Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0404590

Orthogonality Catastrophe in Bose-Einstein Condensates

Jun Sun, Olen Rambow, Qimiao Si A

Published Apr 26, 2004• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Orthogonality catastrophe in fermionic systems is well known: in the thermodynamic limit, the overlap between the ground state wavefunctions with and without a single local scattering potential approaches zero algebraically as a function of the particle number $N$. Here we examine the analogous problem for bosonic systems. In the homogeneous case, we find that ideal bosons display an orthogonality stronger than algebraic: the wavefunction overlap behaves as ${\rm exp}[-λN^{1/3}]$ in three dimensions and as ${\rm exp}[-λN/\ln ^2 N]$ in two dimensions. With interactions, the overlap becomes finite but is still (stretched-)exponentially small for weak interactions. We also consider the cases with a harmonic trap, reaching similar (though not identical) conclusions. Finally, we comment on the implications of our results for spectroscopic experiments and for (de)coherence phenomena.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.cond-mat/0404590

Related papers

Bose-Einstein in two -dimensional traps

Juan Pablo Fernández

The fact that two-dimensional interacting trapped systems do not undergo Bose-Einstein Condensation (BEC) in the thermodynamic limit, though rigorously proved, is somewhat mysterious because all relevant limiting cases (zero temperature, small atom numbers, noninteracting particles) suggest otherwise. We study the possibility of condensation in finite trapped two-dimensional systems. We first consider the ideal gas, which incorporates the inhomogeneity and finite size of experimental systems and can be solved exactly. A semiclassical self-consistent approximation gives us a feel for the temperature scales; diagonalization of the one-body density matrix confirms that the condensation is into a single state. We squeeze a three-dimensional system and see how it crosses over into two dimensions. Mean-field theory, our main tool for the study of interacting systems, prescribes coupled equations for the condensate and the thermal cloud: the condensate receives a full quantum-mechanical treatment, while the noncondensate is described by different schemes of varying sophistication. We analyze the T = 0 case and its approach to the thermodynamic limit, finding a criterion for the dimensionality crossover and obtaining the coupling constant of the two-dimensional system that results from squeezing a three-dimensional trap. We next apply a semiclassical Hartree-Fock approximation to purely two-dimensional finite gases and find that they can be described either with or without a condensate; this continues to be true in the thermodynamic limit. The condensed solutions have a lower free energy at all temperatures but neglect the presence of phonons within the system and cease to exist when we allow for this possibility. The uncondensed solutions, in turn, are valid under a more rigorous scheme but have consistency problems of their own. Path-integral Monte Carlo simulations provide an essentially exact description of finite interacting gases and enable us to study highly anisotropic systems at finite temperature. We find that our two-dimensional Hartree-Fock solutions accurately mimic the surface density profile and predict the condensate fraction of these systems; the equivalent interaction parameter is smaller than that dictated by the T = 0 analysis. We conclude that, in two-dimensional isotropic finite trapped systems and in highly compressed three-dimensional gases, there is a phenomenon resembling a condensation into a single state.

•Jan 1, 2004•0 citations

Stability and condensation of dilute Bose gases

François Louis Antoine Visconti

This thesis is devoted to the rigorous study of dilute Bose gases with two-body and three-body interactions at zero temperature in two and three dimensions. Bose gases are many-body quantum systems composed of bosons, which notably do not obey the Pauli exclusion principle. As a consequence, at extremely low temperatures, a macroscopic fraction of the particles can occupy the same one-body quantum state. This phenomenon, known as Bose–Einstein condensation, was predicted in the 1920s by Bose and Einstein for noninteracting Bose gases, and first realised experimentally by the groups of Cornell and Wieman, and Ketterle, earning them the Nobel Prize for Physics in 2001. However, proving the occurrence of Bose–Einstein condensation in general interacting bosonic systems remains a major open problem and constitutes a central theme in this thesis. Another important property of bosonic matter is that it is generally more unstable than fermionic matter. In particular, for systems interacting via the Coulomb force, the Pauli exclusion principle is essential for explaining the stability of the second kind, which states that the energy and volume scale linearly with the number of particles. Nonetheless, bosonic systems with attractive but less singular interactions can also be stable, and the rigorous proof of this fact forms a second focus of this thesis. In three dimensions, we consider predominantly repulsive interactions. Firstly, we prove a leading order upper bound on the thermodynamic ground state energy of Bose gases with hard-core three-body interactions, which matches an existing lower bound. In addition, we obtain a simpler proof for integrable potentials. Secondly, we derive the leading order of the thermodynamic ground state energy of Bose gases with combined two-body and three-body interactions. More specifically, we show that, at the leading order, the ground state energy is entirely characterised by the scattering length of the two-body potential and the scattering hypervolume of the three-body potential. Thirdly, we study the time evolution of Bose–Einstein condensates with three-body interactions in the so-called Gross–Pitaevskii regime. We show that Bose–Einstein condensation is preserved under many-body evolution and that the condensate wavefunction evolves according to the quintic Gross–Pitaevskii equation. In particular, we show that the effective coupling constant is universal in the sense that it depends only on the scattering hypervolume of the interaction potential. As a by-product of our proof, we derive a stability of the second kind result for Bose gases with attractive two-body interactions and repulsive three-body interactions. In two dimensions, we consider trapped Bose gases with mean-field-type interactions, including the purely attractive case. We prove the stability of the second kind of the system and the convergence of the ground state energy per particle to that of a non-linear Schrödinger energy functional. As a consequence of the stability of the second kind, we also obtain Bose–Einstein condensation for the many-body ground states.

•Aug 4, 2026•0 citations

Zero BEC State Amplitude, and BEC Unnecessary to Define Phase ϕ

Wayne M. Saslow

We define the "BEC state" to be the many-body wavefunction where all particles are in the same one-body state. Using an argument analogous to Anderson's Orthogonality Catastrophe, we argue that for interacting particles the amplitude of the BEC state within the many-body wavefunction goes to zero in the thermodynamic limit. This does not mean that there is no condensate. However, we argue that, if the excitations satisfy the Landau criterion, then the absence of a finite amplitude for the BEC state, or the absence of a condensate, do not prevent the definition of the phase function ϕ, from which the superfluid velocity follows.

arXiv:1108.2252•Aug 10, 2011•0 citations

Three-body scattering area for particles with infinite or zero scattering length in two dimensions

Junjie Liang, Shina Tan

We derive the asymptotic expansions of the wave function of three particles having equal mass with finite-range interactions and infinite or zero two-dimensional scattering length colliding at zero energy and zero orbital angular momentum, from which a three-body parameter $D$ is defined. The dimension of $D$ is length squared, and we call $D$ three-body scattering area. We find that the ground-state energy per particle of a zero-temperature dilute Bose gas with these interactions is approximately $\frac{{\ensuremath{\hbar}}^{2}D}{6m}{\ensuremath{\rho}}^{2}$, where $\ensuremath{\rho}$ is the number density of the bosons and $m$ is the mass of each boson. Such a zero-temperature Bose gas is stable at $D>0$ in the thermodynamic limit, and metastable at $D<0$ in the isotropic harmonic trap if the number of bosons is less than ${N}_{\mathrm{cr}}\ensuremath{\approx}3.6413\sqrt{\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}}{m\ensuremath{\omega}|D|}\phantom{{}^{1}}}$, where $\ensuremath{\omega}$ is the angular frequency of the harmonic trap. If the two-body interaction supports bound states, $D$ typically acquires a negative imaginary part, and we find the relation between this imaginary part and the amplitudes of the pair-boson production processes. We derive a formula for the three-body recombination rate constant of the many-boson system in terms of the imaginary part of $D$.

arXiv:2402.02202•Physical Review A•Jun 24, 2024•2 citations

Bose-Einstein condensation in harmonic double wells

P. Capuzzi, E. Susana Hernández

We discuss Bose-Einstein condensation in harmonic traps where the confinement has undergone a splitting along one direction. We mostly consider three-dimensional potentials consisting of two cylindrical wells separated a distance $2a$ along the z axis. For ideal gases, the thermodynamics of the confined bosons has been investigated, performing exact numerical summations to describe the major details of the transition and comparing the results with the semiclassical density-of-states approximation. We find that for large particle number and increasing well separation, the condensation temperature evolves from the thermodynamic limit value ${T}_{c}^{(0)}(N)$ to ${T}_{c}^{(0)}(N/2).$ The effects of adding a repulsive interaction between atoms has been examined resorting to the Gross-Pitaevskii-Popov procedure, and it is found that the shift of the condensation temperature exhibits different signs according to the separation between wells. In particular, for sufficiently large splitting, the trend opposes the well-known results for harmonic traps, since the critical temperature appears to increase with growing repulsion strength.

arXiv:cond-mat/9810164•Physical Review A•Feb 1, 1999•11 citations

Bose-Einstein Condensation and Superfluidity in 3D and 2D bosons

Andrea Tononi

The refinement and the combination of laser cooling and evaporative cooling in dilute systems of alkali atoms lead to the achievement of Bose-Einstein condensation in 1995. Nowadays there is a fruitful interplay between theoretical and experimental results: in this context, the study of uniform Bose gases plays an important role in the comprehension of the static and dynamic properties of a bosonic system. Here we use quantum field theory, within the approach of functional integration, to study an homogeneous system of weakly-interacting bosonic cold atoms. After characterizing their thermodynamical properties, we derive - at a gaussian level - the number density and the superfluid density in three and in two spatial dimensions, expressed as functions of the condensate density and the temperature. Since the equations derived are valid for a generic interaction potential, we implement these formulas for bosons with a zero-range interaction, providing also an extension of these results with the inclusion of a finite-range interaction.

•Sep 1, 2018•1 citation
Orthogonality catastrophe in fermionic systems is well known: in the thermodynamic limit, the overlap between the ground state wavefunctions with and without a single local scattering potential approaches zero algebraically as a function of the particle number NNN. Here we examine the analogous problem for bosonic systems. In the homogeneous case, we find that ideal bosons display an orthogonality stronger than algebraic: the wavefunction overlap behaves as exp[−λN1/3]{\rm exp}[-λN^{1/3}]exp[−λN1/3] in three dimensions and as exp[−λN/ln⁡2N]{\rm exp}[-λN/\ln ^2 N]exp[−λN/ln2N] in two dimensions. With interactions, the overlap becomes finite but is still (stretched-)exponentially small for weak interactions. We also consider the cases with a harmonic trap, reaching similar (though not identical) conclusions. Finally, we comment on the implications of our results for spectroscopic experiments and for (de)coherence phenomena.
The fact that two-dimensional interacting trapped systems do not undergo Bose-Einstein Condensation (BEC) in the thermodynamic limit, though rigorously proved, is somewhat mysterious because all relevant limiting cases (zero temperature, small atom numbers, noninteracting particles) suggest otherwise. We study the possibility of condensation in finite trapped two-dimensional systems. We first consider the ideal gas, which incorporates the inhomogeneity and finite size of experimental systems and can be solved exactly. A semiclassical self-consistent approximation gives us a feel for the temperature scales; diagonalization of the one-body density matrix confirms that the condensation is into a single state. We squeeze a three-dimensional system and see how it crosses over into two dimensions. Mean-field theory, our main tool for the study of interacting systems, prescribes coupled equations for the condensate and the thermal cloud: the condensate receives a full quantum-mechanical treatment, while the noncondensate is described by different schemes of varying sophistication. We analyze the T = 0 case and its approach to the thermodynamic limit, finding a criterion for the dimensionality crossover and obtaining the coupling constant of the two-dimensional system that results from squeezing a three-dimensional trap. We next apply a semiclassical Hartree-Fock approximation to purely two-dimensional finite gases and find that they can be described either with or without a condensate; this continues to be true in the thermodynamic limit. The condensed solutions have a lower free energy at all temperatures but neglect the presence of phonons within the system and cease to exist when we allow for this possibility. The uncondensed solutions, in turn, are valid under a more rigorous scheme but have consistency problems of their own. Path-integral Monte Carlo simulations provide an essentially exact description of finite interacting gases and enable us to study highly anisotropic systems at finite temperature. We find that our two-dimensional Hartree-Fock solutions accurately mimic the surface density profile and predict the condensate fraction of these systems; the equivalent interaction parameter is smaller than that dictated by the T = 0 analysis. We conclude that, in two-dimensional isotropic finite trapped systems and in highly compressed three-dimensional gases, there is a phenomenon resembling a condensation into a single state.
This thesis is devoted to the rigorous study of dilute Bose gases with two-body and three-body interactions at zero temperature in two and three dimensions. Bose gases are many-body quantum systems composed of bosons, which notably do not obey the Pauli exclusion principle. As a consequence, at extremely low temperatures, a macroscopic fraction of the particles can occupy the same one-body quantum state. This phenomenon, known as Bose–Einstein condensation, was predicted in the 1920s by Bose and Einstein for noninteracting Bose gases, and first realised experimentally by the groups of Cornell and Wieman, and Ketterle, earning them the Nobel Prize for Physics in 2001. However, proving the occurrence of Bose–Einstein condensation in general interacting bosonic systems remains a major open problem and constitutes a central theme in this thesis. Another important property of bosonic matter is that it is generally more unstable than fermionic matter. In particular, for systems interacting via the Coulomb force, the Pauli exclusion principle is essential for explaining the stability of the second kind, which states that the energy and volume scale linearly with the number of particles. Nonetheless, bosonic systems with attractive but less singular interactions can also be stable, and the rigorous proof of this fact forms a second focus of this thesis. In three dimensions, we consider predominantly repulsive interactions. Firstly, we prove a leading order upper bound on the thermodynamic ground state energy of Bose gases with hard-core three-body interactions, which matches an existing lower bound. In addition, we obtain a simpler proof for integrable potentials. Secondly, we derive the leading order of the thermodynamic ground state energy of Bose gases with combined two-body and three-body interactions. More specifically, we show that, at the leading order, the ground state energy is entirely characterised by the scattering length of the two-body potential and the scattering hypervolume of the three-body potential. Thirdly, we study the time evolution of Bose–Einstein condensates with three-body interactions in the so-called Gross–Pitaevskii regime. We show that Bose–Einstein condensation is preserved under many-body evolution and that the condensate wavefunction evolves according to the quintic Gross–Pitaevskii equation. In particular, we show that the effective coupling constant is universal in the sense that it depends only on the scattering hypervolume of the interaction potential. As a by-product of our proof, we derive a stability of the second kind result for Bose gases with attractive two-body interactions and repulsive three-body interactions. In two dimensions, we consider trapped Bose gases with mean-field-type interactions, including the purely attractive case. We prove the stability of the second kind of the system and the convergence of the ground state energy per particle to that of a non-linear Schrödinger energy functional. As a consequence of the stability of the second kind, we also obtain Bose–Einstein condensation for the many-body ground states.
We define the "BEC state" to be the many-body wavefunction where all particles are in the same one-body state. Using an argument analogous to Anderson's Orthogonality Catastrophe, we argue that for interacting particles the amplitude of the BEC state within the many-body wavefunction goes to zero in the thermodynamic limit. This does not mean that there is no condensate. However, we argue that, if the excitations satisfy the Landau criterion, then the absence of a finite amplitude for the BEC state, or the absence of a condensate, do not prevent the definition of the phase function ϕ, from which the superfluid velocity follows.
We derive the asymptotic expansions of the wave function of three particles having equal mass with finite-range interactions and infinite or zero two-dimensional scattering length colliding at zero energy and zero orbital angular momentum, from which a three-body parameter DDD is defined. The dimension of DDD is length squared, and we call DDD three-body scattering area. We find that the ground-state energy per particle of a zero-temperature dilute Bose gas with these interactions is approximately $\frac{{\ensuremath{\hbar}}^{2}D}{6m}{\ensuremath{\rho}}^{2}$, where $\ensuremath{\rho}$ is the number density of the bosons and mmm is the mass of each boson. Such a zero-temperature Bose gas is stable at D>0D>0D>0 in the thermodynamic limit, and metastable at D<0D<0D<0 in the isotropic harmonic trap if the number of bosons is less than ${N}_{\mathrm{cr}}\ensuremath{\approx}3.6413\sqrt{\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}}{m\ensuremath{\omega}|D|}\phantom{{}^{1}}}$, where $\ensuremath{\omega}$ is the angular frequency of the harmonic trap. If the two-body interaction supports bound states, DDD typically acquires a negative imaginary part, and we find the relation between this imaginary part and the amplitudes of the pair-boson production processes. We derive a formula for the three-body recombination rate constant of the many-boson system in terms of the imaginary part of DDD.
We discuss Bose-Einstein condensation in harmonic traps where the confinement has undergone a splitting along one direction. We mostly consider three-dimensional potentials consisting of two cylindrical wells separated a distance 2a2a2a along the z axis. For ideal gases, the thermodynamics of the confined bosons has been investigated, performing exact numerical summations to describe the major details of the transition and comparing the results with the semiclassical density-of-states approximation. We find that for large particle number and increasing well separation, the condensation temperature evolves from the thermodynamic limit value Tc(0)(N){T}_{c}^{(0)}(N)Tc(0)​(N) to Tc(0)(N/2).{T}_{c}^{(0)}(N/2).Tc(0)​(N/2). The effects of adding a repulsive interaction between atoms has been examined resorting to the Gross-Pitaevskii-Popov procedure, and it is found that the shift of the condensation temperature exhibits different signs according to the separation between wells. In particular, for sufficiently large splitting, the trend opposes the well-known results for harmonic traps, since the critical temperature appears to increase with growing repulsion strength.
The refinement and the combination of laser cooling and evaporative cooling in dilute systems of alkali atoms lead to the achievement of Bose-Einstein condensation in 1995. Nowadays there is a fruitful interplay between theoretical and experimental results: in this context, the study of uniform Bose gases plays an important role in the comprehension of the static and dynamic properties of a bosonic system. Here we use quantum field theory, within the approach of functional integration, to study an homogeneous system of weakly-interacting bosonic cold atoms. After characterizing their thermodynamical properties, we derive - at a gaussian level - the number density and the superfluid density in three and in two spatial dimensions, expressed as functions of the condensate density and the temperature. Since the equations derived are valid for a generic interaction potential, we implement these formulas for bosons with a zero-range interaction, providing also an extension of these results with the inclusion of a finite-range interaction.