Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

What is the physical meaning of the quantum wave function?

Donald C. Chang

Published Jan 1, 2021• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

About a hundred years ago, there was a famous debate between Bohr and Einstein: Does the quantum wave function of an electron have a physical meaning beyond probability? This question is still open today. This work proposes a new theoretical framework to address the above question. Our approach is that, based on observations that photons and electrons have similar wave properties, we hypothesize that both of them are quantized excitation waves of the vacuum, the physical properties of which can be modelled based on the Maxwell theory. Using the method of Helmholtz decomposition, we showed that the wave function of the particle is associated with an electric vector potential called “Z”, which plays the role of basic field for the excitation wave. Using this framework, the quantum wave equations of electron can be derived directly from the Maxwell theory.

Related papers

Review on the physical basis of wave–particle duality: Conceptual connection between quantum mechanics and the Maxwell theory

Donald C. Chang

A well-known mystery in quantum mechanics is wave–particle duality: Is an electron a point mass or a physical wave? What is the physical meaning of its wave function? About a hundred years ago, there was a famous debate between Bohr and Einstein on this topic. Their question is still open today. This paper reviews a new theoretical framework to address this problem. Here, it is hypothesized that both photons and electrons are quantized excitation waves of the vacuum, the physical properties of which can be modeled based on the Maxwell theory. Using the method of Helmholtz decomposition, one can show that the wave function of the particle is associated with an electric vector potential called “ Z”, which plays the role of basic field for the excitation wave. Using this framework, the quantum wave equations can be derived based on a quantization of the Maxwell theory. This work suggests that, the quantum wave function truly represents a physical wave; the wave packet looks like a “particle” only in the macroscopic view. Because the vacuum excitation obeys the principle of all-or-none, the probability of detecting this “particle” is related to the wave function as suggested in the Copenhagen interpretation.

Modern Physics Letters B•May 5, 2021•18 citations

Photon wave function, electric and magnetic fields. Relationship to the electromagnetic vacuum.

Constantin Meis

A photon quantization volume is defined, an intrinsic physical geometrical property of a single photon state, showing that photons are not point particles and constitute a particular case in the standard particle model. Based on the quantized vector potential amplitude a photon wave function is established satisfying Schrödinger’s equation and normalized with respect to the quantization volume. The single photon electric and magnetic fields in vacuum are calculated independently on any external cavity parameter and they are proportional to the square of the frequency. The electromagnetic vacuum derives straightforward from the photon vector potential function and has both classical and quantum representations. The photon wave function is directly related to the electromagnetic vacuum states setting the fundamentals for understanding entanglement.

•May 22, 2024•0 citations

Photon wave function, electric and magnetic fields. Relationship to the electromagnetic vacuum.

Constantin Meis

A photon quantization volume is defined, an intrinsic physical geometrical property of a single photon state, showing that photons are not point particles and constitute a particular case in the standard particle model. Based on the quantized vector potential amplitude a photon wave function is established satisfying Schrödinger’s equation and normalized with respect to the quantization volume. The single photon electric and magnetic fields in vacuum are calculated independently on any external cavity parameter and they are proportional to the square of the frequency. The electromagnetic vacuum derives straightforward from the photon vector potential function and has both classical and quantum representations. The photon wave function is directly related to the electromagnetic vacuum states setting the fundamentals for understanding entanglement.

•May 22, 2024•0 citations

On the wave nature of matter: A transition from classical mechanics to quantum mechanics

Donald C. Chang

Following the spirit of de Broglie and Einstein, we think the concepts of matter and radiation can be unified. We know a particle propagates like a wave; its motion is described by certain wave equations. At this point, it is not clear what the wave function represents. Besides the statistical meaning suggested by the Copenhagen interpretation, does the wave function represent any physical motion? For photon, we know it is an electro-magnetic wave. But what about particles with rest mass, such as an electron? To investigate the physical nature of matter wave, we propose that: (1) Like the photon, a particle is an excitation wave of a real physical field. (2) Different types of particles are different excitation modes of the same field. Based on this thinking, we show that the concept of quantum mechanics can be a natural extension of classical mechanics. By critically analyzing the transition from classical physics to quantum physics, we found a new physical meaning for the quantum wave function. This work suggests that various quantum wave equations, including the Klein-Gordon equation, the Dirac equation and the Schrodinger equation, could have a common base relating to the Basic Wave Equation of the matter wave. This work has some interesting implications. It suggests a possible way to explain the origin of visible matters and dark matters in our universe.

arXiv:physics/0505010•May 2, 2005•8 citations

The field meaning of wave function

Canlun Yuan Yuan

Abstract Although this paper is the inheritance and development of Copenhagen quantum mechanics theory, it is a brand-new theory, because although quantum mechanics has achieved great success, its physical significance still needs to be explored. In this paper, the concept of generalized field and generalized quantity is introduced. From the behavior of generalized field in potential well, the conclusion that generalized field exists with energy in the form of standing wave in potential well is obtained. In this paper, only one physical model is used: "the generalized field forms wave, which is wave function". With a basic assumption of mvλ=h , the Einstein de Broglie relation is derived, and the wave function has the meaning of generalized field. Every conclusion given in this paper has clear and obvious physical significance, which makes quantum mechanical problems simple and clear. At the same time, the new atom model is established, and the problems of electron transition, electron spin, electron emission and absorption are discussed.

•Sep 23, 2020•0 citations

5 The Mechanics of Photons

L.D. Faddeev, L.A. Khalfin, I.V. Komarov

We propose to treat Maxwell equations as a wave equation of motion for a photon (a quantum of light) and to develop the photon mechanics on this basis. Consider vectors of electric and magnetic fields E and H as a single object (a bivector) F , which corresponds to the function ψ in the wave theory of the electron. Multiplying the vacuum Maxwell equations − rotH+ 1 c ∂E ∂t = 0, rot E + 1 c ∂H ∂t = 0 (1) by hc 2πi , it is possible to rewrite them in the form HF + h 2πi ∂F ∂t = 0, (2) where H is the operator H = hc 2πi { 0 − rot rot 0 } ; (3) its meaning follows from the comparison of equation (2) with (1). Equation (2) can be interpreted as a wave equation for a photon.

CRC Press eBooks•May 21, 2004•0 citations
About a hundred years ago, there was a famous debate between Bohr and Einstein: Does the quantum wave function of an electron have a physical meaning beyond probability? This question is still open today. This work proposes a new theoretical framework to address the above question. Our approach is that, based on observations that photons and electrons have similar wave properties, we hypothesize that both of them are quantized excitation waves of the vacuum, the physical properties of which can be modelled based on the Maxwell theory. Using the method of Helmholtz decomposition, we showed that the wave function of the particle is associated with an electric vector potential called “Z”, which plays the role of basic field for the excitation wave. Using this framework, the quantum wave equations of electron can be derived directly from the Maxwell theory.
A well-known mystery in quantum mechanics is wave–particle duality: Is an electron a point mass or a physical wave? What is the physical meaning of its wave function? About a hundred years ago, there was a famous debate between Bohr and Einstein on this topic. Their question is still open today. This paper reviews a new theoretical framework to address this problem. Here, it is hypothesized that both photons and electrons are quantized excitation waves of the vacuum, the physical properties of which can be modeled based on the Maxwell theory. Using the method of Helmholtz decomposition, one can show that the wave function of the particle is associated with an electric vector potential called “ Z”, which plays the role of basic field for the excitation wave. Using this framework, the quantum wave equations can be derived based on a quantization of the Maxwell theory. This work suggests that, the quantum wave function truly represents a physical wave; the wave packet looks like a “particle” only in the macroscopic view. Because the vacuum excitation obeys the principle of all-or-none, the probability of detecting this “particle” is related to the wave function as suggested in the Copenhagen interpretation.
A photon quantization volume is defined, an intrinsic physical geometrical property of a single photon state, showing that photons are not point particles and constitute a particular case in the standard particle model. Based on the quantized vector potential amplitude a photon wave function is established satisfying Schrödinger’s equation and normalized with respect to the quantization volume. The single photon electric and magnetic fields in vacuum are calculated independently on any external cavity parameter and they are proportional to the square of the frequency. The electromagnetic vacuum derives straightforward from the photon vector potential function and has both classical and quantum representations. The photon wave function is directly related to the electromagnetic vacuum states setting the fundamentals for understanding entanglement.
A photon quantization volume is defined, an intrinsic physical geometrical property of a single photon state, showing that photons are not point particles and constitute a particular case in the standard particle model. Based on the quantized vector potential amplitude a photon wave function is established satisfying Schrödinger’s equation and normalized with respect to the quantization volume. The single photon electric and magnetic fields in vacuum are calculated independently on any external cavity parameter and they are proportional to the square of the frequency. The electromagnetic vacuum derives straightforward from the photon vector potential function and has both classical and quantum representations. The photon wave function is directly related to the electromagnetic vacuum states setting the fundamentals for understanding entanglement.
Following the spirit of de Broglie and Einstein, we think the concepts of matter and radiation can be unified. We know a particle propagates like a wave; its motion is described by certain wave equations. At this point, it is not clear what the wave function represents. Besides the statistical meaning suggested by the Copenhagen interpretation, does the wave function represent any physical motion? For photon, we know it is an electro-magnetic wave. But what about particles with rest mass, such as an electron? To investigate the physical nature of matter wave, we propose that: (1) Like the photon, a particle is an excitation wave of a real physical field. (2) Different types of particles are different excitation modes of the same field. Based on this thinking, we show that the concept of quantum mechanics can be a natural extension of classical mechanics. By critically analyzing the transition from classical physics to quantum physics, we found a new physical meaning for the quantum wave function. This work suggests that various quantum wave equations, including the Klein-Gordon equation, the Dirac equation and the Schrodinger equation, could have a common base relating to the Basic Wave Equation of the matter wave. This work has some interesting implications. It suggests a possible way to explain the origin of visible matters and dark matters in our universe.
Abstract Although this paper is the inheritance and development of Copenhagen quantum mechanics theory, it is a brand-new theory, because although quantum mechanics has achieved great success, its physical significance still needs to be explored. In this paper, the concept of generalized field and generalized quantity is introduced. From the behavior of generalized field in potential well, the conclusion that generalized field exists with energy in the form of standing wave in potential well is obtained. In this paper, only one physical model is used: "the generalized field forms wave, which is wave function". With a basic assumption of mvλ=h , the Einstein de Broglie relation is derived, and the wave function has the meaning of generalized field. Every conclusion given in this paper has clear and obvious physical significance, which makes quantum mechanical problems simple and clear. At the same time, the new atom model is established, and the problems of electron transition, electron spin, electron emission and absorption are discussed.
We propose to treat Maxwell equations as a wave equation of motion for a photon (a quantum of light) and to develop the photon mechanics on this basis. Consider vectors of electric and magnetic fields E and H as a single object (a bivector) F , which corresponds to the function ψ in the wave theory of the electron. Multiplying the vacuum Maxwell equations − rotH+ 1 c ∂E ∂t = 0, rot E + 1 c ∂H ∂t = 0 (1) by hc 2πi , it is possible to rewrite them in the form HF + h 2πi ∂F ∂t = 0, (2) where H is the operator H = hc 2πi { 0 − rot rot 0 } ; (3) its meaning follows from the comparison of equation (2) with (1). Equation (2) can be interpreted as a wave equation for a photon.