We measure a cone-correlator correlation-temperature proxy on canon, a stochastic grow ing network whose directed edges carry two tunable channels: local edges (density PRETURN) and wormholes (probability w). On the past cone of a vertex, a massless scalar field in the cone ground state defines, through the Peschel-kernel modular Hamiltonian K, a single scale w0 (T ≡ 1/w0): the Mp shell profile is single-scale with boundary/max = 1.00 in QC-passing runs up to 4338-node cones (N = 8, 12, 16); within a fixed regulator only ratios and exponents are physical. The pre-registered additive law fails on the full two-mass grid (R2 = 0.85–0.93; the unmodeled mass channel dominates); adding the mass channel plus one cross term is decisive by AIC (R2 = 0.969–0.976), still below the pre-registered 0.98 threshold—the full-grid threshold test remains primary, and fixed-mass fits are labeled di agnostics. At N=16: aP = 1.28 ± 0.15, bw = 0.46 ± 0.03, γT = 0.13 ± 0.02 stable across N=12–20. Sharing the same m → 0 divergence, the kernel behind K and w0 define a normalization window (drift ≤ 5.4% per mass decade, consistent with zero). Null controls bound interpretation: wormhole rewiring reproduces the surface within confidence intervals; scrambled cones fit equally smooth power laws with different exponents and no positive interference. Smooth scaling is generic; the discriminative content is the exponent family plus the interference sign.
We measure a cone-correlator correlation-temperature proxy on canon, a stochastic grow ing network whose directed edges carry two tunable channels: local edges (density PRETURN) and wormholes (probability w). On the past cone of a vertex, a massless scalar field in the cone ground state defines, through the Peschel-kernel modular Hamiltonian K, a single scale w0 (T ≡ 1/w0): the Mp shell profile is single-scale with boundary/max = 1.00 in QC-passing runs up to 4338-node cones (N = 8, 12, 16); within a fixed regulator only ratios and exponents are physical. The pre-registered additive law fails on the full two-mass grid (R2 = 0.85–0.93; the unmodeled mass channel dominates); adding the mass channel plus one cross term is decisive by AIC (R2 = 0.969–0.976), still below the pre-registered 0.98 threshold—the full-grid threshold test remains primary, and fixed-mass fits are labeled di agnostics. At N=16: aP = 1.28 ± 0.15, bw = 0.46 ± 0.03, γT = 0.13 ± 0.02 stable across N=12–20. Sharing the same m → 0 divergence, the kernel behind K and w0 define a normalization window (drift ≤ 5.4% per mass decade, consistent with zero). Null controls bound interpretation: wormhole rewiring reproduces the surface within confidence intervals; scrambled cones fit equally smooth power laws with different exponents and no positive interference. Smooth scaling is generic; the discriminative content is the exponent family plus the interference sign.
CORRECTION NOTICE (v5, 2026-09-06). The central result of v1-v4 is WITHDRAWN. This record has not been peer reviewed. Issued 2026-09-06 by the author (v5 of this record). This notice was added to the archived record; the manuscript itself is unaltered. This record has not been peer reviewed. What is wrong The force exponent reported here as alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 is an artifact of the fitting procedure, not a property of the data. The fit was unweighted least squares in linear space applied to a steeply falling profile, which places 95.8 percent of its objective on the single point at the shortest retained separation. Re-fitting the same data with nothing discarded, changing only the error model, gives 2.82 (relative-error weighting) or 2.89 (log-space regression). Across fifteen combinations of standard estimator and fit window the exponent spans 2.53 to 3.92, and the value published here is the largest of them. What the data show instead, and how firmly The retraction is certain. The replacement is not. On the open 24-site chain the same data give alpha = 2.6 +/- 0.2, where the interval is the spread of a plateau in the local logarithmic slope over six consecutive separations, not a statistical error (the bootstrap error on the published fit to the same data is 0.63); the plateau value was reproduced at 2.5921 by a separately written implementation run on the same recorded state (SIM-2026-073). This is a single geometry at a single size. On a 24-site periodic ring, analysed with chord distance as pre-registered, two probes that are both energy-density-like (Delta = 1) give 1.83 and 2.37 against a CFT two-point value of 2 (SIM-2026-074): one size, not converged, disagreeing with each other by 29 percent, and not attributable to a single operator channel. No corrected exponent is established. The exchange channel is an open question. Treat 2.6 +/- 0.2 as the provisional open-chain value, not as a result. Also withdrawn or voided alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 (24 sites) and alpha = 3.97 +/- 0.15 (16 sites, exact) from stress-tensor exchange. Was: headline result and its first corroboration. Now: withdrawn. Why: the same estimator artifact: both move in lockstep under it (3.92 to 2.56, 3.97 to 2.75 on dropping the contact point), because they share one observable, one fit window and one fitting routine. scalar exchange (alpha = 2) excluded. Was: stated as excluded at about 12 sigma. Now: withdrawn. Why: the 12 sigma used the covariance error 0.16; at the bootstrap error 0.63 computed before release the exclusion is about 2.2 sigma, and under any window starting at separation 3 the point estimate itself falls to about 2.56. alpha = 4 is universal; alpha = 4.00 at Ising, tricritical Ising and Potts. Was: confirmed at three classes. Now: withdrawn; the operator towers at all three classes stand. Why: the exponent was measured only at Ising and inherited by the other two; the towers are spectra, not forces. third independent evaluation alpha = 4.07 (chi = 3 MERA), and with it the statement that this was the first holographic force measurement from an optimized tensor network state. Was: supporting evidence and a priority claim. Now: both withdrawn. Why: the profile changes sign inside its own fit window and cannot be a fixed-sign power law; the priority claim rests on that evaluation alone and was never gated against prior work. the discriminating test: stress tensor (Z_j Z_j+1) versus spin primary (X_j). Was: registered killer test. Now: void. Why: at the critical point these are one operator, related by exact Kramers-Wannier self-duality. Measured on the periodic ring: identical expectation values to 1e-15 and identical force profiles to 1e-13 at 14 sites, 2.4e-9 at 24 sites (SIM-2026-074). Open boundaries break the duality, which is why the open-chain run of this test (SIM-2026-073) showed a spurious difference between the two arms. The test compared the energy density to itself. Neither label was correct: Z_j Z_j+1 is the energy density, not the stress tensor; X_j is its dual, not the spin primary. transport time T = (pi/2) l_AdS to 1.2 percent as a geometric prediction. Was: confirmed. Now: measurement stands (T = 2.239 at N = 16); geometric reading not established. Why: l_AdS cancels in the cited derivation, which also gives pi rather than the pi/2 the manuscript compares against; the chi = 3 estimate of l_AdS gives a 57 percent miss; the transport driver never applies a MERA. The true spin primary Z_j was never in the design, and the direct replacement test is blocked: Z_j is odd under the Z2 symmetry, so the energy-difference observable used throughout this work subtracts across symmetry sectors and is undefined for it. A replacement test using two Z2-even probes has been pre-registered (PREREGISTRATION-T.md, committed before its driver) and run; its result is deliberately not part of this correction and will appear in a later version. Not previously reported The published fit has a reduced chi-squared of 6.008 on 9 degrees of freedom, and a bootstrap standard deviation of 0.63 rather than the quoted 0.16. Both were computed before release and omitted. What is unaffected Of the claims in this record: the two-phase optimization method, the chi = 3 criticality threshold, the exact-diagonalization gates, the measured OPE coefficient C_sigma-sigma-epsilon = 0.50 +/- 0.03 against the exact 1/2, and the conformal towers at all three classes. Not part of this record, mentioned only because they are sometimes read together with it: the later C_TTT stress-tensor self-coupling measurements (SIM-2026-067/068/069, dated after this record) and the matched off-critical ring control (SIM-2026-074) are unaffected by this correction and make no claim about the force exponent. How the error was found and what this record contains The error was found by the author's own internal adversarial audit, not by a reviewer; the journal submission it was found after is closed, and no review of this work has taken place. Files in this record: the full re-analysis (SIM-2026-072.json, driver, figure), the pre-registered chain test (SIM-2026-073.json) and ring test (SIM-2026-074.json) with both pre-registrations as committed before the runs, the runnable drivers with their shared module and the negative test suite for their validation gates, and the error register (ERRATA.md). Concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.19660302 always resolves to the current version. The abstract of the original manuscript follows unchanged, for the record. Every claim in it about the force exponent should be read against the correction above. We report results from classical simulation of critical spin chains that establish quantitative physical content in the MERA-AdS correspondence. First, the interaction energy between boundary-primary excitations follows a power law F(dr) ~ dr^(-alpha) with three consistent evaluations yielding alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 (24q), 3.97 +/- 0.15 (16q), and 4.07 +/- 0.18 (16q chi=3 MERA), all consistent with stress-tensor exchange (alpha = 2*Delta_T = 4) and inconsistent with scalar exchange (alpha = 2); the exponent is explained by the Ising CFT fusion rule eps x eps = [1]. Because Delta_T = 2 is fixed by conformal symmetry in every unitary 2D CFT, alpha = 4 is universal: we confirm this at two further fixed points - the tricritical Ising model (c = 7/10), where a scale-invariant MERA recovers the full M(4,5) primary spectrum (Delta_sigma = 0.092, Delta_eps = 0.204, Delta_T = 1.999), and the three-state Potts model (c = 4/5), where a Z3-symmetric MERA at chi = 12 recovers Delta_sigma = 0.134, Delta_eps = 0.805, Delta_T = 2.001 - giving alpha = 4.00 at all three universality classes. Second, the holographic transport time matches the AdS_3 null geodesic prediction T = (pi/2) l_AdS to 1.2% at N = 16 sites on a time-grid-converged measurement, with the residual shrinking from 2.8% at N = 12. Third, we introduce a two-phase optimization method (ALM + Z2 projection) for Z2-symmetric MERA ground states at 24 qubits. Fourth, extending the MERA bond dimension from chi=2 to chi=3 overcomes the expressibility barrier, achieving 0.15% energy error at 16 qubits and enabling the first holographic force measurement from an optimized tensor network state. The OPE coefficient is also measured directly from the fixed-point tensors: C_sigma-sigma-eps = 0.50 +/- 0.03 against the exact Ising value 1/2. A hardware path is designed for Quantinuum Helios (57 CNOTs, 0.57% logical error). Version 4 changes (relative to v3): Transport: N=16 residual restated as the time-grid-converged value of -1.21% (dt = 1e-3), with -2.78% at N=12 showing the finite-size trend; the 0.72% figure in v3 was an artifact of the dt = 0.05 integration grid and is now labeled as such. The N=24 transport point carries a new reliability caveat (double-lobe trace structure). The l_AdS comparison table is recomputed against the converged transport time (best fit 1.425, deviation 1.21%). Effective-mass derivation rewritten in a consistent AdS3 convention m^2 l^2 = Delta(Delta-2); m_eff = 0.693 = 1/l_AdS follows from Delta = 1 exactly. NEW: universality section extended to a third fixed point - a Z3-symmetric MERA at chi = 12 recovers the three-state Potts (c = 4/5) tower, giving alpha = 4.00 at all three universality classes (c = 1/2, 7/10, 4/5). NEW: the OPE coefficient C_sigma-sigma-eps = 0.50 +/- 0.03 measured directly from the fixed-point tensors, with C_sigma-sigma-sigma = 0 at machine precision as the Z2 structural check. Supplemental table row SIM-007 annotated (record lost; script preserved); data availability expanded; Zenodo DOI added to the front matter.
Directionally inter-contained causal networks carry Gaussian-Orthogonal- Ensemble (GOE) nearest-neighbour spacing statistics as a parameter- insensitive attractor, with the orthogonal class protected by the causal time-layering itself [2]. Here we quantize the growth network by its symmetrized adjacency, H = A, and test the eigenstate- thermalization battery and long-range spectral probes. Three results. (i) Eigenstates are window-selective: extended but non-GOE in the upper window (Porter–Thomas variance 3.74 vs. 2), recovering GOE variance in an interior window (2.13–2.25) though not the full component law (KS p ≤ 0.001): a three-layer structure, window-dependent throughout. (ii) A localized excitation relaxes to a return probability consistent with its own eigenstate ensemble to within a factor of two, with the residual excess tracking the quasi-degenerate spectrum centre created by the bipartite pairing — dynamics senses the very sector excluded in the static study. (iii) The spectral form factor is window- dependent: a partial ramp in the upper window (fitted slope 0.47) and no ramp at any scale in the interior window (slopes −0.09 to +0.20, statistically consistent with zero): rigidity is absent where the thermodynamic limit would have to build it. We argue the interior- window flatness is the expected spectral fingerprint of a system without a thermodynamic limit, corroborating the nocontinuum-limit statement of the metric study, and we register the discriminator experiment (hidden quasi-conservation vs. finite size) as open. All protocols were pre- registered and all data are deposited.
Decoherence and quantum Darwinism explain why pointer states and environment records dominate the quantum-to-classical transition, yet the operational criterion for "classical determinism" has rarely been tested as a falsifiable, pre-registered hypothesis (here the pre-registered objects are the P−1/P−3 criteria and the Phy-F1–F5 failure conditions; the Hill sigmoid reported below was added after data review and is not pre-registered). We consolidate one testable interface built on the standard pure-dephasing Lindblad model: does the emergence of a classicality index K coincide with a sharp threshold R_c in environment record redundancy R_δ = 1/f_δ (P−1), and does R_δ scale with dimensionless decoherence γ_A T as a platform-comparable power law R_δ ∼ (γ_A T)^κ (P−3)? Using N_f environment fragments, fixed seeds, and 2000-bootstrap 95% confidence intervals, we find: (i) the segmented sharp-threshold model is not supported by the model comparison (ΔAIC = +19.9 vs. a linear fit), and a smooth Hill sigmoid (n = 2.7, a gentle S-curve rather than a switch; post hoc) describes the data best, with Spearman ρ(K, R_δ) = 0.999 [0.997, 1.000]; (ii) in the weak-decoherence regime κ = 0.96 [0.94, 0.97], R² = 0.998, and, within the fitting window declared here (γ_A T ≤ 10²), κ is equivalent across superconducting, trapped-ion and optomechanical platforms (TOST, band ±0.2; all pairwise |Δκ| ≤ 0.019); (iii) that cross-platform equivalence is window-dependent: extending the optomechanical fit four decades into the saturated plateau (γ_A T up to 10⁶, where R_δ is pinned at N_f = 100) returns an effective exponent of 0.25 ± 0.07 with R² = 0.61, which we report but do not read as a platform difference. Record redundancy inherits from Zurek quantum Darwinism; we propose no new physical law. Failure conditions Phy-F1–F5 are stated explicitly.
Ordre topologique à température finie dans le modèle string-net et le modèle du double quantique L'ordre topologique est un ordre quantique particulier qui apparaît dans les systèmes quantiques gappés et fortement interactifs, et qui ne peut pas être décrit par un paramètre d'ordre local et une brisure spontanée de symétrie. En deux dimensions et à température nulle, cet ordre est caractérisé par une dégénérescence de l'état fondamental dépendant de la topologie de la variété, de l'intrication à longue portée et la présence de quasi-particules avec des nombres quantiques et des statistiques d'échange fractionnaires (également appelées anyons). Cette thèse étudie l'ordre topologique à température finie au moyen de deux modèles jouets exactement solubles : le modèle de string-net (réseau de cordes) de Levin et Wen et le modèle du double quantique de Kitaev. L'accent principal est mis sur le modèle de string-net, qui réalise tous les ordres topologiques doublés achiraux, c'est-à-dire tous les ordres topologiques décrits par un centre de Drinfeld. Ce modèle prend comme entrée une catégorie de fusion unitaire et produit le centre de Drinfeld correspondant en sortie. Dans un premier temps, nous dérivons une formule pour les dégénérescences spectrales du modèle, qui dépendent à la fois de la topologie et de l'ordre topologique considéré. En particulier, les dégénérescences dépendent non seulement du centre de Drinfeld mais aussi de la catégorie d'entrée. Ensuite, nous calculons la fonction de partition, à partir de laquelle nous obtenons l'entropie, la chaleur spécifique, et montrons qu'il n'y a pas de transition de phase à température finie. Nous identifions un ensemble particulier d'objets du centre de Drinfeld, appelés fluxons purs, qui dominent le comportement de la fonction de partition dans la limite thermodynamique, et étudions leurs propriétés. Nous obtenons également les moyennes thermiques des opérateurs de cordes fermées et étudions l'information mutuelle. Enfin, nous appliquons notre approche aux modèles du double quantique, où nous dérivons également une formule générale pour les dégénérescences spectrales, la fonction de partition et l'entropie d'intrication, permettant une étude plus générale et détaillée des propriétés à température finie par rapport aux études précédentes.
This paper develops a framework-relative ontology of determinacy. Its core question is not what the world is made of, but what must minimally be accounted for if a stable deter- minate identity is internally self-representing. The primitive and functional core of Version 3.8 is retained: Being, the possibility of distinction, and domain-relative realizability define the sparse primitive basis; coherent self-representation then requires three non-equivalent func- tional questions—Support, Internal Encoding, and Correspondence. Explicit finite witness pairs establish uniform non-determination of each role from the other two in the unrestricted baseline class, while stronger canonical or equivariant subclasses remain open. Version 4.1.1 is a corrective consolidation of Version 4.1 rather than a new upstream on- tology step. It retains the Version 4.0 bridge revision and the Version 4.1 constructional layer. That layer adds the reverse evaluative direction Physics ⇒ Mathematics ⇒ Ontology and records where downstream structures constrain, but do not retroactively constitute, the ontol- ogy. Several previous bridge claims are weakened or rejected. Symmetry classification, tensor factorization, entanglement of a state, and path-dependent dynamics are kept as four distinct mathematical layers. A conditional expectation is treated as a localization map rather than as actualization; a branch instrument defines possible conditional events but does not select one realized branch; and a projection onto admissible spectral sectors is not called conservative dynamics without an independently derived dilation. The causal and propagation bridge is sharpened in two directions. First, a previous can- didate definition of a null relation by vanishing accumulated interval volume is proved degen- erate: every comparable pair admits a chain of links, so that criterion vanishes throughout the causal order. Link ensembles remain useful near-null approximants, but the null sector is therefore a limiting or measure-relative object rather than a pair-local primitive in the de- clared causal-set model. Second, the long-range free-chain calculation at 𝛼 = 2 is separated into two non-commuting limits. The infinite-range spectral symbol has maximal group veloc- ity 𝜋𝐽𝑎, whereas the envelope of finite-cutoff maxima tends to 2𝐽𝑎 Si(𝜋). These are spectral group-velocity statements; a causal signal cone still requires separate Lieb–Robinson-type hy- potheses. Isotropy and a unique physical Lorentz cone remain open. The defect bridge is updated with the completed 𝐾 = 512 data layer of the frozen ratio campaign. All 903 prescribed values of 𝜃 are present with eight branches each; 897 aggregate points are admissible and six lie in a short rejected interval. Neither √ 2 nor 𝜙 is a local or global minimum. The original preregistered primary ratio test nevertheless remains non- evaluable because its 𝐾 = 64 training gate is universally degenerate. Thus 𝐾 = 512 completes a characterization block; it does not retrospectively repair the primary estimator. Provenance registration and cross-platform verification remain pending. Version 4.0 turned Test 28A into an explicit reconstruction audit, and Version 4.1 retains that audit unchanged. For the standard three one-body extractions on ℋ = (C 3 ) ⊗3 , the combined linear map has exact rank 25 and kernel dimension 704. The hidden space splits as 192 two-body plus 512 fully traceless three-body directions; even the full 𝑆3-invariant class retains an exact 156-dimensional hidden sector. The preregistered continuation identifies an exact energy-selected fixed point, the totally antisymmetric state |𝜀⟩, while holonomy and variance objectives yield set-valued argmin correspondences. The historical non-triviality gate is therefore preserved but shown not to be a universal criterion, and no retroactive 𝑉28.4 verdict is declared. A prospectively frozen two-local QPH family provides an exact computer-assisted existence witness: its cycle-phase differential has rank 704/704 on the marginal kernel for the primary family and two preregistered replications, so marginals plus relational cycle phases are locally in- formationally complete in the fixed regularity stratum. Canonical modular-mismatch selectors are then audited rather than assumed. Identical additive qutrit references and every single pure mismatch under exact 𝑆3 protection obey strict capacity/rank no-go bounds. On the protected 156-dimensional domain a physically generated mixed mismatch has sufficient raw capacity but standard phase-only QPH remains incomplete. Exact cumulant analysis explains why order three is the natural next layer: the 𝑆3-hidden sector decomposes as 156 = 36 + 120, and the third connected cumulant is a complete affine coordinate on fibres of fixed proper marginals. A historical preregistered cubic-moment completion is retained only as a delicate T-NUM wit- ness, not as a theorem premise. This is the declared stopping point of the arity/cubic line: selecting one specific cubic observable would require a new independent physical law. Test 28B remains suspended. Version 4.0 added one further macro-level correction, retained in Version 4.1. Causal and conformal structure, transport geometry, stable matter sectors, and quantum correlations are treated as parallel downstream representations of one substrate model, not as a serial matter– space–time chain. A proposed identification of the matter admissibility projector Πadm with spacetime volume is rejected in its literal form: the projector is matter-branch specific, need not be nested under generative updates, and has no canonical finite trace in a type-III con- tinuum. In its place a conditional causal–transport conformal closure theorem is proved. If a causal reconstruction supplies a Lorentzian conformal class and an independent transport limit supplies a positive spatial metric on the same spacelike distribution, the conformal factor is fixed pointwise exactly when the two induced spatial metrics are conformally compatible. A scale-free generalized-eigenvalue defect provides a direct falsifier. The corresponding clock– cone–matter gate is also corrected by conformal weight: frequencies and dimensionful spectral scales have lapse weight one under a pure lapse deformation, whereas spectral ratios, localiza- tion fractions, and dimensionless stability-window coordinates have weight zero. A Tolman– thermal-time comparison is retained only as a relative lapse-profile gate; absolute time units remain open. Version 4.1 introduced a controlled common-substrate realization. Version 4.1.1 corrects its scope: parity alone excludes only an odd or linear mass/source identification with the same signed coordinate; an even law such as 𝑀 ∝ 𝑑 2 is not excluded by parity. On the declared graph Klein–Gordon sector, charge conjugation reverses Noether/gauge-current orientation while leaving mode energy and localization intensity unchanged. A grounded-graph Green- kernel theorem fixes the spatial uniformity of the cross-term sign, while the Coulomb sign itself is conditional on realizing a non-dynamical 𝐴0-type constraint sector; the same kernel in a dynamical scalar sector gives the opposite sign. A separate no-go proves that matter Dirichlet energy alone cannot select a nontrivial interior geometry. A state-selected positive geometry Hessian yields the conditional linear response 𝑦 = 𝐾 −1 𝐸 𝜏 , so weak 𝐶-even stress sources add while 𝐶-odd currents can cancel. The principal new bridge is a conditional stationary common causal–transport–matter con- struction. If one protected center supplies a common base, the transport branch supplies a positive spatial metric ℎ, and several modular/physical clocks agree on one relative lapse 𝑁, then 𝑔CTM = −𝑐 2 *𝑁2𝑑𝑇2 + ℎ has one timelike sign, predicts the same null front for all canonically normalized matter sectors, and fixes its stationary volume element without an additional scalar measure. Different masses and opposite 𝑈(1) representation weights remain lower-order data and do not alter the characteristic cone. The independently reconstructed HSMI conformal class remains a held-out test rather than an input to this construction. A second independent Version 4.1 result supplies a conditional physical law selecting com- plex rank two. A nonzero-Chern line cannot be closed under conjugation at rank one on 𝑆 2 , whereas 𝐿 ⊕ 𝐿¯ is the minimal conjugation-closed carrier; independently, ClC 2 ≃ 𝑀2(C) has minimal irreducible complex module dimension two. The existing odd-Chern defect-link con struction realizes this pair. If its Clifford algebra is physically admissible, the local carrier has 𝑀2(C) qubit kinematics. This is not an assertion that opposite electric charges form a coherent qubit, nor that every particle is a qubit. The resulting Version 4.1.1 is a constrained foundational proposal with a frozen primitive core, stronger positive and negative bridge results, a first common stationary geometry can- didate, an independently motivated minimal rank-two carrier, and a reproducibility-oriented ledger for every step from ontological determinacy toward physics. It also makes the external spin-sign, soft-graviton, equivalence-principle, and mass-budget inputs explicit without treat- ing them as evidence for the ontology.
Parts VIII–XI of this series reduced the program to a single missing object: a quantum measure μ(C) over causal histories. This Part XII specifies that object, realizes it in prototype, and tests whether it selects the observed effective spacetime dimension. The fundamental object is a Hermitian, positive, bi-additive Sorkin decoherence functional D(A,B) with physical measure μ(A)=D(A,A); classical measures obey the two-event sum rule I2=0, while quantum measures have I2≠0 but obey the Sorkin triple sum rule I3=0. An explicit such measure is constructed on the growth histories of small causal sets and verified numerically to satisfy I3=0 to machine precision while I2≠0. The fourth gate is sharpened beyond the standard Lorentzian-continuum requirement: the measure must concentrate on causal orders carrying coherent local proper time (a stable interval volume–proper-time law), the distinctive addition of this program. A systematic test on controlled ensembles then asks whether any non-circular intrinsic ingredient selects the 3+1 sector, with a uniformly negative result. The free measure is dominated by the entropic Kleitman–Rothschild phase (d_MM ≈ 2.37); proper-time coherence with propagation escapes that phase but settles on the effective 2+1 sector; the Benincasa–Dowker quantum phase produces only seed-unstable windows that vanish at the physically natural phase scale; and the Pauli–Jordan operator and the Sorkin–Johnston state, though intrinsic and phase-based, are monotone in dimension. A circularity audit shows that every selector whose optimum lies at four dimensions either inserts the dimension (local gravitational degrees of freedom, bound-matter stability, a (d−4)² term) or was tuned to it. The honest conclusion is that proper-time coherence explains the exit from the entropic phase but not the final 3+1 selection: the bare measure with coherence predicts an effective 2+1 phase, and the open problem is localized as the emergence of the third spatial direction (2+1 → 3+1). This yields a falsifiable prediction and identifies the missing object as a covariant, Bell-causal growth law whose continuum limit would fix the gravitational phase normalization. Supplementary Python scripts reproducing all numerical tests are included.