Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0104284 · Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics

Energies and collapse times of symmetric and symmetry-breaking states of finite systems with a U(1) symmetry

Akira Shimizu, Takayuki Miyadera

Published Oct 24, 2001• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study quantum systems of volume V, which will exhibit the breaking of a U(1) symmetry in the limit of V-->infinity, when V is large but finite. We estimate the energy difference between the "symmetric ground state" (SGS), which is the lowest-energy state that does not break the symmetry, and a "pure phase vacuum" (PPV), which approaches a symmetry-breaking vacuum as V-->infinity. Under some natural postulates on the energy of the SGS, it is shown that PPVs always have a higher energy than the SGS, and we derive a lower bound of the excess energy. We argue that the lower bound is O(V0), which becomes much larger than the excitation energies of low-lying excited states for a large V. We also discuss the collapse time of PPVs for interacting many bosons. It is shown that the wave function collapses in a microscopic time scale, because PPVs are not energy eigenstates. We show, however, that for PPVs the expectation value of any observable, which is a finite polynomial of boson operators and their derivatives, does not collapse for a macroscopic time scale. In this sense, the collapse time of PPVs is macroscopically long.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.64.056121

Related papers

Fragility of Thermodynamically-Abnormal Ground States of Finite Systems

Takayuki Miyadera, Shimizu, Akira

We study a general macroscopic quantum system of a finite size, which will exhibit a symmetry breaking if the system size goes to infinity, when the system interacts with an environment. We evaluate the decoherence rates of the anomalously fluctuating vacuum (AFV), which is the symmetric ground state, and the pure phase vacua (PPVs). By making full use of the locality and huge degrees of freedom, we show that there can exist an interaction with an environment which makes the decoherence rate of the AFV anomalously fast, whereas PPVs are less fragile.

arXiv:quant-ph/0109065•Sep 14, 2001•1 citation

Giant Number-Parity Effect Leading to Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking in Finite-Size Quantum Spin Models

Filippo Caleca, Saverio Bocini, Fabio Mezzacapo +1 more

Spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) occurs when a many-body system governed by a symmetric Hamiltonian, and prepared in a symmetry-broken state by the application of a field coupling to its order parameter O, retains a finite O value even after the field is switched off. SSB is generally thought to occur only in the thermodynamic limit N→∞ (for N degrees of freedom). In this limit, the time to restore the symmetry once the field is turned off, either via thermal or quantum fluctuations, is expected to diverge. Here, we show that SSB can also be observed in finite-size quantum spin systems, provided that the spin is half-integer and three conditions are met: (1) the ground state of the system has long-range correlations, (2) the Hamiltonian conserves the (spin) parity of the order parameter, and (3) N is odd. Using a combination of analytical arguments and numerical results (based on time-dependent variational Monte Carlo and rotor + spin-wave theory), we show that SSB on finite-size systems can be achieved via a quasiadiabatic preparation of the ground state-which, in U(1)-symmetric systems, is shown to require a symmetry-breaking field vanishing over timescales τ∼O(N). In these systems, the symmetry-broken state exhibits spin squeezing with Heisenberg scaling.

arXiv:2412.15493•Physical Review Letters•Nov 10, 2025•4 citations

Wave Function Collapse as a Real Physical Phenomenon Caused by Vacuum Fluctuations Near the Planck Scale

Friedwardt Winterberg

Abstract It is hypothesized that the collapse of the wave function is a real physical phenomenon caused by vacuum fluctuations near the Planck scale. The hypothesis is suggested by a recently proposed model (Planck aether model) according to which the fundamental kinematic symmetry is the Galilei-group with the Lorentz invariance as a derived dynamic symmetry. The proposed model has the goal to derive all fields and their interactions from an exactly nonrelativistic operator field equation, resembling Heisenberg's relativistic spinor field equation. In this model the groundstate of the vacuum is a superfluid consisting of an equal number of positive and negative Planck masses interacting via delta function potentials and making the cosmological constant equal to zero. Gauge bosons come from transverse waves propagating in a lattice of quantized vortices, and spinors are explained in this model as exciton-like quasiparticles held together by gauge bosons. Because vector gauge bosons move in the model with the velocity of light, objects held together by the forcc fields of these bosons obey Lorentz invariance as a dynamic symmetry. With the longitudinal wave modes moving with a superluminal phase velocity at energies near the Planck scale, it is conjectured that the quantum mechanical wave function is real and that its collapse results from the entrapment of the wave function by these longitudinal superluminal wave modes. Because these modes occur near the Planck scale their very large zero point fluctuations might therefore trigger the collapse even through dense matter. But because the fluctuations are finite, and because the wave modes have a finite albeit very large phase velocity, the quantum mechanical correlations would be broken above a ccrtain finite length. In the limit of a vanishing Planck length, and hence vanishing gravitational constant G, the phase velocity would become infinite, and the same would be true for the length above which the correlations are broken. One therefore may say that in the limit G = 0 the collapse is infinitely fast and that in this limit the correlations are not broken even over arbitrarily large distances

Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A•Sep 1, 1991•9 citations

Defect formation preempts dynamical symmetry breaking in closed quantum systems

Carmine Ortix, Jorrit Rijnbeek, Jeroen van den Brink

The theory of spontaneous symmetry breaking---one of the cornerstones of modern condensed-matter physics---underlies the connection between a classically ordered object in the thermodynamic limit and its microscopic quantum-mechanical constituents. However, a large, but not infinitely large, system requires a finite symmetry-breaking perturbation to stabilize a symmetry-broken state over the exact quantum-mechanical ground state, respecting the symmetry. Here, we use the example of a particular antiferromagnetic model system to show that no matter how slowly such a symmetry-breaking perturbation is driven, the adiabatic limit can never be reached. Dynamically induced collective excitations---``quantum defects''---preempt the symmetry-breaking phenomenon and trigger the appearance of a symmetric nonequilibrium state that recursively collapses into the classical equilibrium state, breaking the symmetry at punctured times. The presence of this state allows ``quantum-classical'' transitions to be investigated and controlled in mesoscopic devices by externally supplying a proper dynamical symmetry-breaking perturbation.

arXiv:1103.3208•Physical Review B•Oct 21, 2011•3 citations

Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking

Tomáš Brauner

The roots of the modern understanding of symmetries in physics can be traced to the work of Sophus Lie on transformations of differential equations in the nineteenth century. In this chapter, the history of the subject is used to emphasize the distinction between the symmetry of the dynamics of a physical system and the symmetry of its specific state. The central concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking is then introduced as the discrepancy between the two notions of symmetry. It is shown how the presence of spontaneous symmetry breaking can be detected through the sensitivity of measurements on the physical state to external perturbations. This naturally leads to the concepts of the order parameter and the vacuum manifold. The rest of the chapter is devoted to highlighting some subtle features of spontaneous symmetry breaking. These include the properties of the ground state and the tower of low-lying excited states in a finite volume, and the absence of well-defined unitary operators representing broken symmetry in the thermodynamic limit.

Lecture notes in physics•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

Interpretations of ground-state symmetry breaking and strong correlation in wavefunction and density functional theories

John P. Perdew, Adrienn Ruzsinszky, Jianwei Sun +2 more

Significance The ground state of a quantum mechanical system is the lowest-energy eigenstate of the Hamiltonian. In isolation, it persists unchanged forever, with symmetries dictated by those of the Hamiltonian. But near-eigenstates of broken symmetry can persist for long times, even on the scale of human measurement. The appearance of broken symmetries of the electron density or spin density in a density functional calculation can reveal strong correlations among the electrons that are present in a symmetry-unbroken wavefunction. Symmetry breaking can arise when a wave-like fluctuation drops to zero frequency. The presented examples are the stretched hydrogen molecule, antiferromagnetism in solids, and the static charge-density wave in a low-density jellium, which is shown quantitatively to be a zero-frequency plasma wave.

arXiv:2007.12052•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Jan 20, 2021•111 citations
We study quantum systems of volume V, which will exhibit the breaking of a U(1) symmetry in the limit of V-->infinity, when V is large but finite. We estimate the energy difference between the "symmetric ground state" (SGS), which is the lowest-energy state that does not break the symmetry, and a "pure phase vacuum" (PPV), which approaches a symmetry-breaking vacuum as V-->infinity. Under some natural postulates on the energy of the SGS, it is shown that PPVs always have a higher energy than the SGS, and we derive a lower bound of the excess energy. We argue that the lower bound is O(V0), which becomes much larger than the excitation energies of low-lying excited states for a large V. We also discuss the collapse time of PPVs for interacting many bosons. It is shown that the wave function collapses in a microscopic time scale, because PPVs are not energy eigenstates. We show, however, that for PPVs the expectation value of any observable, which is a finite polynomial of boson operators and their derivatives, does not collapse for a macroscopic time scale. In this sense, the collapse time of PPVs is macroscopically long.
We study a general macroscopic quantum system of a finite size, which will exhibit a symmetry breaking if the system size goes to infinity, when the system interacts with an environment. We evaluate the decoherence rates of the anomalously fluctuating vacuum (AFV), which is the symmetric ground state, and the pure phase vacua (PPVs). By making full use of the locality and huge degrees of freedom, we show that there can exist an interaction with an environment which makes the decoherence rate of the AFV anomalously fast, whereas PPVs are less fragile.
Spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) occurs when a many-body system governed by a symmetric Hamiltonian, and prepared in a symmetry-broken state by the application of a field coupling to its order parameter O, retains a finite O value even after the field is switched off. SSB is generally thought to occur only in the thermodynamic limit N→∞ (for N degrees of freedom). In this limit, the time to restore the symmetry once the field is turned off, either via thermal or quantum fluctuations, is expected to diverge. Here, we show that SSB can also be observed in finite-size quantum spin systems, provided that the spin is half-integer and three conditions are met: (1) the ground state of the system has long-range correlations, (2) the Hamiltonian conserves the (spin) parity of the order parameter, and (3) N is odd. Using a combination of analytical arguments and numerical results (based on time-dependent variational Monte Carlo and rotor + spin-wave theory), we show that SSB on finite-size systems can be achieved via a quasiadiabatic preparation of the ground state-which, in U(1)-symmetric systems, is shown to require a symmetry-breaking field vanishing over timescales τ∼O(N). In these systems, the symmetry-broken state exhibits spin squeezing with Heisenberg scaling.
Abstract It is hypothesized that the collapse of the wave function is a real physical phenomenon caused by vacuum fluctuations near the Planck scale. The hypothesis is suggested by a recently proposed model (Planck aether model) according to which the fundamental kinematic symmetry is the Galilei-group with the Lorentz invariance as a derived dynamic symmetry. The proposed model has the goal to derive all fields and their interactions from an exactly nonrelativistic operator field equation, resembling Heisenberg's relativistic spinor field equation. In this model the groundstate of the vacuum is a superfluid consisting of an equal number of positive and negative Planck masses interacting via delta function potentials and making the cosmological constant equal to zero. Gauge bosons come from transverse waves propagating in a lattice of quantized vortices, and spinors are explained in this model as exciton-like quasiparticles held together by gauge bosons. Because vector gauge bosons move in the model with the velocity of light, objects held together by the forcc fields of these bosons obey Lorentz invariance as a dynamic symmetry. With the longitudinal wave modes moving with a superluminal phase velocity at energies near the Planck scale, it is conjectured that the quantum mechanical wave function is real and that its collapse results from the entrapment of the wave function by these longitudinal superluminal wave modes. Because these modes occur near the Planck scale their very large zero point fluctuations might therefore trigger the collapse even through dense matter. But because the fluctuations are finite, and because the wave modes have a finite albeit very large phase velocity, the quantum mechanical correlations would be broken above a ccrtain finite length. In the limit of a vanishing Planck length, and hence vanishing gravitational constant G, the phase velocity would become infinite, and the same would be true for the length above which the correlations are broken. One therefore may say that in the limit G = 0 the collapse is infinitely fast and that in this limit the correlations are not broken even over arbitrarily large distances
The theory of spontaneous symmetry breaking---one of the cornerstones of modern condensed-matter physics---underlies the connection between a classically ordered object in the thermodynamic limit and its microscopic quantum-mechanical constituents. However, a large, but not infinitely large, system requires a finite symmetry-breaking perturbation to stabilize a symmetry-broken state over the exact quantum-mechanical ground state, respecting the symmetry. Here, we use the example of a particular antiferromagnetic model system to show that no matter how slowly such a symmetry-breaking perturbation is driven, the adiabatic limit can never be reached. Dynamically induced collective excitations---``quantum defects''---preempt the symmetry-breaking phenomenon and trigger the appearance of a symmetric nonequilibrium state that recursively collapses into the classical equilibrium state, breaking the symmetry at punctured times. The presence of this state allows ``quantum-classical'' transitions to be investigated and controlled in mesoscopic devices by externally supplying a proper dynamical symmetry-breaking perturbation.
The roots of the modern understanding of symmetries in physics can be traced to the work of Sophus Lie on transformations of differential equations in the nineteenth century. In this chapter, the history of the subject is used to emphasize the distinction between the symmetry of the dynamics of a physical system and the symmetry of its specific state. The central concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking is then introduced as the discrepancy between the two notions of symmetry. It is shown how the presence of spontaneous symmetry breaking can be detected through the sensitivity of measurements on the physical state to external perturbations. This naturally leads to the concepts of the order parameter and the vacuum manifold. The rest of the chapter is devoted to highlighting some subtle features of spontaneous symmetry breaking. These include the properties of the ground state and the tower of low-lying excited states in a finite volume, and the absence of well-defined unitary operators representing broken symmetry in the thermodynamic limit.
Significance The ground state of a quantum mechanical system is the lowest-energy eigenstate of the Hamiltonian. In isolation, it persists unchanged forever, with symmetries dictated by those of the Hamiltonian. But near-eigenstates of broken symmetry can persist for long times, even on the scale of human measurement. The appearance of broken symmetries of the electron density or spin density in a density functional calculation can reveal strong correlations among the electrons that are present in a symmetry-unbroken wavefunction. Symmetry breaking can arise when a wave-like fluctuation drops to zero frequency. The presented examples are the stretched hydrogen molecule, antiferromagnetism in solids, and the static charge-density wave in a low-density jellium, which is shown quantitatively to be a zero-frequency plasma wave.