Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Principle of Information Set Superposition: An Empirical Study on the Nature of Superposition States and Observational Collapse

Jiale Wu

Published Nov 4, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In traditional quantum mechanical interpretations, "superposition states" are often understood as physical objects simultaneously existing in multiple mutually exclusive states, and "observational collapse" is understood as an abrupt change of the physical ontology during observation. This paper points out that this understanding confuses the physical ontological layer with the information derivative layer, incorrectly projecting the coexistence of multiple candidates at the information level as an objective superposition of the physical ontology. Building upon the "Ontology-Information Dichotomy Framework" and the "Principle of Ontological Statistical Convergence," this paper proposes the Principle of Information Set Superposition: The physical ontology always maintains a unique truth value, and there is no state branching at the ontological level. The so-called superposition of multiple possibilities is the coexistence of multiple candidate results within the observer's information set under the condition of an information gap ; as effective information is input ( decreases), eliminates contradictory candidates and continuously contracts; when information is complete , collapses to a single truth value. This paper designs four groups of lottery jar controlled experiments (different prior information groups, zero-information blind state group, incremental information group, false information group). Keeping the physical ontology constant, only the information input to the observer is altered to empirically demonstrate that the possibility set is constructed by information pruning. This paper reinterprets the information essence of Schrödinger's cat as a typical case, and strictly states: if one assumes ontological superposition in microscopic quantum systems, independent experimental evidence is required; however, regarding phenomena alone, the information set mechanism can perfectly reproduce all observations. The main text strictly strips away subjective consciousness and free will, relegating them only as an independent philosophical extension in the Appendix.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23935441

Related papers

Reinterpreting Schrodinger's Cat Through the Informational Observer Framework

Greco, Giuseppe Junior

Schrodinger's cat is traditionally presented as a paradox highlighting the tension between quantum superposition and classical observation. Standard interpretations invoke either a fundamental wavefunction collapse, ontological branching of universes, or subjective Bayesian updating. In this paper, we propose a reinterpretation grounded in the Informational Observer Framework, according to which the paradox does not originate from an ontological superposition of macroscopic states, but from an unresolved informational configuration at the observer level. The cat itself is never simultaneously alive and dead; rather, the observer remains in a state of informational compression prior to interaction. Within this framework, wavefunction collapse is reinterpreted as an observer-level informational phase transition, not as a fundamental physical discontinuity. This approach preserves macroscopic realism, avoids ontological inflation, and reframes the measurement problem as an emergent informational phenomenon.

•Dec 15, 2025•0 citations

No Quantum Superposition: A Reductio ad Absurdum from Seven Independent Physical Principles

YOUNG HO GOH

The standard interpretation of quantum mechanics holds that a particle exists in a superposition of multiple states prior to measurement — that it simultaneously occupies more than one location, or simultaneously possesses more than one value of an observable. This paper argues, by reductio ad absurdum, that the physical realisation of superposition — simultaneous multi-location existence — is incompatible with seven independent and well-established physical principles: (1) the observational fact that no infinite physical quantity has ever been measured; (2) conservation of energy; (3) the mass-energy equivalence E = mc²; (4) the Bekenstein entropy bound; (5) the second law of thermodynamics; (6) the Heisenberg uncertainty principle; and (7) causality. The argument proceeds through a foundational identification: information, energy, and mass stand in proportional existential relation, established by the Bekenstein bound (I ∝ M), Landauer's principle (E ∝ I), and mass-energy equivalence (E = mc²). Given this proportionality, the infinite information-processing load required by complete superposition implies infinite energy and infinite mass — quantities that are universally absent from the observational record of physics. Finite N-state superposition is excluded by a complementary argument: maintaining N states simultaneously requires N times the information-processing load of a single undetermined state, violating the principle that nature selects minimum-load configurations. The physical alternative proposed is the undetermined state: during propagation, the matter wave is real and physically present, but matter has not yet appeared at any location. This is not a hidden-variable state — no definite position exists to be hidden — but an ontological absence of localisation prior to the formation of a constructive interference maximum. The present paper does not claim to determine which path matter takes; it claims to demonstrate that simultaneous multi-location existence is physically impossible. The undetermined state is the unique physically consistent alternative. Experimental consequences and the connection to the double-slit experiment are developed in a companion paper.

•Apr 22, 2026•0 citations

The Ontology-Information Dichotomy Framework: The Truth Identity Axiom and Empirical Evidence for Macroscopic Apparent Randomness

Jiale Wu

If all hidden variables behind so‑called intrinsic randomness were known to me, would it still be intrinsic randomness? This question exposes a fatal logical impasse within traditional physics: the moment complete information () is achieved, random phenomena vanish. Therefore, all observable randomness in reality is structurally tied to an information gap. This paper proposes the "Ontology‑Information Dichotomy Framework" and the "Theorem of Information Gap‑Randomness Necessity". Through time‑sequence‑separated macroscopic dice‑cup experiments (decoupling physical perturbation from information occlusion) and control tests with AI vision algorithms, we empirically demonstrate that apparent randomness is an inevitable product of finite physical information systems under , independent of biological consciousness. We further prove that unobservable hidden variables and pure observational information deficiency are observationally equivalent. Any claim of "intrinsic randomness" lacking decisive evidence under complete‑input conditions () is either a self‑contradictory notion or a metaphysical presupposition. Ranging from engineering encapsulation (e.g., lotteries, PRNGs) to microscopic quantum scenarios, apparent randomness strictly derived from the information gap constitutes the only empirically supported and logically self‑consistent mechanism.

•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics and Reality: An Interpretation of Everett's Theory.

Christoph Lehner

The central part of Everett's formulation of quantum mechanics is a quantum mechanical model of memory and of observation as the recording of information in a memory. To use this model as an answer to the measurement problem, Everett has to assume that a conscious observer can be in a superposition of such memory states and be unaware of it. This assumption has puzzled generations of readers. The fundamental aim of this dissertation is to find a set of simpler assumptions which are sufficient to show that Everett's model is empirically adequate. I argue that Everett's model needs three assumptions to account for the process of observation: an assumption of decoherence of observers as quantum mechanical systems; an assumption of supervenience of mental states (qualities) over quantum mechanical properties; and an assumption about the interpretation of quantum mechanical states in general: quantum mechanical states describe ensembles of states of affairs coexisting in the same system. I argue that the only plausible understanding of such ensembles is as ensembles of possibilities, and that all standard no-collapse interpretations agree in this reading of quantum mechanical states. Their differences can be understood as different theories about what marks the real state within this ensemble, and Everett's theory as the claim that no additional 'mark of reality' is necessary. Using the three assumptions, I argue that introspection cannot determine the objective quantum mechanical state of an observer. Rather, the introspective qualities of a quantum mechanical state can be represented by a (classical) statistical ensemble of subjective states. An analysis of these subjective states and their dynamics leads to the conclusion that they suffice to give empirically correct predictions. The argument for the empirical adequacy of the subjective state entails that knowledge of the objective quantum mechanical state is impossible in principle. Empirical reality for a conscious observer is not described by the objective state, but by a Everettian relative state conditional on the subjective state, and no theoretical 'mark of reality' is necessary for this concept of reality. I compare the resulting concept of reality to Kant's distinction between empirical and transcendental reality.

•Jan 1, 1997•4 citations

The Quantum Measurement Problem and the Decoherence Programme: The Physical Mechanisms of the First Two Layers and a "Gentle Collapse" Interpretation for the Third

yuguo li

On the basis of decoherence theory and quantum Darwinism, this paper proposes a “gentle collapse” interpretive scheme within the framework of the many-worlds interpretation. Its core assertion is: the state vector is the sole physical reality, not confined to four-dimensional spacetime. The four-dimensional physical world we experience is a single branch that a local observer fixes from the state vector by spending entropy. Probability is an intrinsic property of the state vector. The other possibilities are never locally fixed. This scheme yields physically distinguishable predictions from the many-worlds interpretation at the mesoscopic scale after decoherence is complete: because the many-worlds interpretation commits to all branches being equally physically real, it must expect thermodynamic signatures of residual interactions between branches; the gentle collapse scheme, by declaring that after decoherence is complete the other branches can no longer produce distinguishable physical effects through the local heat bath, expects zero such signatures. The “operational zero” is not an absolute ontological prohibition, but an operational boundary relative to the local observer’s current heat bath; when the heat bath is enlarged, information that was previously unfixed can re-enter the accessible domain. This “zero expectation” is strictly defined by the “operational zero” determined by the second law of thermodynamics via Landauer’s principle, constituting a criterion that is in principle experimentally testable. The paper further argues that acknowledging intrinsic probability and acknowledging the failure of deterministic causality for single events are two equivalent formulations of the same ontological decision, and that the gentle collapse scheme possesses independent advantages in theoretical economy and ontological consistency.

•May 27, 2026•0 citations

The Illusion of Superposition: Structural Deformation of the Quantum Field and the Spasm Model

Teimuraz Matkava, Teimuraz Matkava

Modern quantum mechanics, despite its flawless mathematical apparatus, has been in a deep ontological crisis for over a century. The traditional Copenhagen interpretation has introduced philosophical mysticism and absurd paradoxes into the description of the microworld, such as the famous mental experiments of "Schrödinger's cat." The orthodox claim that a particle exists simultaneously in multiple mutually exclusive states before measurement (quantum superposition) contradicts the most fundamental ontological law of existence. We have built this paper on a new, solid, realistic postulate, which at the same time represents an ontological axiom: Any object at a given moment in time exists only in one specific and definite physical state. Superposition is not an objective reality—it represents merely a mathematical tool for describing the system. Instead of splitting the universe into two, where the macro- and microworlds operate by different logics, we propose a unified causal model. The fundamental substance of the microworld is a continuous quantum field, the vibration of which before measurement manifests as a real physical wave. The act of measurement is not a "passive observation," but rather a harsh physical intervention. When a macroscopic instrument touches the wave structure of the field, an instantaneous non-linear reaction is born—a quantum spasm (a local phase transition), which instantly condenses the wave into a point-like particle. This article describes in detail the mechanism of this spasm and its connection with the structural deformation of the quantum field.

•Jul 16, 2026•0 citations
In traditional quantum mechanical interpretations, "superposition states" are often understood as physical objects simultaneously existing in multiple mutually exclusive states, and "observational collapse" is understood as an abrupt change of the physical ontology during observation. This paper points out that this understanding confuses the physical ontological layer with the information derivative layer, incorrectly projecting the coexistence of multiple candidates at the information level as an objective superposition of the physical ontology. Building upon the "Ontology-Information Dichotomy Framework" and the "Principle of Ontological Statistical Convergence," this paper proposes the Principle of Information Set Superposition: The physical ontology always maintains a unique truth value, and there is no state branching at the ontological level. The so-called superposition of multiple possibilities is the coexistence of multiple candidate results within the observer's information set under the condition of an information gap ; as effective information is input ( decreases), eliminates contradictory candidates and continuously contracts; when information is complete , collapses to a single truth value. This paper designs four groups of lottery jar controlled experiments (different prior information groups, zero-information blind state group, incremental information group, false information group). Keeping the physical ontology constant, only the information input to the observer is altered to empirically demonstrate that the possibility set is constructed by information pruning. This paper reinterprets the information essence of Schrödinger's cat as a typical case, and strictly states: if one assumes ontological superposition in microscopic quantum systems, independent experimental evidence is required; however, regarding phenomena alone, the information set mechanism can perfectly reproduce all observations. The main text strictly strips away subjective consciousness and free will, relegating them only as an independent philosophical extension in the Appendix.
Schrodinger's cat is traditionally presented as a paradox highlighting the tension between quantum superposition and classical observation. Standard interpretations invoke either a fundamental wavefunction collapse, ontological branching of universes, or subjective Bayesian updating. In this paper, we propose a reinterpretation grounded in the Informational Observer Framework, according to which the paradox does not originate from an ontological superposition of macroscopic states, but from an unresolved informational configuration at the observer level. The cat itself is never simultaneously alive and dead; rather, the observer remains in a state of informational compression prior to interaction. Within this framework, wavefunction collapse is reinterpreted as an observer-level informational phase transition, not as a fundamental physical discontinuity. This approach preserves macroscopic realism, avoids ontological inflation, and reframes the measurement problem as an emergent informational phenomenon.
The standard interpretation of quantum mechanics holds that a particle exists in a superposition of multiple states prior to measurement — that it simultaneously occupies more than one location, or simultaneously possesses more than one value of an observable. This paper argues, by reductio ad absurdum, that the physical realisation of superposition — simultaneous multi-location existence — is incompatible with seven independent and well-established physical principles: (1) the observational fact that no infinite physical quantity has ever been measured; (2) conservation of energy; (3) the mass-energy equivalence E = mc²; (4) the Bekenstein entropy bound; (5) the second law of thermodynamics; (6) the Heisenberg uncertainty principle; and (7) causality. The argument proceeds through a foundational identification: information, energy, and mass stand in proportional existential relation, established by the Bekenstein bound (I ∝ M), Landauer's principle (E ∝ I), and mass-energy equivalence (E = mc²). Given this proportionality, the infinite information-processing load required by complete superposition implies infinite energy and infinite mass — quantities that are universally absent from the observational record of physics. Finite N-state superposition is excluded by a complementary argument: maintaining N states simultaneously requires N times the information-processing load of a single undetermined state, violating the principle that nature selects minimum-load configurations. The physical alternative proposed is the undetermined state: during propagation, the matter wave is real and physically present, but matter has not yet appeared at any location. This is not a hidden-variable state — no definite position exists to be hidden — but an ontological absence of localisation prior to the formation of a constructive interference maximum. The present paper does not claim to determine which path matter takes; it claims to demonstrate that simultaneous multi-location existence is physically impossible. The undetermined state is the unique physically consistent alternative. Experimental consequences and the connection to the double-slit experiment are developed in a companion paper.
If all hidden variables behind so‑called intrinsic randomness were known to me, would it still be intrinsic randomness? This question exposes a fatal logical impasse within traditional physics: the moment complete information () is achieved, random phenomena vanish. Therefore, all observable randomness in reality is structurally tied to an information gap. This paper proposes the "Ontology‑Information Dichotomy Framework" and the "Theorem of Information Gap‑Randomness Necessity". Through time‑sequence‑separated macroscopic dice‑cup experiments (decoupling physical perturbation from information occlusion) and control tests with AI vision algorithms, we empirically demonstrate that apparent randomness is an inevitable product of finite physical information systems under , independent of biological consciousness. We further prove that unobservable hidden variables and pure observational information deficiency are observationally equivalent. Any claim of "intrinsic randomness" lacking decisive evidence under complete‑input conditions () is either a self‑contradictory notion or a metaphysical presupposition. Ranging from engineering encapsulation (e.g., lotteries, PRNGs) to microscopic quantum scenarios, apparent randomness strictly derived from the information gap constitutes the only empirically supported and logically self‑consistent mechanism.
The central part of Everett's formulation of quantum mechanics is a quantum mechanical model of memory and of observation as the recording of information in a memory. To use this model as an answer to the measurement problem, Everett has to assume that a conscious observer can be in a superposition of such memory states and be unaware of it. This assumption has puzzled generations of readers. The fundamental aim of this dissertation is to find a set of simpler assumptions which are sufficient to show that Everett's model is empirically adequate. I argue that Everett's model needs three assumptions to account for the process of observation: an assumption of decoherence of observers as quantum mechanical systems; an assumption of supervenience of mental states (qualities) over quantum mechanical properties; and an assumption about the interpretation of quantum mechanical states in general: quantum mechanical states describe ensembles of states of affairs coexisting in the same system. I argue that the only plausible understanding of such ensembles is as ensembles of possibilities, and that all standard no-collapse interpretations agree in this reading of quantum mechanical states. Their differences can be understood as different theories about what marks the real state within this ensemble, and Everett's theory as the claim that no additional 'mark of reality' is necessary. Using the three assumptions, I argue that introspection cannot determine the objective quantum mechanical state of an observer. Rather, the introspective qualities of a quantum mechanical state can be represented by a (classical) statistical ensemble of subjective states. An analysis of these subjective states and their dynamics leads to the conclusion that they suffice to give empirically correct predictions. The argument for the empirical adequacy of the subjective state entails that knowledge of the objective quantum mechanical state is impossible in principle. Empirical reality for a conscious observer is not described by the objective state, but by a Everettian relative state conditional on the subjective state, and no theoretical 'mark of reality' is necessary for this concept of reality. I compare the resulting concept of reality to Kant's distinction between empirical and transcendental reality.
On the basis of decoherence theory and quantum Darwinism, this paper proposes a “gentle collapse” interpretive scheme within the framework of the many-worlds interpretation. Its core assertion is: the state vector is the sole physical reality, not confined to four-dimensional spacetime. The four-dimensional physical world we experience is a single branch that a local observer fixes from the state vector by spending entropy. Probability is an intrinsic property of the state vector. The other possibilities are never locally fixed. This scheme yields physically distinguishable predictions from the many-worlds interpretation at the mesoscopic scale after decoherence is complete: because the many-worlds interpretation commits to all branches being equally physically real, it must expect thermodynamic signatures of residual interactions between branches; the gentle collapse scheme, by declaring that after decoherence is complete the other branches can no longer produce distinguishable physical effects through the local heat bath, expects zero such signatures. The “operational zero” is not an absolute ontological prohibition, but an operational boundary relative to the local observer’s current heat bath; when the heat bath is enlarged, information that was previously unfixed can re-enter the accessible domain. This “zero expectation” is strictly defined by the “operational zero” determined by the second law of thermodynamics via Landauer’s principle, constituting a criterion that is in principle experimentally testable. The paper further argues that acknowledging intrinsic probability and acknowledging the failure of deterministic causality for single events are two equivalent formulations of the same ontological decision, and that the gentle collapse scheme possesses independent advantages in theoretical economy and ontological consistency.
Modern quantum mechanics, despite its flawless mathematical apparatus, has been in a deep ontological crisis for over a century. The traditional Copenhagen interpretation has introduced philosophical mysticism and absurd paradoxes into the description of the microworld, such as the famous mental experiments of "Schrödinger's cat." The orthodox claim that a particle exists simultaneously in multiple mutually exclusive states before measurement (quantum superposition) contradicts the most fundamental ontological law of existence. We have built this paper on a new, solid, realistic postulate, which at the same time represents an ontological axiom: Any object at a given moment in time exists only in one specific and definite physical state. Superposition is not an objective reality—it represents merely a mathematical tool for describing the system. Instead of splitting the universe into two, where the macro- and microworlds operate by different logics, we propose a unified causal model. The fundamental substance of the microworld is a continuous quantum field, the vibration of which before measurement manifests as a real physical wave. The act of measurement is not a "passive observation," but rather a harsh physical intervention. When a macroscopic instrument touches the wave structure of the field, an instantaneous non-linear reaction is born—a quantum spasm (a local phase transition), which instantly condenses the wave into a point-like particle. This article describes in detail the mechanism of this spasm and its connection with the structural deformation of the quantum field.