Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Chinese Journal of Physics

Invariance of the Canonical Quantization Prescription under Classical Canonical Transformations

Gin-yih Tsaur, Jyhpyng Wang

Published Aug 1, 2007• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Dirac's postulate of canonical quantization, [(The Symbol is abbreviated)]=-iħδ(subscript ij) for conjugate canonical variables, has been the most concise and general prescription on how to quantize a classical system. Since classical systems described by variables connected with canonical transformations are equivalent, [(The Symbol is abbreviated)]=-iħδ(subscript ij) must remain invariant under classical canonical transformations This invariance has not been proved except for the limited class of cascaded infinitesimal transformations. In this paper it is shown that if ((The Symbol is abbreviated)) are related to ((The Symbol is abbreviated)) by a classical canonical transformation, then [(The Symbol is abbreviated)]=-iħδ(subscript ij) In other words, the canonical quantization prescription is invariant for variables connected with classical canonical transformations.

Related papers

When Canonical Quantization Fails, Here is How to Fix It

John R. Klauder

Following Dirac, the rules of canonical quantization include classical and quantum contact transformations of classical and quantum phase space variables. While arbitrary classical canonical coordinate transformations exist that is not the case for some analogous quantum canonical coordinate transformations. This failure is due to the rigid connection of quantum variables arising by promoting the corresponding classical variable from a $c$-number to a $q$-number. A different relationship of $c$-numbers and $q$-numbers in the procedures of Enhanced Quantization shows the compatibility of all quantum operators with all classical canonical coordinate transformations.

arXiv:1611.02107•Nov 7, 2016•2 citations

Derivation of the coordinate-momentum commutation relations from canonical invariance

Moshe Shapiro

Based on (i) the spectral resolution definition of the momentum operator, (ii) the linearity of correspondence between physical observables and quantum Hermitian operators, (iii) the definition of conjugate coordinate-momentum variables in classical mechanics, and (iv) the invariance of the classical Hamiltonian to canonical transformations (transformations that change from one set of conjugate variables to another), we show that the $[\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{x},\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{p}]$ coordinate-momentum commutator must have the value $ih$ where $h$ is a real nonzero number (which we can identify with the experimentally determined $\ensuremath{\hbar}$). The results are then extended to include all generalized coordinates and their conjugate momenta as well as the Cartesian special-relativistic case.

Physical Review A•Oct 31, 2006•5 citations

Requirements of the Canonical Quantization in Different Coordinates

Chen Yuan-li

This article illustrates that when we get the formula of _i_j from canonical commutation rules _i,_j=iδ_(ij),we must take into account at the same time the Hermiticity of _j.To get the right quantum Hamiltonian operator  in non-Cartesian coordinates,we always need to change  in Cartesian coordinates into non-Cartesian coordinates by using the coordinates transformation.

Journal of Xihua Teachers College•Jan 1, 2004•0 citations

Canonical commutation relations and special relativity

F. R. Tangherlini

As a way of studying the consequences of a possible breakdown of Lorentz invariance, the canonical commutation relations are enlarged to include time and energy as additional conjugate variables, and with this enlargement, they are shown to be invariant under the Lorentz transformation under the assumption that commutators of non-conjugate operators vanish. Although time does not commute with the energy operator, it does commute with the Hamiltonian. It is also shown that the invariance of the enlarged commutation relations holds for arbitrary non-singular linear transformations that describe a velocity boost to another uniformly moving frame, under the same assumptions about non-conjugate commutators. A covariant enlargement of the Poisson brackets, together with Dirac's interpretation, that would predict this invariance of the commutators is presented. There is a discussion of improper coordinate transformations, and a canonical time-reversal operator is introduced, and compared with the standard time-reversal operator T. It is concluded that even if the Lorentz transformation were to fail, and were to be replaced by another linear transformation, the enlarged canonical commutation relations could still hold.

Physica Scripta•Jun 1, 2008•2 citations

Geometric Quantization

P Goddard

N Woodhouse 1981 Oxford: Oxford University Press 316 pp price £27.50 The familiar elementary prescription for quantising a classical system, by replacing the generalised momenta by partial derivative operators with respect to the coordinates (p a =-ħ∂/∂q a ), is not invariant under the canonical transformations which preserve the form of the classical equations of motion. This means that quantisation is dependent on the choice of coordinates.

Physics Bulletin•Aug 1, 1981•112 citations

Reparametrization-invariant formulation of classical mechanics and the Schrödinger equation

Alexei A. Deriglazov, B. F. Rizzuti

Any classical-mechanics system can be formulated in reparametrization-invariant form. That is, we use the parametric representation for the trajectories, x=x(τ) and t=t(τ) instead of x=x(t). We discuss the quantization rules in this formulation and show that some of the rules become clearer. In particular, both the temporal and the spatial coordinates are subject to quantization, and the canonical Hamiltonian in the reparametrization-invariant formulation is proportional to H̃=pt+H, where H is the usual Hamiltonian and pt is the momentum conjugate to the variable t. Due to reparametrization invariance, H̃ vanishes for any solution, and hence the corresponding quantum-mechanical operator has the property H̃∧Ψ=0, which is the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, iℏ∂tΨ=H∧Ψ. We discuss the quantum mechanics of a relativistic particle as an example.

arXiv:1105.0313•American Journal of Physics•Jul 26, 2011•23 citations
Dirac's postulate of canonical quantization, [(The Symbol is abbreviated)]=-iħδ(subscript ij) for conjugate canonical variables, has been the most concise and general prescription on how to quantize a classical system. Since classical systems described by variables connected with canonical transformations are equivalent, [(The Symbol is abbreviated)]=-iħδ(subscript ij) must remain invariant under classical canonical transformations This invariance has not been proved except for the limited class of cascaded infinitesimal transformations. In this paper it is shown that if ((The Symbol is abbreviated)) are related to ((The Symbol is abbreviated)) by a classical canonical transformation, then [(The Symbol is abbreviated)]=-iħδ(subscript ij) In other words, the canonical quantization prescription is invariant for variables connected with classical canonical transformations.
Following Dirac, the rules of canonical quantization include classical and quantum contact transformations of classical and quantum phase space variables. While arbitrary classical canonical coordinate transformations exist that is not the case for some analogous quantum canonical coordinate transformations. This failure is due to the rigid connection of quantum variables arising by promoting the corresponding classical variable from a ccc-number to a qqq-number. A different relationship of ccc-numbers and qqq-numbers in the procedures of Enhanced Quantization shows the compatibility of all quantum operators with all classical canonical coordinate transformations.
Based on (i) the spectral resolution definition of the momentum operator, (ii) the linearity of correspondence between physical observables and quantum Hermitian operators, (iii) the definition of conjugate coordinate-momentum variables in classical mechanics, and (iv) the invariance of the classical Hamiltonian to canonical transformations (transformations that change from one set of conjugate variables to another), we show that the $[\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{x},\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{p}]$ coordinate-momentum commutator must have the value ihihih where hhh is a real nonzero number (which we can identify with the experimentally determined $\ensuremath{\hbar}$). The results are then extended to include all generalized coordinates and their conjugate momenta as well as the Cartesian special-relativistic case.
As a way of studying the consequences of a possible breakdown of Lorentz invariance, the canonical commutation relations are enlarged to include time and energy as additional conjugate variables, and with this enlargement, they are shown to be invariant under the Lorentz transformation under the assumption that commutators of non-conjugate operators vanish. Although time does not commute with the energy operator, it does commute with the Hamiltonian. It is also shown that the invariance of the enlarged commutation relations holds for arbitrary non-singular linear transformations that describe a velocity boost to another uniformly moving frame, under the same assumptions about non-conjugate commutators. A covariant enlargement of the Poisson brackets, together with Dirac's interpretation, that would predict this invariance of the commutators is presented. There is a discussion of improper coordinate transformations, and a canonical time-reversal operator is introduced, and compared with the standard time-reversal operator T. It is concluded that even if the Lorentz transformation were to fail, and were to be replaced by another linear transformation, the enlarged canonical commutation relations could still hold.
Any classical-mechanics system can be formulated in reparametrization-invariant form. That is, we use the parametric representation for the trajectories, x=x(τ) and t=t(τ) instead of x=x(t). We discuss the quantization rules in this formulation and show that some of the rules become clearer. In particular, both the temporal and the spatial coordinates are subject to quantization, and the canonical Hamiltonian in the reparametrization-invariant formulation is proportional to H̃=pt+H, where H is the usual Hamiltonian and pt is the momentum conjugate to the variable t. Due to reparametrization invariance, H̃ vanishes for any solution, and hence the corresponding quantum-mechanical operator has the property H̃∧Ψ=0, which is the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, iℏ∂tΨ=H∧Ψ. We discuss the quantum mechanics of a relativistic particle as an example.