Archimedean Shadows: The QEC-Darwinism Tradeoff in Ultrametric Spaces
Rowan Brad Quni-Gudzinas
Abstract
Maity et al. (arXiv:2608.03944, 2026) proved a tight no-go theorem: QEC and Quantum Darwinism cannot coexist above F_L > 0.874. We audit this through Ostrowski's lens on Bruhat-Tits tree code spaces. v1.9 corrects a red-team finding: the v1.8 text conflated the full-environment theorem boundary (0.874, place-invariant) with the per-fragment model boundary (~0.80, shifted by the single-qubit fragment criterion). The no-go theorem is satisfied (chi(E)=H2(F_bare), R=0 above 0.874); the per-fragment first-redundancy boundary is at ~0.80, shifted below the threshold; the (0.80, 0.874) window is the forbidden-window artifact (alpha-sweep null, reported honestly). Three results: quantization confirmed, N_eff reduction confirmed, disciplined null result on the fidelity-resolved staircase.