Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Physical Chemistry C

Correlation-Driven Orbital Optimization in One-Dimensional Hubbard Systems

Federico Zorzenon, Guillaume Rouaut, Masahisa Tsuchiizu, Vincent Robert

Published Nov 5, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract The flexibility afforded by molecular orbitals plays a central role in the development of quantum-chemical methods. In this work, we investigate the electronic structure of delocalized half-filled one-dimensional symmetric AA and asymmetric AB systems described by the Hubbard Hamiltonian through a bottom-up strategy designed to assess the performance of a two-step procedure. The proposed framework aims at constructing a correlated wave function, thereby providing a complementary perspective to conventional band-structure descriptions. In a first step, Rayleigh–Schrödinger perturbation theory is applied to a zeroth-order local valence-bond ground state in order to incorporate charge-transfer configurations and account for short-range delocalization effects. In a second step, the resulting second-order energy is minimized with respect to orbital rotations. Starting from the canonical molecular orbitals obtained from the one-electron part of the Hubbard Hamiltonian, the method is benchmarked against exact cluster calculations for both symmetric AA and asymmetric AB systems. Although the second-order energy correction in symmetric systems is insensitive to the choice of the molecular orbitals, electron–electron interactions in asymmetric systems drive departures from the canonical orbital representation, emphasizing the role of local electronic correlations in determining the optimal orbital framework. Beyond its quantitative performance, the present approach complements the conventional Bloch-function picture and offers a chemically intuitive interpretation for extended systems.

DOI
10.1021/acs.jpcc.6c04805

Related papers

Orbital Optimization in the Resonating Hartree-Fock Approximation and Its Application to the One Dimensional Hubbard Model

Atsushi Ikawa, Shoji Yamamoto, Hideo Fukutome

A tractable direct optimization algorithm is developed to optimize orbitals in the Slater determinants (S-dets) in a resonating Hartree-Fock (Res HF) wave function. We reduce the variation space using the orbitals to put the first order energy variation in the steepest descent direction. The orbitals in the next iteration are determined so as to minimize the energy functional including up to the second order variation. This algorithm is applied to the one dimensional Hubbard model of half-filling. The optimized S-dets much deviate from the trial S-dets prepared from the HF calculations. The Res HF ground state generated with a few S-dets explains from 99.9 to 95.0% of the ground state correlation energy in all the correlation regimes. We have spin correlation functions with the correct short and long range behaviors and the lowest triplet and singlet spin excitations with correct dispersions, suggesting that the optimization of orbitals incorporates long range spin fluctuations and their mode-mode couplings.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•May 15, 1993•41 citations

THE VARIATIONAL TWO-ELECTRON REDUCED-DENSITY-MATRIX METHOD FOR EXTENDED SYSTEMS

Nicholas C. Rubin

In this thesis we develop the variational two-electron reduced-density-matrix method for extended systems. Extended systems are represented in two ways: i) lattice models describing the dominant valence electronic structure with periodic boundaries to account for their extended nature and ii) a crystalline-orbital basis built from atomic orbitals using the generalization of molecular orbital theory to polymers. The first part of this thesis (Ch. 3-4) examines the performance of the variational 2-RDM method on lattice systems with tunable electron correlation. The first of these systems is the classic Hubbard model with linear and ladder lattice topologies. Because electron correlation functions, such as charge- and spin-ordering, are linear functions of the 2-RDM, the difference in electronic structure between one- and quasi-one-dimensional systems is accurately characterized. The second model contains only two-body interactions and is unique among typical spin models in that it does not have a mean-field reference wave function. The ground state wave functions from all Hamiltonians in the model have the same 1-electron reduced density matrix; consequently, one-electron theories are largely inapplicable. The superconducting eta-pairing ground states make the model a unique tool for demonstrating the necessary N-representability in highly correlated environments. The second part of this thesis (Ch. 5-6) develops a formalism for modeling materials by solving the full Schrodinger equation. Crystalline-orbital Hartree-Fock provides a set of orbitals and integral tensors for the variational 2-RDM method. We demonstrate that time-reversal symmetry, which is implicitly included in position space electronic structure calculations, must be explicitly included as an N-representability constraint on the 2-RDM when using a momentum space basis. The necessity of these equality constraints is demonstrated by the accurate recovery of the binding energy of two polymers and the symmetry of their natural orbital occupations.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

From one-electron to correlated wave functions in extended systems: A valence-bond investigation

Marie-Bernadette Lepetit, Brahim Oujia, Jean‐Paul Malrieu +1 more

One-electron wave functions of half-filled-band closed-shell systems have been decomposed into their orthogonal single-determinant valence-bond (VB) components (antisymmetrized products of orthogonal atomic orbitals). Despite the ordering effect of the Fermi hole among electrons of the same spin, favoring spin-density and charge-density waves, the relative independence between the \ensuremath{\alpha} and \ensuremath{\beta} parts of the wave function results in an overestimation of the weight of multiply ionic structures. Comparison is made with the internally correlated functions for different graphs and Hamiltonians (Hubbard, Pariser-Parr-Pople, and ab initio types). The scaling effect of the correlation does not appear as essentially dependent on the ionicity of the VB forms but exponentially linked to the mean energy of each VB component.

Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1989•19 citations

Development and applications of density matrix functional theory of generalized Hubbard Models

Matthieu Saubanère

In this Thesis, we develop and apply an accurate method to determine the ground-state properties of strongly-correlated electrons in the framework of lattice model Hamiltonians. In lattice density-functional theory (LDFT) the basic variable is the one-particle density matrix γ. From a generalized HK theorem, the ground state energy Egs[γgs] = minγ E[γ] is obtained by minimizing the energy-functional E[γ] over all the physical or representable γ. The energy functional can be divided into two contributions: the kinetic-energy functional T [γ], which linear dependence on γ is exactly known, and the correlation-energy functional W [γ], which dependence on γ is not explicitly known. Finding accurate approximations for W [γ] constitutes the actual challenge of this thesis. Part of this work is based on previous studies which derive an approximation of W [γ] for the Hubbard Hamiltonian based on scaling hypothesis and an exact analytical results for the Hubbard dimer. However, this approach is limited to spin independent and homogeneous systems. In order to extend the scope of LDFT, we have developed three different approaches to derive W [γ] in order to study broken symmetry problems. First we extend the previous scaling functional to system having charge transfer. By a systematic study of the dependence of W [γ] on the charge distribution we find similar scaling properties as for the homogeneous case. An extension to the Hubbard model on bipartite lattices is then derived and applied to finite and infinite systems with repulsive and attractive interactions. The high accuracy of this functional is demonstrated. Nevertheless, this approach is difficult to transfer to more complex systems, since the calculation of W [γ] applies to the system as a whole. To overcome this problem, we derive another approximation based on local scaling properties. This functional is formulated on-site so that it can be applied to any ordered or disordered Hamiltonian with on-site interaction. As applications we study the metal-insulator transition in the ionic Hubbard model in oneand two-dimensions, as well as the one-dimensional Hubbard chain with first and second nearest neighbor hoppings. Finally, we develop a numerical approach of W [γ], on the basis on exact diagonalizations of an effective many-body Hamiltonian corresponding to a cluster surrounded by an effective medium. This effective Hamiltonian depends on the density matrix γ and allows to derive approximation to W [γ] which improve systematically with increasing cluster size. The formulation is spin-dependent and allows a straightforward generalization to multi-orbital correlated systems such spd-Hamiltonians. In addition it take into account the effects of short-range charge and spin fluctuations in the functional. The accuracy of the method is demonstrated for the Hubbard model by comparison with the Bethe-Ansatz solution (1D) and quantum Monte Carlo simulations (2D). Finally, an outlook or relevant future developments of the theory is provided.

•Jan 25, 2012•0 citations

Coupled cluster treatments of periodic systems from strongly localized reference functions: 1-D and 2-D spin and electron lattices

Beatriz Miguel, Maixent Cousy, Jean‐Paul Malrieu

A modified coupled cluster method is applied to the research of the ground-state energy of periodic systems described by model Hamiltonians. The reference function is always a strongly localized function. The method is applied first to Heisenberg Hamiltonians and spin-frustrated one-dimensional (1-D) chain and square lattices, starting from Neel functions or from products of bond singlets. The same method is then applied to Hubbard Hamiltonian for 1-D chain and two-dimensional (2-D) square lattices starting from Neel function or products of bond molecular orbitals (MOs). In both cases the wave operators involve a very limited number of local operators. Despite its simplicity, the method is able to treat quite satisfactorily highly degenerate situations, approaching correctly the highly delocalized regime from the Neel function or the highly correlated regime from a product of bond MOs. However, the method is not precise enough to treat the subtle phenomenon of bond alternation of polyacetylene. The coupled cluster method from strongly localized reference functions represents an elegant and quite efficient exploratory tool, but its accuracy is limited by the poor treatment of collective effects. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Int J Quant Chem 67: 115–132, 1998

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jan 1, 1998•5 citations

Orbital-Rotated Fermi-Hubbard Model as a Benchmarking Problem for Quantum Chemistry with the Exact Solution

Ryota Kojima, Masahiko Kamoshita, Keita Kanno

Quantum chemistry is a key target for quantum computing, but benchmarking quantum algorithms for large molecular systems remains challenging due to the lack of exactly solvable yet structurally realistic models. In particular, molecular Hamiltonians typically contain$O\left(N^{4}\right)$Pauli terms, significantly increasing the cost of quantum simulations, while many exactly solvable models, such as the one-dimensional Fermi-Hubbard (1D FH) model, contain only$O(N)$terms. In this work, we introduce the orbital-rotated Fermi-Hubbard (ORFH) model as a scalable and exactly solvable benchmarking problem for quantum chemistry algorithms. Starting from the 1D FH model, we apply a spin-involved orbital rotation to construct a Hamiltonian that retains the exact ground-state energy but exhibits a Pauli term count scaling as$O\left(N^{4}\right)$, similar to real molecular systems. We analyze the ORFH Hamiltonian from multiple perspectives, including operator norm and electronic correlation. We benchmark variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) optimizers and Pauli term grouping methods, and compare their performance with those for hydrogen chains. Furthermore, we show that the ORFH Hamiltonian increases the computational difficulty for classical methods such as the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG), offering a nontrivial benchmark beyond quantum algorithms. Our results demonstrate that the ORFH model provides a versatile and scalable testbed for benchmarking quantum chemistry algorithms under realistic structural conditions, while maintaining exact solvability even at large system sizes.

arXiv:2402.11869•IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Aug 30, 2025•4 citations
Abstract The flexibility afforded by molecular orbitals plays a central role in the development of quantum-chemical methods. In this work, we investigate the electronic structure of delocalized half-filled one-dimensional symmetric AA and asymmetric AB systems described by the Hubbard Hamiltonian through a bottom-up strategy designed to assess the performance of a two-step procedure. The proposed framework aims at constructing a correlated wave function, thereby providing a complementary perspective to conventional band-structure descriptions. In a first step, Rayleigh–Schrödinger perturbation theory is applied to a zeroth-order local valence-bond ground state in order to incorporate charge-transfer configurations and account for short-range delocalization effects. In a second step, the resulting second-order energy is minimized with respect to orbital rotations. Starting from the canonical molecular orbitals obtained from the one-electron part of the Hubbard Hamiltonian, the method is benchmarked against exact cluster calculations for both symmetric AA and asymmetric AB systems. Although the second-order energy correction in symmetric systems is insensitive to the choice of the molecular orbitals, electron–electron interactions in asymmetric systems drive departures from the canonical orbital representation, emphasizing the role of local electronic correlations in determining the optimal orbital framework. Beyond its quantitative performance, the present approach complements the conventional Bloch-function picture and offers a chemically intuitive interpretation for extended systems.
A tractable direct optimization algorithm is developed to optimize orbitals in the Slater determinants (S-dets) in a resonating Hartree-Fock (Res HF) wave function. We reduce the variation space using the orbitals to put the first order energy variation in the steepest descent direction. The orbitals in the next iteration are determined so as to minimize the energy functional including up to the second order variation. This algorithm is applied to the one dimensional Hubbard model of half-filling. The optimized S-dets much deviate from the trial S-dets prepared from the HF calculations. The Res HF ground state generated with a few S-dets explains from 99.9 to 95.0% of the ground state correlation energy in all the correlation regimes. We have spin correlation functions with the correct short and long range behaviors and the lowest triplet and singlet spin excitations with correct dispersions, suggesting that the optimization of orbitals incorporates long range spin fluctuations and their mode-mode couplings.
In this thesis we develop the variational two-electron reduced-density-matrix method for extended systems. Extended systems are represented in two ways: i) lattice models describing the dominant valence electronic structure with periodic boundaries to account for their extended nature and ii) a crystalline-orbital basis built from atomic orbitals using the generalization of molecular orbital theory to polymers. The first part of this thesis (Ch. 3-4) examines the performance of the variational 2-RDM method on lattice systems with tunable electron correlation. The first of these systems is the classic Hubbard model with linear and ladder lattice topologies. Because electron correlation functions, such as charge- and spin-ordering, are linear functions of the 2-RDM, the difference in electronic structure between one- and quasi-one-dimensional systems is accurately characterized. The second model contains only two-body interactions and is unique among typical spin models in that it does not have a mean-field reference wave function. The ground state wave functions from all Hamiltonians in the model have the same 1-electron reduced density matrix; consequently, one-electron theories are largely inapplicable. The superconducting eta-pairing ground states make the model a unique tool for demonstrating the necessary N-representability in highly correlated environments. The second part of this thesis (Ch. 5-6) develops a formalism for modeling materials by solving the full Schrodinger equation. Crystalline-orbital Hartree-Fock provides a set of orbitals and integral tensors for the variational 2-RDM method. We demonstrate that time-reversal symmetry, which is implicitly included in position space electronic structure calculations, must be explicitly included as an N-representability constraint on the 2-RDM when using a momentum space basis. The necessity of these equality constraints is demonstrated by the accurate recovery of the binding energy of two polymers and the symmetry of their natural orbital occupations.
One-electron wave functions of half-filled-band closed-shell systems have been decomposed into their orthogonal single-determinant valence-bond (VB) components (antisymmetrized products of orthogonal atomic orbitals). Despite the ordering effect of the Fermi hole among electrons of the same spin, favoring spin-density and charge-density waves, the relative independence between the \ensuremath{\alpha} and \ensuremath{\beta} parts of the wave function results in an overestimation of the weight of multiply ionic structures. Comparison is made with the internally correlated functions for different graphs and Hamiltonians (Hubbard, Pariser-Parr-Pople, and ab initio types). The scaling effect of the correlation does not appear as essentially dependent on the ionicity of the VB forms but exponentially linked to the mean energy of each VB component.
In this Thesis, we develop and apply an accurate method to determine the ground-state properties of strongly-correlated electrons in the framework of lattice model Hamiltonians. In lattice density-functional theory (LDFT) the basic variable is the one-particle density matrix γ. From a generalized HK theorem, the ground state energy Egs[γgs] = minγ E[γ] is obtained by minimizing the energy-functional E[γ] over all the physical or representable γ. The energy functional can be divided into two contributions: the kinetic-energy functional T [γ], which linear dependence on γ is exactly known, and the correlation-energy functional W [γ], which dependence on γ is not explicitly known. Finding accurate approximations for W [γ] constitutes the actual challenge of this thesis. Part of this work is based on previous studies which derive an approximation of W [γ] for the Hubbard Hamiltonian based on scaling hypothesis and an exact analytical results for the Hubbard dimer. However, this approach is limited to spin independent and homogeneous systems. In order to extend the scope of LDFT, we have developed three different approaches to derive W [γ] in order to study broken symmetry problems. First we extend the previous scaling functional to system having charge transfer. By a systematic study of the dependence of W [γ] on the charge distribution we find similar scaling properties as for the homogeneous case. An extension to the Hubbard model on bipartite lattices is then derived and applied to finite and infinite systems with repulsive and attractive interactions. The high accuracy of this functional is demonstrated. Nevertheless, this approach is difficult to transfer to more complex systems, since the calculation of W [γ] applies to the system as a whole. To overcome this problem, we derive another approximation based on local scaling properties. This functional is formulated on-site so that it can be applied to any ordered or disordered Hamiltonian with on-site interaction. As applications we study the metal-insulator transition in the ionic Hubbard model in oneand two-dimensions, as well as the one-dimensional Hubbard chain with first and second nearest neighbor hoppings. Finally, we develop a numerical approach of W [γ], on the basis on exact diagonalizations of an effective many-body Hamiltonian corresponding to a cluster surrounded by an effective medium. This effective Hamiltonian depends on the density matrix γ and allows to derive approximation to W [γ] which improve systematically with increasing cluster size. The formulation is spin-dependent and allows a straightforward generalization to multi-orbital correlated systems such spd-Hamiltonians. In addition it take into account the effects of short-range charge and spin fluctuations in the functional. The accuracy of the method is demonstrated for the Hubbard model by comparison with the Bethe-Ansatz solution (1D) and quantum Monte Carlo simulations (2D). Finally, an outlook or relevant future developments of the theory is provided.
A modified coupled cluster method is applied to the research of the ground-state energy of periodic systems described by model Hamiltonians. The reference function is always a strongly localized function. The method is applied first to Heisenberg Hamiltonians and spin-frustrated one-dimensional (1-D) chain and square lattices, starting from Neel functions or from products of bond singlets. The same method is then applied to Hubbard Hamiltonian for 1-D chain and two-dimensional (2-D) square lattices starting from Neel function or products of bond molecular orbitals (MOs). In both cases the wave operators involve a very limited number of local operators. Despite its simplicity, the method is able to treat quite satisfactorily highly degenerate situations, approaching correctly the highly delocalized regime from the Neel function or the highly correlated regime from a product of bond MOs. However, the method is not precise enough to treat the subtle phenomenon of bond alternation of polyacetylene. The coupled cluster method from strongly localized reference functions represents an elegant and quite efficient exploratory tool, but its accuracy is limited by the poor treatment of collective effects. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Int J Quant Chem 67: 115–132, 1998
Quantum chemistry is a key target for quantum computing, but benchmarking quantum algorithms for large molecular systems remains challenging due to the lack of exactly solvable yet structurally realistic models. In particular, molecular Hamiltonians typically containO(N4)O\left(N^{4}\right)O(N4)Pauli terms, significantly increasing the cost of quantum simulations, while many exactly solvable models, such as the one-dimensional Fermi-Hubbard (1D FH) model, contain onlyO(N)O(N)O(N)terms. In this work, we introduce the orbital-rotated Fermi-Hubbard (ORFH) model as a scalable and exactly solvable benchmarking problem for quantum chemistry algorithms. Starting from the 1D FH model, we apply a spin-involved orbital rotation to construct a Hamiltonian that retains the exact ground-state energy but exhibits a Pauli term count scaling asO(N4)O\left(N^{4}\right)O(N4), similar to real molecular systems. We analyze the ORFH Hamiltonian from multiple perspectives, including operator norm and electronic correlation. We benchmark variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) optimizers and Pauli term grouping methods, and compare their performance with those for hydrogen chains. Furthermore, we show that the ORFH Hamiltonian increases the computational difficulty for classical methods such as the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG), offering a nontrivial benchmark beyond quantum algorithms. Our results demonstrate that the ORFH model provides a versatile and scalable testbed for benchmarking quantum chemistry algorithms under realistic structural conditions, while maintaining exact solvability even at large system sizes.