Local topological markers computed from the band-flattened one-particle density matrix (OPDM) have been proposed as diagnostics of interacting topological phases, with the statement that an open OPDM gap suffices; their authors noted that a failure would need a gapped-OPDM state that cannot be joined to a Gaussian state without closing the gap, and did not know such a state. We construct such states. One layer of commuting, on-site, charge-conserving gates, each coupling an orbital to an ancilla pair holding one fermion, maps the OPDM ρ of any state to λ²ρ + (1 − λ²) diag ρ on the original orbitals, with λ the cosine of the gate angle, at constant many-body spectrum and Hall conductance. At full dephasing, for an integer mean charge on every site, the dressed state has the two-point functions of an on-site product state, so two gapped ground states with the same gapped, on-site OPDM can have Hall conductances e²/h and 0. For translation-invariant two-band insulators the marker drops to zero at an exact threshold; certified witnesses in the Qi–Wu–Zhang model and, with the time-reversal-symmetric version of the dressing, in the Kitaev chain have OPDM gaps above 0.33 and 0.13 and markers 0 inside nontrivial phases. The dressed Hamiltonians are free models rotated by an on-site unitary, strongly interacting only in the bare-fermion basis; the bare-fermion OPDM is not covariant under such unitaries. Statements restricted to weak interactions, or to states joined to a Gaussian state within their phase, are not contradicted.
While topology is a property of a quantum state itself, most existing methods for characterizing the topology of interacting phases of matter require direct knowledge of the underlying Hamiltonian. We offer an alternative by utilizing the one-particle density matrix formalism to extend the concept of the Chern, chiral, and Chern-Simons markers to include interactions. The one-particle density matrix of a free-fermion state is a projector onto the occupied bands, defining a Brillouin zone bundle of the given topological class. This is no longer the case in the interacting limit, but as long as the one-particle density matrix is gapped, its spectrum can be adiabatically flattened, connecting it to a topologically equivalent projector. The corresponding topological markers thus characterize the topology of the interacting phase. Importantly, the one-particle density matrix is defined in terms of a given state alone, making the local markers numerically favorable, and providing a valuable tool for characterizing topology of interacting systems when only the state itself is available. To demonstrate the practical use of the markers we use the chiral marker to identify the topology of midspectrum eigenstates of the Ising-Majorana chain across the transition between the ergodic and many-body localized phases. We also apply the chiral marker to random states with a known topology, and compare it with the entanglement spectrum degeneracy. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Windings of the zero-frequency single-particle Green's function are widely used to diagnose interacting topological phases of one-dimensional fermion chains. Such windings are known to change through Green's-function zeros, or under a change of the Hamiltonian, without a phase transition. We show that the winding of the elementary fermion field is not constant on a gapped symmetric phase even modulo the interacting classification, and even when both states compared have zero-free Green's functions. An exact identity moves a finite-depth circuit of symmetric gates from the field onto the state and the Hamiltonian, so dressing the field is the same as moving the state within its phase at constant many-body spectrum. With such dressings the winding changes by one in the trivial phase of a Majorana chain of class BDI, takes every value modulo eight in the trivial phase of the Fidkowski–Kitaev eight-chain model, and goes from minus one to minus two inside the Kitaev phase, so that even its parity, the Green's-function form of the class-D index, is not a phase label. In the phase of the fully dimerized spinful Peierls–Hubbard chain of Manmana and co-workers it changes by two, also with bond inversion kept. Every path between such endpoints crosses a Green's-function zero, here at constant spectrum, so invariance along zero-free gapped paths is untouched. We also prove sufficient conditions for invariance: Gaussian dressings of any state, finite-component dressings of cluster product states, and Clifford monomial dressings of stabilizer states, the last two modulo eight. A computed winding therefore cannot by itself certify an interacting phase.
Local topological markers provide a real-space characterization of topological phases and are suited to noncrystalline models. We derive a local topological marker, the Chern-Simons descendant marker, for characterizing the topology of two-dimensional time-reversal-invariant near-Gaussian states from the one-particle density matrix
ρ. We construct an auxiliary three-dimensional state characterized by the local Chern-Simons marker, and use dimensional reduction to obtain the Chern-Simons descendant marker for the original two-dimensional state. This derivation introduces a local Hermitian involution
S that is odd under time reversal. When
[S,ρ]=0, the local Chern-Simons descendant marker reduces to half the difference of the local Chern markers in the
S=±1 sectors. Constructing an
S that commutes exactly with
ρ generally requires fine-tuning, but this is not needed---the local Chern-Simon marker remains well defined whenever
Γ={ρ,S}−S has a spectral gap around zero, even when
[S,ρ]=0. This leaves the practical problem of identifying a suitable
S for a given state, which, importantly, is straightforward even when spin is not a candidate. We show this by considering both strong Rashba and Dresselhaus spin-orbit coupling, for which knowledge of the physical origin of the state reduces the general problem of choosing
S to a one-parameter family
S(θ). We evaluate the optimal angle
θ maximizing the spectral gap of
Γ analytically assuming translation invariance, and find that the gap of
Γ remains open for a broad range of angles around the optimum. The same value of
θ remains valid in disordered systems, providing an easy way to obtain choice of
S for evaluating the local Chern-Simons descendant marker of the state.
Strong interactions can give rise to new fermionic symmetry protected topological phases which have no analogs in free fermion systems. As an example, we have systematically studied a spinless fermion model with U(1) charge conservation and time reversal symmetry on a three-leg ladder using density-matrix renormalization group. In the non-interacting limit, there are no topological phases. Turning on interactions, we found two gapped phases. One is trivial and is adiabatically connected to a band insulator, while another one is a nontrivial symmetry protected topological phase resulting from strong interactions.
Recently, a quantum anomalous Hall state at odd-integer filling in moir\'e stacked
MoTe2/WSe2 was convincingly interpreted as a topological Mott insulator state appearing due to strong interactions in band basis [P. Mai, J. Zhao, B. E. Feldman, and P. W. Phillips, Nat. Commun. 14, 5999 (2023)]. In this work, we aim to analyze the formation of a topological Mott insulator due to interactions in orbital basis instead, being more natural for systems where interactions originate from the character of
f or
d orbitals rather than band flatness. For that reason, we study an odd-integer filled Anderson lattice model incorporating odd-parity hybridization between orbitals with different degrees of correlations introduced in the Hatsugai-Kohmoto spirit. We demonstrate that a topological Mott insulating state can be realized in a considered model only when weak intra- and interorbital correlations involving dispersive states are taken into account. Interestingly, we find that all topological transitions between trivial and topological Mott insulating phases are not accompanied by a spectral gap closing, consistent with a phenomenon called first-order topological transition. Instead, they are signaled by a kink developed in spectral function at one of the time reversal invariant momenta. We believe that our approach can provide insightful phenomenology of topological Mott insulators in spin-orbit coupled
f or
d electron systems.
We compare three complementary diagnostics for mixed Gaussian states at nonzero temperature, focusing on the Su-Schrieffer-Heeger (SSH) chain and its inversion-symmetric extension. While the ensemble geometric phase, a mixed-state generalization of the Zak phase, remains well defined at nonzero temperature, the modulus of the corresponding expectation value vanishes in the thermodynamic limit, limiting its practical use. To develop diagnostics suitable for large systems, we introduce local twist operators acting on neighboring sites, whose expectation values provide local indicators of the underlying topological phase. The topological phase is identified from the relative magnitude of these expectation values, which only requires measuring two local expectation values at nonzero temperature, together with one additional nonlocal expectation value when next-nearest-neighbor hopping is included. In addition, we generalize the local chiral marker to mixed Gaussian states, fully determined by its single-particle correlation matrix, with a nonzero purity gap in their effective single-particle Hamiltonian. The presence of a purity gap ensures that the correlation matrix can be flattened to an effective projector. Evaluating the chiral marker with respect to the band-flattened correlation matrix yields a real-space topological invariant that coincides with the winding number in the zero-temperature limit. The ensemble geometric phase, the local twist operators, and the local chiral marker provide complementary methods to characterize topology in the SSH chain beyond pure states.