Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0001105 · Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics Letters

Critical behavior of frustrated systems: Monte Carlo simulations versus renormalization group

Damien Loison, Aleksandr Ivanovich Sokolov, Bertrand Delamotte, S. A. Antonenko, K. D. Schotte, H. T. Diep

Published Sep 1, 2000• 27 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the critical behavior of frustrated systems by means of the Padé-Borel resummed three-loop renormalization group expansions and numerical Monte Carlo simulations. Amazingly, for six-component spins, where the transition is second-order, both approaches disagree. This unusual situation is analyzed both from the point of view of the convergence of the resummed series and from the possible relevance of nonperturbative effects.

DOI
10.1134/1.1328451

Related papers

Nonperturbative renormalization-group approach to frustrated magnets

Bertrand Delamotte, D. Mouhanna, Matthieu Tissier

This article is devoted to the study of the critical properties of classical XY and Heisenberg frustrated magnets in three dimensions. We first analyze the experimental and numerical situations. We show that the unusual behaviors encountered in these systems, typically nonuniversal scaling, are hardly compatible with the hypothesis of a second order phase transition. Moreover, the fact that the scaling laws are significantly violated and that the anomalous dimension is negative in many cases provides strong indications that the transitions in frustrated magnets are most probably of very weak first order. We then review the various perturbative and early nonperturbative approaches used to investigate these systems and argue that none of them provides a completely satisfactory description of the three-dimensional critical behavior. We then recall the principles of the nonperturbative approach---the effective average action method---that we have used to investigate the physics of frustrated magnets and show how it enables to clarify most of the problems encountered in the previous theoretical descriptions of frustrated magnets. First, we get an explanation of the long-standing mismatch between different perturbative approaches which consists in a nonperturbative mechanism of annihilation of fixed points between two and three dimensions. Secondly, we get a coherent picture of the physics of frustrated magnets in agreement with the numerical and experimental results. The central feature that emerges from our approach is the existence of scaling behaviors without fixed or pseudofixed point and that relies on a slowing down of the renormalization group flow in a whole region in the coupling constants space. This phenomenon allow us to explain the occurrence of generic weak first order behaviors and to understand the absence of universality in the critical behavior of frustrated magnets.

arXiv:cond-mat/0309101•Physical Review B•Apr 9, 2004•224 citations

Critical behavior of the weakly disordered Ising model: Six-loop ɛ expansion study

Mikhail Vladimirovich Kompaniets, Andrey Kudlis, Aleksandr Ivanovich Sokolov

The critical behavior of three-dimensional weakly diluted quenched Ising model is examined on the base of six-loop renormalization group expansions obtained within the minimal subtraction scheme in 4-ɛ space dimensions. For this purpose the ϕ^{4} field theory with cubic symmetry was analyzed in the replica limit n→0. Along with renormalization group expansions in terms of renormalized couplings the sqrt[ɛ] expansions of critical exponents are presented. Corresponding numerical estimates for the physical, three-dimensional system are obtained by means of different resummation procedures applied both to the sqrt[ɛ] series and to initial renormalization group expansions. The results given by the latter approach are in a good agreement with their counterparts obtained experimentally and within the Monte Carlo simulations, while resumming of sqrt[ɛ] series themselves turned out to be disappointing.

arXiv:2011.10782•Physical review. E•Feb 19, 2021•9 citations

Relevance of the fixed dimension perturbative approach to frustrated magnets in two and three dimensions

Bertrand Delamotte, M. Dudka, Yurij V. Holovatch +1 more

We show that the critical behavior of two- and three-dimensional frustrated magnets cannot reliably be described from the known five- and six-loop perturbative renormalization-group results. Our conclusions are based on a careful reanalysis of the resummed perturbative series obtained within the zero-momentum massive scheme. In three dimensions, the critical exponents for XY and Heisenberg spins display strong dependences on the parameters of the resummation procedure and on the loop order. This behavior strongly suggests that the fixed points found are in fact spurious. In two dimensions, we find, as in the $O(N)$ case, that there is apparent convergence of the critical exponents but toward erroneous values. As a consequence, the interesting question of the description of the crossover/transition induced by ${Z}_{2}$ topological defects in two-dimensional frustrated Heisenberg spins remains open.

arXiv:1009.1492•Physical Review B•Sep 30, 2010•49 citations

Application of the renormalization group to phase transitions in disordered systems

G. Grinstein, Alan H. Luther

The critical behavior of spin systems with quenched disorder is studied by renormalization-group methods. For the randomly dilute $m$-vector model, the $n=0$ limit is used to construct a translationally invariant effective Hamiltonian which describes the original disordered system. This Hamiltonian is analyzed in the $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$ expansion to order ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}$. Sharp second-order phase transitions with exponents which do not depend continuously on impurity concentration are predicted. For $m>{m}_{c}\ensuremath{\equiv}4\ensuremath{-}4\ensuremath{\epsilon}+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2})$ the isotropic $m$-component fixed point, which characterizes the critical behavior of the pure system, is stable. For $m<{m}_{c}$, a new random fixed point becomes stable. The exponents corresponding to this fixed point are $\ensuremath{\eta}=[\frac{(5{m}^{2}\ensuremath{-}8m)}{256{(m\ensuremath{-}1)}^{2}}]{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{3})$, $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{1}{2}+[\frac{3m}{32(m\ensuremath{-}1)}]\ensuremath{\epsilon}+[\frac{m(127{m}^{2}\ensuremath{-}572m\ensuremath{-}32)}{4096{(m\ensuremath{-}1)}^{3}}]{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{3})$ for $m\ensuremath{\ne}1$, and $\ensuremath{\eta}=\ensuremath{-}\frac{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}{106}+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{\frac{3}{2}})$, $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{1}{2}+\frac{{(\frac{6\ensuremath{\epsilon}}{53})}^{\frac{1}{2}}}{4}+O(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$ for $m=1$. More general random systems are qualitatively discussed from the effective-Hamiltonian viewpoint.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Feb 1, 1976•523 citations

On the crossover to universal criticality in dilute Ising systems

H. K. Janssen, Klaus Oerding, E Sengespeick

Monte Carlo simulations of the critical behaviour of disordered Ising systems have led to concentration-dependent critical exponents which seem to violate universality. We apply the renormalization group to investigate the crossover effects which cause the observed behaviour. We improve the three-loop expansion of the Callan-Symanzik and Wilson functions by a Pade-Borel approximation and solve the flow equations for various initial points. The exponents found in the simulations can be related to regions in the space of coupling coefficients away from the fixed point.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Nov 7, 1995•54 citations

Critical behavior of the three-state Potts model: Monte Carlo renormalization group

Robert H. Swendsen, A. Nihat Berker

The critical behavior of the three-state Potts model in two dimensions is investigated with the use of the Monte Carlo renormalization group (MCRG), and the results are compared with conjectured values as well as with other methods. Recent advances in the MCRG enable greatly improved convergence, as well as greater insight into the structure of the renormalization transformation. The introduction of a four-point interaction is used to control the chemical potential of effective vacancies in a purely Potts Hamiltonian.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Oct 1, 1983•7 citations
We study the critical behavior of frustrated systems by means of the Padé-Borel resummed three-loop renormalization group expansions and numerical Monte Carlo simulations. Amazingly, for six-component spins, where the transition is second-order, both approaches disagree. This unusual situation is analyzed both from the point of view of the convergence of the resummed series and from the possible relevance of nonperturbative effects.
This article is devoted to the study of the critical properties of classical XY and Heisenberg frustrated magnets in three dimensions. We first analyze the experimental and numerical situations. We show that the unusual behaviors encountered in these systems, typically nonuniversal scaling, are hardly compatible with the hypothesis of a second order phase transition. Moreover, the fact that the scaling laws are significantly violated and that the anomalous dimension is negative in many cases provides strong indications that the transitions in frustrated magnets are most probably of very weak first order. We then review the various perturbative and early nonperturbative approaches used to investigate these systems and argue that none of them provides a completely satisfactory description of the three-dimensional critical behavior. We then recall the principles of the nonperturbative approach---the effective average action method---that we have used to investigate the physics of frustrated magnets and show how it enables to clarify most of the problems encountered in the previous theoretical descriptions of frustrated magnets. First, we get an explanation of the long-standing mismatch between different perturbative approaches which consists in a nonperturbative mechanism of annihilation of fixed points between two and three dimensions. Secondly, we get a coherent picture of the physics of frustrated magnets in agreement with the numerical and experimental results. The central feature that emerges from our approach is the existence of scaling behaviors without fixed or pseudofixed point and that relies on a slowing down of the renormalization group flow in a whole region in the coupling constants space. This phenomenon allow us to explain the occurrence of generic weak first order behaviors and to understand the absence of universality in the critical behavior of frustrated magnets.
The critical behavior of three-dimensional weakly diluted quenched Ising model is examined on the base of six-loop renormalization group expansions obtained within the minimal subtraction scheme in 4-ɛ space dimensions. For this purpose the ϕ^{4} field theory with cubic symmetry was analyzed in the replica limit n→0. Along with renormalization group expansions in terms of renormalized couplings the sqrt[ɛ] expansions of critical exponents are presented. Corresponding numerical estimates for the physical, three-dimensional system are obtained by means of different resummation procedures applied both to the sqrt[ɛ] series and to initial renormalization group expansions. The results given by the latter approach are in a good agreement with their counterparts obtained experimentally and within the Monte Carlo simulations, while resumming of sqrt[ɛ] series themselves turned out to be disappointing.
We show that the critical behavior of two- and three-dimensional frustrated magnets cannot reliably be described from the known five- and six-loop perturbative renormalization-group results. Our conclusions are based on a careful reanalysis of the resummed perturbative series obtained within the zero-momentum massive scheme. In three dimensions, the critical exponents for XY and Heisenberg spins display strong dependences on the parameters of the resummation procedure and on the loop order. This behavior strongly suggests that the fixed points found are in fact spurious. In two dimensions, we find, as in the O(N)O(N)O(N) case, that there is apparent convergence of the critical exponents but toward erroneous values. As a consequence, the interesting question of the description of the crossover/transition induced by Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ topological defects in two-dimensional frustrated Heisenberg spins remains open.
The critical behavior of spin systems with quenched disorder is studied by renormalization-group methods. For the randomly dilute mmm-vector model, the n=0n=0n=0 limit is used to construct a translationally invariant effective Hamiltonian which describes the original disordered system. This Hamiltonian is analyzed in the $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$ expansion to order ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}$. Sharp second-order phase transitions with exponents which do not depend continuously on impurity concentration are predicted. For $m>{m}_{c}\ensuremath{\equiv}4\ensuremath{-}4\ensuremath{\epsilon}+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2})$ the isotropic mmm-component fixed point, which characterizes the critical behavior of the pure system, is stable. For m<mcm<{m}_{c}m<mc​, a new random fixed point becomes stable. The exponents corresponding to this fixed point are $\ensuremath{\eta}=[\frac{(5{m}^{2}\ensuremath{-}8m)}{256{(m\ensuremath{-}1)}^{2}}]{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{3})$, $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{1}{2}+[\frac{3m}{32(m\ensuremath{-}1)}]\ensuremath{\epsilon}+[\frac{m(127{m}^{2}\ensuremath{-}572m\ensuremath{-}32)}{4096{(m\ensuremath{-}1)}^{3}}]{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{3})$ for $m\ensuremath{\ne}1$, and $\ensuremath{\eta}=\ensuremath{-}\frac{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}{106}+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{\frac{3}{2}})$, $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{1}{2}+\frac{{(\frac{6\ensuremath{\epsilon}}{53})}^{\frac{1}{2}}}{4}+O(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$ for m=1m=1m=1. More general random systems are qualitatively discussed from the effective-Hamiltonian viewpoint.
Monte Carlo simulations of the critical behaviour of disordered Ising systems have led to concentration-dependent critical exponents which seem to violate universality. We apply the renormalization group to investigate the crossover effects which cause the observed behaviour. We improve the three-loop expansion of the Callan-Symanzik and Wilson functions by a Pade-Borel approximation and solve the flow equations for various initial points. The exponents found in the simulations can be related to regions in the space of coupling coefficients away from the fixed point.
The critical behavior of the three-state Potts model in two dimensions is investigated with the use of the Monte Carlo renormalization group (MCRG), and the results are compared with conjectured values as well as with other methods. Recent advances in the MCRG enable greatly improved convergence, as well as greater insight into the structure of the renormalization transformation. The introduction of a four-point interaction is used to control the chemical potential of effective vacancies in a purely Potts Hamiltonian.