International Conference on Computer Science and Engineering (UBMK)
Comparative Analysis of Classical Machine Learning and Quantum Machine Learning on the NASA C-MAPSS Turbofan Engine Dataset: A Comprehensive Experimental Evaluation Focused on Fault Detection (FD001–FD004)
This study systematically compares classical machine learning (ML) and quantum machine learning (QML) methods in the context of fault detection across all subsets of the NASA Commercial Modular Aero-Propulsion System Simulation (C-MAPSS) dataset (FD001–FD004). Within a binary classification framework (RUL ≤ 30 cycles threshold), classical models such as Random Forest (RF), SMOTE+RF, Gradient Boosting (GBM), XGBoost, and LSTM are compared against quantum/hybrid models such as the Variational Quantum Classifier (VQC), Quantum Support Vector Machine (QSVM), Quantum LSTM (QLSTM), and Hybrid Quantum-Classical CNN (HQCNN). Experiments conducted using 4 qubits, 3 circuit layers, and a Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) simulator (PennyLane default.qubit) reveal that classical ML models—particularly XGBoost (F1 ≥ 0.940, AUC ≥ 0.990)—substantially outperform QML models in the current NISQ era (QLSTM: F1 ≈ 0.903, HQCNN: F1 ≈ 0.877). The ablation study demonstrates that this gap is attributable primarily to model architecture rather than to data volume. The study experimentally characterizes the current limitations of NISQ-era QML applications and offers practical guidance for the design of future hybrid pipelines.
This study systematically compares classical machine learning (ML) and quantum machine learning (QML) methods in the context of fault detection across all subsets of the NASA Commercial Modular Aero-Propulsion System Simulation (C-MAPSS) dataset (FD001–FD004). Within a binary classification framework (RUL ≤ 30 cycles threshold), classical models such as Random Forest (RF), SMOTE+RF, Gradient Boosting (GBM), XGBoost, and LSTM are compared against quantum/hybrid models such as the Variational Quantum Classifier (VQC), Quantum Support Vector Machine (QSVM), Quantum LSTM (QLSTM), and Hybrid Quantum-Classical CNN (HQCNN). Experiments conducted using 4 qubits, 3 circuit layers, and a Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) simulator (PennyLane default.qubit) reveal that classical ML models—particularly XGBoost (F1 ≥ 0.940, AUC ≥ 0.990)—substantially outperform QML models in the current NISQ era (QLSTM: F1 ≈ 0.903, HQCNN: F1 ≈ 0.877). The ablation study demonstrates that this gap is attributable primarily to model architecture rather than to data volume. The study experimentally characterizes the current limitations of NISQ-era QML applications and offers practical guidance for the design of future hybrid pipelines.
This study presents a comparative analysis of classical machine learning (ML) and quantum machine learning (QML) algorithms for industrial equipment fault detection using the AI4I 2020 Predictive Maintenance dataset. A total of nine models were evaluated through 5-fold stratified cross-validation: three classical models - Logistic Regression, Random Forest, and XGBoost - alongside six quantum models, namely Quantum Support Vector Machine (QSVM), Quantum K-Nearest Neighbors (QKNN), Quantum Kernel-based hybrid classifiers (QK+RF, QK+GB), Pegasos Quantum Support Vector Classifier (PegasosQSVC), and Variational Quantum Classifier (VQC). All quantum experiments were conducted using the IBM Qiskit framework and AerSimulator backend. Under a controlled comparison using an identical 300-sample budget and the same 5-fold cross-validation protocol, the best classical model (Random Forest, F1=0.902) outperformed the best quantum kernel method (QKNN, F1=0.820) by approximately 8.2 points. These results indicate that quantum kernel methods do not provide a dataefficiency advantage over classical methods on this dataset, although they achieve reasonably competitive results (F1 ≥0.75 for kernel-based methods) at substantially higher computational cost (quantum: ~124-137 s/fold for kernel methods, up to ~257 s/fold for VQC, vs. classical: 0.01-0.26 s/fold). We analyze the sources of this gap and attribute it primarily to a mismatch between the unitarily-invariant geometry of the fidelity kernel and the axisaligned threshold structure of the AI4I failure modes, rather than to information loss in dimensionality reduction, which the faircomparison design rules out. We further show that this apparent quantum competitiveness stems partly from an unequal-data-volume comparison common in prior QML benchmarking studies, which our fair-comparison protocol corrects.
Breast cancer is a major health concern, and early detection can make a great difference in treatment and survival rates for breast cancer patients. Machine learning methods have noticeably improved prediction accuracy on high-dimensional medical datasets and have become widely used tools in medical diagnostics. The transition to a quantum computational framework has opened new directions in machine learning research. By using qubits instead of classical bits, quantum models may provide new ways to represent and process complex medical data. In medical diagnostics, this has led to a growing interest in whether quantum approaches can improve classification performance more effectively than classical methods. The purpose of this paper is to compare classical and quantum machine learning models on the task of breast cancer classification and to determine whether quantum models can achieve higher accuracy and faster prediction on a selected dataset. Alongside the main simulator-based experiment, a smaller experiment was performed on a real IBM quantum computer to demonstrate the practical execution of the same task under current hardware constraints. In the practical part of the study, the Wisconsin Diagnostic Breast Cancer (WDBC) dataset was used. This dataset consists of 569 samples with 30 numerical features extracted from digitized fine needle aspirate images and provides a reliable basis for evaluating model performance. A comparative analysis was conducted between classical and quantum machine learning models, including a support vector machine (SVM), an artificial neural network (ANN), a quantum support vector machine (QSVM), and a hybrid quantum-classical neural network (QNN). In the simulator-based experiment, both SVM and ANN achieved an accuracy of 0.956 with an F1-score of 0.965 on the test set, while QSVM reached an accuracy of 0.807 with an F1-score of 0.866 and the Hybrid QNN achieved 0.623 accuracy with an F1-score of 0.677. These quantum and hybrid models also required substantially longer training times than the classical baselines. A small hardware experiment on an IBM quantum device further illustrates both the practical feasibility and the current limitations of executing this classification task on noisy intermediate-scale quantum hardware.
With the advancement of quantum computing in the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era, hybrid quantum-classical algorithms have emerged as promising approaches for addressing certain machine learning tasks. This study investigates the Variational Quantum Classifier (VQC), a hybrid model that integrates parameterized quantum circuits with classical optimization routines, implemented via IBM’s Qiskit framework. We provide a detailed account of the VQC architecture, including feature encoding, ansatz construction, and optimization methodology. To assess its performance, we conduct a comparative analysis between VQC and classical Support Vector Classifiers (SVC) across synthetic and real-world datasets, including Iris and a binary-filtered version of MNIST. Experimental results reveal that classical models consistently achieve higher accuracy and faster training times. However, the VQC demonstrates functional viability, particularly under noise-free conditions and reduced-dimensionality settings. These findings underscore the current limitations of quantum models while highlighting the potential of VQC as a proof-of-concept for quantum-enhanced learning as quantum hardware matures.
Cardiovascular diseases remain a leading global health challenge, driving the need for advanced, accurate diagnostic tools. While classical machine learning (ML) models like XGBoost have achieved significant success in medical diagnosis, they often face challenges related to accuracy plateaus and model explainability in complex, high-dimensional data spaces. Quantum machine learning (QML) emerges as a promising paradigm to potentially overcome these limitations by leveraging quantum computational advantages. This study aims to develop and evaluate a hybrid quantum-classical pipeline for the early detection of heart disease. We integrate robust data preprocessing—including missing value imputation, feature engineering, SMOTE for class balancing, and PCA for dimensionality reduction—with two classification approaches: a classical XGBoost model and a quantum Variational Quantum Classifier (VQC). Our results demonstrate that the XGBoost model achieves strong performance with an accuracy of 88.52% and an F1-score of 0.8852 on an imbalanced test set. While the VQC model did not surpass the classical baseline in the current noisy simulation environment, it shows theoretical promise. This work highlights the practical challenges of current QML and outlines a clear pathway for future research towards achieving a quantum advantage in clinical decision support systems.
The increasing complexity and volume of financial transactions pose significant challenges to traditional fraud detection systems. This technical report investigates and compares the efficacy of classical, quantum, and quantum-hybrid machine learning models for the binary classification of fraudulent financial activities. As of our methodology, first, we develop a comprehensive behavioural feature engineering framework to transform raw transactional data into a rich, descriptive feature set. Second, we implement and evaluate a range of models on the IBM Anti-Money Laundering (AML) dataset. The classical baseline models include Logistic Regression, Decision Tree, Random Forest, and XGBoost. These are compared against three hybrid classic quantum algorithms architectures: a Quantum Support Vector Machine (QSVM), a Variational Quantum Classifier (VQC), and a Hybrid Quantum Neural Network (HQNN). Furthermore, we propose Fraud Detection for Quantum Computing (FD4QC), a practical, API-driven system architecture designed for real-world deployment, featuring a classical-first, quantum-enhanced philosophy with robust fallback mechanisms. Our results demonstrate that classical tree-based models, particularly \textit{Random Forest}, significantly outperform the quantum counterparts in the current setup, achieving high accuracy (97.34%) and F-measure (86.95%). Among the quantum models, \textbf{QSVM} shows the most promise, delivering high precision (77.15%) and a low false-positive rate (1.36%), albeit with lower recall and significant computational overhead. This report provides a benchmark for a real-world financial application, highlights the current limitations of quantum machine learning in this domain, and outlines promising directions for future research.
Purpose This study investigates the integration of quantum-enhanced machine learning (QML) into medical image analysis, focusing on classification and feature extraction tasks. It aims to evaluate whether hybrid quantum-classical models can overcome the limitations of traditional machine learning in handling high-dimensional, clinically relevant imaging data. Design/methodology/approach Hybrid architectures combining classical preprocessing with quantum components, specifically variational quantum circuits (VQCs) and quantum kernel methods, were developed and implemented in simulated quantum environments using Qiskit and PennyLane on Google Colab. Publicly available datasets (ChestX-ray14, Brain Tumor MRI and CT Hemorrhage) were preprocessed and encoded into quantum states. Model performance was evaluated against classical baselines (MLP and CNN) using accuracy, precision, recall, F1-score, convergence speed and trainable parameters. Findings Quantum-enhanced models achieved competitive or superior performance compared to classical models with significantly fewer trainable parameters and faster convergence. The Quantum Kernel SVM demonstrated the highest precision (89.1%) and F1-score (88.5%) using only 8 parameters, while VQC models converged up to 2× faster than classical baselines. These results highlight the potential of QML to improve efficiency, robustness and scalability in diagnostic imaging workflows, particularly in resource-constrained or data-limited settings. Research limitations/implications The study relies on simulated quantum environments, which do not capture hardware noise or qubit limitations. Future work will extend to real quantum devices, multimodal data integration and interpretability strategies. Practical implications Quantum kernel methods and lightweight VQC architectures enable faster, resource-efficient diagnostic modeling, making them suitable for clinical environments with limited computational capacity or time-sensitive decision-making needs. Social implications Improving the efficiency and accessibility of medical image analysis has the potential to support faster diagnosis and enhance healthcare delivery, particularly in underserved or resource-limited regions. Originality/value This study provides a practical evaluation of hybrid quantum-classical models applied to multiple real medical imaging datasets in a reproducible simulated environment. It offers an early-stage framework demonstrating how QML techniques can be integrated into existing machine learning pipelines for medical image analysis.