Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Postępy Fizyki

Jak kształcić mechaników kwantowych

David I. Kaiser

Published Jan 1, 2007• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

Quantum mechanics is a theory with many philosophical ramifications that pioneers like Bohr, Heisenberg and Oppenheimer delighted in discussing in the classroom and in their textbooks. After the Second World War, many physicists abandoned this approach to teaching the subject - instead the goal was to train students to calculate with the theory, unburdened by spe- culative, philosophical concerns. New research suggests that this change of approach was driven by the demand for more physicists: large classes simply proved to be unsuitable venues for deep philosophical discussions. The focus on learning to calculate, however, brought many pay-offs, including the Standard Model of particle physics. As quantum computing and communications become reality, the philosophical aspects of quantum mechanics are coming back into fashion.

Related papers

Reflections on the philosophy of Bohr, Heisenberg, and Schrödinger

Abner Shimony

Many of the pioneers of quantum mechanics – notably Planck, Einstein, Bohr, de Broglie, Heisenberg, Schrodinger, Born, Jordan, Landé, Wigner, and London – were seriously concerned with philosophical problems. In each case one can ask a question of psychological and historical interest: was it a philosophical penchant which drew the investigator towards a kind of physics research which is linked to philosophy, or was it rather that the conceptual difficulties of fundamental physics pulled him willynilly into the labyrinth of philosophy? I shall not undertake to discuss this question, but shall cite an opinion of Peter Bergmann, which I find congenial: he learned from Einstein that “the theoretical physicist is … a philosopher in workingman's clothes” ([1], q. v.).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 26, 1993•3 citations

Why are we philosophers interested in quantum field theory?

Tian Yu Cao

This two-tier conference signals a new phase of philosophers' interest in quantum field theory, which has been growing noticeably in the last few years. However, some prominent physicists have shown their deep suspicions against ignorant philosophers' intrusion into their profession, and have expressed their hostility quite openly. In the philosophy community, some prominent philosophers of physics have also expressed their suspicions against the rationale of moving away from the profound foundational problems raised by Einstein and Bohr, Bohm and Bell, such as those concerning the nature of space-time and measurement, possibility and implications of hidden variables and nonlocality, and stepping into the technical complexity of quantum field theory, which is only an application of quantum mechanics in general without intrinsically distinct philosophical questions to be explored. In order to dispel these suspicions, it is desirable to highlight certain aspects of quantum field theory which require philosophical reflections and deserve further investigations. This discussion intends to suggest that philosophers can learn many important lessons from quantum field theory, and may be of some help in clarifying its conceptual foundations. At this stage of crisis that quantum field theory is experiencing now, the clarification may contribute to the radical transformation of our basic concepts in theoretical physics, which is necessary for a happy resolution of the crisis and the emergence of a new promising fundamental physical theory.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 18, 1999•16 citations

Teaching quantum interpretations: Revisiting the goals and practices of introductory quantum physics courses

Charles Baily, Noah D. Finkelstein

This paper is part of the Focused Collection on Upper Division Physics Courses.]Most introductory quantum physics instructors would agree that transitioning students from classical to quantum thinking is an important learning goal, but may disagree on whether or how this can be accomplished.Although (and perhaps because) physicists have long debated the physical interpretation of quantum theory, many instructors choose to avoid emphasizing interpretive themes; or they discuss the views of scientists in their classrooms, but do not adequately attend to student interpretations.In this synthesis and extension of prior work, we demonstrate the following: (i) instructors vary in their approaches to teaching interpretive themes; (ii) different instructional approaches have differential impacts on student thinking; and (iii) when student interpretations go unattended, they often develop their own (sometimes scientifically undesirable) views.We introduce here a new modern physics curriculum that explicitly attends to student interpretations, and provide evidence-based arguments that doing so helps them to develop more consistent interpretations of quantum phenomena, more sophisticated views of uncertainty, and greater interest in quantum physics.

arXiv:1409.8503•Physical Review Special Topics - Physics Education Research•Sep 23, 2015•65 citations

Quantum mechanics 2025 at the crossroads of science and humanities: Towards the epiphany of a new cultural world a century later

Marco Giliberti, Enrico Giannetto, Katarzyna Wyborska +3 more

A century after its formulation, we discuss the multifaceted implications for education of the vast cultural connections that quantum mechanics (QM) has helped establish between physics and other disciplines. Drawing on the most recent research in QM education, we will address the epistemological paradigms that underpin our understanding of nature and the cultural significance of this theory for the intellectual development of students at various educational levels; always maintaining a careful focus on the fundamental educational challenge of teaching and learning about the nature of science through physics education.

Eurasia Journal of Mathematics Science and Technology Education•Jul 21, 2026•0 citations

Heisenberg and the Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics: The Physicist as Philosopher

Kristian Camilleri

This book provides a new perspective on Heisenberg's interpretation of quantum mechanics for researchers and graduate students in the history and philosophy of physics.

•Feb 23, 2009•76 citations

Classical Mechanics

Jeffrey Alan Barrett

Abstract While quantum mechanics is one of the most successful physical theories we have ever had, it is deeply counterintuitive. It must be given the empirical evidence it explains. We consider some of the historical evidence for the theory and the conceptual arguments that led from classical mechanics to quantum mechanics. These considerations illustrate some of the ways in which our commonsense and philosophical intuitions are simply incompatible with the physical world.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 26, 2019•0 citations
Quantum mechanics is a theory with many philosophical ramifications that pioneers like Bohr, Heisenberg and Oppenheimer delighted in discussing in the classroom and in their textbooks. After the Second World War, many physicists abandoned this approach to teaching the subject - instead the goal was to train students to calculate with the theory, unburdened by spe- culative, philosophical concerns. New research suggests that this change of approach was driven by the demand for more physicists: large classes simply proved to be unsuitable venues for deep philosophical discussions. The focus on learning to calculate, however, brought many pay-offs, including the Standard Model of particle physics. As quantum computing and communications become reality, the philosophical aspects of quantum mechanics are coming back into fashion.
Many of the pioneers of quantum mechanics – notably Planck, Einstein, Bohr, de Broglie, Heisenberg, Schrodinger, Born, Jordan, Landé, Wigner, and London – were seriously concerned with philosophical problems. In each case one can ask a question of psychological and historical interest: was it a philosophical penchant which drew the investigator towards a kind of physics research which is linked to philosophy, or was it rather that the conceptual difficulties of fundamental physics pulled him willynilly into the labyrinth of philosophy? I shall not undertake to discuss this question, but shall cite an opinion of Peter Bergmann, which I find congenial: he learned from Einstein that “the theoretical physicist is … a philosopher in workingman's clothes” ([1], q. v.).
This two-tier conference signals a new phase of philosophers' interest in quantum field theory, which has been growing noticeably in the last few years. However, some prominent physicists have shown their deep suspicions against ignorant philosophers' intrusion into their profession, and have expressed their hostility quite openly. In the philosophy community, some prominent philosophers of physics have also expressed their suspicions against the rationale of moving away from the profound foundational problems raised by Einstein and Bohr, Bohm and Bell, such as those concerning the nature of space-time and measurement, possibility and implications of hidden variables and nonlocality, and stepping into the technical complexity of quantum field theory, which is only an application of quantum mechanics in general without intrinsically distinct philosophical questions to be explored. In order to dispel these suspicions, it is desirable to highlight certain aspects of quantum field theory which require philosophical reflections and deserve further investigations. This discussion intends to suggest that philosophers can learn many important lessons from quantum field theory, and may be of some help in clarifying its conceptual foundations. At this stage of crisis that quantum field theory is experiencing now, the clarification may contribute to the radical transformation of our basic concepts in theoretical physics, which is necessary for a happy resolution of the crisis and the emergence of a new promising fundamental physical theory.
This paper is part of the Focused Collection on Upper Division Physics Courses.]Most introductory quantum physics instructors would agree that transitioning students from classical to quantum thinking is an important learning goal, but may disagree on whether or how this can be accomplished.Although (and perhaps because) physicists have long debated the physical interpretation of quantum theory, many instructors choose to avoid emphasizing interpretive themes; or they discuss the views of scientists in their classrooms, but do not adequately attend to student interpretations.In this synthesis and extension of prior work, we demonstrate the following: (i) instructors vary in their approaches to teaching interpretive themes; (ii) different instructional approaches have differential impacts on student thinking; and (iii) when student interpretations go unattended, they often develop their own (sometimes scientifically undesirable) views.We introduce here a new modern physics curriculum that explicitly attends to student interpretations, and provide evidence-based arguments that doing so helps them to develop more consistent interpretations of quantum phenomena, more sophisticated views of uncertainty, and greater interest in quantum physics.
A century after its formulation, we discuss the multifaceted implications for education of the vast cultural connections that quantum mechanics (QM) has helped establish between physics and other disciplines. Drawing on the most recent research in QM education, we will address the epistemological paradigms that underpin our understanding of nature and the cultural significance of this theory for the intellectual development of students at various educational levels; always maintaining a careful focus on the fundamental educational challenge of teaching and learning about the nature of science through physics education.