Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Correlated Error Bursts from Ionising Impacts: A Rate Budget for Millimetre-Scale Surface-Code Patches

William Alexander Aldred

Published Nov 15, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Ionising radiation, from cosmic rays and from trace radioactivity in the laboratory itself, deposits energy in a superconducting chip in bursts that momentarily raise the quasiparticle density across millimetre scales and corrupt many qubits at once. Published monitoring of a large superconducting processor found such events recurring on a timescale of roughly 10 seconds. This paper converts that recurrence into the units of error correction. At a one-microsecond syndrome cycle, bursts arrive every 1.0e7 cycles somewhere on the chip; a distance-twenty-seven patch occupies about 29 per cent of a square-centimetre die, so a thousand-logical-qubit machine spread over many dies should expect a burst inside some patch every few seconds of operation. Correlated bursts are the error model's worst citizen: they violate the independence assumption on which distance-based suppression rests, and the paper budgets the mitigations, gap engineering, phonon trapping, shielding and burst-aware decoding, against the residual rate.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24245320

Related papers

Synchronous detection of cosmic rays and correlated errors in superconducting qubit arrays

P. M. Harrington, M. Li, Max Hays +13 more

Quantum information processing at scale will require sufficiently stable and long-lived qubits, likely enabled by error-correction codes. Several recent superconducting-qubit experiments, however, reported observing intermittent spatiotemporally correlated errors that would be problematic for conventional codes, with ionizing radiation being a likely cause. Here, we directly measured the cosmic-ray contribution to spatiotemporally correlated qubit errors. We accomplished this by synchronously monitoring cosmic-ray detectors and qubit energy-relaxation dynamics of 10 transmon qubits distributed across a 5 × 5 × 0.35 mm3 silicon chip. Cosmic rays caused correlated errors at a rate of $$1/\left(592\begin{array}{c}+48\\ -41\end{array}\,{\rm{s}}\right)$$ , accounting for 17.1 ± 1.3% of all such events. Our qubits responded to essentially all of the cosmic rays and their secondary particles incident on the chip, consistent with the independently measured arrival flux. Moreover, we observed that the landscape of the superconducting gap in proximity to the Josephson junctions dramatically impacts the qubit response to cosmic rays. Given the practical difficulties associated with shielding cosmic rays, our results indicate the importance of radiation hardening—for example, superconducting gap engineering—to the realization of robust quantum error correction. Ionizing radiation from cosmic rays has been identified as a source of correlated errors in superconducting qubits, but a direct demonstration of this link has been lacking. Here the authors measure the coincidence between correlated errors and incident cosmic rays in a chip with 10 transmon qubits.

arXiv:2402.03208•Nature Communications•Jul 11, 2025•57 citations

Reconstruction locality bounds charge-generated dynamics in quantum codes: an exact accuracy floor and a measurable certificate for it

Zongmin Liu

Rare correlated error bursts are the reported scaling limit of below-threshold surface-code memo- ries, and existing analyses treat them as events that elevate the error rate across an entire code patch. We show that this assumption fails in the regime every scaled code must enter, where the patch is larger than the burst. There the logical error rate is controlled not by the burst rate but by the tail of the burst footprint distribution: for Pr[Ω > r] ∼ r−α the burst contribution obeys εb(d) ∝ dD−α, so exponential suppression in code distance is replaced by a power law and fault-tolerance over- head becomes polynomial rather than polylogarithmic, with a critical exponent αc = D separating suppressible from unsuppressible environments. Circuit-level simulations over nine code distances, d = 5 to 21, confirm the scaling function and the exponent transfer. We then measure the footprint distribution itself, from 265 radiation bursts resolved on a 60-qubit gap-engineered array, using a forward model of the array that is calibrated against synthetic catalogues before use. The distribu- tion is lognormal, with σ = 0.23 [0.21, 0.26] and median radius 2.9 mm, and is preferred over the best power law by ∆AIC = 71; that comparison is itself calibrated, placing the observed value 9.4σ from the power-law expectation. A lognormal has no tail exponent, so the non-scalable regime α ≤ D is excluded by ten standard deviations and exponential suppression survives in present hardware — refuting a prediction we had made from radiation-transport scaling. The measurement also shows that gap engineering has acted on the shape of the footprint distribution rather than on the burst rate alone, which under the transfer law makes phonon management an asymptotic rather than a constant-factor intervention. Independently, no burst in 5.2 h is large enough to span a distance-7 patch, which accounts for the absence of burst excess in 28 public distance-7 datasets. The largest footprint sampled corresponds to R = 4.9 mm, leaving the distribution beyond that radius — and hence the asymptotics of larger arrays — open to the same measurement on a larger device.

•Aug 1, 2026•0 citations

Cosmic-ray-induced correlated errors in superconducting qubit array

Xuegang Li, Junhua Wang, Yao-Yao Jiang +15 more

Correlated errors may devastate quantum error corrections that are necessary for the realization of fault-tolerant quantum computation. Recent experiments with superconducting qubits indicate that they can arise from quasiparticle (QP) bursts induced by cosmic-ray muons and γ-rays. Here, we use charge-parity jump and bit flip for monitoring QP bursts and two muon detectors in the dilution refrigerator for detecting muon events. We directly observe QP bursts leading to correlated errors that are induced solely by muons and separate the contributions of muons and γ-rays. We further investigate the dynamical process of QP burst and the impact of QP trapping on correlated errors and particle detection. The proposed method, which monitors multiqubit simultaneous charge-parity jumps, has high sensitivity to QP bursts and may find applications for the detection of cosmic-ray particles, low-mass dark matter, and far-infrared photons. The correlated errors in superconducting qubits have been linked to high-energy particle impacts from cosmic rays, but a direct observation has been lacking. Here, the authors measure the quasiparticle bursts and correlated errors and separate the contributions of cosmic-ray muons and γ-rays in a 63-qubit processor.

arXiv:2402.04245•Nature Communications•May 20, 2025•50 citations

Modeling phonon-mediated quasiparticle poisoning in superconducting qubit arrays

E. Yelton, C. P. Larson, Vito Iaia +8 more

Background radiation can deposit large amounts of energy in the substrate of superconducting qubit arrays. Such events create bursts of energetic phonons that cause transient degradations of coherence, leading to errors. Correlated errors across multiple qubits are problematic for quantum error correction. The authors develop here a numerical model to describe the results of controlled phonon injection experiments. A dense array of qubits is modeled to explore the effectiveness of down-converting metal films for mitigating the effects of gamma ray impacts.

arXiv:2402.15471•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 30, 2024•37 citations

Mitigating cosmic-ray-like correlated events with a modular quantum processor

Xuntao Wu, Yash J. Joshi, Haoxiong Yan +14 more

Quantum processors based on superconducting qubits are being scaled to larger qubit numbers, enabling the implementation of small-scale quantum error-correction codes. However, catastrophic chip-scale correlated errors have been observed in these processors, attributed to, e.g., cosmic ray impacts, which challenge conventional error-correction codes such as the surface code. These events are characterized by a temporary but pronounced suppression of the qubit-energy relaxation times. Here, we explore the potential for modular quantum computing architectures to mitigate such correlated energy decay events. We measure cosmic-ray-like events in a quantum processor comprising a motherboard and two flip-chip bonded daughterboard modules, each module containing two superconducting qubits. We monitor the appearance of correlated qubit decay events within a single module and across the physically separated modules. We find that while decay events within one module are strongly correlated (over $85\mathrm{%}$), events in separate modules only display approximately $2\mathrm{%}$ correlations. We also report coincident decay events in the motherboard and in either of the two daughterboard modules, providing further insight into the nature of these decay events. These results suggest that modular architectures, combined with bespoke error-correction codes, offer a promising approach for protecting future quantum processors from chip-scale correlated errors.

arXiv:2505.15919•Physical Review Applied•Sep 4, 2025•8 citations

Mitigation of Cosmic Rays-Induced Errors in Superconducting Quantum Processors

Ambra Mariani, L. Cardani, N. Casali +5 more

Environmental radioactivity and cosmic-rays have recently been identified as a source of decoherence in super-conducting quantum bits (qubits). In particular, the absorption of cosmic-ray muons and gamma rays emitted by naturally occurring radioactive isotopes in the qubit substrate leads to correlated errors in superconducting quantum processors, posing significant challenges to quantum error correction. To enable quantum computing to scale, it is therefore necessary the devel-opment of mitigation strategies to prevent, or keep under control, error bursts due to particle impacts in the chip. While most environmental radioactive sources can be effectively suppressed using dedicated shielding, cosmic-ray muons, with their high penetration capability, can only be mitigated by moving the entire facility in a deep underground laboratory. This work explores the potential for developing a novel class of quantum processors equipped with an active veto system to protect superconducting-based quantum computers from the detrimental effects of atmospheric muons. Such a device would enable the identification of an atmospheric muon interaction within the processor and veto all operations performed during the occurrence of such an interaction. By demonstrating high detection efficiency and negligible dead time, we aim to establish that the future of quantum processors can be envisioned in above-around facilities.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Sep 17, 2023•4 citations
Ionising radiation, from cosmic rays and from trace radioactivity in the laboratory itself, deposits energy in a superconducting chip in bursts that momentarily raise the quasiparticle density across millimetre scales and corrupt many qubits at once. Published monitoring of a large superconducting processor found such events recurring on a timescale of roughly 10 seconds. This paper converts that recurrence into the units of error correction. At a one-microsecond syndrome cycle, bursts arrive every 1.0e7 cycles somewhere on the chip; a distance-twenty-seven patch occupies about 29 per cent of a square-centimetre die, so a thousand-logical-qubit machine spread over many dies should expect a burst inside some patch every few seconds of operation. Correlated bursts are the error model's worst citizen: they violate the independence assumption on which distance-based suppression rests, and the paper budgets the mitigations, gap engineering, phonon trapping, shielding and burst-aware decoding, against the residual rate.
Quantum information processing at scale will require sufficiently stable and long-lived qubits, likely enabled by error-correction codes. Several recent superconducting-qubit experiments, however, reported observing intermittent spatiotemporally correlated errors that would be problematic for conventional codes, with ionizing radiation being a likely cause. Here, we directly measured the cosmic-ray contribution to spatiotemporally correlated qubit errors. We accomplished this by synchronously monitoring cosmic-ray detectors and qubit energy-relaxation dynamics of 10 transmon qubits distributed across a 5 × 5 × 0.35 mm3 silicon chip. Cosmic rays caused correlated errors at a rate of 1/(592+48−41 s)1/\left(592\begin{array}{c}+48\\ -41\end{array}\,{\rm{s}}\right)1/(592+48−41​s) , accounting for 17.1 ± 1.3% of all such events. Our qubits responded to essentially all of the cosmic rays and their secondary particles incident on the chip, consistent with the independently measured arrival flux. Moreover, we observed that the landscape of the superconducting gap in proximity to the Josephson junctions dramatically impacts the qubit response to cosmic rays. Given the practical difficulties associated with shielding cosmic rays, our results indicate the importance of radiation hardening—for example, superconducting gap engineering—to the realization of robust quantum error correction. Ionizing radiation from cosmic rays has been identified as a source of correlated errors in superconducting qubits, but a direct demonstration of this link has been lacking. Here the authors measure the coincidence between correlated errors and incident cosmic rays in a chip with 10 transmon qubits.
Rare correlated error bursts are the reported scaling limit of below-threshold surface-code memo- ries, and existing analyses treat them as events that elevate the error rate across an entire code patch. We show that this assumption fails in the regime every scaled code must enter, where the patch is larger than the burst. There the logical error rate is controlled not by the burst rate but by the tail of the burst footprint distribution: for Pr[Ω > r] ∼ r−α the burst contribution obeys εb(d) ∝ dD−α, so exponential suppression in code distance is replaced by a power law and fault-tolerance over- head becomes polynomial rather than polylogarithmic, with a critical exponent αc = D separating suppressible from unsuppressible environments. Circuit-level simulations over nine code distances, d = 5 to 21, confirm the scaling function and the exponent transfer. We then measure the footprint distribution itself, from 265 radiation bursts resolved on a 60-qubit gap-engineered array, using a forward model of the array that is calibrated against synthetic catalogues before use. The distribu- tion is lognormal, with σ = 0.23 [0.21, 0.26] and median radius 2.9 mm, and is preferred over the best power law by ∆AIC = 71; that comparison is itself calibrated, placing the observed value 9.4σ from the power-law expectation. A lognormal has no tail exponent, so the non-scalable regime α ≤ D is excluded by ten standard deviations and exponential suppression survives in present hardware — refuting a prediction we had made from radiation-transport scaling. The measurement also shows that gap engineering has acted on the shape of the footprint distribution rather than on the burst rate alone, which under the transfer law makes phonon management an asymptotic rather than a constant-factor intervention. Independently, no burst in 5.2 h is large enough to span a distance-7 patch, which accounts for the absence of burst excess in 28 public distance-7 datasets. The largest footprint sampled corresponds to R = 4.9 mm, leaving the distribution beyond that radius — and hence the asymptotics of larger arrays — open to the same measurement on a larger device.
Correlated errors may devastate quantum error corrections that are necessary for the realization of fault-tolerant quantum computation. Recent experiments with superconducting qubits indicate that they can arise from quasiparticle (QP) bursts induced by cosmic-ray muons and γ-rays. Here, we use charge-parity jump and bit flip for monitoring QP bursts and two muon detectors in the dilution refrigerator for detecting muon events. We directly observe QP bursts leading to correlated errors that are induced solely by muons and separate the contributions of muons and γ-rays. We further investigate the dynamical process of QP burst and the impact of QP trapping on correlated errors and particle detection. The proposed method, which monitors multiqubit simultaneous charge-parity jumps, has high sensitivity to QP bursts and may find applications for the detection of cosmic-ray particles, low-mass dark matter, and far-infrared photons. The correlated errors in superconducting qubits have been linked to high-energy particle impacts from cosmic rays, but a direct observation has been lacking. Here, the authors measure the quasiparticle bursts and correlated errors and separate the contributions of cosmic-ray muons and γ-rays in a 63-qubit processor.
Background radiation can deposit large amounts of energy in the substrate of superconducting qubit arrays. Such events create bursts of energetic phonons that cause transient degradations of coherence, leading to errors. Correlated errors across multiple qubits are problematic for quantum error correction. The authors develop here a numerical model to describe the results of controlled phonon injection experiments. A dense array of qubits is modeled to explore the effectiveness of down-converting metal films for mitigating the effects of gamma ray impacts.
Quantum processors based on superconducting qubits are being scaled to larger qubit numbers, enabling the implementation of small-scale quantum error-correction codes. However, catastrophic chip-scale correlated errors have been observed in these processors, attributed to, e.g., cosmic ray impacts, which challenge conventional error-correction codes such as the surface code. These events are characterized by a temporary but pronounced suppression of the qubit-energy relaxation times. Here, we explore the potential for modular quantum computing architectures to mitigate such correlated energy decay events. We measure cosmic-ray-like events in a quantum processor comprising a motherboard and two flip-chip bonded daughterboard modules, each module containing two superconducting qubits. We monitor the appearance of correlated qubit decay events within a single module and across the physically separated modules. We find that while decay events within one module are strongly correlated (over $85\mathrm{%}$), events in separate modules only display approximately $2\mathrm{%}$ correlations. We also report coincident decay events in the motherboard and in either of the two daughterboard modules, providing further insight into the nature of these decay events. These results suggest that modular architectures, combined with bespoke error-correction codes, offer a promising approach for protecting future quantum processors from chip-scale correlated errors.
Environmental radioactivity and cosmic-rays have recently been identified as a source of decoherence in super-conducting quantum bits (qubits). In particular, the absorption of cosmic-ray muons and gamma rays emitted by naturally occurring radioactive isotopes in the qubit substrate leads to correlated errors in superconducting quantum processors, posing significant challenges to quantum error correction. To enable quantum computing to scale, it is therefore necessary the devel-opment of mitigation strategies to prevent, or keep under control, error bursts due to particle impacts in the chip. While most environmental radioactive sources can be effectively suppressed using dedicated shielding, cosmic-ray muons, with their high penetration capability, can only be mitigated by moving the entire facility in a deep underground laboratory. This work explores the potential for developing a novel class of quantum processors equipped with an active veto system to protect superconducting-based quantum computers from the detrimental effects of atmospheric muons. Such a device would enable the identification of an atmospheric muon interaction within the processor and veto all operations performed during the occurrence of such an interaction. By demonstrating high detection efficiency and negligible dead time, we aim to establish that the future of quantum processors can be envisioned in above-around facilities.