, we discuss the generalization to higher spatial dimensions and demonstrate the connection between quantum critical Eliashberg theory and holographic superconductivity. Our analysis provides a perspective on how quantum criticality shapes the dynamics of strongly correlated metals and superconductors.

arXiv:2506.11952•Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics•Mar 13, 2026•15 citations

Quantum critical behavior in itinerant electron systems: Eliashberg theory and instability of a ferromagnetic quantum critical point

Jérôme Rech, C. Pépin, Andrey V. Chubukov

We consider the problem of fermions interacting with gapless long-wavelength collective bosonic modes. The theory describes, among other cases, a ferromagnetic quantum-critical point (QCP) and a QCP towards nematic ordering. We construct a controllable expansion at the QCP in two steps: we first create a non-Fermi-liquid ``zero-order'' Eliashberg-type theory, and then demonstrate that the residual interaction effects are small. We prove that this approach is justified under two conditions: the interaction should be smaller than the fermionic bandwidth, and either the band mass ${m}_{B}$ should be much smaller than $m={k}_{F}∕{v}_{F}$, or the number of fermionic flavors $N$ should be large. For an SU(2) symmetric ferromagnetic QCP, we find that the Eliashberg theory itself includes a set of singular renormalizations which can be understood as a consequence of an effective long-range dynamic interaction between quasiparticles, generated by the Landau damping term. These singular renormalizations give rise to a negative nonanalytic ${q}^{3∕2}$ correction to the static spin susceptibility, and destroy a ferromagnetic QCP. We demonstrate that this effect can be understood in the framework of the ${\ensuremath{\phi}}^{4}$ theory of quantum criticality. We also show that the nonanalytic ${q}^{3∕2}$ correction to the bosonic propagator is specific to the SU(2) symmetric case. For systems with a scalar order parameter, the ${q}^{3∕2}$ contributions from individual diagrams cancel out in the full expression of the susceptibility, and the QCP remains stable.

arXiv:cond-mat/0605306•Physical Review B•Nov 29, 2006•202 citations
We discuss Ward identities for strongly interacting fermion systems described by Eliashberg-type theories. We show that Ward identities are not in conflict with the Migdal theorem and derive diagrammatically a Ward identity for a charge vertex both in a Fermi liquid and when a Fermi liquid is destroyed at quantum criticality. We argue that a Ward identity for the spin vertex cannot be obtained within the Eliashberg theory.
Transport equation of interacting fermions is re-considered in the light of the conservation law. We show that the exact equation for the particle-hole excitation is derived directly from the Ward identity, by simply transforming it. It is almost identical to that derived diagrammatically by Éliashberg, but the collision integral is written in the symmetric form. We further discuss the hidden ultraviolet divergence in the both treatments, claiming that the microscopic justification of the Landau-Silin equation has not yet been completed. The divergence is removed by incorporating the particle-particle and hole-hole pairs of excitations, without sacrificing the rigour. This requires re-identification of the distribution function, but does not alter the basic structure of the fermi liquid theory.
We analyze the quasiparticle interaction function (the fully dressed and antisymmetrized interaction between fermions) for a two-dimensional Fermi liquid at zero temperature close to a q=0 charge quantum critical point (QCP) in the $s\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{wave}$ channel (the one leading to phase separation). By the Ward identities, this vertex function must be related to quasiparticle residue ZZZ, which can be obtained independently from the fermionic self-energy. We show that to satisfy these Ward identities, one needs to go beyond the standard diagrammatic formulation of Fermi-liquid theory and include a series of additional contributions to the vertex function. These contributions are not present in a conventional Fermi liquid, but do emerge near a QCP, where the effective 4-fermion interaction is mediated by a soft dynamical boson. We demonstrate explicitly that including these terms restores the Ward identity. Our analysis is built on previous studies of the vertex function near an antiferromag netic QCP [Phys. Rev. B 89, 045108 (2014)] and a ddd-wave charge-nematic QCP [Phys. Rev. B 81, 045110 (2010)]. We show th at for $s\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{wave}$ charge QCP the analysis is more straightforward and allows one to obtain the full quasiparticle interaction function (the Landau function) near a QCP. We show that all partial components of this function (Landau parameters) diverge near a QCP, in the same way as the effective mass m∗{m}^{*}m∗, except for the sss-wave charge component, which approaches $\ensuremath{-}1$. Consequently, the susceptibilities in all channels, except for the critical one, remain finite at a QCP, as they should.
The applicability of Eliashberg theory, for fermions interacting with fluctuations of a soft collective boson near a quantum-critical point (QCP) in two dimensions, remains a subject of debate. The velocity of the soft boson is comparable to the Fermi velocity. Hence, Migdal's justification of Eliashberg theory is formally not applicable. The authors argue here that some elements of Migdal's reasoning remain valid because the collective boson is overdamped, yet vertex corrections to Eliashberg theory are OOO(1). At the same time, they show that these corrections are numerically small, at least near an Ising-nematic QCP.
Quantum criticality plays a central role in understanding non-Fermi liquid behavior and unconventional superconductivity in strongly correlated systems. In this review, we explore the quantum critical Eliashberg theory, which extends conventional Eliashberg approaches to non-Fermi liquid regimes governed by critical fluctuations. We discuss the theoretical foundations and recent developments in the field, focusing on the interplay between electronic interactions and bosonic modes near quantum phase transitions as described in the Yukawa-coupled version of the Sachdev–Ye–Kitaev model. Special emphasis is placed on the breakdown of quasiparticle coherence, anomalous scaling behavior, Cooper pairing without quasiparticles, and emergent universality in different physical settings. Starting from a zero-dimensional quantum dot model, we discuss the generalization to higher spatial dimensions and demonstrate the connection between quantum critical Eliashberg theory and holographic superconductivity. Our analysis provides a perspective on how quantum criticality shapes the dynamics of strongly correlated metals and superconductors.
We consider the problem of fermions interacting with gapless long-wavelength collective bosonic modes. The theory describes, among other cases, a ferromagnetic quantum-critical point (QCP) and a QCP towards nematic ordering. We construct a controllable expansion at the QCP in two steps: we first create a non-Fermi-liquid ``zero-order'' Eliashberg-type theory, and then demonstrate that the residual interaction effects are small. We prove that this approach is justified under two conditions: the interaction should be smaller than the fermionic bandwidth, and either the band mass mB{m}_{B}mB​ should be much smaller than m=kF∕vFm={k}_{F}∕{v}_{F}m=kF​∕vF​, or the number of fermionic flavors NNN should be large. For an SU(2) symmetric ferromagnetic QCP, we find that the Eliashberg theory itself includes a set of singular renormalizations which can be understood as a consequence of an effective long-range dynamic interaction between quasiparticles, generated by the Landau damping term. These singular renormalizations give rise to a negative nonanalytic q3∕2{q}^{3∕2}q3∕2 correction to the static spin susceptibility, and destroy a ferromagnetic QCP. We demonstrate that this effect can be understood in the framework of the ${\ensuremath{\phi}}^{4}$ theory of quantum criticality. We also show that the nonanalytic q3∕2{q}^{3∕2}q3∕2 correction to the bosonic propagator is specific to the SU(2) symmetric case. For systems with a scalar order parameter, the q3∕2{q}^{3∕2}q3∕2 contributions from individual diagrams cancel out in the full expression of the susceptibility, and the QCP remains stable.