Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0102429

Charge superselection rule does not rule out pure states of subsystems to be coherent superpositions of states with different charges

Shimizu, Akira, Takayuki Miyadera

Published Feb 23, 2001• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider a huge quantum system that is subject to the charge superselection rule, which requires that any pure state must be an eigenstate of the total charge. We regard some parts of the system as "subsystems," and the rest as an environment E. We assume that one does not measure anything of E, i.e., one is only interested in observables of the subsystems. We show that there exist states with the following properties: (i) Its reduced density operator is completely equivalent to a vector state of the subsystems for any gauge-invariant observable of the subsystems. (ii) The vector state is a simple product of vector states of individual subsystems, each of which is not an eigenstate of the charge of each subsystem. Furthermore, one can associate to each subsystem its vector state, which is a pure state, and observables which are not necessarily gauge invariant in each subsystem. These results justify taking (a) superpositions of states with different charges, and (b) non-gauge-invariant operators, such as the order parameter of the breaking of the gauge symmetry, as observables, for subsystems.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.cond-mat/0102429

Related papers

AB effect and Aharonov–Susskind charge non-superselection

N Erez

We consider a particle in a coherent superposition of states with different electric charges moving in the vicinity of a magnetic flux. Formally, it should acquire a (gauge-dependent) Aharonov–Bohm (AB) relative phase between the charge states, even for an incomplete loop. If measurable, such a geometric, rather than topological, AB phase would seem to break gauge invariance. Wick, Wightman and Wigner argued that since (global) charge-dependent phase transformations are physically unobservable, charge state superpositions are unphysical (‘charge superselection rule’). This would resolve the apparent paradox in a trivial way. However, Aharonov and Susskind disputed this superselection rule: they distinguished between such global charge-dependent transformations and transformations of the relative inter-charge phases of two particles, and showed that the latter could in principle be observable! Finally, the paradox again disappears once we consider the ‘calibration’ of the phase measured by the Aharonov–Susskind phase detectors, as well as the phase of the particle at its initial point. It turns out that such a detector can only distinguish between the relative phases of two paths if their (oriented) difference forms a loop around the flux.

arXiv:1003.1044•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Aug 12, 2010•3 citations

Charge Superselection Rule

Yakir Aharonov, Leonard Susskind

Questions concerning superselection rules are considered. Two experiments are discussed. In the first, coherent superpositions of different angular-momentum states are constructed. In the second, coherent superpositions of states with different charge are constructed in complete analogy with the angular-momentum case. We suggest that, contrary to a widespread belief, interference may be possible between states with different charges.

Physical Review•Mar 25, 1967•247 citations

A first-quantized proof of the symmetrization postulate

Donald Edward Wagoner

Methods used to prove the existence of superselection rules are studied in detail. It is shown that the known methods of proving superselection rules are applicable only if the superselecting operator is an observable. In particular, place permutations are not observables, so the fact that place permutations commute with all observables does not lead to a superselection rule between vectors of different symmetry types. It is shown that if states not having a definite symmetry type can exist, then it is possible to have several different states which are eigenstates of the same observables with the same eigenvalues. In this case a maximal set of observables does not exist. Therefore a proof of the Symmetrization Postulate (SP) which assumes a maximal set of observables actually presupposes part of what is to be proved. A rigorous proof of the SP must depend only on the weaker assumption of a non-degenerate set of observables. The usual formulation of the Transition Probability Postulate (TPP) is used to construct a trivial proof of the assertion that physical states are represented by unique rays in Hilbert space; however the feature of the TPP which is essential to this proof is not essential to the TPP itself. The features of the TPP which are essential for computing transition probabilities are identified. These essential features of the TPP are then used to prove that states are represented by unique rays. The difficulties involved in rigorously defining the interchange operator Pij are discussed and a careful definition of Pij is given. The uniqueness of the ray is then used to show that states of systems containing several indistinguishable particles must be eigenstates of Pij and must satisfy the Symmetrization Postulate. Finally, the SP is used to prove the slightly stronger result that a given state must have the same symmetry type for each pair of the same species of particles.

•Jan 1, 1971•0 citations

ALGEBRAIC THEORY OF SUPERSELECTION SECTORS AND THE MEASUREMENT PROBLEM IN QUANTUM MECHANICS

Nicolaas P. Landsman

A synthesis is attempted between the algebraic theory of superselection sectors (not necessarily of infinite systems), which is based on the representation theory of C* algebras (which we review), and recent ideas on the measurement problem, classical behavior in open quantum systems, and the peculiar nature of subsystems in quantum mechanics. The key point is a proper use of the notion of a state, in combination with an appropriate choice of algebras of observables for which the superposition “principle” may be invalid. In this way, a major part of the measurement problem becomes equivalent to the study of superselection sectors in models for a measurement situation, and can in principle be resolved unambiguously. Special emphasis is placed on the transition from pure to mixed states, and the (non)uniqueness of the decomposition of the latter into pure states.

International Journal of Modern Physics A•Dec 20, 1991•43 citations

On the need to revise the superposition principle for a particle with a continuous energy spectrum: superselection rule for a one-dimensional scattering

Nikolay Leonidovich Chuprikov

It is shown that spontaneous symmetry breaking occurs in this scattering problem. As a result, the unitary, asymptotically free quantum dynamics of this process is unstable. It transforms into dynamics associated with the violation of $P$- and $T$-symmetries and the appearance of a superselection rule. Here, the non-unitary scattering state is a mixed vector state, which is a coherent superposition of transmission and reflection states related to different Hamiltonians. Superselection operators for the transmission and reflection subprocesses are defined.

arXiv:1805.03952•May 3, 2018•0 citations

Physical Observables and Superselection

M. P. Vaughan

It is well-known that a physical state may be represented by a unit vector in a Hilbert space, whilst a physical observable may be represented by a self-adjoint operator on that same space. However, the introduction of a superselection rule on a Hilbert space imposes constraints such that not all self-adjoint operators can represent observables, which has further consequences for the states themselves as well as the physical processes that transform them. In this article, we review the concept of superselection from the view of how such rules would affect what we consider to be physical. Arguments for the existence of a superselection rule due to charge or possibly energy conservation are given and the emergence of effective superselection rules due to decoherence or the lack of a shared reference frame are also discussed.

arXiv:2611.17051•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations
We consider a huge quantum system that is subject to the charge superselection rule, which requires that any pure state must be an eigenstate of the total charge. We regard some parts of the system as "subsystems," and the rest as an environment E. We assume that one does not measure anything of E, i.e., one is only interested in observables of the subsystems. We show that there exist states with the following properties: (i) Its reduced density operator is completely equivalent to a vector state of the subsystems for any gauge-invariant observable of the subsystems. (ii) The vector state is a simple product of vector states of individual subsystems, each of which is not an eigenstate of the charge of each subsystem. Furthermore, one can associate to each subsystem its vector state, which is a pure state, and observables which are not necessarily gauge invariant in each subsystem. These results justify taking (a) superpositions of states with different charges, and (b) non-gauge-invariant operators, such as the order parameter of the breaking of the gauge symmetry, as observables, for subsystems.
We consider a particle in a coherent superposition of states with different electric charges moving in the vicinity of a magnetic flux. Formally, it should acquire a (gauge-dependent) Aharonov–Bohm (AB) relative phase between the charge states, even for an incomplete loop. If measurable, such a geometric, rather than topological, AB phase would seem to break gauge invariance. Wick, Wightman and Wigner argued that since (global) charge-dependent phase transformations are physically unobservable, charge state superpositions are unphysical (‘charge superselection rule’). This would resolve the apparent paradox in a trivial way. However, Aharonov and Susskind disputed this superselection rule: they distinguished between such global charge-dependent transformations and transformations of the relative inter-charge phases of two particles, and showed that the latter could in principle be observable! Finally, the paradox again disappears once we consider the ‘calibration’ of the phase measured by the Aharonov–Susskind phase detectors, as well as the phase of the particle at its initial point. It turns out that such a detector can only distinguish between the relative phases of two paths if their (oriented) difference forms a loop around the flux.
Methods used to prove the existence of superselection rules are studied in detail. It is shown that the known methods of proving superselection rules are applicable only if the superselecting operator is an observable. In particular, place permutations are not observables, so the fact that place permutations commute with all observables does not lead to a superselection rule between vectors of different symmetry types. It is shown that if states not having a definite symmetry type can exist, then it is possible to have several different states which are eigenstates of the same observables with the same eigenvalues. In this case a maximal set of observables does not exist. Therefore a proof of the Symmetrization Postulate (SP) which assumes a maximal set of observables actually presupposes part of what is to be proved. A rigorous proof of the SP must depend only on the weaker assumption of a non-degenerate set of observables. The usual formulation of the Transition Probability Postulate (TPP) is used to construct a trivial proof of the assertion that physical states are represented by unique rays in Hilbert space; however the feature of the TPP which is essential to this proof is not essential to the TPP itself. The features of the TPP which are essential for computing transition probabilities are identified. These essential features of the TPP are then used to prove that states are represented by unique rays. The difficulties involved in rigorously defining the interchange operator Pij are discussed and a careful definition of Pij is given. The uniqueness of the ray is then used to show that states of systems containing several indistinguishable particles must be eigenstates of Pij and must satisfy the Symmetrization Postulate. Finally, the SP is used to prove the slightly stronger result that a given state must have the same symmetry type for each pair of the same species of particles.
A synthesis is attempted between the algebraic theory of superselection sectors (not necessarily of infinite systems), which is based on the representation theory of C* algebras (which we review), and recent ideas on the measurement problem, classical behavior in open quantum systems, and the peculiar nature of subsystems in quantum mechanics. The key point is a proper use of the notion of a state, in combination with an appropriate choice of algebras of observables for which the superposition “principle” may be invalid. In this way, a major part of the measurement problem becomes equivalent to the study of superselection sectors in models for a measurement situation, and can in principle be resolved unambiguously. Special emphasis is placed on the transition from pure to mixed states, and the (non)uniqueness of the decomposition of the latter into pure states.
It is shown that spontaneous symmetry breaking occurs in this scattering problem. As a result, the unitary, asymptotically free quantum dynamics of this process is unstable. It transforms into dynamics associated with the violation of PPP- and TTT-symmetries and the appearance of a superselection rule. Here, the non-unitary scattering state is a mixed vector state, which is a coherent superposition of transmission and reflection states related to different Hamiltonians. Superselection operators for the transmission and reflection subprocesses are defined.
It is well-known that a physical state may be represented by a unit vector in a Hilbert space, whilst a physical observable may be represented by a self-adjoint operator on that same space. However, the introduction of a superselection rule on a Hilbert space imposes constraints such that not all self-adjoint operators can represent observables, which has further consequences for the states themselves as well as the physical processes that transform them. In this article, we review the concept of superselection from the view of how such rules would affect what we consider to be physical. Arguments for the existence of a superselection rule due to charge or possibly energy conservation are given and the emergence of effective superselection rules due to decoherence or the lack of a shared reference frame are also discussed.