Until now, orthodox science has not had any real reason to question the “locality” assumption about reality, which maintains that all cause-and-effect relationships are mediated by some form of local interaction: One cue ball strikes another cue ball at a definite locus; the cog wheels of machines inter mesh locally because the teeth of the wheels actually touch and push each other. “Locality” underlies a11 our commonsensical beliefs about normal cause-effect, rational interactions in science and everyday life. Jung, however, found it necessary to postulate “synchronicity” as an a causal reality to account for many psychological phenomena that apparently could not be accounted for in terms of this ordinary view of local, cause-effect relationships. The recent experimental confirmation of Bell's Theorem may be the first scientific evidence against the locality assumption. It suggests that non-locality at the quantum level underlies all phenomena—even at the common everyday level of reality as we experience it. We can only wonder if this research, summarized here by physicist Nick Herbert, can serve as a new empirical foundation for Jung's concept of synchronicity. of particular interest is Herbert's statement that nonlocal “unmediated connections are present not only in rare and exotic circumstances, but underlie all the events of everyday life.” If this is true, then it would support Meier's general theory of synchronicity versus Jung's special theory [see interview with CA. Meier in this issue]. Herbert has re-edited and clarified his description of “How Bell Proved Reality Cannot be Local” from his book, Quantum Reality (1985. Doubleday). Herbert will be a speaker at the Fall Conference on “God, Consciousness, and Quantum Reality,” to be sponsored by Psychological Perspectives on November 12, 1988.
Until now, orthodox science has not had any real reason to question the “locality” assumption about reality, which maintains that all cause-and-effect relationships are mediated by some form of local interaction: One cue ball strikes another cue ball at a definite locus; the cog wheels of machines inter mesh locally because the teeth of the wheels actually touch and push each other. “Locality” underlies a11 our commonsensical beliefs about normal cause-effect, rational interactions in science and everyday life. Jung, however, found it necessary to postulate “synchronicity” as an a causal reality to account for many psychological phenomena that apparently could not be accounted for in terms of this ordinary view of local, cause-effect relationships. The recent experimental confirmation of Bell's Theorem may be the first scientific evidence against the locality assumption. It suggests that non-locality at the quantum level underlies all phenomena—even at the common everyday level of reality as we experience it. We can only wonder if this research, summarized here by physicist Nick Herbert, can serve as a new empirical foundation for Jung's concept of synchronicity. of particular interest is Herbert's statement that nonlocal “unmediated connections are present not only in rare and exotic circumstances, but underlie all the events of everyday life.” If this is true, then it would support Meier's general theory of synchronicity versus Jung's special theory [see interview with CA. Meier in this issue]. Herbert has re-edited and clarified his description of “How Bell Proved Reality Cannot be Local” from his book, Quantum Reality (1985. Doubleday). Herbert will be a speaker at the Fall Conference on “God, Consciousness, and Quantum Reality,” to be sponsored by Psychological Perspectives on November 12, 1988.
Explaining observations in terms of cause-and-effect (causal) relations is central to empirical science. However, in his seminal 1964 work [1], John Bell showed that the correlations between entangled quantum systems cannot be explained in terms of, possibly hidden, cause and effect relations. After four decades of experimental effort, Bell's prediction has recently been confirmed in an unambiguous way by a series of loophole-free Bell-test experiments [2-4]. These experiments, however, cannot reveal where exactly quantum mechanics breaks with our classical notion of cause and effect. Specifically, Bell's theorem is based on the central assumptions of realism and local causality. Realism posits that physical systems have real, objective properties, independent of whether we observe them or not, and local causality assumes that causal influences cannot propagate faster than the speed of light.
Local realism must predict empirical Bell violations in a reasonable way to become a compelling causal explanation of reality. According to the paper at the link given below, it can now do that. On the other hand, theory, despite its wonderful statistical predictions, must transcend its infamous paradoxes to become a compelling causal explanation of anything. Unfortunately, paradoxes reduce to contradictions, and thus to nonsense. Take quantum superposition. Is this the simultaneous existence of mutually exclusive states or not? If it is, then we have a contradiction, and all further claims from theory fail to have meaningful interpretations. If superposition is something other than that contradiction, then what -- exactly -- is superposition? And let's take physical while we are at it. Defending theory as a causal explanation of reality requires that reality is not exclusively reality! Whoops. What -- exactly -- is so difficult about simply admitting when we have no sensible causal explanation for certain phenomena like Bell violations in EPR(B) experiments? In psychology, we know the answer to such questions. Our beliefs are evidence resistant. We thus predict that the rational threat from local realism to widespread beliefs -- its implication that reality might be mostly explained without appeal to antilocal mysticism -- will continue to be buried under reams of empirical observations stitched together by nonsense insinuations that that paradoxes are assets rather than contradictions. In any case, the paper below arguably formulates a theory of local realism that constitutes a causally valid description of reality. No nonsense required. Or, it could just be wrong. But it is waiting to be tested. Indeed, even existing data could bear on the empirical question if the theory is sound enough. See ** http://vixra.org/abs/1704.0078 ** Local Realism Explains Bell Violations (author Andrew P. Yake) - for a demonstration that all empirical evidence taken to support theory over local realism plausibly does the reverse. The article comprises 8 pages, 4 figures, 6 equations, 32 references, a graph of testable predictions, and two paragraphs that purport to expose how the Bell inequality misrepresents the local realistic predictions for the EPR experiment. Thoughtful feedback appreciated (apyake@gmail.com).
Walking through the guarded gate of CERN. a center for peaceful atomic research near Geneva, Switzerland, one finds oneself in what seems to be a typical industrial park Upon coming to thefirst corner, one has a sense of the surreal tofind pleasant signs marking it as the intersection of Einstein and W. Pauli streets. Ambling along a bit further, one comes to a quiet, treeshaded building housing the office of theoretical physicist, John Stewart Bell, whose work on “nonlocality” is regarded by some as fermenting yet another conceptual revolution in our world view. With an almost shy Irish brogue from his native Dublin, however, Bell modestly disavows any such significance to what is called “Bell's Inequality” in the literature of quantum physics. In this interview, our editor queried Bell on the relevance of his work for Jung's view of synchronicity as a non- causal factor in human affairs. Bell cautions that everything he says here is only his “opinion of the mystery and muddle of it all.”
The notion of Non-Locality (NL) in physics has great epistemological implications and impact on the perceptive of Reality. Numerous counter intuitive experimental results that clearly violate Bell's inequality have prompted several physicists to believe in 'mysterious' non-local correlations particularly in quantum systems of EPR type. Not commenting much on whether NL is true or not, our contention is that NL, in general, leads to the concept of holistic universe and further to a global concept of 'Consciousness-Centered-Cosmos' (CCC) as almost inevitable rational outcome. These suggestions though ostensibly unorthodox, are rather within rational and legitimate frame work of science. Our reasoning is quite distinct from the erstwhile doctrine of the role of consciousness in the measurement problem and state vector reduction although the latter may add further credence to the our contention. We address particularly the implications NL and discuss certain related aspects of new quantum world view in general. The less recognized association of the principles of uncertainty with locality, causality, the arrow of time and reality are brought out. Perhaps these underpinnings are much less appreciated than necessary.
In the 80 years since the seminal Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) paper, physicists and philosophers have mused about the `spooky action at a distance' aspect of quantum mechanics that so bothered Einstein. In his formal analysis of EPR-type entangled quantum states, Bell (1964) concluded that any hidden variable theory designed to reproduce the predictions of quantum mechanics must necessarily be nonlocal and allow superluminal interactions. This doesn't immediately imply that nonlocality is a characteristic feature of quantum mechanics let alone a fundamental property of nature; however, many physicists and philosophers of science do harbor this belief. Experts in the field often use the term `nonlocality' to designate particular non-classical aspects of quantum entanglement and do not confuse the term with superluminal interactions. However, many physicists seem to take the term more literally. I endeavor to disabuse the latter of this notion by emphasizing that the correlations of Bell-type entanglement are a result of ordinary quantum superposition with no need to introduce nonlocality. The conclusion of the EPR paper wasn't that quantum mechanics is nonlocal but rather that it is an incomplete description of reality. For different reasons, many physicists, including me, agree with Einstein that quantum mechanics is necessarily an incomplete description of reality.
Nick Herbert is an experimental physicist living in California whose recent book, Quantum Reality: Beyoad the New Pbysics, has been highly regarded as a lucid introduction to the many alternative interpretations of quantum mechanics that are currently being debated among professional physicists. In this playful article, he treads the fine line between science, fact, and fantasy to give us a metaphorical glimpse into some future possibilities about quantum dynamics in everyday life. Dr. Herbert will be a speaker and panelist at our upcoming Fall 1988 conference on “Cod, Consciousness, and the New Quantum Psychologies” where he will present his most recent views on the reconstruction of a physics that includes consciousness and observer-created realities on many levels.