Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Entropy Attunement Protocol: QOdata72 Validation and Honest Dimensionality Assessment

Roger Yau

Published Nov 6, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Technical report, originally published April 2026 (v2.1); this is v1.1 of that report, corrected October 2026. We report validation results from applying the Entropy Attunement Protocol (EAP) framework to the complete QOdata72 dataset — 72 question order studies comprising 53,078 participants — provided directly by Prof. Jerome Busemeyer from the Wang & Busemeyer (2014) PNAS article. The quantum model's core prediction (QQ equality) is not rejected across the 72 studies (p = 0.80, bootstrap 95% CI contains zero). We also report an honest finding: when the four-dimensional Ψ composite is applied to static question order data, the effective dimensionality reduces to three independent information sources — base rate probability, joint distribution shape, and interference phase — because Ψ1 and Ψ2 both derive deterministically from the marginal probability. Ψ3 alone is genuinely independent (R² = 0.03 from all other quantities combined). We document the Ψ4 redefinition from |sin(θ)·cos(φ)| to |φ|/(π/2). No raw QOdata72 data is redistributed; only derived aggregate statistics are reported. v1.1 corrections: removed an unsupported reference to unposted RNN/architecture-comparison results; the cited "Yau 2026b" manuscript is marked unpublished; QQ-equality wording changed from "confirmed" to "not rejected / equivalence supported".

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24020523

Related papers

Insight137 Research: Quantum Cognition, Entropy Measurement, and AI Safety

Roger Yau

Research from Insight137 applying peer-reviewed quantum cognition mathematics (Busemeyer & Bruza, 2012) to behavioral prediction and AI safety measurement. This project contains: (1) the Entropy Attunement Protocol (EAP) — a substrate-independent framework for measuring cognitive systems through four-dimensional entropy profiling without consciousness attribution; (2) an entropy measurement framework for detecting, classifying, and temporally locating self-preservation behaviors in AI systems; (3) QOdata72 validation — testing the quantum model's QQ equality prediction across 72 studies (53,078 participants) from Busemeyer's original dataset (not rejected, p = 0.80), with honest dimensionality assessment revealing 3 independent information sources; and (4) Entropy Signatures — a quantum-like entropy framework for behavioral transitions, evaluated across 82,932 samples in human survey, AI agent, and keystroke-biometric domains. All build on established science including quantum probability theory, the Free Energy Principle (Friston), Prospect Theory (Kahneman & Tversky), and observational entropy (Aguirre et al.). Reference implementation: https://github.com/Insight137/insight137-eap Archived corrected editions (v1.1, Zenodo, 2026-11-06): - EAP v1.0 Framework — https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24020119 - EAP v2.1 QOdata72 Validation — https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24020523 - Self-Preservation in AI Systems — https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24022713 - Entropy Signatures of Behavioral Transitions — https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24023389 Individual papers are licensed CC BY-NC-ND 4.0; see each file’s title page and Zenodo record.

•Mar 9, 2026•0 citations

Entropy Signatures of Behavioral Transitions: A Quantum-Like Framework for Human and AI Decision Analysis

Roger Yau

Preprint, originally published April 2026; this is v1.1, corrected October 2026. We present an entropy-based behavioral measurement framework integrating quantum-like Bayesian network interference (Moreira & Wichert, 2016), Deng entropy (Deng, 2016), and belief-entropy interference measurement (Huang et al., 2019) into a four-dimensional entropy profiling system (Ψ). We evaluate this framework across 82,932 samples spanning four domains: human survey decisions (53,078 participants across 72 studies), AI agent shutdown avoidance (2,200 transcripts across 11 models), AI agent complex sabotage (7,254 transcripts), and keystroke biometrics (20,400 samples). Key findings: (1) the Huang interference method reduces prediction error by 49% versus static quantum approaches on Prisoner's Dilemma data (avg error 0.061 vs 0.119), with paper-verified mathematical consistency (Db = −0.9421 matching the published −0.9420); (2) applied to AI safety, the framework detects behavioral mode transitions with Cohen's h = 1.986 (comply-to-bypass) and produces large effect sizes across three Ψ dimensions (Ψ₁ d = 1.182, Ψ₂ d = 0.806, Ψ₃ d = 1.024); (3) five distinct behavioral archetypes emerge across AI models, with no single detection method covering all types; (4) a four-phase temporal model (持樞, chí shū) identifies intervention windows averaging 6.8 steps before transition consolidation, evaluated on Palisade transcripts (25 seeds; Fisher p < 0.0001, Cohen's h = 1.611), with SHADE-Arena and CMU keystroke data serving as scope checks; (5) dimensional independence is domain-specific (Ψ₁–Ψ₂ r = −0.59 in human surveys, r = 0.014 in AI behavioral data). No raw third-party data is redistributed. v1.1 corrections (six items, listed in the erratum section of the PDF): QOdata72 participant count corrected to 53,078; total sample count corrected to 82,932 (previously double-counted); the "75,600 samples in three domains" phrase withdrawn; o3/o1-preview bypass rates relabelled as pooled classification over the released subset; the |D_b| > 0.48 subgroup labelled exploratory with a post-hoc threshold; "Ψ₂ as automatic model selector" restated as a hypothesis for a pre-registered test.

•Nov 6, 2026•0 citations

Causally Isolated Reproducible Collective Burst Modes on 156 Qubits: Experimental Results of the Decentralized Per-Qubit QITE Lambda Field on IBM Heron R2 — Multi-Shock and Random-Angle Null Control Demonstration with 300 Cycles Establishing Feedback Necessity (10 vs 0 Bursts, p<0.01)

Bernd Westrick

On 4-5 July 2026, an identical shock protocol was executed on the same 156-qubit IBM Heron R2 architecture (ibm_fez) but with the QITE lambda feedback replaced by uniformly random rotation angles per cycle. This random-angle null control preserves every structural variable — RY+RZ+CZ layer, Heavy-Hex CZ coupling, 4096 shots/cycle, seed 20260602, the same 150 cycles, and the same six shocks at the same cycles (20/40/60/80/100/120), the same target qubits (q78, q69, q67, q47, q37, q16) with the same amplitudes (l1,l2) — while removing only the decentralized per-qubit lambda feedback dynamics. Backend selection was driven by queue availability; both are 156-qubit Heron R2 devices with identical architecture, and calibration differences cannot account for the qualitative burst-count contrast reported below. The result is a clean negative: zero collective bursts across all six shocks. The four non-parametric statistical tests (identical methodology to v1) all confirm the absence of shock-driven collective response: (1) permutation test yields p = 1.0 for shock alignment against the noise-saturated per-cycle transitions; (2) pairwise Pearson correlation between per-transition delta-p1 vectors drops from r_mean = +0.65 in the multi-shock run to r_mean = +0.017 in the null; (3) cross-session hypergeometric overlap between null "top-active" qubits and the v1 multi-shock top-active set is not significant (Jaccard = 0.11, p = 0.24); (4) Mann-Whitney U on shock-cycle max|delta p1| versus baseline shows ratio 0.989 with p = 0.89 — statistically indistinguishable from noise. Baseline global coherence exp(-8*Var(p1)) sits at 0.413 +/- 0.022 across all 150 cycles under random angles, versus 0.99 +/- 0.01 under QITE feedback in v1 — two distinct dynamical regimes. That the shock protocol itself executed correctly on the null run is verified locally at the target qubit: for each of the six shocks, the measured p1[q_target] at the shock cycle agrees with the theoretical prediction from theta_shock = 2*atan2(l2, l1) to within <5% (q78 shock: predicted 0.016, measured 0.018; q69 shock: predicted 0.985, measured 0.939; and so on for all six). One cycle after each shock, the target qubit returns to the random baseline distribution — with no feedback dynamics, there is no restoring trajectory. The shocks are physically executed; what is absent is the collective response. Causal conclusion: the QITE per-qubit lambda feedback dynamics are necessary for the observed collective burst phenomenology. The circuit structure (RY+RZ+CZ on Heron R2 Heavy-Hex topology) and shock protocol alone do not produce bursts. Six identical shocks on QITE-stabilized baseline produce 10 collective bursts with 6/10 shock-aligned (p = 0.008); the same six shocks on random baseline produce zero. This 10-vs-0 hardware contrast, verified by four independent non-parametric tests, establishes feedback necessity as a falsifiable causal claim rather than a phenomenological observation. The v2 bundle contains the complete null-control primary data (150-cycle JSONL, consolidated JSON, p1 numpy matrix), all IBM Runtime job IDs with per-cycle timestamps, Tee'd console logs of both the initial run and the resume run (a mid-run job-poll stall on 4 July required a resume from cycle 7 with deterministic per-cycle RNG seeds), five analysis figures including direct null-vs-multi comparison plots, the full side-by-side statistical comparison JSON, the v1 multi-shock p1 matrix and statistical test outputs for reanalysis, an 8-page supplement PDF (Section 5) integrating with the v1 paper, and SHA-256 checksums of every file in MANIFEST_v2.json. Backend (v2 null control): IBM Heron R2 (ibm_fez), 156 qubits, 4096 shots/cycle.Companion patents: DPMA Az. 10 2025 003 906.9 (QITE), 10 2025 004 891.2 (QISE).Predecessor (v1): Westrick, Reproducible Collective Burst Modes on 156 Qubits: Decentralized Per-Qubit QITE Lambda Field on IBM Heron R2, 1 June 2026. On 1 June 2026, a decentralized per-qubit lambda field was implemented on the IBM Heron R2 processor (ibm_kingston, 156 qubits) and probed with a multi-shock excitation protocol. Unlike the predecessor work (Westrick, Controllable Quantum Collective States on 156 Qubits: Experimental Results of the QITE Formalism on IBM Heron R2, 12 April 2026), which tested a globally controlled QITE quantum collective, each qubit here carries its own lambda state and receives, in the feedback loop, only its own measurement statistic p1_i. The only inter-qubit coupling propagates physically through the CZ gates of the Heavy-Hex topology. Six shocks were applied at six different positions on the chip: central (q*=78), nearest neighbor (d=1), intermediate (d=3, d=5), deep (d=8), and edge (d=12). Each individual shock triggered a chip-wide burst within 1-8 cycles (peak |delta p1| between 0.308 and 0.366; 10 to 22 simultaneously active qubits). Four additional spontaneous bursts were detected between shocks, for a total of 10 bursts in 150 cycles. The 6/6 reproducibility was verified by four independent non-parametric statistical tests, all positive: (1) permutation test p = 0.008 against chance alignment; (2) pairwise burst-vector Pearson correlation r_mean = +0.65 with all 15 pairs above noise; (3) cross-session reproducibility 9/10 qubit overlap between two independent IBM Quantum sessions, hypergeometric p = 0.008; (4) Mann-Whitney U test of burst amplitude versus Phase-A baseline, ratio 2.7, p < 0.0001. This bundle contains the complete primary data (raw JSON logs, NumPy matrices), all 27 visualizations, IBM job IDs of every submitted job, console logs of all runs, the pre-registration documents with locked detection thresholds, and SHA-256 checksums of every file (MANIFEST.json) for independent verification. Backend: IBM Heron R2 (ibm_kingston), 156 qubits, 4096 shots/cycle.Patent filings: DPMA Az. 10 2025 003 906.9 (QITE), 10 2025 004 891.2 (QISE).Predecessor: Westrick, Controllable Quantum Collective States on 156 Qubits, 12 April 2026.

•Jun 30, 2026•0 citations

Works on My QPU: Reproducibility in Quantum Computing Research

Dominik Köster, Maja Franz, Benjamin Zec +3 more

This repository contains all scripts, data, and plotting code to reproduce the experiments and figures presented in the paper: Works on My QPU: Reproducibility in Quantum Computing Research (QCE 2026)

•Jul 24, 2026•0 citations

Modeling combination of question order effect, response replicability effect, and QQ-equality with quantum instruments

Masanao Ozawa, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We continue to analyze basic constraints on the human decision making from the viewpoint of quantum measurement theory (QMT). As it has been found, the conventional QMT based on the projection postulate cannot account for the combination of the question order effect (QOE) and the response replicability effect (RRE). This was an alarming finding for quantum-like modeling of decision making. Recently, it was shown that this difficulty can be resolved by using of the general QMT based on quantum instruments. In the present paper we analyze the problem of the combination of QOE, RRE, and the well-known QQ-equality (QQE). This equality was derived by Busemeyer and Wang, and it was shown (in a joint paper with Solloway and Shiffrin) that statistical data from many social opinion polls satisfy it. Here we construct quantum instruments satisfying QOE, RRE and QQE. The general features of our approach are formalized with postulates that generalize (the Wang–Busemeyer) postulates for quantum-like modeling of decision making. Moreover, we show that our model closely reproduces the statistics of the well-known Clinton–Gore Poll data with a prior belief state independent of the question order. This model successfully corrects for the order effect in the data to determine the “genuine” distribution of the opinions in the Poll. The paper also provides an accessible introduction to the theory of quantum instruments — the most general mathematical framework for quantum measurements.

arXiv:2010.10444•Journal of Mathematical Psychology•Dec 26, 2020•58 citations

Kvantno probabilističko modeliranje u kognitivnoj psihologiji: efekt redoslijeda

Monika Švogor

The order effect is a well-known phenomenon in cognitive psychology which violates specific axioms of the classical probability theory and refers to different probabilities of measurement outcomes (answers to questions) depending on their order. In this research, the order effect was analyzed using quantum probabilistic modeling of cognitive processes. The Quantum Question (QQ) model suggested by Wang and Busemeyer (2013) was tested on a sample of participants that had answered three yes/no questions about a painting, in different orders. For that purpose, three problems were considered. The first problem was to examine the presence of the order effect in participants’ answers and the results showed order effects for all three questions. The second problem was to test data fitness with a model prediction called QQ equality and the data proved to be a good fit to the model. The purpose of the third problem was to examine the dependency of the q value derived from the model on a third question. Given that the QQ equality is a prediction which includes only two yes/no questions, an additional prediction was derived from the model which includes a third question and according to which, the q value is independent of a third question. The results showed a limitation in the model in explaining empirical data. A proposal was made how to expand the theory, so it would include models with three or more questions.

•Sep 18, 2018•0 citations
Technical report, originally published April 2026 (v2.1); this is v1.1 of that report, corrected October 2026. We report validation results from applying the Entropy Attunement Protocol (EAP) framework to the complete QOdata72 dataset — 72 question order studies comprising 53,078 participants — provided directly by Prof. Jerome Busemeyer from the Wang & Busemeyer (2014) PNAS article. The quantum model's core prediction (QQ equality) is not rejected across the 72 studies (p = 0.80, bootstrap 95% CI contains zero). We also report an honest finding: when the four-dimensional Ψ composite is applied to static question order data, the effective dimensionality reduces to three independent information sources — base rate probability, joint distribution shape, and interference phase — because Ψ1 and Ψ2 both derive deterministically from the marginal probability. Ψ3 alone is genuinely independent (R² = 0.03 from all other quantities combined). We document the Ψ4 redefinition from |sin(θ)·cos(φ)| to |φ|/(π/2). No raw QOdata72 data is redistributed; only derived aggregate statistics are reported. v1.1 corrections: removed an unsupported reference to unposted RNN/architecture-comparison results; the cited "Yau 2026b" manuscript is marked unpublished; QQ-equality wording changed from "confirmed" to "not rejected / equivalence supported".
Research from Insight137 applying peer-reviewed quantum cognition mathematics (Busemeyer & Bruza, 2012) to behavioral prediction and AI safety measurement. This project contains: (1) the Entropy Attunement Protocol (EAP) — a substrate-independent framework for measuring cognitive systems through four-dimensional entropy profiling without consciousness attribution; (2) an entropy measurement framework for detecting, classifying, and temporally locating self-preservation behaviors in AI systems; (3) QOdata72 validation — testing the quantum model's QQ equality prediction across 72 studies (53,078 participants) from Busemeyer's original dataset (not rejected, p = 0.80), with honest dimensionality assessment revealing 3 independent information sources; and (4) Entropy Signatures — a quantum-like entropy framework for behavioral transitions, evaluated across 82,932 samples in human survey, AI agent, and keystroke-biometric domains. All build on established science including quantum probability theory, the Free Energy Principle (Friston), Prospect Theory (Kahneman & Tversky), and observational entropy (Aguirre et al.). Reference implementation: https://github.com/Insight137/insight137-eap Archived corrected editions (v1.1, Zenodo, 2026-11-06): - EAP v1.0 Framework — https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24020119 - EAP v2.1 QOdata72 Validation — https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24020523 - Self-Preservation in AI Systems — https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24022713 - Entropy Signatures of Behavioral Transitions — https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24023389 Individual papers are licensed CC BY-NC-ND 4.0; see each file’s title page and Zenodo record.
Preprint, originally published April 2026; this is v1.1, corrected October 2026. We present an entropy-based behavioral measurement framework integrating quantum-like Bayesian network interference (Moreira & Wichert, 2016), Deng entropy (Deng, 2016), and belief-entropy interference measurement (Huang et al., 2019) into a four-dimensional entropy profiling system (Ψ). We evaluate this framework across 82,932 samples spanning four domains: human survey decisions (53,078 participants across 72 studies), AI agent shutdown avoidance (2,200 transcripts across 11 models), AI agent complex sabotage (7,254 transcripts), and keystroke biometrics (20,400 samples). Key findings: (1) the Huang interference method reduces prediction error by 49% versus static quantum approaches on Prisoner's Dilemma data (avg error 0.061 vs 0.119), with paper-verified mathematical consistency (Db = −0.9421 matching the published −0.9420); (2) applied to AI safety, the framework detects behavioral mode transitions with Cohen's h = 1.986 (comply-to-bypass) and produces large effect sizes across three Ψ dimensions (Ψ₁ d = 1.182, Ψ₂ d = 0.806, Ψ₃ d = 1.024); (3) five distinct behavioral archetypes emerge across AI models, with no single detection method covering all types; (4) a four-phase temporal model (持樞, chí shū) identifies intervention windows averaging 6.8 steps before transition consolidation, evaluated on Palisade transcripts (25 seeds; Fisher p < 0.0001, Cohen's h = 1.611), with SHADE-Arena and CMU keystroke data serving as scope checks; (5) dimensional independence is domain-specific (Ψ₁–Ψ₂ r = −0.59 in human surveys, r = 0.014 in AI behavioral data). No raw third-party data is redistributed. v1.1 corrections (six items, listed in the erratum section of the PDF): QOdata72 participant count corrected to 53,078; total sample count corrected to 82,932 (previously double-counted); the "75,600 samples in three domains" phrase withdrawn; o3/o1-preview bypass rates relabelled as pooled classification over the released subset; the |D_b| > 0.48 subgroup labelled exploratory with a post-hoc threshold; "Ψ₂ as automatic model selector" restated as a hypothesis for a pre-registered test.
On 4-5 July 2026, an identical shock protocol was executed on the same 156-qubit IBM Heron R2 architecture (ibm_fez) but with the QITE lambda feedback replaced by uniformly random rotation angles per cycle. This random-angle null control preserves every structural variable — RY+RZ+CZ layer, Heavy-Hex CZ coupling, 4096 shots/cycle, seed 20260602, the same 150 cycles, and the same six shocks at the same cycles (20/40/60/80/100/120), the same target qubits (q78, q69, q67, q47, q37, q16) with the same amplitudes (l1,l2) — while removing only the decentralized per-qubit lambda feedback dynamics. Backend selection was driven by queue availability; both are 156-qubit Heron R2 devices with identical architecture, and calibration differences cannot account for the qualitative burst-count contrast reported below. The result is a clean negative: zero collective bursts across all six shocks. The four non-parametric statistical tests (identical methodology to v1) all confirm the absence of shock-driven collective response: (1) permutation test yields p = 1.0 for shock alignment against the noise-saturated per-cycle transitions; (2) pairwise Pearson correlation between per-transition delta-p1 vectors drops from r_mean = +0.65 in the multi-shock run to r_mean = +0.017 in the null; (3) cross-session hypergeometric overlap between null "top-active" qubits and the v1 multi-shock top-active set is not significant (Jaccard = 0.11, p = 0.24); (4) Mann-Whitney U on shock-cycle max|delta p1| versus baseline shows ratio 0.989 with p = 0.89 — statistically indistinguishable from noise. Baseline global coherence exp(-8*Var(p1)) sits at 0.413 +/- 0.022 across all 150 cycles under random angles, versus 0.99 +/- 0.01 under QITE feedback in v1 — two distinct dynamical regimes. That the shock protocol itself executed correctly on the null run is verified locally at the target qubit: for each of the six shocks, the measured p1[q_target] at the shock cycle agrees with the theoretical prediction from theta_shock = 2*atan2(l2, l1) to within <5% (q78 shock: predicted 0.016, measured 0.018; q69 shock: predicted 0.985, measured 0.939; and so on for all six). One cycle after each shock, the target qubit returns to the random baseline distribution — with no feedback dynamics, there is no restoring trajectory. The shocks are physically executed; what is absent is the collective response. Causal conclusion: the QITE per-qubit lambda feedback dynamics are necessary for the observed collective burst phenomenology. The circuit structure (RY+RZ+CZ on Heron R2 Heavy-Hex topology) and shock protocol alone do not produce bursts. Six identical shocks on QITE-stabilized baseline produce 10 collective bursts with 6/10 shock-aligned (p = 0.008); the same six shocks on random baseline produce zero. This 10-vs-0 hardware contrast, verified by four independent non-parametric tests, establishes feedback necessity as a falsifiable causal claim rather than a phenomenological observation. The v2 bundle contains the complete null-control primary data (150-cycle JSONL, consolidated JSON, p1 numpy matrix), all IBM Runtime job IDs with per-cycle timestamps, Tee'd console logs of both the initial run and the resume run (a mid-run job-poll stall on 4 July required a resume from cycle 7 with deterministic per-cycle RNG seeds), five analysis figures including direct null-vs-multi comparison plots, the full side-by-side statistical comparison JSON, the v1 multi-shock p1 matrix and statistical test outputs for reanalysis, an 8-page supplement PDF (Section 5) integrating with the v1 paper, and SHA-256 checksums of every file in MANIFEST_v2.json. Backend (v2 null control): IBM Heron R2 (ibm_fez), 156 qubits, 4096 shots/cycle.Companion patents: DPMA Az. 10 2025 003 906.9 (QITE), 10 2025 004 891.2 (QISE).Predecessor (v1): Westrick, Reproducible Collective Burst Modes on 156 Qubits: Decentralized Per-Qubit QITE Lambda Field on IBM Heron R2, 1 June 2026. On 1 June 2026, a decentralized per-qubit lambda field was implemented on the IBM Heron R2 processor (ibm_kingston, 156 qubits) and probed with a multi-shock excitation protocol. Unlike the predecessor work (Westrick, Controllable Quantum Collective States on 156 Qubits: Experimental Results of the QITE Formalism on IBM Heron R2, 12 April 2026), which tested a globally controlled QITE quantum collective, each qubit here carries its own lambda state and receives, in the feedback loop, only its own measurement statistic p1_i. The only inter-qubit coupling propagates physically through the CZ gates of the Heavy-Hex topology. Six shocks were applied at six different positions on the chip: central (q*=78), nearest neighbor (d=1), intermediate (d=3, d=5), deep (d=8), and edge (d=12). Each individual shock triggered a chip-wide burst within 1-8 cycles (peak |delta p1| between 0.308 and 0.366; 10 to 22 simultaneously active qubits). Four additional spontaneous bursts were detected between shocks, for a total of 10 bursts in 150 cycles. The 6/6 reproducibility was verified by four independent non-parametric statistical tests, all positive: (1) permutation test p = 0.008 against chance alignment; (2) pairwise burst-vector Pearson correlation r_mean = +0.65 with all 15 pairs above noise; (3) cross-session reproducibility 9/10 qubit overlap between two independent IBM Quantum sessions, hypergeometric p = 0.008; (4) Mann-Whitney U test of burst amplitude versus Phase-A baseline, ratio 2.7, p < 0.0001. This bundle contains the complete primary data (raw JSON logs, NumPy matrices), all 27 visualizations, IBM job IDs of every submitted job, console logs of all runs, the pre-registration documents with locked detection thresholds, and SHA-256 checksums of every file (MANIFEST.json) for independent verification. Backend: IBM Heron R2 (ibm_kingston), 156 qubits, 4096 shots/cycle.Patent filings: DPMA Az. 10 2025 003 906.9 (QITE), 10 2025 004 891.2 (QISE).Predecessor: Westrick, Controllable Quantum Collective States on 156 Qubits, 12 April 2026.
We continue to analyze basic constraints on the human decision making from the viewpoint of quantum measurement theory (QMT). As it has been found, the conventional QMT based on the projection postulate cannot account for the combination of the question order effect (QOE) and the response replicability effect (RRE). This was an alarming finding for quantum-like modeling of decision making. Recently, it was shown that this difficulty can be resolved by using of the general QMT based on quantum instruments. In the present paper we analyze the problem of the combination of QOE, RRE, and the well-known QQ-equality (QQE). This equality was derived by Busemeyer and Wang, and it was shown (in a joint paper with Solloway and Shiffrin) that statistical data from many social opinion polls satisfy it. Here we construct quantum instruments satisfying QOE, RRE and QQE. The general features of our approach are formalized with postulates that generalize (the Wang–Busemeyer) postulates for quantum-like modeling of decision making. Moreover, we show that our model closely reproduces the statistics of the well-known Clinton–Gore Poll data with a prior belief state independent of the question order. This model successfully corrects for the order effect in the data to determine the “genuine” distribution of the opinions in the Poll. The paper also provides an accessible introduction to the theory of quantum instruments — the most general mathematical framework for quantum measurements.
The order effect is a well-known phenomenon in cognitive psychology which violates specific axioms of the classical probability theory and refers to different probabilities of measurement outcomes (answers to questions) depending on their order. In this research, the order effect was analyzed using quantum probabilistic modeling of cognitive processes. The Quantum Question (QQ) model suggested by Wang and Busemeyer (2013) was tested on a sample of participants that had answered three yes/no questions about a painting, in different orders. For that purpose, three problems were considered. The first problem was to examine the presence of the order effect in participants’ answers and the results showed order effects for all three questions. The second problem was to test data fitness with a model prediction called QQ equality and the data proved to be a good fit to the model. The purpose of the third problem was to examine the dependency of the q value derived from the model on a third question. Given that the QQ equality is a prediction which includes only two yes/no questions, an additional prediction was derived from the model which includes a third question and according to which, the q value is independent of a third question. The results showed a limitation in the model in explaining empirical data. A proposal was made how to expand the theory, so it would include models with three or more questions.