There is a liquid that is not made of atoms in the ordinary sense but of the excitations of a Fermi sea, and for seventy years it has been the working language of every normal metal and of liquid helium-3. Lev Landau built that language in 1956 from a single correspondence idea: switch the interactions on slowly, and the interacting system's low-lying states stand in one-to-one correspondence with the free Fermi gas's — the quasiparticle. From it flow an effective mass, a specific heat linear in temperature with a computable enhancement, compressibility and susceptibility ratios, first sound, and the prediction of zero sound, a collective mode later found in nature. I credit all of it at full strength in this paper. What I evaluate is the correspondence's provenance, and the provenance of the numbers the machinery runs on. The correspondence is assumed, not proved: nothing in the 1956 paper shows it survives a real interaction, and its failures — a pairing instability in any attractive channel, the Mott transition, one dimension, where the quasiparticle pole dissolves entirely — were found by exception, not predicted from inside. The Landau parameters the theory runs on are per-material fitted inputs, an infinite tower truncated by hand, and its exact relations recombine them without deriving any: on my bench the effective-mass ratio runs from 0.033333 to 6.000000 as the single fitted input F₁ˢ runs from −2.90 to +15.00 — the output is the input, divided by three and shifted by one. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING — explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.
There is a liquid that is not made of atoms in the ordinary sense but of the excitations of a Fermi sea, and for seventy years it has been the working language of every normal metal and of liquid helium-3. Lev Landau built that language in 1956 from a single correspondence idea: switch the interactions on slowly, and the interacting system's low-lying states stand in one-to-one correspondence with the free Fermi gas's — the quasiparticle. From it flow an effective mass, a specific heat linear in temperature with a computable enhancement, compressibility and susceptibility ratios, first sound, and the prediction of zero sound, a collective mode later found in nature. I credit all of it at full strength in this paper. What I evaluate is the correspondence's provenance, and the provenance of the numbers the machinery runs on. The correspondence is assumed, not proved: nothing in the 1956 paper shows it survives a real interaction, and its failures — a pairing instability in any attractive channel, the Mott transition, one dimension, where the quasiparticle pole dissolves entirely — were found by exception, not predicted from inside. The Landau parameters the theory runs on are per-material fitted inputs, an infinite tower truncated by hand, and its exact relations recombine them without deriving any: on my bench the effective-mass ratio runs from 0.033333 to 6.000000 as the single fitted input F₁ˢ runs from −2.90 to +15.00 — the output is the input, divided by three and shifted by one. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING — explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.
Census evaluation (row CC-116) of the founding step of Landau's 'The Theory of a Fermi Liquid,' Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 30, 1058 (1956), with 'Oscillations in a Fermi Liquid,' 32, 59 (1957), against a fixed bench (what is postulated, what is derived, what the postulates return numerically, what they cannot reach). The step is one correspondence postulate -- the interacting system's low-lying states assumed in one-to-one adiabatic correspondence with the free Fermi gas's -- plus the per-material Landau parameter set, phenomenological inputs throughout (all notebook values are declared bench values, not any material's parameters). Verified in the notebook (9 checks, exit 0): m*/m = 1 + F1s/3 returns 1.000 / 1.500 / 2.000 / 2.800 / 3.000 across the declared grid with the specific-heat ratio equal to it; at one combined bench point the compressibility ratio is 0.1818 and the spin susceptibility ratio exactly 4.000; zero sound is solved exactly from the l = 0 dispersion relation, s = 1.0051 at F0s = 0.5 to 3.2568 at F0s = 30. Remainders at full size: no parameter is computed for any material; the stability boundaries are unguarded (compressibility ratio 200.00 at F0s = -0.99, diverging at -1; m*/m = 0.0333 at F1s = -2.9); and in any attractive pairing channel, however weak, the correspondence fails outright with no threshold. Scout-grade verification disclosed on the manuscript's face (CC-91 form): no verbatim quotation, no page-specific claim. EXTENSION. Vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED; quantum gravity NOT SOLVED.
Landau (1958) gave a rigorous microscopic derivation of his phenomenological Fermi -liquid theory starting from the first principles Hamiltonian of strongly interacting Fermions. The derivation is based on an asymptotic expansion in small parameters such as q/kF, bc.>/EF, kT/EF, where q and c.> represent the wave numbers and frequencies of real excitations of the system. Landau showed that the dynamics of these low-lying excitations (quasiparticles and collective modes) is governed by classical transport equations with all quantum many-body effects absorbed into effective interaction parameters. Landau's approach has been generalized to superfluid Fermi liquids and superconductors by Leggett (1965) and, going beyond linear response, by Eliashberg (1971). Their ideas merged into a recent review on the quasiclassical approach to superfluid 3 He by Serene and Rainer (1983). I will use the notation of this review throughout this paper. Landau's transport theory together with its offsprings will be called 'quasiclassical theory in the following. In this context it is important to mention that Eilenberger (1968) and Larkin and Ovchinnikov (1968) have shown that the complete theory of superconductors can be formulated as a quasiclassical transport theory. Surprisingly, this theory permits calculating microscopic properties, e.g. the quasiparticle excitation spectrum, which are predominantly governed by quantum effects.
It is quite beyond the purpose of this book to give a comprehensive review of the modern theory of metals. I shall touch only on those topics which are related to the mainstream of this course: the problem of strong interactions. As I have noted before, strong interactions can appear as a result of renormalization, and from the aesthetic point of view this is, perhaps, the most interesting case. As we shall see in Part IV, such renormalizations are particularly strong in one-dimensional systems, where practically any interaction leads to quite dramatic effects. Therefore a one-dimensional electron gas neither undergoes a phase transition (this is forbidden due to the low dimensionality), nor behaves like a system of free electrons. On the contrary, in higher dimensions at low temperatures a system of electrons either undergoes a phase transition (superconductivity, magnetic ordering, etc.), or behaves like a free electron gas. When temperatures as low as several degrees became experimentally available, physicists discovered that an enormous amount of experimental data on normal metals can be described by the model where one neglects electron–electron interactions. This apparent miracle was explained by Landau who demonstrated that the interaction pattern drastically simplifies close to the Fermi surface. Provided the system does not undergo a symmetry breaking phase transition, all interactions except forward scattering effectively vanish on the Fermi surface and low-lying excitations carry quantum numbers of electrons. Therefore they are called quasi-particles . The meaning of the word quasi will become clear in a moment.
The microscopic theory of a superfluid Fermi liquid at finite temperature is developed for the case of a pure system with S-wave pairing, and applied to the calculation of the static properties. As a function of $\ensuremath{\theta}\ensuremath{\equiv}\frac{T}{{T}_{c}}$ these properties are determined entirely by the Landau parameters F0, F1, Z0, etc., characterizing quasiparticle interactions in the normal phase. In particular the spin susceptibility $\ensuremath{\chi}$ and the density of the normal component ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{n}$ are given by $\frac{\ensuremath{\chi}(\ensuremath{\theta})}{\ensuremath{\chi}(1)}=(1+\frac{1}{4}{Z}_{0})\frac{f(\ensuremath{\theta})}{[1+\frac{1}{4}{Z}_{0}f(\ensuremath{\theta})]},$ $\frac{{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{n}}{\ensuremath{\rho}}=(1+\frac{1}{3}{F}_{1})\frac{f(\ensuremath{\theta})}{[1+\frac{1}{3}{F}_{1}f(\ensuremath{\theta})]},$ where the universal function $f(\ensuremath{\theta})\ensuremath{\equiv}\ensuremath{-}{[\ensuremath{\nu}(0)]}^{\ensuremath{-}1}{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\mathrm{p}}(\frac{\mathrm{dn}}{d{E}_{\mathrm{p}}})$ is the "effective density of states near the Fermi surface" relative to its value $\ensuremath{\nu}(0)$ in the normal phase. Thus the often-quoted expression ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{n}=\frac{1}{3}{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\mathrm{p}}{\mathrm{p}}^{2}(\frac{\mathrm{dn}}{d{E}_{\mathrm{p}}})$ is valid for an interacting system only in the limit $T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$. In the latter part of the paper a simple phenomenological theory of "Fermi-liquid" effects on $\ensuremath{\chi}$ and ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{n}$ is developed for arbitrary conditions (including the presence of impurities and pairing with $l\ensuremath{\ne}0$); it is found that under most circumstances explicit expressions for $\ensuremath{\chi}$ and ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{n}$ may be obtained which involve only the Landau parameters and a suitably generalized effective density of states. The theory should apply to the possible superfluid phase of He3 and to most superconductors. It is suggested that the Knight shift in nontransition-metal superconductors should display some "Fermi-liquid" effects. The weak-field dc penetration depth $\ensuremath{\lambda}(T)$ is shown to be insensitive to such effects both in the Pippard limit and near Tc; however, in a London superconductor at lower temperatures the correction to $\ensuremath{\lambda}(T)$ should be observable and yield a direct estimate of F1.
This paper is a short review on the foundations and recent advances in the microscopic Fermiliquid (FL) theory.We demonstrate that this theory is built on five identities, which follow from conservation of total charge (particle number), spin, and momentum in a translationally and SU (2)invariant FL.These identities allows one to express the effective mass and quasiparticle residue in terms of an exact vertex function and also impose constraints on the "quasiparticle" and "incoherent" (or "low-energy" and "high-energy") contributions to the observable quantities.Such constraints forbid certain Pomeranchuk instabilities of a FL, e.g., towards phases with order parameters that coincide with charge and spin currents.We provide diagrammatic derivations of these constraints and of the general (Leggett) formula for the susceptibility in arbitrary angular momentum channel, and illustrate the general relations through simple examples treated in the perturbation theory.It is our great pleasure to write this article for the special volume in celebration of the 85th birthday of Lev Petrovich Pitaevskii, who, in our view, is one the greatest physicist of his generation and the model of a scientist and citizen.His seminal volumes on Statistical Physics (with E. M. Lifshitz), 1 Physical Kinetics 2 (also with E. M. Lifshitz), and Quantum Electrodynamics 3 (with V. B. Berestetskii and E. M. Lifshitz), all parts of the Landau and Lifshitz Course on Theoretical Physics, as well as on Bose-Einstein condensation and superfluidity 4 (with S. Stringari) are not only used by every contemporary physicist but also, as we are positive, will serve the future generations of scientists from around the world.The paper we present for this volume is devoted to the microscopic theory of a Fermi liquid, which was pioneered by Lev Petrovich in the early 1960s.The general relations he obtained with Landau, which express the effective mass m * /m and the quasiparticle residue Z in terms of the vertex function (the Pitaevskii-Landau relations), set the gold standard for many-body theory.We hope that Lev Petrovich and other readers of this volume will find our summary of recent developments in this field interesting.
In 1920 Wilhelm Lenz simplified the magnet to two-valued variables on a lattice, and in 1925 Ernst Ising solved the one-dimensional case of that simplification in his doctoral thesis, a problem suggested to him by Lenz. I credit those papers at full strength: they produced the first exactly soluble model of a magnet, an exact negative result in one dimension, and, through the later exact two-dimensional solution at this same address, the founding landmark of the modern theory of critical phenomena and universality. Nothing in this paper falsifies a result derived inside the model, and nothing in it disputes the model's organising power. What I evaluate is the standing of the model itself in 1920 and 1925. A magnet is replaced, by postulation, with variables sigma_i = ±1 on a lattice, interacting only as nearest neighbours through a single coupling J in H = -J sum over nearest-neighbour pairs of sigma_i sigma_j. The continuous moment, its transverse components, every longer-range interaction and every multi-spin interaction are deleted, and J is a free parameter that no step in 1920 or 1925 sets from the material. My bench evaluates what that postulation carries, on declared inputs only. In two dimensions, on a square lattice, the exact condition sinh(2/t_c) = 1 returns t_c = 2.269185, where t = k_B T / J, with sinh(2/t_c) = 1.000000 at that point; mean field, with coordination number z = 4, returns 4.000000, an overstatement of 76.274717 per cent. The spontaneous magnetisation in Yang's form is M = 0.999276 at t = 1, M = 0.911319 at t = 2 and M = 0.671854 at t = 2.25, and it is zero at and above t_c. In one dimension, Ising's own case, the exact critical temperature is 0.000000, while mean field, with z = 2, invents a transition at 2.000000; the correlation length xi/a = 27.296022 at t = 0.5, 3.671861 at t = 1, 1.295443 at t = 2 and 0.710818 at t = 4, finite at every temperature above zero. Counted plainly: 1 postulated Hamiltonian, carrying 1 fitted coupling and 2 deletion classes, against 0 derivations in 1920 and 1925. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: **REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING** — PREMISE-ONLY, explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: **vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.**