Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Ghirardi, Rimini and Weber (1986): Collapse by Postulate — One Law Added, Two Constants Chosen, Zero Derivation Equations

William Alexander Aldred

Published Nov 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Reason found, and the question is still open (not solved). GRW solves the measurement problem by making collapse physical. Schrödinger dynamics never localizes anything. The 1986 paper adds a stochastic hit process on top of it, by postulate. Each particle takes localization hits as a Poisson process at mean rate λ. Each hit multiplies the wavefunction by a Gaussian of width a^(-1/2). The two constants are chosen, not derived: λ ≈ 10^{-16} s^{-1} per particle and a^(-1/2) ≈ 10^{-5} cm, which is r_C = 10^{-7} m. That is the claim this paper counts. The count is plain. Postulated laws: 1. Chosen numbers: 2. Derivation equations outputting the law, λ, or r_C: 0. The price is computed, not argued. At the chosen λ, one particle waits a mean time of 1.000000e+16 s between hits. That is about 3.17e+08 yr. Pure N-amplification cuts that to 1.66e-08 s for an Avogadro-scale system. The chosen width sits at r_C/size = 1.89e+03 against the Bohr radius and 0.010000 against a dust-grain diameter. Both ends of the window hold. Neither end is derived. Adler's later proposal for the same λ sits at ratio 1.000000e+08 from the GRW value. That is log_10(ratio) = 8.000000 orders of magnitude. Under Adler, the per-particle chance of a hit in one year is 0.271, against GRW's 3.16e-09. A derived constant does not admit two competent values eight orders apart. A chosen one does. No derivation of the collapse law, of λ, or of r_C is claimed here. Experimental bounds are treated as bounds in this paper. They exclude a region of the (λ, r_C) plane. They do not confirm any point in it. The larger question behind my own work remains unsolved: no derivation of mine has produced the observed vacuum energy.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23910741

Related papers

Parameter diagrams of the GRW and CSL theories of wavefunction collapse

William Feldmann, Roderich Tumulka

It has been hypothesized that the time evolution of wavefunctions might include collapses, rather than being governed by the Schrödinger equation. The leading models of such an evolution, Ghirardi–Rimini–Weber (GRW) and continuous spontaneous localization (CSL), have two parameters (or new constants of nature): the collapse width σ and the collapse rate λ. We draw a diagram of the σλ-plane showing the region that is empirically refuted and the region that is philosophically unsatisfactory.

arXiv:1109.6579•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 26, 2012•98 citations

A Relativistic Version of the Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber Model

Roderich Tumulka

Carrying out a research program outlined by John S. Bell in 1987, we arrive at a relativistic version of the Ghirardi–Rimini–Weber (GRW) model of spon-taneous wavefunction collapse. The GRW model was proposed as a solution of the measurement problem of quantum mechanics and involves a stochastic and nonlinear modification of the Schrödinger equation. It deviates very little from the Schrödinger equation for microscopic systems but efficiently suppresses, for macroscopic systems, superpositions of macroscopically different states. As sug-gested by Bell, we take the primitive ontology, or local beables, of our model to be a discrete set of space-time points, at which the collapses are centered. This set is random with distribution determined by the initial wavefunction. Our model is nonlocal and violates Bell’s inequality though it does not make use of a preferred slicing of space-time or any other sort of synchronization of spacelike separated points. Like the GRW model, it reproduces the quantum probabilities in all cases presently testable, though it entails deviations from the quantum formalism that are in principle testable. Our model works in Minkowski space-time as well as in (well-behaved) curved background space-times. PACS numbers: 03.65.Ta; 03.65.Ud; 03.30.+p. Key words: spontaneous wave-function collapse; relativity; quantum theory without observers. 1

•Jan 1, 2004•248 citations

Spontaneous Localization (SL) Theory

Philip Pearle

Abstract Before examining experimental consequences of CSL, this chapter discusses the spontaneous localization (SL) theory of Ghirardi, Rimini and Weber (GRW). As for CSL, the chapter presents the structure of the theory, and then specializes it to a non-relativistic theory. SL does not add a term to Schrodinger’s equation. Instead, the state vector is suddenly altered by a “hit” (GRW’s ‘spontaneous localization’), that is, multiplication by an operator, followed by renormalization. The hits occur at random times. The chapter shows the specific choice of operator made by GRW for their non-relativistic theory. Emphasized are two aspects of SL that helped the journey to CSL. One is that the collapse is always acting (one need not “turn it on.” The other is the “smeared” character of the GRW operator. The chapter then shows how the density matrix is calculated. Finally, it discusses the numerical values, chosen by GRW, of the two parameters of SL theory, λ and a, that are provisionally adopted for CSL.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 30, 2024•0 citations

Quantum collapse dynamics with attractive densities

Franck Laloë

We discuss a model of spontaneous collapse of the quantum state that does not require adding any stochastic processes to the standard dynamics. The additional ingredient with respect to the wave function is a position in the configuration space which drives the collapse in a completely deterministic way. This new variable is equivalent to a set of positions of all the particles, i.e., a set of Bohmian positions, which obey the usual guiding equation of Bohmian theory. Any superposition of quantum states of a macroscopic object occupying different regions of space is projected by a localization process onto the region occupied by the positions. Since the Bohmian positions are well defined in a single realization of the experiment, a space localization into one region is produced. The mechanism is based on the correlations between these positions arising from the cohesive forces inside macroscopic objects. The model introduces two collapse parameters which play a role very similar to those of the Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber (GRW) [Ghirardi et al., Phys. Rev. D 34, 470 (1986)] and continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) [Pearle, Phys. Rev. A 39, 2277 (1989); Ghirardi et al., Phys. Rev. A 42, 78 (1990)] theories. With appropriate values of these parameters, we check that the corresponding dynamics rapidly projects superpositions of macroscopic states localized in different regions of space into a single region, while it maintains a negligible effect in all situations where the predictions of standard quantum dynamics are known to be correct. We briefly speculate about the possible relations with gravity. We then study the evolution of the density operator and a mean-field approximation of the dynamical equations of this model, as well as the change of the evolution of the momentum introduced by the localization process. Possible theoretical interpretations are discussed. Generally speaking, this model introduces a sharper border between the quantum and classical worlds than the GRW and CSL theories and leaves a broader range of acceptable values for the parameters.

arXiv:1901.08016•Physical Review A•May 14, 2019•4 citations

Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber model with massive flashes

Antoine Tilloy

I introduce a modification of the Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber (GRW) model in which the flashes (or space-time collapse events) source a classical gravitational field. The resulting semiclassical theory of Newtonian gravity preserves the statistical interpretation of quantum states of matter in contrast with mean field approaches. It can be seen as a discrete version of recent proposals of consistent hybrid quantum classical theories. The model is in agreement with known experimental data and introduces new falsifiable predictions: (1) single particles do not self-interact, (2) the $1/r$ gravitational potential of Newtonian gravity is cut off at short ($\ensuremath{\lesssim}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}7}\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{m}$) distances, and (3) gravity makes spatial superpositions decohere at a rate inversely proportional to that coming from the vanilla GRW model. Together, the last two predictions make the model experimentally falsifiable for all values of its parameters.

arXiv:1709.03809•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jan 23, 2018•25 citations

The Thermodynamic Origin of Wavefunction Collapse: Deriving the GRW Parameter from Reversibility Costs

Khang Lui

The Measurement Problem in quantum mechanics arises from the tension between the linear, unitary evolution of the Schrödinger equation and the non-linear, stochastic collapse observed during measurement. Spontaneous Collapse theories (such as Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber, GRW) resolve this by postulating a fundamental collapse frequency lambda. However, standard GRW treats lambda as a new constant of nature without an underlying mechanism. In this paper, we derive the collapse parameter from the Dual-Primitive Ontology. We posit that macroscopic superpositions are computationally unstable due to the Reversibility Cost Theorem. When the complexity of a superposition exceeds a critical threshold Nc, the Asymmetric Causation (AC) field triggers a stochastic reduction to minimise the thermodynamic cost of history tracking. We derive a complexity-dependent collapse rate lambda(C) proportional to epsilon(C) and demonstrate that for microscopic systems, lambda approaches 0 (recovering standard Quantum Mechanics), while for macroscopic systems, lambda diverges, ensuring objective classicality.

•Jan 28, 2026•0 citations
Reason found, and the question is still open (not solved). GRW solves the measurement problem by making collapse physical. Schrödinger dynamics never localizes anything. The 1986 paper adds a stochastic hit process on top of it, by postulate. Each particle takes localization hits as a Poisson process at mean rate λ. Each hit multiplies the wavefunction by a Gaussian of width a^(-1/2). The two constants are chosen, not derived: λ ≈ 10^{-16} s^{-1} per particle and a^(-1/2) ≈ 10^{-5} cm, which is r_C = 10^{-7} m. That is the claim this paper counts. The count is plain. Postulated laws: 1. Chosen numbers: 2. Derivation equations outputting the law, λ, or r_C: 0. The price is computed, not argued. At the chosen λ, one particle waits a mean time of 1.000000e+16 s between hits. That is about 3.17e+08 yr. Pure N-amplification cuts that to 1.66e-08 s for an Avogadro-scale system. The chosen width sits at r_C/size = 1.89e+03 against the Bohr radius and 0.010000 against a dust-grain diameter. Both ends of the window hold. Neither end is derived. Adler's later proposal for the same λ sits at ratio 1.000000e+08 from the GRW value. That is log_10(ratio) = 8.000000 orders of magnitude. Under Adler, the per-particle chance of a hit in one year is 0.271, against GRW's 3.16e-09. A derived constant does not admit two competent values eight orders apart. A chosen one does. No derivation of the collapse law, of λ, or of r_C is claimed here. Experimental bounds are treated as bounds in this paper. They exclude a region of the (λ, r_C) plane. They do not confirm any point in it. The larger question behind my own work remains unsolved: no derivation of mine has produced the observed vacuum energy.
It has been hypothesized that the time evolution of wavefunctions might include collapses, rather than being governed by the Schrödinger equation. The leading models of such an evolution, Ghirardi–Rimini–Weber (GRW) and continuous spontaneous localization (CSL), have two parameters (or new constants of nature): the collapse width σ and the collapse rate λ. We draw a diagram of the σλ-plane showing the region that is empirically refuted and the region that is philosophically unsatisfactory.
Carrying out a research program outlined by John S. Bell in 1987, we arrive at a relativistic version of the Ghirardi–Rimini–Weber (GRW) model of spon-taneous wavefunction collapse. The GRW model was proposed as a solution of the measurement problem of quantum mechanics and involves a stochastic and nonlinear modification of the Schrödinger equation. It deviates very little from the Schrödinger equation for microscopic systems but efficiently suppresses, for macroscopic systems, superpositions of macroscopically different states. As sug-gested by Bell, we take the primitive ontology, or local beables, of our model to be a discrete set of space-time points, at which the collapses are centered. This set is random with distribution determined by the initial wavefunction. Our model is nonlocal and violates Bell’s inequality though it does not make use of a preferred slicing of space-time or any other sort of synchronization of spacelike separated points. Like the GRW model, it reproduces the quantum probabilities in all cases presently testable, though it entails deviations from the quantum formalism that are in principle testable. Our model works in Minkowski space-time as well as in (well-behaved) curved background space-times. PACS numbers: 03.65.Ta; 03.65.Ud; 03.30.+p. Key words: spontaneous wave-function collapse; relativity; quantum theory without observers. 1
Abstract Before examining experimental consequences of CSL, this chapter discusses the spontaneous localization (SL) theory of Ghirardi, Rimini and Weber (GRW). As for CSL, the chapter presents the structure of the theory, and then specializes it to a non-relativistic theory. SL does not add a term to Schrodinger’s equation. Instead, the state vector is suddenly altered by a “hit” (GRW’s ‘spontaneous localization’), that is, multiplication by an operator, followed by renormalization. The hits occur at random times. The chapter shows the specific choice of operator made by GRW for their non-relativistic theory. Emphasized are two aspects of SL that helped the journey to CSL. One is that the collapse is always acting (one need not “turn it on.” The other is the “smeared” character of the GRW operator. The chapter then shows how the density matrix is calculated. Finally, it discusses the numerical values, chosen by GRW, of the two parameters of SL theory, λ and a, that are provisionally adopted for CSL.
We discuss a model of spontaneous collapse of the quantum state that does not require adding any stochastic processes to the standard dynamics. The additional ingredient with respect to the wave function is a position in the configuration space which drives the collapse in a completely deterministic way. This new variable is equivalent to a set of positions of all the particles, i.e., a set of Bohmian positions, which obey the usual guiding equation of Bohmian theory. Any superposition of quantum states of a macroscopic object occupying different regions of space is projected by a localization process onto the region occupied by the positions. Since the Bohmian positions are well defined in a single realization of the experiment, a space localization into one region is produced. The mechanism is based on the correlations between these positions arising from the cohesive forces inside macroscopic objects. The model introduces two collapse parameters which play a role very similar to those of the Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber (GRW) [Ghirardi et al., Phys. Rev. D 34, 470 (1986)] and continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) [Pearle, Phys. Rev. A 39, 2277 (1989); Ghirardi et al., Phys. Rev. A 42, 78 (1990)] theories. With appropriate values of these parameters, we check that the corresponding dynamics rapidly projects superpositions of macroscopic states localized in different regions of space into a single region, while it maintains a negligible effect in all situations where the predictions of standard quantum dynamics are known to be correct. We briefly speculate about the possible relations with gravity. We then study the evolution of the density operator and a mean-field approximation of the dynamical equations of this model, as well as the change of the evolution of the momentum introduced by the localization process. Possible theoretical interpretations are discussed. Generally speaking, this model introduces a sharper border between the quantum and classical worlds than the GRW and CSL theories and leaves a broader range of acceptable values for the parameters.
I introduce a modification of the Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber (GRW) model in which the flashes (or space-time collapse events) source a classical gravitational field. The resulting semiclassical theory of Newtonian gravity preserves the statistical interpretation of quantum states of matter in contrast with mean field approaches. It can be seen as a discrete version of recent proposals of consistent hybrid quantum classical theories. The model is in agreement with known experimental data and introduces new falsifiable predictions: (1) single particles do not self-interact, (2) the 1/r1/r1/r gravitational potential of Newtonian gravity is cut off at short ($\ensuremath{\lesssim}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}7}\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{m}$) distances, and (3) gravity makes spatial superpositions decohere at a rate inversely proportional to that coming from the vanilla GRW model. Together, the last two predictions make the model experimentally falsifiable for all values of its parameters.
The Measurement Problem in quantum mechanics arises from the tension between the linear, unitary evolution of the Schrödinger equation and the non-linear, stochastic collapse observed during measurement. Spontaneous Collapse theories (such as Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber, GRW) resolve this by postulating a fundamental collapse frequency lambda. However, standard GRW treats lambda as a new constant of nature without an underlying mechanism. In this paper, we derive the collapse parameter from the Dual-Primitive Ontology. We posit that macroscopic superpositions are computationally unstable due to the Reversibility Cost Theorem. When the complexity of a superposition exceeds a critical threshold Nc, the Asymmetric Causation (AC) field triggers a stochastic reduction to minimise the thermodynamic cost of history tracking. We derive a complexity-dependent collapse rate lambda(C) proportional to epsilon(C) and demonstrate that for microscopic systems, lambda approaches 0 (recovering standard Quantum Mechanics), while for macroscopic systems, lambda diverges, ensuring objective classicality.