Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The EPR Paradox Is Not a Paradox: A Supplement to "Observation as Simultaneous Emission and Absorption" — Reading the Position–Momentum Pair as a Closure Identity

Noriaki Kihara

Published Nov 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The EPR argument has three steps. (i) Measuring the position of one member A of a pair predicts with certainty the position of the other member B, and measuring the momentum predicts B's momentum (perfect correlation). (ii) The measurement at A does not disturb the distant B (locality). (iii) Hence B's position and momentum are simultaneously elements of reality, and the quantum-mechanical description is incomplete. This paper takes the readout rule of the preceding paper "Observation as Simultaneous Emission and Absorption" (Concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23857884) as its premise and re-reads the argument. The pair is a closure q_A + q_B = 0 that held once at the source, from which x_B = −x_A and p_B = −p_A follow simultaneously as identities. A single end has no value (the one-sided distribution is uniform), nothing happens at B when A is read, and the correlation depends neither on the order of the readouts nor on the distance between the two. The element of reality is the relation called the closure, not an attribute of one end. Step (ii) is correct, step (i) is a relational identity, and only the attribution in step (iii) is mistaken. That a destructive readout exists, drops the chosen variable to one of two values and severs the relation with the conjugate variable, is placed as a known fact (resonant absorption, photodetection, homodyne detection); deriving its mechanism is a separate task. "Instantaneous selection" is not written: what can be shown is only that no finite-speed influence exists. No new number appears. The claim is that, given the preceding paper, EPR is neither a paradox nor a mystery but a misreading of a relational identity. Earlier work reaching the same conclusion (Peres, Mermin, Smerlak and Rovelli, Griffiths, Jarrett, Spekkens, Wharton and Argaman, Cramer) is placed up front, and what belongs to this paper alone is limited to four points. Japanese original (authoritative) and English translation, with TeX sources, PDFs, two figures (Japanese and English labels), the figure program and the numerical identity checks.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23860605

Related papers

The Premises That Drew the Line: EPR's Criterion and Separation, Priced

William Alexander Aldred

In 1935 Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen asked whether the quantum-mechanical description of physical reality can be considered complete, and they answered no. I credit that paper at full strength: EPR did not dispute a single quantum prediction. They built a two-system state with perfect correlations so that a measurement choice made on one system fixes, with certainty, either the position or the momentum of a distant system it no longer interacts with, and, given their two premises, the inference that follows is valid: simultaneous elements of reality for position and momentum, and with them the incompleteness of the wave-function description. What I evaluate is the pair of premises that inference rests on: the criterion of reality — if, without in any way disturbing a system, we can predict with certainty the value of a physical quantity, then there exists an element of reality corresponding to that quantity — and the separation premise — at the time of measurement the two systems no longer interact, so no real change can take place in the second system in consequence of anything that may be done to the first. Neither premise is derived in the paper; both are used as definitions, and the conclusion is exactly as strong as the pair, no stronger. On declared inputs only, my bench evaluates the conjunction of the two premises, not either premise alone: an exhaustive enumeration of all 16 deterministic local-realist assignments returns every assignment at |S| = 2 exactly — 8 at S = +2 and 8 at S = −2 — so the conjunction forces the bound |S| ≤ 2, while the declared spin-singlet correlation at the standard angles returns S = −2.828427, |S| = 2.828427 = 2√2. The gap is 0.828427 — the quantum return exceeds the bound the premises force by 41.421356 per cent of the bound — and the excess is a band, not a tuned point, running 2.449490 at 15 and 75 degrees and 2.732051 at 30 and 60 degrees across the declared sweep. John Bell is credited at his own address as the later address that made this conjunction testable, in 1964; the experimental record since runs against local realism, stated plainly. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: **REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING** — explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: **vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.**

•Nov 5, 2026•0 citations

THE EPR ARGUMENT AND QUANTUM NONLOCALITY

Bidyut Kumar Datta, V. de Sabbata, Renuka Datta

We view the final remark of the EPR paper : “one would not be able to arrive at the above conclusion if two or more physical quantities are regarded as simultaneous elements of reality only when they can be simultaneously measured or predicted”. On this point of view, because of the collapse of the wave function of the combined system, the EPR entangled relations (or correlations) of momenta and positions belonging to two spatially separated particles considered in the first part of the paper do not hold good simultaneously for two separate measurements. This case does not reconcile with the locality principle and hence exhibits quantum nonlocality. Moreover, it is quite compatible with uncertainty principle. It is concluded that the EPR argument does not exhibit any paradox.

•Aug 1, 2000•0 citations

Resolution of EPR Entanglement Paradox: Relativistic Quantum Correlations as Hidden Variables

Hamid Naghieh

Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR) constructed a scenario in which, from a measure- ment on one particle of an entangled pair, one can infer with certainty the value of a conjugate observable of the other particle, purportedly without disturbing it. EPR argued that perfect correlations permit simultaneous reality of non-commuting prop- erties and thereby demanded either absolute simultaneity or incompleteness of the wavefunction. We show in detail that their conclusion rests on two logical/structural errors: (i) conflation of prediction (inferential assignment within a model) with mea- surement (physical interaction producing an outcome in a specified frame), and (ii) implicit assumption of absolute simultaneity across orthogonal reference frames. We further prove that Bell’s inequality is structurally incompatible with quantum predic- tions because it replaces quantum eigenfunctions σ (vectors/operators in H obeying linearity, orthogonality, and conservation) with scalar hidden parameters λ lacking eigenfunction properties. We propose the so-called “hidden variables” are the implicit quantum mechanical laws themselves: orthogonality of eigenvectors, linearity of su- perposition, and conservation constraints. With these reinstated, the wavefunction provides a complete, relativistically consistent description of physical reality.

•Nov 12, 2025•0 citations

Closer Look at EPR Paradox and Bell’s Inequality

Vladimir K. Ignatovich

The EPR paradox is shown to be a result of the wrong definitions in quantum mechanics of such physical quantities as momentum and position. The corrected definitions show that momentum and position of particles can be precisely defined simultaneously and uncertainty relations do not prevent it. Therefore, with correct definition of physical quantities in quantum mechanics, the paradox disappears. The Bohm Aharonov version of the EPR paradox is illustrated by the example of measuring the polarization of photon pairs. The common view of the two photon state radiated by a source is presented. The common Bell’s inequality is discussed and the simplest version of it for a specific hidden variable is derived. A possibility of an experimental study of whether a photon and its polarization are preexistent before measurements is considered.

American Journal of Modern Physics•Apr 17, 2015•1 citation

Reconsidering the EPR Paradox through the Separation of Prediction and Observation

Kei Itoh

This paper reexamines the EPR paradox through a logical separation of “prediction” and “observation.” Even when a conditional prediction supplied by quantum theory reaches probability 1, this fact alone does not imply that an observation event has occurred at a remote location or that a particular ontology holds for an unobserved quantity. When this distinction is generalized into a minimal rule against generating ontology without warrant from an observational formalism, the inference that depends on EPR’s criterion of reality can be stopped without introducing new dynamics or a superluminal mechanism. At the same time, correlations that resist local causal factorization, as manifested in violations of Bell inequalities, remain. Thus, EPR-type “instantaneous remote determination” need not be identified with Bell nonlocality. The paper further reconsiders the possibility of reading state collapse as conditioning on an observation outcome rather than as transport through spacetime, its relation to the invariance of the speed of light, Bohr’s response to EPR and the logical ambiguity of the Copenhagen interpretation, and Einstein’s ontological concerns. Finally, the problem is considered as a “renewed Kantian overreach of reason,” in which an overreach that had been constrained by modern science and Kantian critique reappears through the mediation of precise quantum formalism. AI Assistance DisclosureGenerative AI was used as an auxiliary tool in drafting, adjusting expressions, and organizing the structure of this paper. The author bears final responsibility for the text, claims, citations, and factual verification. Keywords: EPR paradox, prediction, observation, state collapse, Bell nonlocality, Copenhagen interpretation, ontology, Kant

•Sep 17, 2026•0 citations

Observation as Simultaneous Emission and Absorption: Deriving the Born Rule, Bell Correlations and the Tsirelson Bound from a Viewing-Angle Readout Rule

Noriaki Kihara

What quantum mechanics calls "observation" has lumped together three interactions of different character: one that switches the discrete state of the partner, one that leaves the partner's state unswitched and shifts only the internal phases, and one that severs the mutual phase relation. This paper places the substance of observation in the second, the readout of the interference of a phase difference, and adopts only three premises. (P1) The distance between two parties is set by the ratio of a shared viewing angle to the partner's size; only ratios are readable and the absolute scale is not. (P2) An interaction is a single relation in which emission and absorption hold simultaneously; the speed of light appears on the readout side as a conversion factor between local clocks. (P3) The phase of a relation carries a harmonic order n that depends on the kind of wave. From these, the fact that a probability is the product of an amplitude and its conjugate (the form of the Born rule), the two-party correlation E = ∓cos nθ, the upper bound 2√2 of the CHSH quantity (the Tsirelson bound), and no-signaling follow in a few lines. The normalization that turns this into a probability is the division that discards the size ratio, i.e. the choice of the η = 0 section. As a consequence, the bound is 2√2 independently of the kind of wave, and the detector angle giving the maximal violation shrinks in proportion to 1/n (45° for spin-½, 22.5° for photons, 11.25° for gravitational waves). For a localized relation that is a sum of harmonics the correlation is the autocorrelation of the pulse shape; the bound holds for any weights, equality is attained only for a single harmonic, and a rectangular pulse reduces to a local hidden-variable model with S ≤ 2. Japanese original (authoritative) and English translation, with TeX sources, PDFs, five figures (Japanese and English labels) and the figure-generating program.

•Nov 1, 2026•1 citation
The EPR argument has three steps. (i) Measuring the position of one member A of a pair predicts with certainty the position of the other member B, and measuring the momentum predicts B's momentum (perfect correlation). (ii) The measurement at A does not disturb the distant B (locality). (iii) Hence B's position and momentum are simultaneously elements of reality, and the quantum-mechanical description is incomplete. This paper takes the readout rule of the preceding paper "Observation as Simultaneous Emission and Absorption" (Concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23857884) as its premise and re-reads the argument. The pair is a closure q_A + q_B = 0 that held once at the source, from which x_B = −x_A and p_B = −p_A follow simultaneously as identities. A single end has no value (the one-sided distribution is uniform), nothing happens at B when A is read, and the correlation depends neither on the order of the readouts nor on the distance between the two. The element of reality is the relation called the closure, not an attribute of one end. Step (ii) is correct, step (i) is a relational identity, and only the attribution in step (iii) is mistaken. That a destructive readout exists, drops the chosen variable to one of two values and severs the relation with the conjugate variable, is placed as a known fact (resonant absorption, photodetection, homodyne detection); deriving its mechanism is a separate task. "Instantaneous selection" is not written: what can be shown is only that no finite-speed influence exists. No new number appears. The claim is that, given the preceding paper, EPR is neither a paradox nor a mystery but a misreading of a relational identity. Earlier work reaching the same conclusion (Peres, Mermin, Smerlak and Rovelli, Griffiths, Jarrett, Spekkens, Wharton and Argaman, Cramer) is placed up front, and what belongs to this paper alone is limited to four points. Japanese original (authoritative) and English translation, with TeX sources, PDFs, two figures (Japanese and English labels), the figure program and the numerical identity checks.
In 1935 Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen asked whether the quantum-mechanical description of physical reality can be considered complete, and they answered no. I credit that paper at full strength: EPR did not dispute a single quantum prediction. They built a two-system state with perfect correlations so that a measurement choice made on one system fixes, with certainty, either the position or the momentum of a distant system it no longer interacts with, and, given their two premises, the inference that follows is valid: simultaneous elements of reality for position and momentum, and with them the incompleteness of the wave-function description. What I evaluate is the pair of premises that inference rests on: the criterion of reality — if, without in any way disturbing a system, we can predict with certainty the value of a physical quantity, then there exists an element of reality corresponding to that quantity — and the separation premise — at the time of measurement the two systems no longer interact, so no real change can take place in the second system in consequence of anything that may be done to the first. Neither premise is derived in the paper; both are used as definitions, and the conclusion is exactly as strong as the pair, no stronger. On declared inputs only, my bench evaluates the conjunction of the two premises, not either premise alone: an exhaustive enumeration of all 16 deterministic local-realist assignments returns every assignment at |S| = 2 exactly — 8 at S = +2 and 8 at S = −2 — so the conjunction forces the bound |S| ≤ 2, while the declared spin-singlet correlation at the standard angles returns S = −2.828427, |S| = 2.828427 = 2√2. The gap is 0.828427 — the quantum return exceeds the bound the premises force by 41.421356 per cent of the bound — and the excess is a band, not a tuned point, running 2.449490 at 15 and 75 degrees and 2.732051 at 30 and 60 degrees across the declared sweep. John Bell is credited at his own address as the later address that made this conjunction testable, in 1964; the experimental record since runs against local realism, stated plainly. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: **REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING** — explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: **vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.**
We view the final remark of the EPR paper : “one would not be able to arrive at the above conclusion if two or more physical quantities are regarded as simultaneous elements of reality only when they can be simultaneously measured or predicted”. On this point of view, because of the collapse of the wave function of the combined system, the EPR entangled relations (or correlations) of momenta and positions belonging to two spatially separated particles considered in the first part of the paper do not hold good simultaneously for two separate measurements. This case does not reconcile with the locality principle and hence exhibits quantum nonlocality. Moreover, it is quite compatible with uncertainty principle. It is concluded that the EPR argument does not exhibit any paradox.
Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR) constructed a scenario in which, from a measure- ment on one particle of an entangled pair, one can infer with certainty the value of a conjugate observable of the other particle, purportedly without disturbing it. EPR argued that perfect correlations permit simultaneous reality of non-commuting prop- erties and thereby demanded either absolute simultaneity or incompleteness of the wavefunction. We show in detail that their conclusion rests on two logical/structural errors: (i) conflation of prediction (inferential assignment within a model) with mea- surement (physical interaction producing an outcome in a specified frame), and (ii) implicit assumption of absolute simultaneity across orthogonal reference frames. We further prove that Bell’s inequality is structurally incompatible with quantum predic- tions because it replaces quantum eigenfunctions σ (vectors/operators in H obeying linearity, orthogonality, and conservation) with scalar hidden parameters λ lacking eigenfunction properties. We propose the so-called “hidden variables” are the implicit quantum mechanical laws themselves: orthogonality of eigenvectors, linearity of su- perposition, and conservation constraints. With these reinstated, the wavefunction provides a complete, relativistically consistent description of physical reality.
The EPR paradox is shown to be a result of the wrong definitions in quantum mechanics of such physical quantities as momentum and position. The corrected definitions show that momentum and position of particles can be precisely defined simultaneously and uncertainty relations do not prevent it. Therefore, with correct definition of physical quantities in quantum mechanics, the paradox disappears. The Bohm Aharonov version of the EPR paradox is illustrated by the example of measuring the polarization of photon pairs. The common view of the two photon state radiated by a source is presented. The common Bell’s inequality is discussed and the simplest version of it for a specific hidden variable is derived. A possibility of an experimental study of whether a photon and its polarization are preexistent before measurements is considered.
This paper reexamines the EPR paradox through a logical separation of “prediction” and “observation.” Even when a conditional prediction supplied by quantum theory reaches probability 1, this fact alone does not imply that an observation event has occurred at a remote location or that a particular ontology holds for an unobserved quantity. When this distinction is generalized into a minimal rule against generating ontology without warrant from an observational formalism, the inference that depends on EPR’s criterion of reality can be stopped without introducing new dynamics or a superluminal mechanism. At the same time, correlations that resist local causal factorization, as manifested in violations of Bell inequalities, remain. Thus, EPR-type “instantaneous remote determination” need not be identified with Bell nonlocality. The paper further reconsiders the possibility of reading state collapse as conditioning on an observation outcome rather than as transport through spacetime, its relation to the invariance of the speed of light, Bohr’s response to EPR and the logical ambiguity of the Copenhagen interpretation, and Einstein’s ontological concerns. Finally, the problem is considered as a “renewed Kantian overreach of reason,” in which an overreach that had been constrained by modern science and Kantian critique reappears through the mediation of precise quantum formalism. AI Assistance DisclosureGenerative AI was used as an auxiliary tool in drafting, adjusting expressions, and organizing the structure of this paper. The author bears final responsibility for the text, claims, citations, and factual verification. Keywords: EPR paradox, prediction, observation, state collapse, Bell nonlocality, Copenhagen interpretation, ontology, Kant
What quantum mechanics calls "observation" has lumped together three interactions of different character: one that switches the discrete state of the partner, one that leaves the partner's state unswitched and shifts only the internal phases, and one that severs the mutual phase relation. This paper places the substance of observation in the second, the readout of the interference of a phase difference, and adopts only three premises. (P1) The distance between two parties is set by the ratio of a shared viewing angle to the partner's size; only ratios are readable and the absolute scale is not. (P2) An interaction is a single relation in which emission and absorption hold simultaneously; the speed of light appears on the readout side as a conversion factor between local clocks. (P3) The phase of a relation carries a harmonic order n that depends on the kind of wave. From these, the fact that a probability is the product of an amplitude and its conjugate (the form of the Born rule), the two-party correlation E = ∓cos nθ, the upper bound 2√2 of the CHSH quantity (the Tsirelson bound), and no-signaling follow in a few lines. The normalization that turns this into a probability is the division that discards the size ratio, i.e. the choice of the η = 0 section. As a consequence, the bound is 2√2 independently of the kind of wave, and the detector angle giving the maximal violation shrinks in proportion to 1/n (45° for spin-½, 22.5° for photons, 11.25° for gravitational waves). For a localized relation that is a sum of harmonics the correlation is the autocorrelation of the pulse shape; the bound holds for any weights, equality is attained only for a single harmonic, and a rectangular pulse reduces to a local hidden-variable model with S ≤ 2. Japanese original (authoritative) and English translation, with TeX sources, PDFs, five figures (Japanese and English labels) and the figure-generating program.