Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0209417 · Physical Review Letters

Comment on “Confinement of Slave Particles in U(1) Gauge Theories of Strongly Interacting Electrons”

Masaki Oshikawa

Published Nov 5, 2003• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

I reexamine the Nayak's criticism [Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 178 (2000); 86, 943 (2001).] on the U(1) gauge theory approach to the strongly correlated systems. Contrary to his conclusion, the arbitrariness of the charge assignment observed by him does not contradict the possibility of a deconfinement. Should the deconfinement occur, the deconfined slave particle carries an effective fractional charge, which is independent of the arbitrary assignment but is rather determined dynamically.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.91.199701

Related papers

Comment on “Confinement of Slave Particles in U(1) Gauge Theories of Strongly Interacting Electrons”

Ikuo Ichinose, Tetsuo Matsui

In a recent Letter, Nayak argued that slave partices are always confined in gauge theories of strongly-correlated electron systems like the t-J model. The argument mostly relies on Elitzur's theorem and the fact that the effective gauge theory under discussion is at infinite coupling. On the other hand, in the previous papers we studied dynamics of the gauge theory of the t-J model showing that the slave particles are in the Coulomb phase below certain critical temperature T{CSS} that depends on hole doping. We comment on the discrepancy between the results in two papers.

arXiv:cond-mat/0008099•Physical Review Letters•Jan 29, 2001•18 citations

Confinement of Slave Particles in U(1) Gauge Theories of Strongly Interacting Electrons

Chetan Nayak

We show that slave particles are always confined in U(1) gauge theories of interacting electron systems. Consequently, the low-lying degrees of freedom are different from the slave particles. This is done by constructing a dual formulation of the slave-particle representation in which the no-double-occupancy constraint becomes linear and, hence, soluble. Spin-charge separation, if it occurs, is due to the existence of solitons with fractional quantum numbers in a particular dual action.

arXiv:cond-mat/9912270•Physical Review Letters•Jul 3, 2000•42 citations

Fractionalization and confinement in theU(1) andZ2gauge theories of strongly correlated systems

T. Senthil, Matthew P. A. Fisher

Recently, we have elucidated the physics of electron fractionalization in strongly interacting electron systems using a Z 2 gauge theory formulation. Here we discuss the connection with the earlier U (1) gauge theory approaches based on the slave boson mean field theory. In particular, we identify the relationship between the holons and Spinons of the slave-boson theory and the true physical excitations of the fractionalized phases that are readily described in the Z 2 approach.

arXiv:cond-mat/0006500•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Mar 2, 2001•23 citations

On attraction between particles with fractionalized quantum numbers in one-dimensional devices

Bogdan Andrei Bernevig, Domenico Giuliano, R. B. Laughlin

We make some comments about the results we obtained in Phys. Rev. Lett. 86,3392(2001), and in Phys. Rev. Lett.87, 177206 (2001), and show that the conclusion of a recent paper [cond-mat/0409495] leveling some criticism on our results is, in fact, incorrect

arXiv:cond-mat/0410147•Oct 6, 2004•3 citations

Mechanism of charge-spin separation in thet-Jmodel: Dynamics ofU(1) gauge theory with multiple gauge fields

Ikuo Ichinose, Tetsuo Matsui

The mechanism of the charge-spin separation (CSS) in the t-J model, both in the slave-boson and the slave-fermion representations, is studied in detail from the viewpoint of gauge theory. The dynamics of the composite gauge bosons, i.e., of phase degrees of freedom of mean fields defined on links, is carefully analyzed. The Polyakov-Sussskind theory of the confinement-deconfinement (CD) phase transition plays an essential role in this analysis. As we showed generally in our previous paper, the CSS phase corresponds to the deconfinement phase of gauge theory of the mean field. The quasiparticles here are holons, spinons, and gauge bosons. Across the CD transition, another phase, the electron phase, is realized, which corresponds to the confinement phase of gauge theory. The quasiparticles in this phase are conventional electrons, which may be viewed as bound states of holons and spinons. In this paper, we demonstrate that the two-dimensional t-J model exhibits the phenomenon of CSS below a certain critical temperature ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathrm{CD}}$, the CD transition temperature, and calculate ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathrm{CD}}$ as a function of hole concentration. The most important contribution to the realization of CSS comes from nonrelativistic gapless excitations via screening of confining potential among holons and spinons. Reflecting upon two kinds of mean fields, i.e., in the normal and super channels, the resulting CSS deconfinement phase of the t-J model is further classified into Coulomb and Higgs phases. By applying the Polyakov-Susskind theory, they are described by the spin-ordered phase of the isotropic and of the anisotropic XY spin model, respectively.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•May 1, 1995•36 citations

Consistent gauge theories for the slave particle representation of the strongly correlated t – J model

Xi Luo, Tao Shi, Yue Yu +1 more

Abstract We aim to clarify the confusion and inconsistency in our recent works (Luo et al 2023 Commun. Theor. Phys. 75 095702; Liang et al 2024 Phys. Rev. B 110 075125), and to address the incompleteness therein. In order to avoid the ill-defined nature of the free propagator of the gauge field in the ordered states of the t – J model, we adopted a gauge fixing that was not of the Becchi–Rouet–Stora–Tyutin (BRST) exact form in our previous work (Liang et al 2024 Phys. Rev. B 110 075125). This led to the situation where Dirac’s second-class constraints, namely, the slave particle number constraint and the Ioffe–Larkin current constraint, were not rigorously obeyed. Here we show that a consistent gauge fixing condition that enforces the exact constraints is BRST-exact in our theory. An example is the Lorenz gauge. On the other hand, we prove that although the free propagator of the gauge field in the Lorenz gauge is ill-defined, the full propagator is still well-defined. This implies that the strongly correlated t – J model can be exactly mapped to a perturbatively controllable theory within the slave particle representation.

arXiv:2510.09264•Communications in Theoretical Physics•Dec 25, 2025•0 citations
I reexamine the Nayak's criticism [Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 178 (2000); 86, 943 (2001).] on the U(1) gauge theory approach to the strongly correlated systems. Contrary to his conclusion, the arbitrariness of the charge assignment observed by him does not contradict the possibility of a deconfinement. Should the deconfinement occur, the deconfined slave particle carries an effective fractional charge, which is independent of the arbitrary assignment but is rather determined dynamically.
In a recent Letter, Nayak argued that slave partices are always confined in gauge theories of strongly-correlated electron systems like the t-J model. The argument mostly relies on Elitzur's theorem and the fact that the effective gauge theory under discussion is at infinite coupling. On the other hand, in the previous papers we studied dynamics of the gauge theory of the t-J model showing that the slave particles are in the Coulomb phase below certain critical temperature T{CSS} that depends on hole doping. We comment on the discrepancy between the results in two papers.
The mechanism of the charge-spin separation (CSS) in the t-J model, both in the slave-boson and the slave-fermion representations, is studied in detail from the viewpoint of gauge theory. The dynamics of the composite gauge bosons, i.e., of phase degrees of freedom of mean fields defined on links, is carefully analyzed. The Polyakov-Sussskind theory of the confinement-deconfinement (CD) phase transition plays an essential role in this analysis. As we showed generally in our previous paper, the CSS phase corresponds to the deconfinement phase of gauge theory of the mean field. The quasiparticles here are holons, spinons, and gauge bosons. Across the CD transition, another phase, the electron phase, is realized, which corresponds to the confinement phase of gauge theory. The quasiparticles in this phase are conventional electrons, which may be viewed as bound states of holons and spinons. In this paper, we demonstrate that the two-dimensional t-J model exhibits the phenomenon of CSS below a certain critical temperature TCD{\mathit{T}}_{\mathrm{CD}}TCD​, the CD transition temperature, and calculate TCD{\mathit{T}}_{\mathrm{CD}}TCD​ as a function of hole concentration. The most important contribution to the realization of CSS comes from nonrelativistic gapless excitations via screening of confining potential among holons and spinons. Reflecting upon two kinds of mean fields, i.e., in the normal and super channels, the resulting CSS deconfinement phase of the t-J model is further classified into Coulomb and Higgs phases. By applying the Polyakov-Susskind theory, they are described by the spin-ordered phase of the isotropic and of the anisotropic XY spin model, respectively.
Abstract We aim to clarify the confusion and inconsistency in our recent works (Luo et al 2023 Commun. Theor. Phys. 75 095702; Liang et al 2024 Phys. Rev. B 110 075125), and to address the incompleteness therein. In order to avoid the ill-defined nature of the free propagator of the gauge field in the ordered states of the t – J model, we adopted a gauge fixing that was not of the Becchi–Rouet–Stora–Tyutin (BRST) exact form in our previous work (Liang et al 2024 Phys. Rev. B 110 075125). This led to the situation where Dirac’s second-class constraints, namely, the slave particle number constraint and the Ioffe–Larkin current constraint, were not rigorously obeyed. Here we show that a consistent gauge fixing condition that enforces the exact constraints is BRST-exact in our theory. An example is the Lorenz gauge. On the other hand, we prove that although the free propagator of the gauge field in the Lorenz gauge is ill-defined, the full propagator is still well-defined. This implies that the strongly correlated t – J model can be exactly mapped to a perturbatively controllable theory within the slave particle representation.