Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0302015 · Physical Review B

Coherence window in the dynamics of quantum nanomagnets

Philip C. E. Stamp, I. S. Tupitsyn

Published Jan 8, 2004• 58 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Decoherence in many solid-state systems is anomalously high, frustrating efforts to make solid-state qubits. We show that in nanomagnetic insulators in large transverse fields, there can be a fairly narrow-field region in which both phonon- and nuclear-spin-mediated decoherence are drastically reduced. As examples we calculate decoherence rates for the Fe-8 nanomolecule, for Ni particles, and for Ho ions in ${\mathrm{LiHo}}_{x}{\mathrm{Y}}_{1\ensuremath{-}x}{\mathrm{F}}_{4}.$ The reduction in the decoherence, compared to low field rates, can exceed six orders of magnitude. The results also give limitations on the observability of macroscopic coherence effects in magnetic systems.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.69.014401

Related papers

PHASE DYNAMICS OF SOLID-STATE QUBITS: MAGNETS AND SUPERCONDUCTORS

Philip C. E. Stamp

It is widely believed that quantum information devices like quantum computers will be built from solid-state qubits. Making functioning networks of these will pose formidable challenges coming from decoherence, which is usually very strong in the solid state. Here I review theoretical progress in understanding the decoherence mechanisms in superconductors and magnetic systems, wherein we believe decoherence can be made extremely small, and for which experiments reporting large-scale coherence already exist. Our microscopic understanding of superconducting and magnetic qubits is reviewed – the way in which one arrives at a low-energy effective Hamiltonian is explained in detail for a magnetic system. The way in which decoherence enters the dynamics of solid-state qubits is then discussed, along with the connection to experiment. Finally, I discuss ways in which decoherence can be further suppressed, using for example applied transverse fields.

Solvay Conference on Physics•Aug 1, 2003•1 citation

Decoherence in the Quantum Dynamics of a "Central Spin" Coupled to a Spin Environment

Nikolay V. Prokof'ev, Philip C. E. Stamp

We consider here the problem of a "central spin", with spin quantum number $S \gg 1$, interacting with a set of microscopic spins. Interactions between the microscopic spins are ignored. This model describes magnetic grains or magnetic macromolecules (ferromagnetically or antiferromagnetically ordered) interacting with nuclear spins and with any surrounding paramagnetic electronic spins. It has also been used to describe $Si:P$ near the metal-insulator transition, and quantum spin glasses. In this paper we consider the possible coherent motion of the central spin. We reduce the model to an effective low-energy Hamiltonian, and then calculate the correlation function using instanton methods. The general solution is given for the unbiased case, for all relevant values of the couplings. Under certain conditions, nuclear spin diffusion also plays a role. The results are then used to calculate the spectral absorption for 2 experimental systems, viz., $TbFe_3$ grains, and ferritin molecules. Our results have general implications for the observation of mesoscopic and macroscopic quantum coherence, and for the foundations of quantum mechanics. They show that a spin environment usually has a very destructive effect on coherence, which cannot be understood using the conventional "oscillator bath" models of quantum environments.

arXiv:cond-mat/9511011•Nov 2, 1995•11 citations

Decoherence in large NMR quantum registers

Hans Georg Krojanski, Dieter Suter

Decoherence causes the decay of the quantum information that is stored in highly correlated states during quantum computation. It is thus a limiting factor for all implementations of a quantum computer. Because a scalable quantum computer with hundreds or thousands of qubits is not available yet, experimental data about decoherence rates was restricted to small quantum registers. With solid state nuclear magnetic resonance we create highly correlated multiqubit states that serve as a model quantum register and measure their decay. By measuring the decay as a function of the system size, we determined the scaling of the decoherence rate with the number of qubits. Using the same system, we also used decoupling techniques to reduce the coupling between system and environment and thereby the decoherence rate by more than an order of magnitude, independent of the system size. For the free decay as well as for the decoupled case, we found a relatively weak scaling with system size, which could be fitted to a power law $\ensuremath{\propto}{\overline{K}}^{p}$ with an exponent $p\ensuremath{\approx}1∕2$. This raises the prospect for large-scale quantum computation.

Physical Review A•Dec 26, 2006•40 citations

ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS ON QUANTUM REVERSAL OF MESOSCOPIC SPINS

Romain Giraud, I. Chiorescu, Wolfgang Wernsdorfer +5 more

We describe what we learnt these last years on quantum reversal of large magnetic moments, using mainly conventional SQUID or micro-SQUID magnetometry. Beside the case of ferromagnetic nanoparticles with 10 3 – 10 5 atoms (e.g. Co , Ni , Fe , Ferrites), most fruitful systems appeared to be ensembles of magnetic molecules. These molecules, generally arranged in single crystals, carry relatively small magnetic moments (S = 10 in Mn 12 - ac and Fe 8 ). They are sufficiently apart from each other not to be coupled by exchange interactions. The ground multiplet is split over an energy barrier of tens of kelvin (≈ 67 K for Mn 12 ) by a strong local crystal field, leading to an Ising-type ground-state. Only weak inter-molecular dipolar interactions are present, as well as intra-molecular interactions, such as hyperfine interactions. Quantum properties of molecule spins are crucially dependent on their magnetic environment of electronic and nuclear spins (the spin bath). Energy fluctuations of the spin bath of about 0.1 K are important, especially at very low temperatures. In particular, they are much larger than the ground-state tunnel splitting of large-spin molecules in low applied fields, of about 10 -8 K or even less (such a low value is due to the presence of large energy barriers). Theoretical predictions are experimentally checked for tunneling effects in the presence of non-equilibrated or equilibrated spin-energy distribution. It is also shown that the phonon-bath plays no role in low field, except when the temperature approaches the cross-over temperature to the thermal activation regime. In fact, spin–phonon transitions can play a role only if the tunnel splitting is not too small in comparison with k B T . This is the case both for large-spin molecules in a large magnetic field (e.g. Mn 12 - ac in a few tesla) and for low-spin molecules, as shown with the study of the molecule V 15 (Hilbert space dimension as large as 2 15 and spin 1/2). We also give our latest results on the extension of these studies beyond molecular magnetism. Single-ion slow quantum relaxation is observed in rare-earth Ho 3+ ions highly diluted in an insulating matrix LiYF 4 . This relaxation is due to the coherent tunneling of individual Ho 3+ spins strongly coupled to their nuclear spins, leading to electro-nuclear entangled states at avoided level crossings. In fact tunneling of the spin system is induced by the hyperfine coupling. Together with the important role of the "spin bath", the roles of cross–spin and spin–phonon relaxations are also considered. All these results confirm the emergence of a new field of research: "mesoscopic magnetism".

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics in the Light of New Technology•Oct 1, 2002•0 citations

Decoherence-governed magnetic-moment dynamics of supported atomic objects

J. P. Gauyacq, Nicolás Lorente

Due to the quantum evolution of molecular magnetic moments, the magnetic state of nanomagnets can suffer spontaneous changes. This process can be completely quenched by environment-induced decoherence. However, we show that for typical small supported atomic objects, the substrate-induced decoherence does change the magnetic-moment evolution but does not quell it. To be specific and to compare with experiment, we analyze the spontaneous switching between two equivalent magnetization states of atomic structures formed by Fe on Cu2N/Cu (1 0 0), measured by Loth et al (2012 Science 335 196-9). Due to the substrate-induced decoherence, the Rabi oscillations proper to quantum tunneling between magnetic states are replaced by an irreversible decay of long characteristic times leading to the observed stochastic magnetization switching. We show that the corresponding switching rates are small, rapidly decreasing with system's size, with a 1/T thermal behavior and in good agreement with experiments. Quantum tunneling is recovered as the switching mechanism at extremely low temperatures below the μK range for a six-Fe-atom system and exponentially lower for larger atomic systems. The unexpected conclusion of this work is that experiments could detect the switching of these supported atomic systems because their magnetization evolution is somewhere between complete decoherence-induced stability and unobservably fast quantum-tunneling switching.

Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Oct 16, 2015•24 citations

Scaling of Decoherence in Wide NMR Quantum Registers

Hans Georg Krojanski, Dieter Suter

Among the most important parameters for the usefulness of quantum computers are the size of the quantum register and the decoherence time for the quantum information. The decoherence time is expected to get shorter with the number of correlated qubits, but experimental data are only available for small numbers of qubits. Solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance allows one to correlate large numbers of qubits (several hundred) and measure their decoherence rates. We use a modified magnetic dipole-dipole interaction to correlate the proton spins in a solid sample and observe the decay of the resulting highly correlated states. By systematically varying the number of correlated spins, we measure the increase of the decoherence rate with the size of the quantum register.

Physical Review Letters•Aug 24, 2004•131 citations
Decoherence in many solid-state systems is anomalously high, frustrating efforts to make solid-state qubits. We show that in nanomagnetic insulators in large transverse fields, there can be a fairly narrow-field region in which both phonon- and nuclear-spin-mediated decoherence are drastically reduced. As examples we calculate decoherence rates for the Fe-8 nanomolecule, for Ni particles, and for Ho ions in LiHoxY1\ensuremath−xF4.{\mathrm{LiHo}}_{x}{\mathrm{Y}}_{1\ensuremath{-}x}{\mathrm{F}}_{4}.LiHox​Y1\ensuremath−x​F4​. The reduction in the decoherence, compared to low field rates, can exceed six orders of magnitude. The results also give limitations on the observability of macroscopic coherence effects in magnetic systems.
It is widely believed that quantum information devices like quantum computers will be built from solid-state qubits. Making functioning networks of these will pose formidable challenges coming from decoherence, which is usually very strong in the solid state. Here I review theoretical progress in understanding the decoherence mechanisms in superconductors and magnetic systems, wherein we believe decoherence can be made extremely small, and for which experiments reporting large-scale coherence already exist. Our microscopic understanding of superconducting and magnetic qubits is reviewed – the way in which one arrives at a low-energy effective Hamiltonian is explained in detail for a magnetic system. The way in which decoherence enters the dynamics of solid-state qubits is then discussed, along with the connection to experiment. Finally, I discuss ways in which decoherence can be further suppressed, using for example applied transverse fields.
We consider here the problem of a "central spin", with spin quantum number S≫1S \gg 1S≫1, interacting with a set of microscopic spins. Interactions between the microscopic spins are ignored. This model describes magnetic grains or magnetic macromolecules (ferromagnetically or antiferromagnetically ordered) interacting with nuclear spins and with any surrounding paramagnetic electronic spins. It has also been used to describe Si:PSi:PSi:P near the metal-insulator transition, and quantum spin glasses. In this paper we consider the possible coherent motion of the central spin. We reduce the model to an effective low-energy Hamiltonian, and then calculate the correlation function using instanton methods. The general solution is given for the unbiased case, for all relevant values of the couplings. Under certain conditions, nuclear spin diffusion also plays a role. The results are then used to calculate the spectral absorption for 2 experimental systems, viz., TbFe3TbFe_3TbFe3​ grains, and ferritin molecules. Our results have general implications for the observation of mesoscopic and macroscopic quantum coherence, and for the foundations of quantum mechanics. They show that a spin environment usually has a very destructive effect on coherence, which cannot be understood using the conventional "oscillator bath" models of quantum environments.
Decoherence causes the decay of the quantum information that is stored in highly correlated states during quantum computation. It is thus a limiting factor for all implementations of a quantum computer. Because a scalable quantum computer with hundreds or thousands of qubits is not available yet, experimental data about decoherence rates was restricted to small quantum registers. With solid state nuclear magnetic resonance we create highly correlated multiqubit states that serve as a model quantum register and measure their decay. By measuring the decay as a function of the system size, we determined the scaling of the decoherence rate with the number of qubits. Using the same system, we also used decoupling techniques to reduce the coupling between system and environment and thereby the decoherence rate by more than an order of magnitude, independent of the system size. For the free decay as well as for the decoupled case, we found a relatively weak scaling with system size, which could be fitted to a power law $\ensuremath{\propto}{\overline{K}}^{p}$ with an exponent $p\ensuremath{\approx}1∕2$. This raises the prospect for large-scale quantum computation.
We describe what we learnt these last years on quantum reversal of large magnetic moments, using mainly conventional SQUID or micro-SQUID magnetometry. Beside the case of ferromagnetic nanoparticles with 10 3 – 10 5 atoms (e.g. Co , Ni , Fe , Ferrites), most fruitful systems appeared to be ensembles of magnetic molecules. These molecules, generally arranged in single crystals, carry relatively small magnetic moments (S = 10 in Mn 12 - ac and Fe 8 ). They are sufficiently apart from each other not to be coupled by exchange interactions. The ground multiplet is split over an energy barrier of tens of kelvin (≈ 67 K for Mn 12 ) by a strong local crystal field, leading to an Ising-type ground-state. Only weak inter-molecular dipolar interactions are present, as well as intra-molecular interactions, such as hyperfine interactions. Quantum properties of molecule spins are crucially dependent on their magnetic environment of electronic and nuclear spins (the spin bath). Energy fluctuations of the spin bath of about 0.1 K are important, especially at very low temperatures. In particular, they are much larger than the ground-state tunnel splitting of large-spin molecules in low applied fields, of about 10 -8 K or even less (such a low value is due to the presence of large energy barriers). Theoretical predictions are experimentally checked for tunneling effects in the presence of non-equilibrated or equilibrated spin-energy distribution. It is also shown that the phonon-bath plays no role in low field, except when the temperature approaches the cross-over temperature to the thermal activation regime. In fact, spin–phonon transitions can play a role only if the tunnel splitting is not too small in comparison with k B T . This is the case both for large-spin molecules in a large magnetic field (e.g. Mn 12 - ac in a few tesla) and for low-spin molecules, as shown with the study of the molecule V 15 (Hilbert space dimension as large as 2 15 and spin 1/2). We also give our latest results on the extension of these studies beyond molecular magnetism. Single-ion slow quantum relaxation is observed in rare-earth Ho 3+ ions highly diluted in an insulating matrix LiYF 4 . This relaxation is due to the coherent tunneling of individual Ho 3+ spins strongly coupled to their nuclear spins, leading to electro-nuclear entangled states at avoided level crossings. In fact tunneling of the spin system is induced by the hyperfine coupling. Together with the important role of the "spin bath", the roles of cross–spin and spin–phonon relaxations are also considered. All these results confirm the emergence of a new field of research: "mesoscopic magnetism".
Due to the quantum evolution of molecular magnetic moments, the magnetic state of nanomagnets can suffer spontaneous changes. This process can be completely quenched by environment-induced decoherence. However, we show that for typical small supported atomic objects, the substrate-induced decoherence does change the magnetic-moment evolution but does not quell it. To be specific and to compare with experiment, we analyze the spontaneous switching between two equivalent magnetization states of atomic structures formed by Fe on Cu2N/Cu (1 0 0), measured by Loth et al (2012 Science 335 196-9). Due to the substrate-induced decoherence, the Rabi oscillations proper to quantum tunneling between magnetic states are replaced by an irreversible decay of long characteristic times leading to the observed stochastic magnetization switching. We show that the corresponding switching rates are small, rapidly decreasing with system's size, with a 1/T thermal behavior and in good agreement with experiments. Quantum tunneling is recovered as the switching mechanism at extremely low temperatures below the μK range for a six-Fe-atom system and exponentially lower for larger atomic systems. The unexpected conclusion of this work is that experiments could detect the switching of these supported atomic systems because their magnetization evolution is somewhere between complete decoherence-induced stability and unobservably fast quantum-tunneling switching.
Among the most important parameters for the usefulness of quantum computers are the size of the quantum register and the decoherence time for the quantum information. The decoherence time is expected to get shorter with the number of correlated qubits, but experimental data are only available for small numbers of qubits. Solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance allows one to correlate large numbers of qubits (several hundred) and measure their decoherence rates. We use a modified magnetic dipole-dipole interaction to correlate the proton spins in a solid sample and observe the decay of the resulting highly correlated states. By systematically varying the number of correlated spins, we measure the increase of the decoherence rate with the size of the quantum register.