Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Springer eBooks

The Significance of Human Observation in Measurement in Quantum Mechanics; the Nature of the Traditional Separation between Psychology and Physics

Douglas Snyder

Published Jan 1, 1989• 1 citation
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/978-94-017-0849-4_47

Related papers

Concept of consciousness in the context of quantum mechanics

Михаил Борисович Менский

Conceptual problems of the quantum theory of measurement are considered, which are embodied in well-known paradoxes and in Bell's inequalities. Arguments are advanced in favor of the viewpoint that these problems may hardly be solved without direct inclusion of the observer's consciousness in the theoretical description of a quantum measurement. Discussed in this connection is the so-called many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics proposed by Everett, as is the extension of Everett's concept, which consists in the assumption that separating the quantum state components corresponding to alternative measurements is not only associated with the observer's consciousness but is completely identified with it. This approach is shown to open up qualitatively new avenues for the unification of physics and psychology and, more broadly, of the sciences and the humanities. This may lead to an extension of the theory of consciousness and shed light on significant and previously misunderstood phenomena in the sphere of consciousness.

Physics-Uspekhi•Apr 30, 2005•56 citations

A Reinterpretation of Quantum Mechanics and Extension to the Macroscopic Realm – A Case for Psychophysics

Stephen Engleman

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

On the nature of relationships involving the observer and the observed phenomenon in psychology and physics

Douglas Snyder

The Journal of mind and behavior•Jan 1, 1983•16 citations

Hidden human variables in quantum mechanics?

Göte Nyman

The problem of the observer in quantum mechanics is getting new human content. The paradox of Wigner's friend and its extended versions have observers who not only observe quantum phenomena, but communicate, have memories and even super-observer powers. Observers are represented by particle paths and state memories and advanced AI has been suggested to act as an observer. There is a new call for a solid theory of the observer in quantum mechanics. Two different branches of observer theories have emerged. The purely physical one is Heisenbergian, e.g. relational quantum mechanics where the observer is considered as any other physical quantum system. The other branch is psychologically rich as its observer has complex human faculties such as a mind, mental states and memory (Many minds), or the observer is considered as an active and experiencing agent, with continuously refreshed, scientific expectations (QBism). Is the human observer a special case, different from other quantum mechanical systems? Why is there no theory of the general observer in quantum mechanics? A historical summary is covered on how quantum mechanical interpretations have treated the observer, and the concept of hidden human variables is suggested to continue the discussion on the theoretical nature of the observer.

arXiv:2010.03419•Oct 6, 2020•0 citations

Quantum concepts in Psychology: Exploring the interplay of physics and the human psyche

Theodoros A. Kyriazos, Mary Poga

Biosystems•Nov 7, 2023•26 citations

Contrary to Mermin, Bohr Did Acknowledge a Significant Quantum Measurement Problem - The Importance of William James, The Early American Psychologist, To Bohr, Mermin, And Carroll’s Epistemic Option For Quantum Measurement

Douglas Michael Snyder

James’s complementarity works very well with the proofs that are at the heart of null and positive measurements in quantum mechanics. It is important for the physics community to know that complementarity originated in psychology in 1890, in the work of William James, to know James’s finding that “the total possible consciousnesses may be split into parts which coexist but mutually ignore each other, and share the objects of knowledge between them.” The human observer is central in James’s formulation of complementarity. Consciousness and knowledge are essential. It appears that James’s concept of complementarity may truly characterize what Carroll is referring to as the epistemic option. It seems it is likely the correct conceptual model for quantum mechanical measurement. For example, there can be no hidden physical variables with a null measurement because the outcome of a null measurement as discussed above is not dependent on a physical interaction. Bohr was open to ideas from psychology. Bohr borrowed James’s complementarity and adapted it for physics by introducing an unavoidable physical interaction between a physical measuring instrument and the physical system measured. This physical interaction has an aspect that cannot be controlled. This lack of control allowed Bohr to apply the uncertainty principle. Bohr’s complementarity for physics is unwarranted. Once there is a logical proof that the electron will not pass through one of the slits, the wave component associated with the slit through which the electron does not pass vanishes. No superposition is possible because that wave component has vanished. Contrary to Mermin, Bohr did acknowledge a significant quantum measurement problem. Bohr held to his view discussed above of complementarity for physics instead of adopting James’s approach where the knowing individual is directly related to the physical system measured as an object of knowledge. Perhaps through the collaboration of physics and other fields, in particular psychology, further progress can be made in developing a self-consistent view of quantum mechanical measurement that is supported by empirical evidence.

•Nov 24, 2022•0 citations
Conceptual problems of the quantum theory of measurement are considered, which are embodied in well-known paradoxes and in Bell's inequalities. Arguments are advanced in favor of the viewpoint that these problems may hardly be solved without direct inclusion of the observer's consciousness in the theoretical description of a quantum measurement. Discussed in this connection is the so-called many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics proposed by Everett, as is the extension of Everett's concept, which consists in the assumption that separating the quantum state components corresponding to alternative measurements is not only associated with the observer's consciousness but is completely identified with it. This approach is shown to open up qualitatively new avenues for the unification of physics and psychology and, more broadly, of the sciences and the humanities. This may lead to an extension of the theory of consciousness and shed light on significant and previously misunderstood phenomena in the sphere of consciousness.
The problem of the observer in quantum mechanics is getting new human content. The paradox of Wigner's friend and its extended versions have observers who not only observe quantum phenomena, but communicate, have memories and even super-observer powers. Observers are represented by particle paths and state memories and advanced AI has been suggested to act as an observer. There is a new call for a solid theory of the observer in quantum mechanics. Two different branches of observer theories have emerged. The purely physical one is Heisenbergian, e.g. relational quantum mechanics where the observer is considered as any other physical quantum system. The other branch is psychologically rich as its observer has complex human faculties such as a mind, mental states and memory (Many minds), or the observer is considered as an active and experiencing agent, with continuously refreshed, scientific expectations (QBism). Is the human observer a special case, different from other quantum mechanical systems? Why is there no theory of the general observer in quantum mechanics? A historical summary is covered on how quantum mechanical interpretations have treated the observer, and the concept of hidden human variables is suggested to continue the discussion on the theoretical nature of the observer.
James’s complementarity works very well with the proofs that are at the heart of null and positive measurements in quantum mechanics. It is important for the physics community to know that complementarity originated in psychology in 1890, in the work of William James, to know James’s finding that “the total possible consciousnesses may be split into parts which coexist but mutually ignore each other, and share the objects of knowledge between them.” The human observer is central in James’s formulation of complementarity. Consciousness and knowledge are essential. It appears that James’s concept of complementarity may truly characterize what Carroll is referring to as the epistemic option. It seems it is likely the correct conceptual model for quantum mechanical measurement. For example, there can be no hidden physical variables with a null measurement because the outcome of a null measurement as discussed above is not dependent on a physical interaction. Bohr was open to ideas from psychology. Bohr borrowed James’s complementarity and adapted it for physics by introducing an unavoidable physical interaction between a physical measuring instrument and the physical system measured. This physical interaction has an aspect that cannot be controlled. This lack of control allowed Bohr to apply the uncertainty principle. Bohr’s complementarity for physics is unwarranted. Once there is a logical proof that the electron will not pass through one of the slits, the wave component associated with the slit through which the electron does not pass vanishes. No superposition is possible because that wave component has vanished. Contrary to Mermin, Bohr did acknowledge a significant quantum measurement problem. Bohr held to his view discussed above of complementarity for physics instead of adopting James’s approach where the knowing individual is directly related to the physical system measured as an object of knowledge. Perhaps through the collaboration of physics and other fields, in particular psychology, further progress can be made in developing a self-consistent view of quantum mechanical measurement that is supported by empirical evidence.