Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

What happened to the Bohr-Sommerfeld elliptic orbits in Schrodinger's wave mechanics?

Michael Nauenberg

Published Jan 1, 2015• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

According to Heisenberg and Pauli, two of the great pioneers of quantum mechanics, in the domain of atoms and molecules the Bohr-Sommerfeld elliptic orbits disappear. But Bohr's correspondence principle requires that for large quantum numbers, quantum mechanics corresponds to classical mechanics. It is shown here how this correspondence, generally ignored in physics textbooks, takes place.

Related papers

Further steps to quantum mechanics: the old quantum mechanics of Bohr and Sommerfeld

Robert Golub, S. K. Lamoreaux

Abstract We review the Bohr atomic model, where certain conditions (quantum conditions) were used to select certain “allowed” circular orbits for the electrons in an atom. Sommerfeld realized that a more generalized condition, applied to the action variables, would be consistent with the Bohr condition and also allow elliptical orbits. This condition amounted to the quantization of the phase space occupied by an orbit. This had independently been suggested by Planck. We also discuss the similarities between classical mechanics and the geometric optics limit of a wave theory.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 28, 2023•0 citations

Sommerfeld's elliptical atomic orbits revisited—A useful preliminary to the study of quantum mechanics

Tony Deeney, Colm T O'Sullivan

The Bohr-Sommerfeld atomic model is recast in the language of wave-particle duality and it is shown that requirements equivalent to the Sommerfeld-Wilson quantisation conditions arise naturally in this context. It is suggested that treating the one-electron atom in this way provides a useful introduction for students prior to encountering the more formal analysis based on the solution of the Schrödinger equation.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 26, 2014•14 citations

Quantum-Classical Connection for Hydrogen atom-like systems

Debapriyo Syam, Arup Roy

The Bohr-Sommerfeld quantum theory specifies the rules of quantization for circular and elliptical orbits for a one-electron hydrogen atom-like system. This article illustrates how a formula connecting the principal quantum number 'n' and the length of the major axis of an elliptical orbit may be arrived at starting from the quantum mechanical description and how, in the limit when 'n' is large, one gets the expected classical result.

European Journal Of Physics Education•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Reviving Bohr Molecules

Gilbert Chin

Before the Heisenberg-Schrödinger formulation of quantum mechanics, the semiclassical Bohr-Sommerfeld theory successfully accounted for quantized properties such as the energy levels in the hydrogen atom. However, the forcing of closed orbits for particle motion ran afoul of the uncertainty principle. Recently, the use of Dscaling, in which the motion of each particle is described by a vector in D dimensions, was used to reintroduce the uncertainty principle to this earlier theory. When properly done, such equations reduce to the correct Schrödinger form for D = 3 but can still be solved in the more tractable D→ ∞ limit. This D scaling approach was applied successfully to atoms but did not yield bound states for molecules.

Science•Sep 1, 2005•0 citations

Wave and Matrix Mechanics of Schrodinger, Heisenberg and Dirac

Harish Parthasarathy

Bohr’s correspondence principle is that associated with each observable in classical mechanics is an observable in quantum mechanics that follows certain quantization axioms which can be used to explain the energy spectra of atoms and quantum oscillators. In Schrodinger’s wave mechanics, the state of the system at any time is described by a density operator in a Hilbert space. The chapter describes how the Pauli equation can be used to calculate the average electric dipole moment and average magnetic dipole moment of an atom in an external electromagnetic field. This calculation enables to calculate the electric polarization field and the magnetization field of a material.

CRC Press eBooks•Jul 29, 2021•0 citations

Understanding the relation between classical and quantum mechanics: prospects for undergraduate teaching

Marco Di Mauro, A. Drago, Adele Naddeo

Abstract Classical and quantum mechanics are two very different theories, each describing the world within its own range of validity. It is often stated that classical mechanics emerges from quantum mechanics in a certain limit. This is known as the correspondence principle. According to Planck’s version of the correspondence principle, classical mechanics is recovered when the limit in which a dimensionless parameter containing Planck’s constant h goes to zero is taken, while Bohr’s version entails taking the limit of large quantum numbers. However, despite what is usually stated in textbooks, the relation between the two theories is much more complex to state and understand. Here we deal with this issue by analysing some key examples, in some of which also the analogously subtle relation between wave and geometric optics is considered. Implications for quantum mechanics teaching at undergraduate level are carefully discussed.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Mar 1, 2024•0 citations
According to Heisenberg and Pauli, two of the great pioneers of quantum mechanics, in the domain of atoms and molecules the Bohr-Sommerfeld elliptic orbits disappear. But Bohr's correspondence principle requires that for large quantum numbers, quantum mechanics corresponds to classical mechanics. It is shown here how this correspondence, generally ignored in physics textbooks, takes place.
Abstract We review the Bohr atomic model, where certain conditions (quantum conditions) were used to select certain “allowed” circular orbits for the electrons in an atom. Sommerfeld realized that a more generalized condition, applied to the action variables, would be consistent with the Bohr condition and also allow elliptical orbits. This condition amounted to the quantization of the phase space occupied by an orbit. This had independently been suggested by Planck. We also discuss the similarities between classical mechanics and the geometric optics limit of a wave theory.
Before the Heisenberg-Schrödinger formulation of quantum mechanics, the semiclassical Bohr-Sommerfeld theory successfully accounted for quantized properties such as the energy levels in the hydrogen atom. However, the forcing of closed orbits for particle motion ran afoul of the uncertainty principle. Recently, the use of Dscaling, in which the motion of each particle is described by a vector in D dimensions, was used to reintroduce the uncertainty principle to this earlier theory. When properly done, such equations reduce to the correct Schrödinger form for D = 3 but can still be solved in the more tractable D→ ∞ limit. This D scaling approach was applied successfully to atoms but did not yield bound states for molecules.
Bohr’s correspondence principle is that associated with each observable in classical mechanics is an observable in quantum mechanics that follows certain quantization axioms which can be used to explain the energy spectra of atoms and quantum oscillators. In Schrodinger’s wave mechanics, the state of the system at any time is described by a density operator in a Hilbert space. The chapter describes how the Pauli equation can be used to calculate the average electric dipole moment and average magnetic dipole moment of an atom in an external electromagnetic field. This calculation enables to calculate the electric polarization field and the magnetization field of a material.
Abstract Classical and quantum mechanics are two very different theories, each describing the world within its own range of validity. It is often stated that classical mechanics emerges from quantum mechanics in a certain limit. This is known as the correspondence principle. According to Planck’s version of the correspondence principle, classical mechanics is recovered when the limit in which a dimensionless parameter containing Planck’s constant h goes to zero is taken, while Bohr’s version entails taking the limit of large quantum numbers. However, despite what is usually stated in textbooks, the relation between the two theories is much more complex to state and understand. Here we deal with this issue by analysing some key examples, in some of which also the analogously subtle relation between wave and geometric optics is considered. Implications for quantum mechanics teaching at undergraduate level are carefully discussed.