Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Could quantum field theory be an effective description of a classical field theory?

Jarek Duda

Published Nov 13, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

For the whole Universe QFT is a Feynman ensemble of histories evolving unitarily - so could we focus on one history of a classical field, fixed at both ends, with QFT as its statistics? Tested here on solvable models: positive ensembles of classical histories give two-point functions and Born densities, fail at the interaction vertex, and what works is a pair of past and future histories.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24195053

Related papers

On the problem of hidden variables for quantum field theory

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We show that QFT (as well as QM) is not a complete physical theory. We constructed a classical statistical model inducing quantum field averages. The phase space consists of square integrable functions, $f(ϕ),$ of the classical bosonic field, $ϕ(x).$ We call our model prequantum classical statistical field-functional theory -- PCSFFT. The correspondence between classical averages given by PCSFFT and quantum field averages given by QFT is asymptotic. The QFT-average gives the main term in the expansion of the PCSFFT-average with respect to the small parameter $α$ -- dispersion of fluctuations of "vacuum field functionals.'' The Scrödinger equation of QFT is obtained as the Hamilton equation for functionals, $F(f),$ of classical field functions, $f(ϕ).$ The main experimental prediction of PCSFFT is that QFT gives only approximative statistical predictions that might be violated in future experiments.

arXiv:hep-th/0604163•Il Nuovo Cimento B•Apr 23, 2006•14 citations

Not Particles, Not Quite Fields: An Ontology for Quantum Field Theory

Tracy Lupher

There are significant problems involved in determining the ontology of quantum field theory (QFT). An ontology involving particles seems to be ruled out due to the problem of defining localized position operators, issues involving interactions in QFT, and, perhaps, the appearance of unitarily inequivalent representations. While this might imply that fields are the most natural ontology for QFT, the wavefunctional interpretation of QFT has significant drawbacks. A modified field ontology is examined where determinables are assigned to open bounded regions of spacetime instead of spacetime points.

Humana.mente•Jan 1, 2010•4 citations

Quantum field theory for classical fields

Christof Wetterich

For classical field theories with probabilistic initial conditions the classical field observables are an idealization. Their arbitrarily precise values poorly reflect the characteristic uncertainty in the presence of substantial fluctuations. We propose to employ observables based on fluctuating fields. In terms of these "statistical observables" the probabilistic classical field theory becomes a quantum field theory. Non-commuting operators are associated to observables. The quantum rules follow from the laws for classical probabilities. The ``quantum'' is part of the ``classical''. A regularized functional integral guarantees the unitarity of the quantum field theory. We discuss in detail the classical relativistic Klein-Gordon equation with interactions.

quant-pharXiv:2603.05061•APS Open Science•Mar 6, 2026•4 citations

On the Statistical Origin of Physical Laws

Riko Schadow

We consider an embedded observer with no prior knowledge of the existence or nature of the dynamical process generating her observations and ask how such an observer should infer the underlying dynamics from a finite observational history. Rather than taking fixed dynamical laws as the starting point and observations as their consequence, we begin with observations and ask how stable effective laws emerge from them. To this end, we develop an inferential framework in which dynamical laws are treated as statistical objects. The observer, modeled as a quantum reference frame interacting with an environment, explains past observations and predicts future observations by averaging over an ensemble of computable dynamical models, each represented by a CPTP map. We show that the posterior distribution over dynamical models assumes a Gibbs-Boltzmann form in which the minimum description length (MDL) plays the role of an effective energy. The posterior arises as the minimizer of a variational free-MDL functional balancing algorithmic simplicity against epistemic entropy. Sequential updating statistically tends to reinforce compressible regularities, thereby stabilizing the corresponding effective dynamical laws. These emerge as the optimal explanatory and predictive structures for past and future observations, respectively. The results suggest that the lawfulness experienced by embedded observers is a statistical property of rational inference and can arise and persist without fundamental laws. Effective laws emerge and remain stable under typical continuations of the observational history while still allowing, in principle, transitions to competing laws when sufficiently atypical observations accumulate. The resulting picture is that of a statistical mechanics on the space of computable dynamical models, connecting universal induction, algorithmic information theory, and equilibrium statistical mechanics within an observer-centered theory of dynamical inference.

•Jul 24, 2026•0 citations

Four-dimensional understanding of quantum mechanics and Bell violation

Jarek Duda

While our natural intuition suggests us that we live in 3D space evolving in time, modern physics presents fundamentally different picture: 4D spacetime, Einstein's block universe, in which we travel in thermodynamically emphasized direction: arrow of time. Arguments for such nonintuitive and nonlocal living in kind of "4D jello" come among others from: Lagrangian mechanics we use from QFT to GR saying that history between fixed past and future situation is the one optimizing action, special relativity saying that different velocity observers have different own time directions, general relativity deforming shape of the entire spacetime up to switching time and space below the black hole event horizon, or the CPT theorem concluding fundamental symmetry between past and future for example in the Feynman-Stueckelberg interpretation of antiparticles as propagating back in time. Accepting this nonintuitive living in 4D spacetime: with present moment being in equilibrium between past and future - minimizing tension as action of Lagrangian, leads to crucial surprising differences from intuitive "evolving 3D" picture - allowing to conclude Bell inequalities, violated by the real physics. Specifically, particle in spacetime becomes own trajectory: 1D submanifold of 4D, making that statistical physics should consider ensembles like Boltzmann distribution among entire paths (like in Ising model), what leads to quantum behavior as we know from Feynman's Euclidean path integrals or similar Maximal Entropy Random Walk (MERW).

arXiv:0910.2724•Oct 14, 2009•7 citations

Reconstruction of Quantum Field Theory as Extension of Wave Mechanics

Manfred Buth

The task to be carried out should be clear from the title. One motivation for this endeavour is coming from the fact that the usual version of quantum field theory is not acceptable. In the paper, above all, three intentions are pursued (a) an adequate consideration of the interaction (b) a proof that the means of classical field theory are sufficient (c) a new attempt to describe particles by stable wave packets.

•Oct 1, 2014•0 citations
For the whole Universe QFT is a Feynman ensemble of histories evolving unitarily - so could we focus on one history of a classical field, fixed at both ends, with QFT as its statistics? Tested here on solvable models: positive ensembles of classical histories give two-point functions and Born densities, fail at the interaction vertex, and what works is a pair of past and future histories.
We show that QFT (as well as QM) is not a complete physical theory. We constructed a classical statistical model inducing quantum field averages. The phase space consists of square integrable functions, f(ϕ),f(ϕ),f(ϕ), of the classical bosonic field, ϕ(x).ϕ(x).ϕ(x). We call our model prequantum classical statistical field-functional theory -- PCSFFT. The correspondence between classical averages given by PCSFFT and quantum field averages given by QFT is asymptotic. The QFT-average gives the main term in the expansion of the PCSFFT-average with respect to the small parameter ααα -- dispersion of fluctuations of "vacuum field functionals.'' The Scrödinger equation of QFT is obtained as the Hamilton equation for functionals, F(f),F(f),F(f), of classical field functions, f(ϕ).f(ϕ).f(ϕ). The main experimental prediction of PCSFFT is that QFT gives only approximative statistical predictions that might be violated in future experiments.
There are significant problems involved in determining the ontology of quantum field theory (QFT). An ontology involving particles seems to be ruled out due to the problem of defining localized position operators, issues involving interactions in QFT, and, perhaps, the appearance of unitarily inequivalent representations. While this might imply that fields are the most natural ontology for QFT, the wavefunctional interpretation of QFT has significant drawbacks. A modified field ontology is examined where determinables are assigned to open bounded regions of spacetime instead of spacetime points.
For classical field theories with probabilistic initial conditions the classical field observables are an idealization. Their arbitrarily precise values poorly reflect the characteristic uncertainty in the presence of substantial fluctuations. We propose to employ observables based on fluctuating fields. In terms of these "statistical observables" the probabilistic classical field theory becomes a quantum field theory. Non-commuting operators are associated to observables. The quantum rules follow from the laws for classical probabilities. The ``quantum'' is part of the ``classical''. A regularized functional integral guarantees the unitarity of the quantum field theory. We discuss in detail the classical relativistic Klein-Gordon equation with interactions.
We consider an embedded observer with no prior knowledge of the existence or nature of the dynamical process generating her observations and ask how such an observer should infer the underlying dynamics from a finite observational history. Rather than taking fixed dynamical laws as the starting point and observations as their consequence, we begin with observations and ask how stable effective laws emerge from them. To this end, we develop an inferential framework in which dynamical laws are treated as statistical objects. The observer, modeled as a quantum reference frame interacting with an environment, explains past observations and predicts future observations by averaging over an ensemble of computable dynamical models, each represented by a CPTP map. We show that the posterior distribution over dynamical models assumes a Gibbs-Boltzmann form in which the minimum description length (MDL) plays the role of an effective energy. The posterior arises as the minimizer of a variational free-MDL functional balancing algorithmic simplicity against epistemic entropy. Sequential updating statistically tends to reinforce compressible regularities, thereby stabilizing the corresponding effective dynamical laws. These emerge as the optimal explanatory and predictive structures for past and future observations, respectively. The results suggest that the lawfulness experienced by embedded observers is a statistical property of rational inference and can arise and persist without fundamental laws. Effective laws emerge and remain stable under typical continuations of the observational history while still allowing, in principle, transitions to competing laws when sufficiently atypical observations accumulate. The resulting picture is that of a statistical mechanics on the space of computable dynamical models, connecting universal induction, algorithmic information theory, and equilibrium statistical mechanics within an observer-centered theory of dynamical inference.
While our natural intuition suggests us that we live in 3D space evolving in time, modern physics presents fundamentally different picture: 4D spacetime, Einstein's block universe, in which we travel in thermodynamically emphasized direction: arrow of time. Arguments for such nonintuitive and nonlocal living in kind of "4D jello" come among others from: Lagrangian mechanics we use from QFT to GR saying that history between fixed past and future situation is the one optimizing action, special relativity saying that different velocity observers have different own time directions, general relativity deforming shape of the entire spacetime up to switching time and space below the black hole event horizon, or the CPT theorem concluding fundamental symmetry between past and future for example in the Feynman-Stueckelberg interpretation of antiparticles as propagating back in time. Accepting this nonintuitive living in 4D spacetime: with present moment being in equilibrium between past and future - minimizing tension as action of Lagrangian, leads to crucial surprising differences from intuitive "evolving 3D" picture - allowing to conclude Bell inequalities, violated by the real physics. Specifically, particle in spacetime becomes own trajectory: 1D submanifold of 4D, making that statistical physics should consider ensembles like Boltzmann distribution among entire paths (like in Ising model), what leads to quantum behavior as we know from Feynman's Euclidean path integrals or similar Maximal Entropy Random Walk (MERW).