We develop a new theoretical framework for describing and analyzing exotic phases of strongly correlated electrons which support excitations with fractional quantum numbers. Starting with a class of microscopic models believed to capture much of the essential physics of the cuprate superconductors, we derive a new gauge theory---based upon a discrete Ising or
Z2 symmetry---which interpolates naturally between an antiferromagnetic Mott insulator and a conventional d-wave superconductor. We explore the intervening regime, and demonstrate the possible existence of an exotic fractionalized insulator, the nodal liquid, as well as various more conventional insulating phases exhibiting broken lattice symmetries. A crucial role is played by vortex configurations in the
Z2 gauge field. Fractionalization is obtained if they are uncondensed. Within the insulating phases, the dynamics of these
Z2 vortices in two dimensions is described, after a duality transformation, by an Ising model in a transverse field, the Ising spins representing the
Z2 vortices. The presence of an unusual Berry's phase term in the gauge theory leads to a doping-dependent ``frustration'' in the dual Ising model, being fully frustrated at half filling. The
Z2 gauge theory is readily generalized to a variety of different situations, in particular, it can also describe three-dimensional insulators with fractional quantum numbers. We point out that the mechanism of fractionalization for
d>1 is distinct from the well-known one-dimensional spin--charge separation. Other interesting results include a description of an exotic fractionalized superconductor in two or higher dimensions.
We describe the phases of a solvable $t\text{\ensuremath{-}}J$ model of electrons with infinite-range, and random, hopping, and exchange interactions, similar to those in the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev models. The electron fractionalizes, as in an ``orthogonal metal,'' into a fermion
f, which carries both the electron spin and charge, and a boson $\ensuremath{\phi}$. Both
f and $\ensuremath{\phi}$ carry emergent
Z2 gauge charges. The model has a phase in which the $\ensuremath{\phi}$ bosons are gapped, and the
f fermions are gapless and critical, and so the electron spectral function is gapped. This phase can be considered as a toy model for the underdoped cuprates, without spatial structure. The model also has an extended, critical, ``quasi-Higgs'' phase where both $\ensuremath{\phi}$ and
f are gapless, and the electron operator $\ensuremath{\sim}f\ensuremath{\phi}$ has a Fermi liquid-like $1/\ensuremath{\tau}$ propagator in imaginary time, $\ensuremath{\tau}$. So while the electron spectral function has a Fermi liquid form, other properties are controlled by
Z2 fractionalization and the anomalous exponents of the
f and $\ensuremath{\phi}$ excitations. This quasi-Higgs phase is proposed as a toy model of the overdoped cuprates. We also describe the critical state separating these two phases.
We demonstrate that spin-charge separation can occur in two dimensions and note its confluence with superconductivity, topology, gauge theory, and fault-tolerant quantum computation. We construct a microscopic Ising-like model and, at a special coupling constant value, find its exact ground state as well as neutral spin-
21 (spinon), spinless charge e (holon), and
Z2 vortex (vison) states and energies. The fractionalized excitations reflect the topological order of the ground state which is evinced by its fourfold degeneracy on the torus---a degeneracy which is unrelated to translational or rotational symmetry---and is described by a
Z2 gauge theory. A magnetic moment coexists with the topological order. Our model is a member of a family of topologically ordered models, one of which is integrable and realizes the toric quantum error correction code but does not conserve any component of the spin. We relate our model to a dimer model which could be a spin
SU(2) symmetric realization of topological order and its concomitant quantum number fractionalization.
Many popular models of fractionalized spin liquids contain neutral fermionic spinon excitations on a Fermi surface, carrying unit charges under a compact U(1) gauge force. We argue that except at possible critical points, instanton effects generically render such states unstable to confinement in two spatial dimensions, so that all elementary excitations are gauge neutral, and there is no spinon Fermi surface. Similar results are expected to apply to SU(2) spin liquids. However, fractionalized states can appear when the gauge symmetry is broken down to a discrete subgroup by the Higgs mechanism. Our argument generalizes earlier results on confinement in the pure gauge theory, and arguments for the instability of the U(1) ``staggered flux'' and ``algebraic'' spin liquids with a Dirac spectrum for fermionic spinons.
The compact U(1) gauge field occurs in many fractionalized descriptions of low dimensional quantum magnetism and heavy fermion systems. In this respect a fundamental question about the gauge field is whether it is confined or not in the presence of Fermi surface. In this paper we show that the U(1) gauge field with a possible positive anomalous dimension in the presence of Fermi surface has to be in the confined state, although it is strongly coupled to abundant gapless fermionic excitations near the Fermi surface in two spatial dimensions. This means that some quantum spin liquids and/or fractionalized metallic states described in terms of this kind of gauge fields with positive anomalous dimensions are unstable to other possible symmetry-breaking states, as a result, they are not be appropriate candidates for ground states in related systems. The instability obtained shows some novel features of the quantum spin liquids and/or fractionalized metallic states in the presence of Fermi surface which have not been reported in the literature. The result could be useful for further study in the quantum spin liquids and many related slave-particle gauge theories in strongly correlated electron systems.
We investigate the continuous quantum phase transition from an antiferromagnetic metal to a heavy-fermion liquid based on the Kondo lattice model in two dimensions. We propose that antiferromagnetic spin fluctuations and conduction electrons fractionalize into neutral bosonic spinons and charged spinless fermions at the quantum critical point. This deconfined quantum criticality leads us to establish a critical field theory in terms of the fractionalized fields interacting via emergent U(1) gauge fields. The critical field theory not only predicts non-Fermi liquid physics near the quantum critical point but also recovers Fermi liquid physics away from the quantum critical point.