Ontological Constraints on Epistemic Syntax: How Informationally-Constrained Access to Reality Shaped the Axiomatic Structure of Quantum, Relativistic, and Gravitational Theories
Three physical properties of any measurement probe $\pi$ in a substrate $\mathcal{G}$ --- non-zero energy cost (A1: $E_\pi > 0$), finite propagation speed (A2: $v_\pi \leq c$), and constitutive excitation (A3: $\pi \in \mathcal{G}$) --- tightly constrain the axiomatic structures of quantum mechanics, relativity, and quantum field theory. A1 $\wedge$ A3 tightly constrains non-commutativity and the Born rule; A2 entails Lorentz invariance and microcausality; their conjunction yields the Wightman axioms and CPT. A3 enriches both registers: complexification in $\mathcal{D}_\mathrm{QM}$ and curvature in $\mathcal{D}_\mathrm{GR}$. Each major step is grounded in a published theorem (Ignatowski, Gleason, Jost, Malament, Jacobson). The linearity of quantum mechanics is identified as a screening artefact of the Hilbert-space habitat. A classification criterion for the mass gap --- nonlinearity plus non-trivial homotopy --- is consistent with all six known test cases (consistency checks, not blind predictions).
Three physical properties of any measurement probe π in a substrate G --- non-zero energy cost (A1: Eπ>0), finite propagation speed (A2: vπ≤c), and constitutive excitation (A3: π∈G) --- tightly constrain the axiomatic structures of quantum mechanics, relativity, and quantum field theory. A1 ∧ A3 tightly constrains non-commutativity and the Born rule; A2 entails Lorentz invariance and microcausality; their conjunction yields the Wightman axioms and CPT. A3 enriches both registers: complexification in DQM and curvature in DGR. Each major step is grounded in a published theorem (Ignatowski, Gleason, Jost, Malament, Jacobson). The linearity of quantum mechanics is identified as a screening artefact of the Hilbert-space habitat. A classification criterion for the mass gap --- nonlinearity plus non-trivial homotopy --- is consistent with all six known test cases (consistency checks, not blind predictions).
We demonstrate that nine foundational puzzles of quantum mechanics — superposition, the Born rule, state reduction, decoherence, entropy, entanglement, the arrow of time, the black-hole information paradox, and the Unruh effect — are not independent problems requiring separate solutions but nine facets of a single structural limitation: the inability of the linear Hilbert-space habitat H to express the nonlinear, non-separable dynamics of the generative substrate G. The argument rests on the axiomatic closure of the descriptive interface D established in the companion articles [20, 22]: the informational axioms that define DQM as a coherent syntax force its linearity as a theorem, and this linearity constitutively screens all nonlinear content arriving through the coarse-graining map Π:G→D. We formalize four structural properties of Π (non-injective, non-surjective, non-linear, non-factorizing) and show that each property generates a specific subset of the nine phenomena. Crucially, the screening is not a binary on/off filter: quantitative results from the Emergence Programme [25, 26] reveal an *anatomy of screening* resolved by isospin channel, Dirac bilinear structure of the insertion operator, and proper-time depth τ, with deficit magnitudes ranging from <2% (mass, Class A) to 100% (isoscalar magnetic quark form factor, Class D). The Gisin-Polchinski no-signaling constraint, which appears to forbid any ontological nonlinearity, is dissolved as a category error: it prohibits nonlinearity at D, not at G. The spectral invariants of G (including the mass gap) propagate faithfully through Π as global properties of the coarse-graining equivalence classes.
We present the Quantum Reality Framework (QRF), a minimal ontological interpretation of quantum mechanics and special relativity constructed from a single primitive concept: structural openness with actualization disposition and tendency (Seinspunkt). From this primitive and three axioms, we formally derive the Born rule (via Gleason 1957), the Lorentz metric (via Malament 1977), the Standard Model gauge group U(1)×SU(2)×SU(3) and its Z6 quotient structure (via Hopf fibration hierarchy and Hurwitz 1898), a fine structure constant candidate 1/(14π²) agreeing to 99.17% with measurement, a fermion mass scheme from G2 Fano topology, and a cosmological constant consistent with observation via the Sorkin mechanism on causal sets. QRF solves the quantum measurement problem without additional postulates: it requires neither a block universe, nor Many Worlds branching, nor a pilot wave, nor instrumentalist agnosticism. Non-locality, interference, entanglement, tunneling, and spin all receive structural derivations within the framework. A master equation iħ·∂_W A = [H_matter + H_gravity, A] unifies quantum mechanics and general relativity with both as limiting cases. This paper serves two explicit goals, both of which we regard as achieved: (1) demonstrating that a coherent fifth interpretation of quantum mechanics exists beyond the four established paradigms; and (2) demonstrating that substantive quasi-academic research is feasible within a sustained human-AI collaboration. Both goals are addressed explicitly in the text.Six falsifiable experimental predictions are formulated. The most urgent is the qubit/qutrit decoherence ratio 3/5 across two distinct qubit architectures. The most novel is a quadratic Lorentz invariance violation δv/v ~ -(E/E_Planck)²/6, testable with the Cherenkov Telescope Array.
In contemporary physics, fundamental structures such as space, time, matter, spin, and measurement are typically introduced as independent primitives or axiomatic ingredients. While quantum mechanics and relativistic field theories describe these structures with extraordinary precision, they do not explain why such structures exist, why they are discrete or stable, nor why reality manifests in exactly three spatial dimensions with an irreversible arrow of time. This work presents a unified informational–geometric framework—the Universal Gravito–Informational Theory (TGIU)—in which physical reality emerges from a pre-geometric informational substrate governed by two complementary gradients: informational coherence (Φ) and informational entropy (S). Their interaction is regulated by a real-valued dynamical mechanism composed of the Curvature–State Transform (CST) and the TGIU Equilibrium Force (TEF). Together, these operators generate bounded, orthogonal informational rotations whose stabilized projections give rise to geometry, matter, and observable physical laws. Within this framework, electron orbitals are reinterpreted as CST limit cycles, spin emerges as the topological orientation of these cycles, and the Pauli exclusion principle arises from phase–space saturation rather than postulated antisymmetry. Atomic stability, the absence of radiative decay in stationary states, fine structure, and the Lamb shift are shown to follow from TEF anisotropy and vacuum curvature granularity, while remaining fully consistent with quantum electrodynamics in its predictive domain. Measurement and wavefunction collapse are described as local TEF locking events, providing a deterministic but non-restorative mechanism for outcome selection without invoking fundamental randomness. Time itself is shown to emerge as monotonic CST phase accumulation, explaining both its one-dimensional nature and its irreversibility as geometric consequences of bounded informational curvature. The existence of exactly three spatial dimensions follows from a CST dimensional closure condition, identifying three dimensions as the only geometry capable of sustaining stable, non-divergent informational rotation. Importantly, TGIU does not replace quantum mechanics, general relativity, or field theory. Instead, it supplies a deeper explanatory layer that clarifies why these frameworks work, why their structures are constrained as observed, and why no physical process can reach absolute annihilation or infinite divergence. Extremes are not restored but redirected: identity is not conserved, yet nature persists through renewed coherence. This work positions TGIU as an empirically motivated, geometrically grounded extension of modern physics—one that unifies matter, time, measurement, and dimensionality under a single informational principle, while remaining compatible with established theories in their respective limits.
This doctoral dissertation on the foundations of quantum theory isolates and formalizes physical knowability constraints, understood here as constraints on what any conceivable observer can know about the physical world; I henceforth call these “epistemic constraints” for terseness. Here, epistemic constraints concern the definite, intersubjectively agreeable, ordinary-language conditions under which experiments are described. The usual formulation of the quantum measurement problem, which I call the Schrodingerian measurement problem, has the structure of an anomaly: if we take quantum theory at face value, we expect no definite values, and yet we see definite values in experiments. The responses to this problem have been either to solve it or to dissolve it. These responses, which have taken the form of interpretation, modification, or reconstruction of quantum mechanics, seek either to derive (conceptually or mathematically) epistemic constraints from within quantum mechanics or suitable modifications of it, as is the case with certain interpretations and modifications, or to posit the epistemic constraint, or parts of it, as a primitive assumption with the goal of deriving quantum mechanics, as is the case in some reconstruction programs. In contrast to the Schrodingerian measurement problem, which had the structure of an anomaly, this dissertation develops the Bohrian Program, which (for lack of a better comparison) has a structure similar to the problem historically associated with Euclid’s fifth postulate. It seeks to keep epistemic constraints as primitive in an onto-epistemic sense. It then seeks new physical conclusions from the joint consideration of quantum mechanics and epistemic constraints, without seeking to derive one from the other. Among other results, this leads to a notion of the probability of instantiability of the Born Rule that specifies when to apply the Born Rule and when to apply a unitary transformation to a quantum state.
Logic Realism Theory (LRT) derives non-relativistic quantum mechanics from the claim that the Three Fundamental Laws of Logic are ontological constraints constitutive of physical distinguishability. This paper extends LRT to quantum field theory through a tiered derivation structure with explicit physical inputs at each level. We establish three principal results: (1) Fock space structure is derived from LRT axioms plus Lorentz invariance and locality; (2) the spin-statistics connection follows from Lorentz invariance and microcausality via the standard Pauli argument; (3) the uniqueness of complex QFT is established. The paper distinguishes derivations from interpretations. Cluster decomposition, vacuum uniqueness, and the spectral gap are physical inputs (Tier 4), not consequences of logical constraints. Renormalization is interpreted as 3FLL-restoration at UV scales, but this does not derive renormalization group equations. Four predictions and six strong falsifiers are identified.
This doctoral dissertation on the foundations of quantum theory isolates and formalizes physical knowability constraints, understood here as constraints on what any conceivable observer can know about the physical world; I henceforth call these “epistemic constraints” for terseness. Here, epistemic constraints concern the definite, intersubjectively agreeable, ordinary-language conditions under which experiments are described. The usual formulation of the quantum measurement problem, which I call the Schrodingerian measurement problem, has the structure of an anomaly: if we take quantum theory at face value, we expect no definite values, and yet we see definite values in experiments. The responses to this problem have been either to solve it or to dissolve it. These responses, which have taken the form of interpretation, modification, or reconstruction of quantum mechanics, seek either to derive (conceptually or mathematically) epistemic constraints from within quantum mechanics or suitable modifications of it, as is the case with certain interpretations and modifications, or to posit the epistemic constraint, or parts of it, as a primitive assumption with the goal of deriving quantum mechanics, as is the case in some reconstruction programs. In contrast to the Schrodingerian measurement problem, which had the structure of an anomaly, this dissertation develops the Bohrian Program, which (for lack of a better comparison) has a structure similar to the problem historically associated with Euclid’s fifth postulate. It seeks to keep epistemic constraints as primitive in an onto-epistemic sense. It then seeks new physical conclusions from the joint consideration of quantum mechanics and epistemic constraints, without seeking to derive one from the other. Among other results, this leads to a notion of the probability of instantiability of the Born Rule that specifies when to apply the Born Rule and when to apply a unitary transformation to a quantum state.