Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association

Making Sense of Approximate Decoherence

Guido Bacciagaluppi, Meir Hemmo

Published Jan 1, 1994• 14 citations
Publisher

Abstract

One of the main goals of no-collapse interpretations of quantum mechanics is to show how results of measurements are objectified, or, in a more poignant terminology, how in a measurement situation facts arise. One needs to show how in their dynamical evolution the measured system and, perhaps more importantly, the measuring apparatus acquire, or at least appear to acquire, the definite properties that are otherwise explained by the collapse of the state. This can be seen as a special case of the problem whether quantum mechanics alone can account for the classical behaviour of macroscopic systems; in particular, the permanent definiteness of at least those properties of macroscopic systems that are directly observable, such as the position of the pointer of a measuring apparatus. In other words, whether quantum mechanics can account for macrofacts of the familiar kind.

DOI
10.1086/psaprocbienmeetp.1994.1.193039

Related papers

Environmental Decoherence and Definite Outcomes in Quantum Measurement: Separating Dynamical Explanation from Interpretive Commitment

Qingxiang Liao

Environmental decoherence is central to contemporary accounts of quantum measurement, yet its relation to definite outcomes remains disputed. This review distinguishes four explanatory demands: interference suppression, preferred-basis selection, operational objectivity, and outcome actualization. It compares open-system formalism and experimental evidence with the principal philosophical accounts of definiteness. In nonrelativistic models, environmental entanglement disperses phase coherence into inaccessible correlations, rendering the reduced system–apparatus state approximately diagonal in an interaction-selected pointer basis. Experiments support this loss of locally observable interference, while einselection and redundant environmental records explain the stability and intersubjective accessibility of macroscopic properties. These achievements neither convert an improper mixture into ignorance about an actual result nor select one component of the global state. Everettian interpretations reject global uniqueness, Bohmian mechanics adds an actual configuration, objective-collapse theories modify the dynamics, and QBist or pragmatist approaches revise quantum-state semantics. Decoherence is therefore indispensable to the formation of classical records but insufficient, by itself, for an interpretation-neutral derivation of unique actualization. Its foundational significance lies in identifying where unitary dynamical explanation ends and an ontological, dynamical, or semantic account of definiteness must begin.

Scholarly review .•Sep 4, 2026•0 citations

Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics and Measurement Problem

Marco Genovese

We present a panoramic view on various attempts to "solve" the problems of quantum measurement and macro-objectivation, i.e. of the transition from a probabilistic quantum mechanic microscopic world to a deterministic classical macroscopic world.

arXiv:1002.0990•Advanced Science Letters•Sep 1, 2010•42 citations

The Measurement Problem: Decoherence and Some Interpretations that Admit an Ontology of Quantum Objects and Events

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 31, 2022•0 citations

The ‘Decoherence’ Approach to the Measurement Problem in Quantum Mechanics

Andrew Elby

The decoherence approach to the measurement problem invokes dissipative interactions between a measuring apparatus and its environment to explain, within the context of ‘pure’ quantum mechanics (QM), why such devices appear to possess definite pointer readings. By ‘pure’ QM, I mean Schrödinger evolution with no wavefunction collapse. Several classes of interpretations of pure QM can rely on decoherence. One class is the ‘modal’ interpretations of van Fraassen (1979), Dieks (1989), Healey (1989), and others. Another class is the relative-state and many-world interpretations. I will argue that decoherence cannot help these interpretations address the general metaphysical challenges raised against them. But decoherence can help pick out a ‘special’ basis that determines which observables receive definite values. I'll explore to what extent decoherence rescues the modal (biorthogonal) basis-selection rule, and Zurek's (environmental interaction) basis-selection rule, from the basis degeneracy problem and the imperfect measurement problem.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1994•16 citations

Epistemological Problems of Measurement in Quantum Mechanics and the Appearance of the Classical World of Macroscopic Objects

Erhard Oeser

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1999•0 citations

History Selection Removes the Need for Interpretive Supplementation in Quantum Measurement

Jonah Brent

The quantum measurement problem is commonly framed as a tension between unitary microscopic dynamics and the appearance of definite macroscopic outcomes. Decoherence theory explains the suppression of interference but does not explain why a single, persistent outcome is realized rather than a superposition of mutually incompatible macroscopic records. Interpretive responses—including collapse models, many-worlds branching, and observer-centric accounts—add ontological or epistemic structure beyond standard quantum mechanics. In this work, we show that such supplementation is unnecessary. We demonstrate that decoherence alone is generically insufficient to stabilize consistent macroscopic measurement histories under irreversible record formation. We introduce history-level coherence selection as a minimal structural requirement for persistent outcomes. This mechanism operates without modifying unitary dynamics, introducing collapse postulates, or invoking observers. We show that measurement outcomes correspond to stable, selection-supported histories rather than instantaneous state reductions. This reframing resolves the measurement problem by identifying the missing macroscopic mechanism—history selection under irreversible constraint—rather than by altering quantum theory. Keywords: quantum measurement problem, history selection, decoherence insufficiency, classical records, interpretation of quantum mechanics, consistent histories, irreversibility, information flow, foundational physics, measurement theory

•Jan 22, 2026•0 citations
One of the main goals of no-collapse interpretations of quantum mechanics is to show how results of measurements are objectified, or, in a more poignant terminology, how in a measurement situation facts arise. One needs to show how in their dynamical evolution the measured system and, perhaps more importantly, the measuring apparatus acquire, or at least appear to acquire, the definite properties that are otherwise explained by the collapse of the state. This can be seen as a special case of the problem whether quantum mechanics alone can account for the classical behaviour of macroscopic systems; in particular, the permanent definiteness of at least those properties of macroscopic systems that are directly observable, such as the position of the pointer of a measuring apparatus. In other words, whether quantum mechanics can account for macrofacts of the familiar kind.
Environmental decoherence is central to contemporary accounts of quantum measurement, yet its relation to definite outcomes remains disputed. This review distinguishes four explanatory demands: interference suppression, preferred-basis selection, operational objectivity, and outcome actualization. It compares open-system formalism and experimental evidence with the principal philosophical accounts of definiteness. In nonrelativistic models, environmental entanglement disperses phase coherence into inaccessible correlations, rendering the reduced system–apparatus state approximately diagonal in an interaction-selected pointer basis. Experiments support this loss of locally observable interference, while einselection and redundant environmental records explain the stability and intersubjective accessibility of macroscopic properties. These achievements neither convert an improper mixture into ignorance about an actual result nor select one component of the global state. Everettian interpretations reject global uniqueness, Bohmian mechanics adds an actual configuration, objective-collapse theories modify the dynamics, and QBist or pragmatist approaches revise quantum-state semantics. Decoherence is therefore indispensable to the formation of classical records but insufficient, by itself, for an interpretation-neutral derivation of unique actualization. Its foundational significance lies in identifying where unitary dynamical explanation ends and an ontological, dynamical, or semantic account of definiteness must begin.
The decoherence approach to the measurement problem invokes dissipative interactions between a measuring apparatus and its environment to explain, within the context of ‘pure’ quantum mechanics (QM), why such devices appear to possess definite pointer readings. By ‘pure’ QM, I mean Schrödinger evolution with no wavefunction collapse. Several classes of interpretations of pure QM can rely on decoherence. One class is the ‘modal’ interpretations of van Fraassen (1979), Dieks (1989), Healey (1989), and others. Another class is the relative-state and many-world interpretations. I will argue that decoherence cannot help these interpretations address the general metaphysical challenges raised against them. But decoherence can help pick out a ‘special’ basis that determines which observables receive definite values. I'll explore to what extent decoherence rescues the modal (biorthogonal) basis-selection rule, and Zurek's (environmental interaction) basis-selection rule, from the basis degeneracy problem and the imperfect measurement problem.
The quantum measurement problem is commonly framed as a tension between unitary microscopic dynamics and the appearance of definite macroscopic outcomes. Decoherence theory explains the suppression of interference but does not explain why a single, persistent outcome is realized rather than a superposition of mutually incompatible macroscopic records. Interpretive responses—including collapse models, many-worlds branching, and observer-centric accounts—add ontological or epistemic structure beyond standard quantum mechanics. In this work, we show that such supplementation is unnecessary. We demonstrate that decoherence alone is generically insufficient to stabilize consistent macroscopic measurement histories under irreversible record formation. We introduce history-level coherence selection as a minimal structural requirement for persistent outcomes. This mechanism operates without modifying unitary dynamics, introducing collapse postulates, or invoking observers. We show that measurement outcomes correspond to stable, selection-supported histories rather than instantaneous state reductions. This reframing resolves the measurement problem by identifying the missing macroscopic mechanism—history selection under irreversible constraint—rather than by altering quantum theory. Keywords: quantum measurement problem, history selection, decoherence insufficiency, classical records, interpretation of quantum mechanics, consistent histories, irreversibility, information flow, foundational physics, measurement theory