Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Birkhäuser Basel eBooks

Schrödinger’s View of Natural Laws

Robert Aebi

Published Jan 1, 1996• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This is an exploration with today’s tools of probability theory into the mystery of ‘Über die Umkehrung der Naturgesetze’ (On time-reversal of natural laws) written by Erwin Schrödinger in 1931. He propagates the idea that diffusions given their marginal distributions at finite initial and final time are time-reversible. We are going to meet clouds of identical and independent particles considering them as realizations of diffusions. The particle dynamics is assumed to be known. Given the observation of such a cloud in terms of distribution densities at finite initial and final time, the intention is to find the ‘most probable’ distribution density of the cloud at intermediate times.

DOI
10.1007/978-3-0348-9027-4_1

Related papers

Über die Umkehrung der Naturgesetze

Erwin Schrödinger

Abstract A decade before his 1926 paperb reporting his discovery of wave mechanics, a derivation of the time-independent wave equation, and its solutions for hydrogen-like atoms, Erwin Schrödinger had carried out several studies dealing with Brownian motion. It is clear from several of the papers he wrote that he was completely familiar with diffusion equations, the Fokker-Planck equation in many forms, their connections with Green’s functions, and with behavior of systems of particles undergoing random walks including those in force fields.c Thus, it is not surprising that Schrödinger was aware of the relation of the Schrödinger equation in imaginary time, to the diffusion equation governing particles undergoing diffusion, In this paper, with the title “On the Reversal of Natural Laws,” Schrödinger pointed out the remarkable formal analogy of diffusion with quantum mechanics and the discrepancies introduced by the factor J=T. In his discussion Schrödinger made the statement, “I am unable to foresee whether this analogy will prove itself useful in the clarification of quantum mechanical concepts,” but he finished the paper with the hope it would. There is no indication that Schrödinger was aware of the possibilities of a next step into quantum Monte Carlo - the use of random walks to provide solutions to the wave equation. This was left for others to discover later.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 18, 2007•67 citations

E. Schrödinger’s 1931 paper “On the Reversal of the Laws of Nature” [“Über die Umkehrung der Naturgesetze”, Sitzungsberichte der preussischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, physikalisch-mathematische Klasse, 8 N9 144–153]

Raphaël Chétrite, Paolo Muratore-Ginanneschi, Kay Schwieger

Abstract We present an English translation of Erwin Schrödinger’s paper on “On the Reversal of the Laws of Nature‘’. In this paper, Schrödinger analyses the idea of time reversal of a diffusion process. Schrödinger’s paper acted as a prominent source of inspiration for the works of Bernstein on reciprocal processes and of Kolmogorov on time reversal properties of Markov processes and detailed balance. The ideas outlined by Schrödinger also inspired the development of probabilistic interpretations of quantum mechanics by Fényes, Nelson and others as well as the notion of “Euclidean Quantum Mechanics” as probabilistic analogue of quantization. In the second part of the paper, Schrödinger discusses the relation between time reversal and statistical laws of physics. We emphasize in our commentary the relevance of Schrödinger’s intuitions for contemporary developments in statistical nano-physics.

arXiv:2105.12617•The European Physical Journal H•Nov 22, 2021•41 citations

Schrödinger Diffusion Processes

Robert Aebi

In 1931 Erwin Schrödinger considered the following problem: A huge cloud of independent and identical particles with known dynamics is supposed to be observed at finite initial and final times. What i

Birkhäuser Basel eBooks•Jan 1, 1996•17 citations

Controlling Uncertainty

Yongxin Chen, Tryphon T. Georgiou, Michele Pavon

Our account begins in 1931/1932, when one of the fathers of quantum theory, Erwin Schrodinger, proposed a Gedankenexperiment to comprehend the propagation of a cloud of Brownian particles. He proposed [1], [2] the inference problem to identify the most likely evolution of a large collection of particles as they traverse between two endpoints in time- their distribution being measured and available at the two endpoints. This random evolution, now known as the Schrodinger bridge, entails a flow of one-time distributions that interpolate the known initial and final marginals.

IEEE Control Systems•Jul 26, 2021•14 citations

Introduction To Quantum Relaxation Processes

Abraham Nitzan

The first question to ask about the phenomenon of relaxation is why it occurs at all. Both the Newton and the Schrödinger equations are symmetrical under time reversal: The Newton equation, dx/dt = v ; dv/dt = −∂V/∂x, implies that particles obeying this law of motion will retrace their trajectory back in time after changing the sign of both the time t and the particle velocities v. The Schrödinger equation, ∂ψ/∂t = −(i/.h) Ĥ ψ, implies that if (ψ (t) is a solution then ψ *(−t) is also one, so that observables which depend on |ψ|2 are symmetric in time. On the other hand, nature clearly evolves asymmetrically as asserted by the second law of thermodynamics. How does this asymmetry arise in a system that obeys temporal symmetry in its time evolution? Readers with background in thermodynamics and statistical mechanics have encountered the intuitive answer: Irreversibility in a system with many degrees of freedom is essentially a manifestation of the system “getting lost in phase space”:Asystem starts from a given state and evolves in time. If the number of accessible states is huge, the probability that the system will find its way back to the initial state in finite time is vanishingly small, so that an observer who monitors properties associated with the initial state will see an irreversible evolution. The question is how is this irreversible behavior manifested through the reversible equations of motion, and how does it show in the quantitative description of the time evolution. This chapter provides an introduction to this subject using the time-dependent Schrödinger equation as a starting point. Chapter 10 discusses more advanced aspects of this problem within the framework of the quantum Liouville equation and the density operator formalism.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 6, 2006•0 citations

Schrödinger Equations and Diffusion Theory

Masao Nagasawa

Schrödinger Equations and Diffusion Theory addresses the question "What is the Schrödinger equation?" in terms of diffusion processes, and shows that the Schrödinger equation and diffusion equations in duality are equivalent. In turn, Schrödinger's conjecture of 1931 is solved. The theory of diffusion processes for the Schrödinger equation tell us that we must go further into the theory of systems of (infinitely) many interacting quantum (diffusion) particles. The method of relative entropy and the theory of transformations enable us to construct severely singular diffusion processes which appear to be equivalent to Schrödinger equations. The theory of large deviations and the propagation of chaos of interacting diffusion particles reveal the statistical mechanical nature of the Schrödinger equation, namely, quantum mechanics. The text is practically self-contained and requires only an elementary knowledge of probability theory at the graduate level.

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1993•152 citations
This is an exploration with today’s tools of probability theory into the mystery of ‘Über die Umkehrung der Naturgesetze’ (On time-reversal of natural laws) written by Erwin Schrödinger in 1931. He propagates the idea that diffusions given their marginal distributions at finite initial and final time are time-reversible. We are going to meet clouds of identical and independent particles considering them as realizations of diffusions. The particle dynamics is assumed to be known. Given the observation of such a cloud in terms of distribution densities at finite initial and final time, the intention is to find the ‘most probable’ distribution density of the cloud at intermediate times.
Abstract A decade before his 1926 paperb reporting his discovery of wave mechanics, a derivation of the time-independent wave equation, and its solutions for hydrogen-like atoms, Erwin Schrödinger had carried out several studies dealing with Brownian motion. It is clear from several of the papers he wrote that he was completely familiar with diffusion equations, the Fokker-Planck equation in many forms, their connections with Green’s functions, and with behavior of systems of particles undergoing random walks including those in force fields.c Thus, it is not surprising that Schrödinger was aware of the relation of the Schrödinger equation in imaginary time, to the diffusion equation governing particles undergoing diffusion, In this paper, with the title “On the Reversal of Natural Laws,” Schrödinger pointed out the remarkable formal analogy of diffusion with quantum mechanics and the discrepancies introduced by the factor J=T. In his discussion Schrödinger made the statement, “I am unable to foresee whether this analogy will prove itself useful in the clarification of quantum mechanical concepts,” but he finished the paper with the hope it would. There is no indication that Schrödinger was aware of the possibilities of a next step into quantum Monte Carlo - the use of random walks to provide solutions to the wave equation. This was left for others to discover later.
Abstract We present an English translation of Erwin Schrödinger’s paper on “On the Reversal of the Laws of Nature‘’. In this paper, Schrödinger analyses the idea of time reversal of a diffusion process. Schrödinger’s paper acted as a prominent source of inspiration for the works of Bernstein on reciprocal processes and of Kolmogorov on time reversal properties of Markov processes and detailed balance. The ideas outlined by Schrödinger also inspired the development of probabilistic interpretations of quantum mechanics by Fényes, Nelson and others as well as the notion of “Euclidean Quantum Mechanics” as probabilistic analogue of quantization. In the second part of the paper, Schrödinger discusses the relation between time reversal and statistical laws of physics. We emphasize in our commentary the relevance of Schrödinger’s intuitions for contemporary developments in statistical nano-physics.
Our account begins in 1931/1932, when one of the fathers of quantum theory, Erwin Schrodinger, proposed a Gedankenexperiment to comprehend the propagation of a cloud of Brownian particles. He proposed [1], [2] the inference problem to identify the most likely evolution of a large collection of particles as they traverse between two endpoints in time- their distribution being measured and available at the two endpoints. This random evolution, now known as the Schrodinger bridge, entails a flow of one-time distributions that interpolate the known initial and final marginals.
The first question to ask about the phenomenon of relaxation is why it occurs at all. Both the Newton and the Schrödinger equations are symmetrical under time reversal: The Newton equation, dx/dt = v ; dv/dt = −∂V/∂x, implies that particles obeying this law of motion will retrace their trajectory back in time after changing the sign of both the time t and the particle velocities v. The Schrödinger equation, ∂ψ/∂t = −(i/.h) Ĥ ψ, implies that if (ψ (t) is a solution then ψ *(−t) is also one, so that observables which depend on |ψ|2 are symmetric in time. On the other hand, nature clearly evolves asymmetrically as asserted by the second law of thermodynamics. How does this asymmetry arise in a system that obeys temporal symmetry in its time evolution? Readers with background in thermodynamics and statistical mechanics have encountered the intuitive answer: Irreversibility in a system with many degrees of freedom is essentially a manifestation of the system “getting lost in phase space”:Asystem starts from a given state and evolves in time. If the number of accessible states is huge, the probability that the system will find its way back to the initial state in finite time is vanishingly small, so that an observer who monitors properties associated with the initial state will see an irreversible evolution. The question is how is this irreversible behavior manifested through the reversible equations of motion, and how does it show in the quantitative description of the time evolution. This chapter provides an introduction to this subject using the time-dependent Schrödinger equation as a starting point. Chapter 10 discusses more advanced aspects of this problem within the framework of the quantum Liouville equation and the density operator formalism.
Schrödinger Equations and Diffusion Theory addresses the question "What is the Schrödinger equation?" in terms of diffusion processes, and shows that the Schrödinger equation and diffusion equations in duality are equivalent. In turn, Schrödinger's conjecture of 1931 is solved. The theory of diffusion processes for the Schrödinger equation tell us that we must go further into the theory of systems of (infinitely) many interacting quantum (diffusion) particles. The method of relative entropy and the theory of transformations enable us to construct severely singular diffusion processes which appear to be equivalent to Schrödinger equations. The theory of large deviations and the propagation of chaos of interacting diffusion particles reveal the statistical mechanical nature of the Schrödinger equation, namely, quantum mechanics. The text is practically self-contained and requires only an elementary knowledge of probability theory at the graduate level.