How can coherent light be certified when its amplitude is unknown or its preparations are correlated? This article treats these as distinct inference problems: learning an actual coherent reference with optimal source-copy cost for independent identical inputs, and certifying the photon-counting predictions of the light left unused in a preprepared correlated batch. Optimal source-copy cost with a learned reference. For a normal one-mode source prepared independently and identically, an ideal passive multiport test and heterodyne readout produce an actual amplitude \(\hat\alpha\). After displacement by this reference and ideal quantum-limited amplification of fixed gain \(G>1\), let \(P_{\rho,\hat\alpha}^{G}\) be the photon-number distribution and \(\pi_G(k)=(G-1)^k/G^{k+1}\) the coherent benchmark. The task-specific comparison is \[\frac{1-\langle\hat\alpha|\rho|\hat\alpha\rangle}{G}\le\operatorname{TV}(P_{\rho,\hat\alpha}^{G},\pi_G)\le1-\langle\hat\alpha|\rho|\hat\alpha\rangle.\] With at most N input copies, the protocol controls the unconditional event of accepting a reference whose actual total-variation error exceeds \(\varepsilon\). For \(0<\varepsilon<1/2\), soundness error \(\beta_s\to0\), and fixed coherent-source rejection tolerance \(\beta_c<1\), the optimal fixed-maximum source-copy count obeys \[\frac{N_{\rm opt}[-\log(1-\varepsilon)]}{\log(1/\beta_s)}\longrightarrow1.\] The matching converse covers collective and adaptive protocols under the same source-copy contract. At 1% accuracy and 5% soundness and completeness errors, the finite bounds are \(293\le N_{\rm opt}\le572\). These are source-copy bounds under ideal optical access, not an optimum for total hardware or reference energy. The actual unmeasured batch after the full record. A separate protocol allows an arbitrary preprepared correlated or entangled optical batch, including correlations with an environment. A pilot first fixes the reference; a private random subset is then tested. A multiplicative sampling inequality yields a frequentist guarantee for the average marginal photon-count error of the retained conditional state, conditioned on the complete actual measurement record. It does not replace that state by premeasurement marginals or assert the same error for its full joint distribution. The trusted detector contract requires product joint test effects and local instruments that leave retained systems and the external environment untouched. Calibration envelopes must cover the actual signal-time gates. The bounds retain infinite photon tails and charge detector efficiency, dark counts, imperfect displacement, reference drift and calibration failure. Explicit counterexamples explain why marginal detector efficiencies or product effects alone are insufficient. An ideal finite example uses 3730 prepared systems: 1491 pilot, 1339 tested and 900 retained; calibration and optical-control resources are additional. Relation to the original two-copy result. The earlier mean-energy-controlled arm-swap cancellation and full trace-distance certificate remain valid for independent, possibly nonidentical product batches. Their source and target are kept separate from the new arbitrary-batch marginal PNR guarantee. The analysis builds on established coherent-state comparison, quantum verification and sampling identities; the new connections supply the learned-reference resource law and the full-record conditional-state return. Version 1.1 is a substantial update of Certifying unused optical states with imperfect two-copy interference, first published on 31 October 2026. The integrated 24-page PDF contains three figure groups, a source-and-target comparison table, complete proofs and references. The figures illustrate proved bounds and specified theoretical protocols, not experimental measurements.
How can coherent light be certified when its amplitude is unknown or its preparations are correlated? This article treats these as distinct inference problems: learning an actual coherent reference with optimal source-copy cost for independent identical inputs, and certifying the photon-counting predictions of the light left unused in a preprepared correlated batch. Optimal source-copy cost with a learned reference. For a normal one-mode source prepared independently and identically, an ideal passive multiport test and heterodyne readout produce an actual amplitude (\hat\alpha). After displacement by this reference and ideal quantum-limited amplification of fixed gain (G>1), let (P_{\rho,\hat\alpha}^{G}) be the photon-number distribution and (\pi_G(k)=(G-1)^k/G^{k+1}) the coherent benchmark. The task-specific comparison is [\frac{1-\langle\hat\alpha|\rho|\hat\alpha\rangle}{G}\le\operatorname{TV}(P_{\rho,\hat\alpha}^{G},\pi_G)\le1-\langle\hat\alpha|\rho|\hat\alpha\rangle.] With at most N input copies, the protocol controls the unconditional event of accepting a reference whose actual total-variation error exceeds (\varepsilon). For (0<\varepsilon<1/2), soundness error (\beta_s\to0), and fixed coherent-source rejection tolerance (\beta_c<1), the optimal fixed-maximum source-copy count obeys [\frac{N_{\rm opt}[-\log(1-\varepsilon)]}{\log(1/\beta_s)}\longrightarrow1.] The matching converse covers collective and adaptive protocols under the same source-copy contract. At 1% accuracy and 5% soundness and completeness errors, the finite bounds are (293\le N_{\rm opt}\le572). These are source-copy bounds under ideal optical access, not an optimum for total hardware or reference energy. The actual unmeasured batch after the full record. A separate protocol allows an arbitrary preprepared correlated or entangled optical batch, including correlations with an environment. A pilot first fixes the reference; a private random subset is then tested. A multiplicative sampling inequality yields a frequentist guarantee for the average marginal photon-count error of the retained conditional state, conditioned on the complete actual measurement record. It does not replace that state by premeasurement marginals or assert the same error for its full joint distribution. The trusted detector contract requires product joint test effects and local instruments that leave retained systems and the external environment untouched. Calibration envelopes must cover the actual signal-time gates. The bounds retain infinite photon tails and charge detector efficiency, dark counts, imperfect displacement, reference drift and calibration failure. Explicit counterexamples explain why marginal detector efficiencies or product effects alone are insufficient. An ideal finite example uses 3730 prepared systems: 1491 pilot, 1339 tested and 900 retained; calibration and optical-control resources are additional. Relation to the original two-copy result. The earlier mean-energy-controlled arm-swap cancellation and full trace-distance certificate remain valid for independent, possibly nonidentical product batches. Their source and target are kept separate from the new arbitrary-batch marginal PNR guarantee. The analysis builds on established coherent-state comparison, quantum verification and sampling identities; the new connections supply the learned-reference resource law and the full-record conditional-state return. Version 1.1 is a substantial update of Certifying unused optical states with imperfect two-copy interference, first published on 31 October 2026. The integrated 24-page PDF contains three figure groups, a source-and-target comparison table, complete proofs and references. The figures illustrate proved bounds and specified theoretical protocols, not experimental measurements.
How many uses of an optical device are needed to certify that it preserves quantum information? This article determines the optimal asymptotic number of coherent-light probes under an average photon budget. Matching upper and lower bounds show that a single optical mode carries an unavoidable logarithmic cost, while every fixed higher mode number follows a different power law. Certification task and resource accounting. The device is an arbitrary normal, memoryless bosonic quantum channel. The task distinguishes the identity from channels at least ε away in the energy-constrained diamond norm, defined using the full trace norm and a signal-energy budget Es. This guarantee includes inputs entangled with an unrestricted reference system. The physical probes are fresh coherent states with classically chosen amplitudes. Adaptive choices, retained quantum outputs and a final joint measurement are allowed. Every device call, including a vacuum pulse, is counted, and the actual illumination obeys ∑t=1TEK∥αt∥2≤TEp under every channel in the testing promise. The probe budget Ep is distinct from the signal budget Es defining the certification guarantee. Optimal mean-energy query laws. For fixed positive Es,Ep, fixed finite mode number m, and both testing errors at most δ, the minimax number of calls satisfies Tmean(1)(ε,δ)=ΘEs,Ep(ε−4logε1logδ1),Tmean(m)(ε,δ)=Θm,Es,Ep(ε−(2m+2)logδ1),m≥2. The bounds hold for sufficiently small ε, uniformly over 0<δ≤1/4. Independent probes drawn from a physical positive multiscale source, followed by individual binary target tests, attain these orders. The matching converse covers adaptive coherent-probe protocols with quantum output memory. Thus those additional processing capabilities do not improve the asymptotic order within the stated preparation model. The result specifies matching scaling laws, rather than exact finite-query counts or optimal numerical constants. Why one mode has an extra logarithm. Rare high-photon coherences can strongly affect an energy-bounded quantum input while leaving only a weak signature on coherent probes. The proof retains this interference through a positive coherent-frame Green kernel. Its spectral sum grows as tlogt for one mode and as tm for fixed m≥2. A complementary family of physical channels shows that the single-mode logarithm is necessary, rather than an artifact of the reconstruction bound. What source brightness changes. The optimal mean-only laws contrast with prescribed independent Gaussian modulation, for which logTG=Θ(ε−2) at fixed confidence. A fixed brightness cap gives logTcap=Θ(ε−2log(1/ε)). The article also establishes matching logarithmic orders under stretched-exponential brightness constraints and develops the conversion from average coherent-probe error to thermal Choi-state and energy-constrained worst-input guarantees. These are worst-case certification limits for the specified coherent-probe access model. The channel class retains infinite photon tails and imposes no output-energy bound. This updated, integrated 37-page article contains the main results, two figure groups, complete proofs and references.
How much quantum memory is needed to restore an unknown optical pulse together with its correlations? This paper gives matching storage laws showing that the answer depends on the actual joint preparation, even when the optical marginal is a positive mixture of coherent states. Fix an optical mode number m, a known real k-dimensional displacement subspace with 1≤k≤2m, and a positive mean photon budget U0. The source is any probability mixture of coherent states in that subspace with actual mean photons at most U0. One normal encoder and decoder must work for the entire unknown source class, and every transmitted message or flag counts toward the same register dimension. The reference is inaccessible to both maps. Let δ be the required half trace-distance error and qmin(δ) the least encoded qubit count. As δ↓0, qmin(δ)=⎩⎨⎧2klog2(1/δ)+O(1),klog2(1/δ)+O(1),optical marginal or joint coherent preparation,arbitrary reference extension or classical-bit reference. A single inaccessible classical bit already witnesses the larger leading cost. To recover the smaller cost for correlations, the joint source must actually be prepared as ωAB=∫∣Jx⟩⟨Jx∣⊗τB(x)dμ(x), with ∫∣x∣2dμ≤U0. Here J is the known displacement embedding and τB(x) may be noncommuting normal reference states. The constants are uniform in the reference dimension and the orientation of J; the codec may depend on the known J. The mechanism is the difference between the probability of a rare bright component and the square-root amplitude of its retained correlations. Exact optical Gram matrices and a reference-coherence witness establish the converse for arbitrary normal decoders, including infinite-rank outputs. A common finite optical subspace supplies the attaining compression schemes while retaining the full photon tails. These are single-input universal memory-dimension laws at fixed m,k,U0, with every communication resource counted. They complement established known-source and many-copy compression theory. The integrated 10-page PDF contains two figures, complete proofs and references.
Purity does not change under a phase rotation, but estimating it from successive optical pulses can still require relative-phase information. This article determines the best possible precision when an unknown single-mode source is independently prepared, undergoes photon loss, and is then rotated by a hidden correlated phase trajectory. A uniform precision law. The normal source state satisfies Tr(ρN)≤E and Tr(ρNs)≤M, with fixed E,M>0 and s≥1. The phase starts uniformly on the circle, independently of the entire sequence of independent increments, whose known Fourier spectrum is exp(−γ∣q∣β), with γ>0 and 0<β≤2. The target is the purity Pη=Tr[Lη(ρ)2] after pure loss, not the purity of the phase-averaged marginal. For m source preparations, set p=1−η, Lm=[log(m+e)]1/β and qm=⌈[logm/(2γ)]1/β⌉. The minimax expected absolute error obeys Rm(Pη)≍Fm(p),Fm(p)=Lm−sηqm+Lm−2s(1+pLm)−2s. The comparison constants are uniform for η∈[1/2,1], including transmissivities approaching one as the budget grows. An ideal adjacent-pair interference measurement, independent of the transmissivity, attains the order. The converse allows arbitrary joint measurements on the complete correlated quantum history. The same law holds for the second Rényi entropy −logPη. What loss changes. Vacuum–high-photon coherence and coherence between broad high-photon packets give two different hard pairs of legal sources. Without loss the rate is (logm)−s/β; at fixed nonzero loss it is (logm)−4s/β. Each loss level has its own output target. The faster rate therefore does not mean improved recovery of the original input purity. Both constructions retain their actual moment budgets, the same source within each experiment and complete photon tails. Mean cost, stopping and unbiased readings. Allowing arbitrary quantum memory, feedback and an observable stopping time leaves the order unchanged when only the worst-case mean number of requested raw source slots is bounded by B: RBstop(Pη)≍F⌊B⌋(1−η). Every requested slot is charged, including discarded slots and failed outcomes. An exactly unbiased purity estimator attains the same absolute-error order with finite mean cost and almost-sure termination, using rare, unbounded signed readings. Under the specified independent common-phase reset and auxiliary-reset permissions for repeated blocks, exact unbiasedness and uniformly finite mean cost rule out uniformly finite variance. This is a uniform obstruction over sources, not a claim of infinite variance at every source; exact unbiasedness is not asserted for the Rényi entropy. The analysis builds on swap/parity measurements, drift diagnostics, quadratic-functional deconvolution and randomized telescoping. Its contribution is the matching quantum-history law, its uniform loss dependence and its return to the actual mean preparation budget. The integrated 14-page PDF contains two figure groups, complete proofs and references. The figures illustrate asymptotic rate functions, not experimental data or calibrated sample requirements; detector, phase-control, storage and elapsed-time costs are separate from the source-slot optimum.
How far can an amplifier's complete photon-count record depart from its coherent-light reference when the output entropy and the source's mean-photon budget are known? This article determines sharp endpoint laws for that inference. Photon counting reads occupations, but coherence changes the entropy cost of producing those occupations; the available energy budget selects the most efficient coherent pattern. A common physical comparison. For one optical mode, let μ=Tr(aρ), ρc=D(−μ)ρD(μ), and Ec=Tr(Nρ)−∣μ∣2. The reference is the source's actual field mean. For the quantum-limited amplifier A2 of gain two with a vacuum auxiliary mode, define Δ(ρ)=g−1(S(A2ρ))−1,T(ρ)=21∑k≥0⟨k∣A2(ρc)∣k⟩−2−k−1, where S is von Neumann entropy in nats and g(x)=(x+1)log(x+1)−xlogx. Thus Δ is an output quantum-entropy excess expressed in photon units, rather than the Shannon entropy of the observed counts. The constrained frontier is FE(δ)=sup{T(ρ):Ec(ρ)≤E,Δ(ρ)≤δ}. Three sharp endpoints. For every fixed finite E>0, FE(δ)=169δ+o(δ),δ↓0. Weak squeezing attains this coefficient. The corresponding local ratio also holds on every fixed finite number of modes, using the complete joint count record and the total entropy photon-number excess. Its neighbourhood may depend on the fixed mode count and energy budget. For centred mean-photon budgets m=1,2, put Λm=1−2−m and δmsat=g−1(S(A2(∣m⟩⟨m∣)))−1. The exact saturated frontier is Fm(δ)=Λm for δ≥δmsat, and its approach from below obeys Fm(δ)=Λm−cm(δmsat−δ)+o(δmsat−δ), with c1≃0.73151177, c2≃0.16207193, δ1sat≃0.92689630, and δ2sat≃1.70174873. The article gives exact expressions and certified numerical enclosures. Mean-cancelling vacuum/one-/two-photon superpositions attain the first saturation slope; phase-aligned zero-/two-/four-photon superpositions attain the second. The pure-state and full mixed-state optimizations have the same endpoint coefficients. Scope and mechanism. The budgets constrain centred mean energy, not the maximum photon number in each preparation. The proofs retain arbitrary normal mixed states and moving infinite photon tails. They combine uniform entropy comparisons with a decomposition that keeps the coherent part and mixed remainder tied to the same physical source. The endpoint laws concern a fixed ideal channel and its full count distribution; learning the reference and estimating entropy require separate measurement resources. The intermediate frontiers are not interpolated or claimed to be globally solved. This independent article complements entropy-minimization and single-event no-click bounds by treating the complete count law with actual-mean compensation. The integrated 27-page PDF contains four figure groups, complete proofs, reconstructible coefficient certificates and references.
Detecting non-Gaussian light establishes that a resource is present. Its structure and preparation record determine the cost of turning it into a specified output. This paper gives matching conversion-cost laws for weak optical sources and a general input certificate that can exclude every allowed Gaussian receiver before a circuit is designed. Sources with identical energy, covariance and total photon statistics can have different cost exponents; losing a classical phase bit can make a fixed-source conversion impossible. Source, target and accounting. The Wigner-positive two-mode sources are obtained by half loss on each mode: ρt,e,q=L1/2⊗2[1+t2∣00⟩⟨00∣+t2{(1−q)∣p+⟩⟨p+∣+q∣p−⟩⟨p−∣}],∣p±⟩=1+e2∣22⟩±e(∣40⟩+∣04⟩)/2,0≤e≤41,0≤q≤21,E=1+t22t2. Here e selects the source, q is an unflagged phase-record error probability, and E is delivered mean photon number. Conversion targets τ∗=(18∣0⟩⟨0∣+6∣1⟩⟨1∣+∣2⟩⟨2∣)/25,21∥σout−τ∗∥1≤δ,0<δ<10−5. Joint processing of independent supplied copies, Gaussian ancillas, squeezing, memory, Gaussian measurements, feedback, discarding and postselection are allowed. Cost is C=EK/ps: every source request counts, including vacuum requests and failed attempts. The task uses ideal Gaussian operations and charges supplied copies. 1. A source-selection law controlled by record accuracy. Optimizing both the source parameter e and the allowed Gaussian protocol gives, uniformly in q∈[0,1/2] as E→0, logCbest(E,q)=Θδ(max{E−1/3,q/E}). Errors of order E1/3 or smaller preserve the fastest logarithmic cost. Above that scale, record quality controls the optimum. Equivalently, for q=q0Ea, fixed 0<q0≤1/2 and a≥0, logCbest=Θδ(E−β),β=max{1/3,(1−a)/2}. At fixed nonzero error, choosing the phase-insensitive source keeps conversion possible at logarithmic cost of order E−1/2. 2. The same elementary diagnostics, exponentially different costs. The normalized excitation polynomials pA(z)=48z14−z24,pB(z)=8(z12−z22)2 give calibrated half-loss sources with identical energy, covariance and total photon-number statistics, but for the same target and tolerance, logCA(E)=Θδ(E−1/3),logCB(E)=Θδ(E−1/2). The distinction is the local structure of their excitation-polynomial zeros. Full Gaussian-protocol lower bounds and matching heterodyne constructions establish both orders. 3. Certification survives errors that obstruct conversion. In the symmetric quartic family, the full first-mode photon distribution is independent of q. In particular, Px(1)=16(1+e2)E(4+e2)≥E/5,Px(N≥5)=0. Every state in the full one-mode Gaussian convex hull instead satisfies P(N≥5)≥4608000P(1)6. Photon counting therefore supplies a sufficient O(E−6) request budget at fixed false-positive and missed-detection probabilities against independent repetitions of any one unknown Gaussian-hull state. Yet, in the joint limit t→0, e/t→∞, finite-cost conversion has the threshold qc(t,e;δ)=Θδ((E/e2)1/3). For fixed e>0, any fixed positive unflagged error thus eventually obstructs this output. Flagged erasures behave differently: independently retaining a correct bit with probability ar>0 adds at most a factor 1/ar to a protocol that discards erasures. 4. A transferable exclusion certificate and an explicit receiver. A verified positive phase-space minorant with a physical pure Gaussian curvature reference supplies a source budget bκ. For a requested one-mode output whose trace-distance gap from the Gaussian convex hull is at least g, every allowed Gaussian protocol obeys C≥bκg2−κ/(2−κ),2−κκ<g2. The manuscript constructs the certificate and explicit incomplete-gamma budgets for the quartic sources. It also gives a centred-root heterodyne receiver. In its specified joint limit, with scaled error λ=deq(e/t)2/3, its optimized limiting one-photon population is supw=2[1+43−3/4λ3/4]1. The paper supplies de, the receiver action, and a photon-statistical output witness. These receiver formulas connect the desired output to tolerable record error; the general certificate supplies the protocol-independent cost bound. Together they let source designers compare preparation structure, record quality and total request budget for the same optical task.
An unknown optical phase can hide quantum non-Gaussianity in every individual mode while leaving it certifiable in the joint light. This paper shows when Gaussian measurements can exclude the complete Gaussian convex hull without knowing the source's common phase, and gives explicit finite-sample tests. The results guide whether to preserve phase relations between emissions and how to process the resulting measurement records. 1. Certification against the full Gaussian model. Let Gn be the trace-norm-closed convex hull of all physical n-mode Gaussian states. For a fixed known ρ∈/G1, form the common-phase state Ωn=∫02π(UϕρUϕ†)⊗n2πdϕ,Uϕ=e−iϕN. Finite Gaussian measurements with a laboratory phase reference and bounded classical scores achieve arbitrarily small false-positive and missed-detection probabilities. The null includes arbitrary Gaussian entanglement and classical correlations, with unrestricted displacement, squeezing and energy. In particular, infσn∈Gn∥Ωn−σn∥1⟶2. The norm is the full, unhalved trace norm. An unavailable common phase therefore differs operationally from independently randomising the phase of each emission. 2. An exact coherence boundary and a joint-only resource. For the displaced two-Gaussian-packet family, centred by its actual mean before pure loss, the Gaussian-hull boundary is ρη,ν∈G1⟺ν≤νc,νc=exp[−2(1−η)(v−1/2)2v2R]. Here v>1/2 is the packet quadrature variance, R the momentum displacement, 0<τ,η<1 the packet weight and transmissivity, and 0≤ν≤1 the coherence visibility. The same membership boundary holds after common-phase averaging for every n≥3. At (v,R,τ,ν,η)=(20,2/9,9/50,1,1/2), each phase-averaged single mode is a Gaussian mixture, while the joint common-phase state lies outside Gn for n≥3. Independent phase averaging instead gives a Gaussian mixture at every block size. These states are separable and Wigner-positive: their difference is carried by phase relations across emissions. 3. The same two-packet source has an explicit finite certificate. Heterodyne phase training, a finite homodyne score and an eight-direction bounded tail test provide a complete certificate for the preceding parameter choice. With ideal Gaussian readout, the sufficient raw acquisition budget and certified errors are nraw=1015+2(4×1015)=9×1015,PFP<3.86×10−22,PFN<0.002068. This conservative budget establishes finite-sample certification of the joint-only resource; it is not an optimised experimental acquisition requirement. The PDF contains the measurement coefficients and complete proof. 4. A complementary two-million-trial implementation. For a displaced lossy single-photon source with unknown common phase, the target conditional state is ωφ=D(eiφ)2∣0⟩⟨0∣+∣1⟩⟨1∣D†(eiφ). A bounded homodyne score uses the full-Gaussian one-photon benchmark 33/(4e), 128 phase candidates and decision threshold 0.490. Including the specified source and readout tolerances, n=2×106,PFP<1.86×10−4,PFN<7.908×10−3. All vacuum emissions, loss events and measurement outcomes count towards the raw budget. This is a separate source family from the two-packet example. Together, the results distinguish unknown common phase from destructive phase randomisation and connect full-model exclusion to explicit Gaussian-measurement scores, error bounds and acquisition costs. The 15-page PDF includes the manuscript, two figures and complete supplementary proofs.