Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Engineering the Post-Quantum Transition at Scale: Protocol Integration, Library Defaults, and the In-Between Era of Internet Security (2025)

Feng Hao, Danda B. Rawat

Published Dec 1, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Background: The August 2024 finalization of FIPS 203, 204, and 205 established the cryptographic core of the post-quantum transition; 2025 was the year that core was engineered into the default path of the Internet . Within twelve months, ML-KEM-based hybrid key exchange became a default, zero-configuration behavior across the major browser engines, a mainstream language runtime (Go 1.24's crypto/mlkem standard-library package), and — decisively for server operators — OpenSSL 3.5.0 (April 2025, LTS), whose default TLS keyshares offer X25519MLKEM768. By late October 2025, more than half of human-initiated traffic observed at a major CDN was post-quantum protected. Objective: This paper characterizes the 2025 state of the post-quantum transition as an engineering achievement, and identifies what the achievement does not yet cover. Methods: Following a design-analytical methodology, we (i) verify the 2025 default-enablement sequence against primary release documentation (OpenSSL, Go, browser engines, platform vendors, CDN telemetry), (ii) analyze the standards pipeline as it stood at year-end (the HQC selection of March 2025; the pending FN-DSA draft; the IR 8547 deprecation schedule), and (iii) construct a residual-risk register mapping six risk classes against six mitigation classes. Results: The deployment achievement is real but asymmetric: confidentiality (key establishment) has moved to post-quantum hybrids at scale, while authentication remains entirely classical — public post-quantum certificates are not expected to be widely issued before 2026 and broadly trusted later. We term this the in-between era and show that it closes the harvest-now-decrypt-later window for transit confidentiality while leaving an open window for identity forgery and server impersonation. The residual-risk register identifies implementation maturity (the KyberSlash-class timing-defect lesson), certificate and PKI latency, and the non-upgradeable long-tail client population as the dominant open risks. Conclusions: The engineering problem of 2025 was enabling post-quantum key exchange by default; the engineering problem of 2026–2027 is post-quantum authentication on the same schedule — and organizations should plan PKI re-issuance, validation pipelines, and legacy-exception registers against that window now.

DOI
10.68556/sw6hxr84

Related papers

From Standards to Systems: A Crypto-Agility Framework for Post-Quantum Cryptography Migration in Enterprise and Internet Infrastructure

Sepideh Malektaji, Carla Mouradian

Background: In August 2024, the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) finalized the first three post-quantum cryptography (PQC) standards — FIPS 203 (ML-KEM), FIPS 204 (ML-DSA), and FIPS 205 (SLH-DSA) — and, in November 2024, published the initial public draft of NIST IR 8547, which schedules the deprecation of classical public-key cryptography by 2030 and its disallowance after 2035. Organizations therefore face, for the first time, a regulator-defined deadline for a global cryptographic transition. Objective: This paper characterizes the state of PQC deployment as of the end of 2024 and develops a structured, reusable migration framework that converts the new standards into an actionable organizational process. Methods: We apply a design-science methodology combining (i) documentary analysis of the 2024 standards and transition guidance, (ii) a structured synthesis of publicly documented, at-scale PQC deployments in transport, messaging, and shell protocols during 2022–2024, (iii) characterization of wire-size and throughput overheads using published benchmark data, and (iv) construction and cross-validation of a five-phase Crypto-Agility Migration Process (CAMP) against NIST transition guidance and NCCoE migration practices. Results: Deployment evidence shows that hybrid key establishment (X25519 + ML-KEM-768) is already operational at Internet scale, adding approximately 1.2 KB to the TLS 1.3 handshake with negligible latency impact, whereas post-quantum signatures remain the dominant constraint (ML-DSA-65 signatures are 3309 bytes versus 256 bytes for RSA-2048). We identify four systemic migration bottlenecks — FIPS validation lead times, embedded device lifecycles, PKI signature-size pressure, and organizational cryptographic invisibility — and operationalize CAMP to address them, anchoring prioritization in Mosca's inequality and the 2030/2035 deadlines of NIST IR 8547. Conclusions: The 2024 finalization of the PQC standards transforms post-quantum readiness from a research question into an engineering and governance problem. Organizations that establish cryptographic inventory, hybrid piloting, and crypto-agile library interfaces during 2025 will be positioned to meet the 2030 deprecation horizon; organizations that do not will face compressed, higher-risk migrations later in the decade.

•Dec 1, 2024•0 citations

Post-Quantum Cryptography Migration in Communication Networks: A Systematic Review of Protocol Integration, Performance Trade-Offs, and Transition Readiness

Merve Güllü, Esra Söğüt

The prospect of a cryptographically relevant quantum computer (CRQC) undermines the public-key primitives that secure virtually every layer of modern communication networks, from subscriber authentication in cellular cores to transport-layer key exchange. Adversaries already following a harvest-now, decrypt-later (HNDL) strategy make this threat actionable today for any traffic whose confidentiality must outlast a decade. Following NIST’s finalisation of the first post-quantum cryptography (PQC) standards, ML-KEM (FIPS 203), ML-DSA (FIPS 204), and SLH-DSA (FIPS 205) in August 2024, and the selection of HQC as a fourth key-encapsulation candidate in March 2025, research has shifted from algorithm design to network-level integration. This paper reports a PRISMA-2020-compliant systematic literature review of PQC migration in communication networks, structured around five research questions covering protocol and scenario coverage, quantitative performance impact, hybrid cryptography strategies, transition barriers, and open research gaps. Six databases (IEEE Xplore, Scopus, Web of Science, ACM Digital Library, SpringerLink, and MDPI) were searched (3229 records identified); after deduplication, title-keyword screening, full-text eligibility assessment, and a pre-specified quality appraisal (Q1–Q6, threshold ≥3/6) applied to 310 eligible studies, a final synthesis corpus of 141 studies (68 journal articles, 68 conference papers, 4 conference-derived book chapters, 1 workshop paper) was screened, quality-appraised, and synthesised narratively with supporting evidence tables. The review finds that transport-layer protocols (TLS 1.3, QUIC, DTLS 1.3) dominate the literature, that lattice-based ML-KEM/ML-DSA offer the most favourable latency–bandwidth–energy trade-off among standardised families, and that classical–PQC hybrid schemes are the de facto transition strategy across 5G/6G, IoT, VPN, and automotive scenarios, at the cost of 10–100× larger keys/signatures and 8–40% handshake latency overhead. Persistent barriers include constrained-device resource limits, immature hardware acceleration, incomplete IETF/3GPP standardisation, and public-key-infrastructure scaling. We propose a five-level PQC transition-readiness maturity model and identify large-scale field validation, PQC–QKD integration, and lightweight signature schemes as priority directions for future work.

Electronics•Oct 11, 2026•0 citations

Post-Quantum Cryptography Migration in Internet Protocols: A Review of ML-KEM Hybrid Key Exchange in TLS and SSH

Yan Zhang

Internet public-key cryptography faces long-term risk from quantum computers, especially when traffic can be collected now and decrypted later. After the NIST post-quantum cryptography standards, the deployment task has shifted from algorithm selection to protocol migration. This paper reviews ML-KEM hybrid key exchange in TLS and SSH through a standards-first narrative review and protocol comparison. It synthesizes NIST standards, RFCs and IETF drafts, experiments, measurements, and primary deployment reports. The paper develops a deployment-readiness framework with four layers: security continuity, protocol integration, operational observability, and crypto-agility. The analysis shows hybrid key exchange represents the most feasible short-term solution, as it introduces post-quantum confidentiality without discarding existing elliptic curve security guarantees. However, hybrid deployment does not provide full post-quantum security. The review argues that readiness depends on protocol binding, implementation behavior, monitoring, and governance as much as on algorithm strength. Handshake size, middlebox compatibility, implementation safety, telemetry, authentication migration, and organizational crypto-agility determine whether migration can progress without weakening current Internet security.

Applied and Computational Engineering•Aug 11, 2026•0 citations

Post-Quantum Cryptography Migration for Enterprise Security

Mini T. V

Large-scale quantum computers threaten the public-key cryptography that protects enterprise data, communications, and digital identity. Shor's algorithm solves integer factorization and discrete logarithms in polynomial time, which would break RSA, Diffie-Hellman, and elliptic-curve schemes once a cryptographically relevant quantum computer exists. The danger is not only future. Adversaries can record encrypted traffic today and decrypt it later, a tactic known as harvest-now-decrypt-later. In August 2024 the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology published its first post-quantum standards: FIPS 203 (ML-KEM, derived from CRYSTALS-Kyber), FIPS 204 (ML-DSA, from CRYSTALS-Dilithium), and FIPS 205 (SLH-DSA, from SPHINCS+). This paper presents a practical migration framework for enterprises. It reviews the quantum threat and Mosca's inequality for timing the transition, summarizes the new standards with their key and signature sizes, and proposes a five-phase roadmap built on crypto-agility: discovery and inventory, risk prioritization, agility engineering, hybrid deployment, and validation. Performance trade-offs are analyzed using documented parameter sizes and illustrative TLS handshake figures. ML-KEM-768 carries a 1,184-byte public key against 64 bytes for an elliptic-curve key, while SPHINCS+ signatures can exceed 17 kilobytes. The work does not report a real deployment. It consolidates published parameters and field guidance into an actionable plan, and it highlights open challenges in certificate sizing, hardware support, and long-lived embedded systems.

International Journal of Information Technology Research Studies (IJITRS)•Jul 30, 2026•0 citations

We Are on the Precipice of a Post-Quantum World: Are You Prepared? A Review of NIST-Approved Post-Quantum Cryptographic Mechanisms for Immediate Adoption in Financial Infrastructure

Maria Teigeiro

Post-quantum cryptographic standardization is complete for the algorithms that matter most, yet adoption across financial infrastructure remains uneven and, in critical segments, largely absent. This paper argues that migration is no longer a research question but an execution question, and that the window for orderly transition is narrower than the commonly cited “Q-Day” horizon of 2030-2035 implies. Because adversaries can record encrypted traffic today and store it for decryption once cryptographically relevant quantum computers exist, the effective deadline for protecting data with multi-year confidentiality requirements has already passed. We review the NIST-approved suite — ML-KEM (FIPS 203), ML-DSA (FIPS 204), and SLH-DSA (FIPS 205) — alongside hybrid key-exchange constructions now deployed at internet scale, and assess their applicability to financial systems. We map the compliance landscape consolidating around 2030 and 2035, including NIST IR 8547, NSA CNSA 2.0, and the 2026 G7 Cyber Expert Group roadmap, alingside converging UK and EU timelines. Finally, we offer a practical migration framework organized around cryptographic inventory, exposure-window triage, and crypto-agility. Our central finding is that technical barriers to beginning migration are substantially lower than institutional inertia suggests: for many systems, post-quantum key agreement is a library upgrade rather than a redesign.

•Oct 6, 2026•0 citations

Measurement Study of Post-Quantum Readiness of Internet: 2026

Vanishka Mohan Dubey, Gaurav Varshney

The emergence of quantum computing presents a fundamental challenge to the security of current Internet communication systems. Transport Layer Security (TLS), which forms the backbone of secure web communication, predominantly relies on classical public-key cryptographic algorithms such as RSA and elliptic curve cryptography (ECC), both of which are susceptible to quantum attacks. This paper conducts a large scale empirical evaluation of post-quantum readiness across 32,011 domains, with a primary focus on real-world TLS deployments across diverse sectors by analysing negotiated TLS parameters, including protocol versions, cipher suites, key exchange mechanisms, and certificates. The results indicate that while modern protocols like TLS 1.3 and QUIC are gaining adoption, 15.70% of domains especially in critical sectors such as banking and government still rely on TLS 1.2. Furthermore, 49.3% of domains support hybrid post-quantum key exchange mechanisms (e.g., MLKEM768 with X25519), whereas 50.7% continue to use classical key exchange, reflecting partial transition. Notably, 0% adoption of hybrid post-quantum certificates was observed, leaving the authentication layer vulnerable to quantum-enabled attacks such as certificate forgery. The findings reveal uneven adoption of post-quantum mechanisms across sectors, where technology driven platforms are advancing more rapidly than legacy-dependent infrastructures. Overall, the study highlights that achieving complete quantum resilience requires a coordinated transition not only in key exchange mechanisms but also in certificate infrastructures. Without such comprehensive migration, Internet communication systems remain vulnerable to long-term threats, including Harvest-Now-Decrypt-Later (HNDL) attacks.

arXiv:2606.16473•Jun 15, 2026•5 citations
Background: The August 2024 finalization of FIPS 203, 204, and 205 established the cryptographic core of the post-quantum transition; 2025 was the year that core was engineered into the default path of the Internet . Within twelve months, ML-KEM-based hybrid key exchange became a default, zero-configuration behavior across the major browser engines, a mainstream language runtime (Go 1.24's crypto/mlkem standard-library package), and — decisively for server operators — OpenSSL 3.5.0 (April 2025, LTS), whose default TLS keyshares offer X25519MLKEM768. By late October 2025, more than half of human-initiated traffic observed at a major CDN was post-quantum protected. Objective: This paper characterizes the 2025 state of the post-quantum transition as an engineering achievement, and identifies what the achievement does not yet cover. Methods: Following a design-analytical methodology, we (i) verify the 2025 default-enablement sequence against primary release documentation (OpenSSL, Go, browser engines, platform vendors, CDN telemetry), (ii) analyze the standards pipeline as it stood at year-end (the HQC selection of March 2025; the pending FN-DSA draft; the IR 8547 deprecation schedule), and (iii) construct a residual-risk register mapping six risk classes against six mitigation classes. Results: The deployment achievement is real but asymmetric: confidentiality (key establishment) has moved to post-quantum hybrids at scale, while authentication remains entirely classical — public post-quantum certificates are not expected to be widely issued before 2026 and broadly trusted later. We term this the in-between era and show that it closes the harvest-now-decrypt-later window for transit confidentiality while leaving an open window for identity forgery and server impersonation. The residual-risk register identifies implementation maturity (the KyberSlash-class timing-defect lesson), certificate and PKI latency, and the non-upgradeable long-tail client population as the dominant open risks. Conclusions: The engineering problem of 2025 was enabling post-quantum key exchange by default; the engineering problem of 2026–2027 is post-quantum authentication on the same schedule — and organizations should plan PKI re-issuance, validation pipelines, and legacy-exception registers against that window now.
Background: In August 2024, the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) finalized the first three post-quantum cryptography (PQC) standards — FIPS 203 (ML-KEM), FIPS 204 (ML-DSA), and FIPS 205 (SLH-DSA) — and, in November 2024, published the initial public draft of NIST IR 8547, which schedules the deprecation of classical public-key cryptography by 2030 and its disallowance after 2035. Organizations therefore face, for the first time, a regulator-defined deadline for a global cryptographic transition. Objective: This paper characterizes the state of PQC deployment as of the end of 2024 and develops a structured, reusable migration framework that converts the new standards into an actionable organizational process. Methods: We apply a design-science methodology combining (i) documentary analysis of the 2024 standards and transition guidance, (ii) a structured synthesis of publicly documented, at-scale PQC deployments in transport, messaging, and shell protocols during 2022–2024, (iii) characterization of wire-size and throughput overheads using published benchmark data, and (iv) construction and cross-validation of a five-phase Crypto-Agility Migration Process (CAMP) against NIST transition guidance and NCCoE migration practices. Results: Deployment evidence shows that hybrid key establishment (X25519 + ML-KEM-768) is already operational at Internet scale, adding approximately 1.2 KB to the TLS 1.3 handshake with negligible latency impact, whereas post-quantum signatures remain the dominant constraint (ML-DSA-65 signatures are 3309 bytes versus 256 bytes for RSA-2048). We identify four systemic migration bottlenecks — FIPS validation lead times, embedded device lifecycles, PKI signature-size pressure, and organizational cryptographic invisibility — and operationalize CAMP to address them, anchoring prioritization in Mosca's inequality and the 2030/2035 deadlines of NIST IR 8547. Conclusions: The 2024 finalization of the PQC standards transforms post-quantum readiness from a research question into an engineering and governance problem. Organizations that establish cryptographic inventory, hybrid piloting, and crypto-agile library interfaces during 2025 will be positioned to meet the 2030 deprecation horizon; organizations that do not will face compressed, higher-risk migrations later in the decade.
The prospect of a cryptographically relevant quantum computer (CRQC) undermines the public-key primitives that secure virtually every layer of modern communication networks, from subscriber authentication in cellular cores to transport-layer key exchange. Adversaries already following a harvest-now, decrypt-later (HNDL) strategy make this threat actionable today for any traffic whose confidentiality must outlast a decade. Following NIST’s finalisation of the first post-quantum cryptography (PQC) standards, ML-KEM (FIPS 203), ML-DSA (FIPS 204), and SLH-DSA (FIPS 205) in August 2024, and the selection of HQC as a fourth key-encapsulation candidate in March 2025, research has shifted from algorithm design to network-level integration. This paper reports a PRISMA-2020-compliant systematic literature review of PQC migration in communication networks, structured around five research questions covering protocol and scenario coverage, quantitative performance impact, hybrid cryptography strategies, transition barriers, and open research gaps. Six databases (IEEE Xplore, Scopus, Web of Science, ACM Digital Library, SpringerLink, and MDPI) were searched (3229 records identified); after deduplication, title-keyword screening, full-text eligibility assessment, and a pre-specified quality appraisal (Q1–Q6, threshold ≥3/6) applied to 310 eligible studies, a final synthesis corpus of 141 studies (68 journal articles, 68 conference papers, 4 conference-derived book chapters, 1 workshop paper) was screened, quality-appraised, and synthesised narratively with supporting evidence tables. The review finds that transport-layer protocols (TLS 1.3, QUIC, DTLS 1.3) dominate the literature, that lattice-based ML-KEM/ML-DSA offer the most favourable latency–bandwidth–energy trade-off among standardised families, and that classical–PQC hybrid schemes are the de facto transition strategy across 5G/6G, IoT, VPN, and automotive scenarios, at the cost of 10–100× larger keys/signatures and 8–40% handshake latency overhead. Persistent barriers include constrained-device resource limits, immature hardware acceleration, incomplete IETF/3GPP standardisation, and public-key-infrastructure scaling. We propose a five-level PQC transition-readiness maturity model and identify large-scale field validation, PQC–QKD integration, and lightweight signature schemes as priority directions for future work.
Internet public-key cryptography faces long-term risk from quantum computers, especially when traffic can be collected now and decrypted later. After the NIST post-quantum cryptography standards, the deployment task has shifted from algorithm selection to protocol migration. This paper reviews ML-KEM hybrid key exchange in TLS and SSH through a standards-first narrative review and protocol comparison. It synthesizes NIST standards, RFCs and IETF drafts, experiments, measurements, and primary deployment reports. The paper develops a deployment-readiness framework with four layers: security continuity, protocol integration, operational observability, and crypto-agility. The analysis shows hybrid key exchange represents the most feasible short-term solution, as it introduces post-quantum confidentiality without discarding existing elliptic curve security guarantees. However, hybrid deployment does not provide full post-quantum security. The review argues that readiness depends on protocol binding, implementation behavior, monitoring, and governance as much as on algorithm strength. Handshake size, middlebox compatibility, implementation safety, telemetry, authentication migration, and organizational crypto-agility determine whether migration can progress without weakening current Internet security.
Large-scale quantum computers threaten the public-key cryptography that protects enterprise data, communications, and digital identity. Shor's algorithm solves integer factorization and discrete logarithms in polynomial time, which would break RSA, Diffie-Hellman, and elliptic-curve schemes once a cryptographically relevant quantum computer exists. The danger is not only future. Adversaries can record encrypted traffic today and decrypt it later, a tactic known as harvest-now-decrypt-later. In August 2024 the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology published its first post-quantum standards: FIPS 203 (ML-KEM, derived from CRYSTALS-Kyber), FIPS 204 (ML-DSA, from CRYSTALS-Dilithium), and FIPS 205 (SLH-DSA, from SPHINCS+). This paper presents a practical migration framework for enterprises. It reviews the quantum threat and Mosca's inequality for timing the transition, summarizes the new standards with their key and signature sizes, and proposes a five-phase roadmap built on crypto-agility: discovery and inventory, risk prioritization, agility engineering, hybrid deployment, and validation. Performance trade-offs are analyzed using documented parameter sizes and illustrative TLS handshake figures. ML-KEM-768 carries a 1,184-byte public key against 64 bytes for an elliptic-curve key, while SPHINCS+ signatures can exceed 17 kilobytes. The work does not report a real deployment. It consolidates published parameters and field guidance into an actionable plan, and it highlights open challenges in certificate sizing, hardware support, and long-lived embedded systems.
Post-quantum cryptographic standardization is complete for the algorithms that matter most, yet adoption across financial infrastructure remains uneven and, in critical segments, largely absent. This paper argues that migration is no longer a research question but an execution question, and that the window for orderly transition is narrower than the commonly cited “Q-Day” horizon of 2030-2035 implies. Because adversaries can record encrypted traffic today and store it for decryption once cryptographically relevant quantum computers exist, the effective deadline for protecting data with multi-year confidentiality requirements has already passed. We review the NIST-approved suite — ML-KEM (FIPS 203), ML-DSA (FIPS 204), and SLH-DSA (FIPS 205) — alongside hybrid key-exchange constructions now deployed at internet scale, and assess their applicability to financial systems. We map the compliance landscape consolidating around 2030 and 2035, including NIST IR 8547, NSA CNSA 2.0, and the 2026 G7 Cyber Expert Group roadmap, alingside converging UK and EU timelines. Finally, we offer a practical migration framework organized around cryptographic inventory, exposure-window triage, and crypto-agility. Our central finding is that technical barriers to beginning migration are substantially lower than institutional inertia suggests: for many systems, post-quantum key agreement is a library upgrade rather than a redesign.
The emergence of quantum computing presents a fundamental challenge to the security of current Internet communication systems. Transport Layer Security (TLS), which forms the backbone of secure web communication, predominantly relies on classical public-key cryptographic algorithms such as RSA and elliptic curve cryptography (ECC), both of which are susceptible to quantum attacks. This paper conducts a large scale empirical evaluation of post-quantum readiness across 32,011 domains, with a primary focus on real-world TLS deployments across diverse sectors by analysing negotiated TLS parameters, including protocol versions, cipher suites, key exchange mechanisms, and certificates. The results indicate that while modern protocols like TLS 1.3 and QUIC are gaining adoption, 15.70% of domains especially in critical sectors such as banking and government still rely on TLS 1.2. Furthermore, 49.3% of domains support hybrid post-quantum key exchange mechanisms (e.g., MLKEM768 with X25519), whereas 50.7% continue to use classical key exchange, reflecting partial transition. Notably, 0% adoption of hybrid post-quantum certificates was observed, leaving the authentication layer vulnerable to quantum-enabled attacks such as certificate forgery. The findings reveal uneven adoption of post-quantum mechanisms across sectors, where technology driven platforms are advancing more rapidly than legacy-dependent infrastructures. Overall, the study highlights that achieving complete quantum resilience requires a coordinated transition not only in key exchange mechanisms but also in certificate infrastructures. Without such comprehensive migration, Internet communication systems remain vulnerable to long-term threats, including Harvest-Now-Decrypt-Later (HNDL) attacks.