This paper compares Bohmian mechanics, Copenhagen interpretations, and the Scretching–Planck (SP) density–phase formulation, emphasizing the relationship between quantum density and energy. An exact contact-density relation for nonrelativistic Coulomb nS states reproduces Bohr’s hydrogen energies and photon transition energies under matching assumptions, including the approximately 10.1987154 eV transition from n = 1 to n = 2. Extensions to many-electron atoms, molecules, and free electrons clarify the limits of density as an energy proxy and the role of phase in kinetic energy. Electromagnetic coupling, selection rules, and measurement assumptions remain essential. No universal density-only energy law or new experimental validation is claimed.
This paper compares Bohmian mechanics, Copenhagen interpretations, and the Scretching–Planck (SP) density–phase formulation, emphasizing the relationship between quantum density and energy. An exact contact-density relation for nonrelativistic Coulomb nS states reproduces Bohr’s hydrogen energies and photon transition energies under matching assumptions, including the approximately 10.1987154 eV transition from n = 1 to n = 2. Extensions to many-electron atoms, molecules, and free electrons clarify the limits of density as an energy proxy and the role of phase in kinetic energy. Electromagnetic coupling, selection rules, and measurement assumptions remain essential. No universal density-only energy law or new experimental validation is claimed.
This paper compares Copenhagen, Bohmian, and Scretching–Planck (SP) accounts of |ψ|² through a detailed analysis of hydrogen. Using the reduced-mass Coulomb model, it derives orbitals, radial probabilities, currents, energy levels, virial relations, contact densities, and transition properties. Calculations yield a ground-state energy of −13.598287264 eV and a first excitation energy of 10.198715448 eV within the ideal model. The analysis explains the conditional SP contact-density energy relation, distinguishes model results from measured values, and demonstrates why local density alone cannot generally determine energy. These results support SP as a density–phase representation of established dynamics without establishing a separate measurement ontology or new predictive extension.
This paper examines the symmetries of the Scretching–Planck (SP) framework as a density–phase formulation of the nonrelativistic Schrödinger equation. Where the density is positive, the SP equations are locally equivalent to Schrödinger dynamics and take the form of a continuity equation and a quantum Hamilton–Jacobi equation. The analysis derives probability conservation from global U(1) symmetry and examines gauge covariance, Galilean transformations, spacetime symmetries, the hydrogenic SO(4) symmetry, and electric-dipole selection rules. For hydrogenic nS states in a specified Coulomb family, the paper derives an exact relation between the density at the nucleus and the binding energy. A counterexample shows that wavefunctions with the same density can have different energies because their phases differ. Comparison with NIST reference data quantifies the discrepancy in the reduced-mass Coulomb model. The paper treats spin, non-Abelian gauge theory, and curved spacetime as proposed extensions beyond the equivalence established here. The study is theoretical and uses published data for benchmarking [1–9].
The Scretching–Planck (SP) continuity and phase equations, obtained from ψ = √P e^(iS/ħ), are the same scalar equations that underlie de Broglie–Bohm mechanics [1–3]. The SP quantum term is Bohm’s quantum potential, and the SP flow velocity ∇S/m is the guidance velocity. Bohmian mechanics assigns positions to particles, while the SP programme uses (P, S) as working variables. The two-slit example illustrates equivariance with a Kolmogorov–Smirnov distance of 0.0178 for 4,000 trajectories, below the approximate 5% critical value of 0.0215. The free-state energy split conserves ⟨p²⟩/(2m) as the Fisher and flow contributions change. Further examples show no crossing, rigid coherent-state motion and the pointwise balance for real stationary states, where the guidance velocity vanishes and ⟨T⟩ = ⟨Q_SP⟩. A single-valued wave function imposes the circulation condition ∮∇S·dl = nh, which the local hydrodynamic equations alone do not supply [4]. Eight solved problems are included.
This paper examines how the Scretching–Planck (SP) density–phase formulation recovers Schrödinger dynamics and, through a separately specified covariant scalar action, Klein–Gordon dynamics. It clarifies phase, nodal, boundary, and operator requirements and identifies the additional structures needed for matrix mechanics, Dirac, Proca, London, and Yang–Mills theories. Reproducible numerical checks test hydrogen energies and transitions, density inversion, oscillator truncation, Clifford algebra, magnetic screening, and non-Abelian examples. Twenty-four corrected solved problems and numerical methods support the analysis. The results verify mathematical equivalences and model calculations without establishing new physical predictions or independent experimental validation.
The Scretching–Planck (SP) density–phase action is locally equivalent to the Schrödinger equation wherever the density is positive. Reconstructing a global wavefunction also requires single-valuedness and compatibility with nodal and boundary conditions. Relativistic and gauge extensions require independently specified fields and dynamics. Varying the gauged matter action together with a separately chosen parity-even gauge kinetic term yields the classical Yang–Mills equations. On a finite spatial lattice, the spectral gap in the physical sector is given by the vacuum-weighted Poincaré constant with the Hamiltonian’s kinetic prefactor. Constructing the four-dimensional continuum theory and establishing a uniform positive gap in physical units remain open. For hydrogen, the reduced-mass Coulomb calculation gives a ground-state energy of −13.5982873 eV and a 1S–2P interval of 10.1987154 eV before additional recoil and level corrections.