In classical physics if we have two distinct physical states ψ1 6=ψ2 of a physical system and we know that ψ1ORψ2 is a true statement we can easily deduce that ψ1XORψ2 is a true statement too. In Quantum Mechanics however we encounter a novel possibility for quantum coherent superposition. It has been verified in numerous experiments that a qubit can be prepared in a linear combination of two orthogonal states, and this parallel existence in the quantum realm, in the form ψ1ANDψ2, is what requires caution when we draw conclusions from a given set of premises — the truth of ψ1ORψ2 now does not lead to the truth of ψ1XORψ2. If a qubit at point x is in a state ψ1XORψ2 then ψ1 and ψ2 are called distinguishable states. Logically, if the qubit at point x is in a state ψ1XNORψ2 the two states ψ1 and ψ2 will be indistinguishable. From the requirement for mathematical consistency it follows that two states ψ1 and ψ2 cannot be both distinguishable and indistinguishable at the same time. The concept of distinguishability is intimately tied with the notion of quantum complementarity. While the quantum amplitudes evolve linearly according to the Schrodinger equation, the physical observables are obtained from the underlying quantum amplitudes through nonlinearity prescribed by Born’s rule. Thus if quantum states ψ1(x) 6=0 and ψ2(x) 6=0 are indistinguishable at a point x (coherent superposition), that is ψ1(x)ANDψ2(x), the probability distribution (observed intensity) is given by P = |ψ1(x) + ψ2(x)|. The density matrix of the setup is a pure type one, ρ= ( |ψ1| 2 ψ1ψ ∗ 2
In classical physics if we have two distinct physical states ψ1 6=ψ2 of a physical system and we know that ψ1ORψ2 is a true statement we can easily deduce that ψ1XORψ2 is a true statement too. In Quantum Mechanics however we encounter a novel possibility for quantum coherent superposition. It has been verified in numerous experiments that a qubit can be prepared in a linear combination of two orthogonal states, and this parallel existence in the quantum realm, in the form ψ1ANDψ2, is what requires caution when we draw conclusions from a given set of premises — the truth of ψ1ORψ2 now does not lead to the truth of ψ1XORψ2. If a qubit at point x is in a state ψ1XORψ2 then ψ1 and ψ2 are called distinguishable states. Logically, if the qubit at point x is in a state ψ1XNORψ2 the two states ψ1 and ψ2 will be indistinguishable. From the requirement for mathematical consistency it follows that two states ψ1 and ψ2 cannot be both distinguishable and indistinguishable at the same time. The concept of distinguishability is intimately tied with the notion of quantum complementarity. While the quantum amplitudes evolve linearly according to the Schrodinger equation, the physical observables are obtained from the underlying quantum amplitudes through nonlinearity prescribed by Born’s rule. Thus if quantum states ψ1(x) 6=0 and ψ2(x) 6=0 are indistinguishable at a point x (coherent superposition), that is ψ1(x)ANDψ2(x), the probability distribution (observed intensity) is given by P = |ψ1(x) + ψ2(x)|. The density matrix of the setup is a pure type one, ρ= ( |ψ1| 2 ψ1ψ ∗ 2
For around five decades, physicists have been experimenting with single quanta such as single photons. Insofar as the practised ensemble reasoning has become obsolete for the interpretation of these experiments, the non-classical intrinsic probabilistic nature of quantum theory has gained increased importance. One of the most important exclusive features of quantum physics is the undeniable existence of the superposition of states, even for single quantum objects. One known example of this effect is entanglement. In this paper, two classically contradictory phenomena are combined to one single experiment. This experiment incontestably shows that a single photon incident on an optical beam splitter can either be reflected or transmitted. The almost complete absence of coincident clicks of two photodetectors demonstrates that these two output states are incompatible. However, when combining these states using two mirrors, we can observe interference patterns in the counting rate of the single photon detector. The only explanation for this is that the two incompatible output states are prepared and kept simultaneously—a typical consequence of a quantum superposition of states. (Semi-)classical physical concepts fail here, and a full quantum concept is predestined to explain the complementary experimental outcomes for the quantum optical “non-waves” called single photons. In this paper, we intend to demonstrate that a true quantum physical key experiment (“true” in the sense that it cannot be explained by any classical physical concept), when combined with full quantum reasoning (probability, superposition and interference), influences students’ readiness to use quantum elements for interpretation.
According to a recent no-go theorem [M. Pusey, J. Barrett and T. Rudolph, Nat. Phys. 8, 475 (2012)], models in which quantum states correspond to probability distributions over the values of some underlying physical variables must have the following feature: the distributions corresponding to distinct quantum states do not overlap. In such a model, it cannot coherently be maintained that the quantum state merely encodes information about underlying physical variables. The theorem, however, considers only models in which the physical variables corresponding to independently prepared systems are independent, and this has been used to challenge the conclusions of that work. Here we consider models that are defined for a single quantum system of dimension d, such that the independence condition does not arise, and derive an upper bound on the extent to which the probability distributions can overlap. In particular, models in which the quantum overlap between pure states is equal to the classical overlap between the corresponding probability distributions cannot reproduce the quantum predictions in any dimension d ≥ 3. Thus any ontological model for quantum theory must postulate some extra principle, such as a limitation on the measurability of physical variables, to explain the indistinguishability of quantum states. Moreover, we show that as d→∞, the ratio of classical and quantum overlaps goes to zero for a class of states. The result is noise tolerant, and an experiment is motivated to distinguish the class of models ruled out from quantum theory.
Appendix 33 Quantum Correspondence Tests 33.1 Mapping to Hilbert Space Formalism 33.1.1 Objective This section establishes the requirement that BSFM admits a well-defined mapping into a Hilbert space structure in regimes where quantum mechanical behavior is observed. The purpose is to ensure compatibility with the standard mathematical framework of quantum theory. 33.1.2 Hilbert Space Embedding Requirement BSFM must allow a mapping such that: • each physical state S ∈ S corresponds to a vector |Ψ⟩ ∈ H • the set of admissible states maps into a complete inner-product space • superposition structure is preserved under state combination This implies the existence of a well-defined embedding: • Φ : S → H 33.1.3 Linearity Condition Within the mapped representation: • linear combinations of states must correspond to valid physical superpositions • evolution must be representable as a linear (or effectively linear) operator in the quantum regime • interference effects must be preserved under the mapping This ensures consistency with quantum mechanical structure. 33.1.4 Inner Product Consistency The mapping must define an inner product structure such that: • physical distinguishability corresponds to orthogonality relations • probability amplitudes are derived from inner product magnitudes • normalization conditions are preserved under evolution Formally, physical probabilities must be recoverable from: • ⟨Ψ|Ψ⟩ 33.1.5 State Completeness Requirement The mapped Hilbert space representation must be: • complete under limits of convergent sequences of states • closed under allowed linear operations in the quantum regime • sufficient to represent all physically distinguishable configurations This ensures no loss of physical information under mapping. 33.1.6 Branch-to-State Correspondence Within BSFM, branching structure must map consistently into quantum structure such that: • branches correspond to components of a superposed state • branch weights correspond to amplitude coefficients • coherence relations between branches map to phase structure This provides the structural link between BSFM evolution and quantum formalism. 33.1.7 Failure Condition The mapping to Hilbert space fails if: • no consistent vector space representation exists for BSFM states • inner product structure cannot be defined or preserved • branching cannot be represented as superposition without contradiction • linearity or normalization is violated in the quantum regime 33.1.8 Summary BSFM is compatible with quantum formalism only if its state structure can be consistently embedded into a Hilbert space where superposition, inner products, and linear evolution reproduce standard quantum mechanical behavior in the appropriate limit. Appendix 33 — Quantum Correspondence Tests 33.2 Unitarity and Norm Preservation Conditions 33.2.1 Objective This section establishes the requirement that BSFM must preserve total probability (norm) under evolution in the quantum correspondence regime. This ensures compatibility with unitary evolution in standard quantum mechanics and prevents loss or creation of probability mass. 33.2.2 Norm Definition Requirement In the Hilbert space representation: • each physical state |Ψ⟩ ∈ Hmust satisfy a well-defined norm • probability interpretation requires normalization of state vectors Formally: • ⟨Ψ|Ψ⟩ =1 for all physically valid states after normalization. 33.2.3 Unitary Evolution Condition For an evolution operator U acting in the quantum regime: • |Ψₙ₊₁⟩ = U|Ψₙ⟩ BSFM must ensure that: • U†U = 1 This guarantees that evolution preserves inner products between states and maintains probability consistency over time. 33.2.4 Norm Preservation Requirement Under BSFM evolution in the quantum correspondence regime: • total probability must remain invariant under iteration • branching weights (when mapped to amplitudes) must conserve norm globally • no net gain or loss of probability mass is permitted Formally: • ⟨Ψₙ₊₁|Ψₙ₊₁⟩ = ⟨Ψₙ|Ψₙ⟩ 33.2.5 Branch-Amplitude Consistency Condition If BSFM branching maps to quantum amplitudes: • the sum of squared amplitude magnitudes must remain constant • interference structure must not alter total probability • redistribution among branches is permitted only under unitary constraints Formally: • Σᵢ |cᵢ⁽ⁿ⁺¹⁾|² = Σᵢ |cᵢⁿ|² 33.2.6 Conservation of Probability Flow In dynamic evolution: • probability may redistribute across states or branches • but total probability within the Hilbert space must remain fixed • no leakage outside the admissible state space is allowed This ensures closed-system behavior in the quantum regime. 33.2.7 Non-Unitary Failure Detection Any deviation from unitary behavior indicates breakdown of quantum correspondence. This includes: • loss of normalization under evolution • growth or decay of total probability • non-invertible evolution operators in the quantum regime • inconsistent amplitude mapping from branching structure 33.2.8 Boundary Condition for Emergent Unitarity If unitarity is not fundamental in BSFM but emergent: • there must exist a regime where effective dynamics become unitary • non-unitary effects must be suppressed or canceled in that limit • deviations must vanish under appropriate coarse-graining or symmetry conditions 33.2.9 Summary BSFM is consistent with quantum mechanics only if its mapped evolution preserves norm and satisfies unitary dynamics in the Hilbert space representation, ensuring conservation of probability and reversible evolution in the quantum correspondence regime. Appendix 33 — Quantum Correspondence Tests 33.3 Superposition and Interference Consistency 33.3.1 Objective This section establishes that BSFM must reproduce the defining quantum features of superposition and interference when mapped into its Hilbert space correspondence. The requirement is that linear combination of states and phase-dependent effects must emerge consistently from the underlying branching structure. 33.3.2 Superposition Principle Requirement In the quantum correspondence regime, BSFM must allow state combinations such that: • if |Ψ₁⟩ and |Ψ₂⟩ are valid states, then a|Ψ₁⟩ + b|Ψ₂⟩ • is also a valid physical state where a, b ∈ ℂ This ensures closure under linear combination within the mapped Hilbert space structure. 33.3.3 Branch-State Correspondence In BSFM terms: • individual branches correspond to components of a composite state • branching structure maps to decomposition of a superposed state • branch weights correspond to amplitude magnitudes and phases The mapping must preserve distinguishability and recombination behavior of branches. 33.3.4 Interference Requirement BSFM must reproduce interference effects such that: • combined amplitudes produce non-classical probability distributions • phase relationships between components affect observable outcomes • constructive and destructive interference emerge naturally from the structure Formally, observable probabilities must depend on: • cross terms of amplitude combinations, not only individual contributions 33.3.5 Coherence Preservation Condition For interference to remain valid: • phase relationships between components must be preserved under evolution • coherence between branches must not collapse prematurely in the quantum regime • decoherence must only emerge under classical-limit conditions (Appendix 32 regime boundary) This ensures correct separation between quantum and classical behavior. 33.3.6 Non-Additive Probability Structure BSFM must reproduce the quantum rule that: • probabilities are not simply additive over branches • interference terms modify total outcomes • classical probability emerges only when coherence is lost This distinguishes quantum behavior from classical stochastic aggregation. 33.3.7 Consistency Requirement The mapping must ensure: • superposition in Hilbert space corresponds consistently to branching combinations in BSFM • interference patterns remain invariant under valid transformations • no hidden classical averaging removes quantum phase dependence 33.3.8 Failure Condition Superposition and interference consistency fails if: • linear combinations of states are not preserved in the mapping • interference terms cannot be recovered from branch structure • probabilities reduce to purely additive classical form in the quantum regime • phase information is lost or undefined under evolution 33.3.9 Summary BSFM is consistent with quantum superposition only if its branching structure maps into a linear state space where phase-dependent interference effects are preserved, producing non-classical probability behavior consistent with standard quantum mechanics. Appendix 33 — Quantum Correspondence Tests 33.4 Path Integral Equivalence Validation 33.4.1 Objective This section establishes the requirement that BSFM must reproduce, in an appropriate limit, the structure and predictions of the path integral formulation of quantum mechanics. The goal is to ensure equivalence between BSFM branching evolution and summation over histories. 33.4.2 Path Integral Correspondence Requirement In the quantum regime, BSFM must admit an equivalence such that: • the total amplitude for transition between states is given by a sum over all allowed evolution histories • each history contributes with a well-defined weight and phase structure • the full evolution is recoverable as an aggregate over all admissible paths Formally, BSFM must support a mapping consistent with: • “sum over histories” structure in the quantum correspondence limit 33.4.3 Branch-History Mapping Condition BSFM branching must correspond to path decomposition such that: • each branch corresponds to a distinct dynamical history • the full set of branches represents the complete set of allowed paths • recombination of branches reproduces full transition amplitudes This ensures structural eq
Two photons are said to be identical if they are prepared in the same quantum state. Given the latter, there is a unique way to achieve this. Conversely, there are many different ways of preparing two non-identical photons: they may differ in frequency, polarization, amplitude, etc. Therefore, photon distinguishability depends upon the specific degree of freedom being varied. By means of a careful analysis of the coincidence probability distribution in a Hong–Ou–Mandel experiment, we can show that photon distinguishability can be actually quantified by the rate of distinguishability of photons, an experimentally measurable parameter that crucially depends on both the photon quantum state and the degree of freedom under control.