Reproducibility note and two wording corrections (28 October 2026). The note’s appendix promises check_dissipation_law.py, which version 1 did not carry. It has been written and run: 109 checks, 109 pass, with 53 derived from the C60 adjacency alone, 45 from the stated premises, 6 internal-consistency, 4 Monte-Carlo and 1 using a reconstructed input. The MEASURED set is empty, and that is itself a check: the note’s own flow-position paragraph says it compares no kernel number with measured data, and that was confirmed rather than assumed. Definitions are tagged as such and are never counted as derivations. Every entry of Table 1 and every number in §3, §4, §5.3, §6.1 and §6.2 reproduces. 1. §3.1’s “fails by at least 19%” is a property of one draw, not a bound. On the setup described, the smallest control deviation is 40.6%, so the floor holds there comfortably. But across 500 random cases (25 draws × 5 β × 4 t) the minimum falls to 10.1%, with 0.6% of cases below 19%. The substantive content is far stronger than the stated floor and should be given instead: every one of the 500 control cases exceeds its own KMS error by a factor of 3.5×10¹³ or more. Suggested wording: “fails by factors of 10¹³ or more above the machine-precision residual.” Relatedly, §3.1’s “relative error 3×10⁻¹⁵” is the typical value, not an attainable bound: the median over 500 cases is 3.23×10⁻¹⁵, the 90th percentile 8.1×10⁻¹⁵, the maximum 2.2×10⁻¹³. 2. §6.2’s “Stratonovich simulation” label does not fit the reported figure. The number itself is right — the theory value 19.44 and the closed form are exact and confirmed — but a direct Stratonovich–Heun integral of the locked case carries a large O(dt) bias, because the phase-difference modes relax at rate ~K = 30: dt = 0.002 gives 14.94 and dt = 0.001 gives 17.16, so reaching the reported 0.15% would need dt ≈ 10⁻⁵, far beyond what “N = 6, D = 0.25, K = 30, 400 replicas” implies. The exact Itō form of the same quantity, D⁻¹(⟨ΣFi²⟩ + D⟨∇·F⟩), carries no stochastic-integral bias and gives 19.4651 at dt = 0.001, converging to theory as dt falls. So the estimator, not the result, is what the label misnames. Separately, the ω list is never given, so the printed simulated triple is not reproducible as such; the printed theory triple is internally consistent (24.42 − 19.44 = 4.98 exactly) and is reproduced exactly from a reconstructed ω with mean 0.9 and population variance 0.2075. The note’s “var” is unambiguously the population variance — the identity fails for the sample variance. 3. §1’s “the C60 spectral values 1, 4−φ and φ” is loose on the third. 1 is an eigenvalue of A with multiplicity 9; 4−φ is an eigenvalue of L = 3I − A with multiplicity 5, since 3 − 1/φ = 4 − φ; but φ is an eigenvalue of neither (nearest level 0.0565 away in A, 0.1796 in L). Only −φ is, with multiplicity 5. The note says so itself two paragraphs later, so this is internal looseness of wording rather than a numerical error, and the product identity (4−φ)·φ = 3φ−1 = 3.854101966249685 is exact. Two results are worth naming because they are stronger than stated. Aut(A) ≅ Ih is confirmed structurally, not merely by order: order 120, 31 involutions, centre of order 2 and no element of order 4, which pins A₅ × C₂ and rules out S₅ (25 involutions, trivial centre). And in §6.1 the garbled line is ΔSsys = −TC₁, the total correlation: the system’s entropy falls by exactly the correlation that forms, verified symbolically, with C/8 = H(p₁) exactly — which is why the printed closed form for (E/S)op holds. Ψop was rebuilt from ledger quantities alone, with no A, B or C in it, and agrees with the printed form to 2.5×10⁻¹⁷⁵. A scope and status note on the coherence dissipation law. Separates what the C60 adjacency forces from what it forbids, and states the open-system form that survives after the bare coefficient was retired in the record. The law in every surviving form is posited, not forced, and the paper says so wherever it matters. Includes the two-ledger theorem under stated premises, a no-go result limited to coherence functionals built from the adjacency, and a verification script.
Reproducibility note and two wording corrections (28 October 2026). The note’s appendix promises check_dissipation_law.py, which version 1 did not carry. It has been written and run: 109 checks, 109 pass, with 53 derived from the C60 adjacency alone, 45 from the stated premises, 6 internal-consistency, 4 Monte-Carlo and 1 using a reconstructed input. The MEASURED set is empty, and that is itself a check: the note’s own flow-position paragraph says it compares no kernel number with measured data, and that was confirmed rather than assumed. Definitions are tagged as such and are never counted as derivations. Every entry of Table 1 and every number in §3, §4, §5.3, §6.1 and §6.2 reproduces. 1. §3.1’s “fails by at least 19%” is a property of one draw, not a bound. On the setup described, the smallest control deviation is 40.6%, so the floor holds there comfortably. But across 500 random cases (25 draws × 5 β × 4 t) the minimum falls to 10.1%, with 0.6% of cases below 19%. The substantive content is far stronger than the stated floor and should be given instead: every one of the 500 control cases exceeds its own KMS error by a factor of 3.5×10¹³ or more. Suggested wording: “fails by factors of 10¹³ or more above the machine-precision residual.” Relatedly, §3.1’s “relative error 3×10⁻¹⁵” is the typical value, not an attainable bound: the median over 500 cases is 3.23×10⁻¹⁵, the 90th percentile 8.1×10⁻¹⁵, the maximum 2.2×10⁻¹³. 2. §6.2’s “Stratonovich simulation” label does not fit the reported figure. The number itself is right — the theory value 19.44 and the closed form are exact and confirmed — but a direct Stratonovich–Heun integral of the locked case carries a large O(dt) bias, because the phase-difference modes relax at rate ~K = 30: dt = 0.002 gives 14.94 and dt = 0.001 gives 17.16, so reaching the reported 0.15% would need dt ≈ 10⁻⁵, far beyond what “N = 6, D = 0.25, K = 30, 400 replicas” implies. The exact Itō form of the same quantity, D⁻¹(⟨ΣFi²⟩ + D⟨∇·F⟩), carries no stochastic-integral bias and gives 19.4651 at dt = 0.001, converging to theory as dt falls. So the estimator, not the result, is what the label misnames. Separately, the ω list is never given, so the printed simulated triple is not reproducible as such; the printed theory triple is internally consistent (24.42 − 19.44 = 4.98 exactly) and is reproduced exactly from a reconstructed ω with mean 0.9 and population variance 0.2075. The note’s “var” is unambiguously the population variance — the identity fails for the sample variance. 3. §1’s “the C60 spectral values 1, 4−φ and φ” is loose on the third. 1 is an eigenvalue of A with multiplicity 9; 4−φ is an eigenvalue of L = 3I − A with multiplicity 5, since 3 − 1/φ = 4 − φ; but φ is an eigenvalue of neither (nearest level 0.0565 away in A, 0.1796 in L). Only −φ is, with multiplicity 5. The note says so itself two paragraphs later, so this is internal looseness of wording rather than a numerical error, and the product identity (4−φ)·φ = 3φ−1 = 3.854101966249685 is exact. Two results are worth naming because they are stronger than stated. Aut(A) ≅ Ih is confirmed structurally, not merely by order: order 120, 31 involutions, centre of order 2 and no element of order 4, which pins A₅ × C₂ and rules out S₅ (25 involutions, trivial centre). And in §6.1 the garbled line is ΔSsys = −TC₁, the total correlation: the system’s entropy falls by exactly the correlation that forms, verified symbolically, with C/8 = H(p₁) exactly — which is why the printed closed form for (E/S)op holds. Ψop was rebuilt from ledger quantities alone, with no A, B or C in it, and agrees with the printed form to 2.5×10⁻¹⁷⁵. A scope and status note on the coherence dissipation law. Separates what the C60 adjacency forces from what it forbids, and states the open-system form that survives after the bare coefficient was retired in the record. The law in every surviving form is posited, not forced, and the paper says so wherever it matters. Includes the two-ledger theorem under stated premises, a no-go result limited to coherence functionals built from the adjacency, and a verification script.
The complete fourth-order coefficient of the mean relative-entropy disturbance of a reduced encoded state under Gaussian coherent noise decomposes into five channels. Closed forms were previously available for two of them. This note evaluates the remaining three for the unitarily invariant ensemble, so that the whole coefficient is explicit for every bulk dimension d_1, every geometric dimension d_2 and every spectrum. The delta1-delta3 channel, reported in earlier work as measured but not evaluated, is A_13 = -(5/3) D (Xi - 1), with D = (d_1 d_2)^2 the total Hilbert-space dimension and Xi the Kubo-Mori spectral functional of the second-order theory. The proof uses only the two operator identities sum_a A_a^2 = D and sum_a A_a M A_a = Tr(M), and is independent of the code. The channel is negative for every spectrum, and not merely because Xi > 1: since the logarithmic mean is dominated by the arithmetic one, Xi >= d_1^2 with equality exactly at a degenerate spectrum, so A_13 <= -(5/3) D (d_1^2 - 1). The quartic commutator channel C is obtained in closed form as a contraction of the divided-difference kernel l_3 with two copies of the mode-sum tensor N, and is proved independent of d_2. The mixed channel B splits as B_1 + B_2. The remainder B_2 is the one that resisted: it is obtained here in closed form for every d_1, every d_2 and every spectrum, B_2 = 3 Xi - chi/2 - 2 + T, with chi = sum_u 1/p_u and T = sum_uvs l_2(u,v,s) p_u, where l_2 is the second confluent divided difference of the logarithm. T is a third spectral functional, and it is shown not to be a function of the other two: the best affine fit to {Xi, chi, 1} over forty interior spectra leaves worst residuals 2.86, 8.34 and 13.80 at d_1 = 3, 4, 5, against values of abs T reaching 82, 297 and 542. T is nevertheless not an alien object. In the variables m_k(t) = sum_u (p_u + t)^(-k) and h(t) = sum_u p_u/(p_u + t), the three functionals are Xi = integral h m_1 dt, chi = integral m_2 dt and T = -integral h m_1^2 dt, so T is the next member of one family. T and chi moreover scale alike, both as p^(-1), so no counting of degrees separates them; only the mode sum does. The derivation has two halves. The double mode sum Q_uvs = sum_ab (J_a)_uv (J_b)_vs (K_ab + K_ba)_su closes on the bulk spectrum alone, by four completeness identities: two that the preceding paper already prints, and two that carry an uncontracted mode operator and are what close the terms of K carrying A_a A_b Phi. Twenty-four cases are involved, and they are tabulated in the derivation note deposited in this record. The resulting divided-difference contractions then collapse by two identities proved from the integral representation of the Kubo-Mori kernels, F_4 = -d_1^2/2 and F_3 = d_1^2/2 - Xi. Three statements that could previously only be checked numerically follow as corollaries: B_2 is independent of d_2 and of the code; at a degenerate spectrum B_2 = -(1/2)(d_1^2 - 1)(d_1^2 - 4); and at d_1 = 2 it reduces to 2 (Xi - chi), that collapse being an accident of the dimension, since T there equals -(3/2) chi - w_12. Consequently the assembled coefficient is explicit at every configuration, its d_2-independent constant collapsing to 2 Xi - chi/2 - 1 + T + C. At d_1 = 2, d_2 = 2 and p = (0.7, 0.3) it reproduces a direct sampling measurement to 0.13 standard errors, at d_1 = 3 with a degenerate spectrum to 0.45, and the formula for A_13 reproduces retrodictively, to 0.55 standard errors, a measurement published before this derivation existed. Every closed form is certified against exact mode sums on an explicit orthonormal Hermitian basis of the full space, link by link rather than only end to end, and the formula for B_2 is tested on held-out spectra it never saw. An erratum to the preceding paper is also recorded. As printed, its third-order mode object L_abc = R([A_a,[A_b,[A_c,rho]]]) is anti-Hermitian, which would force A_13 to vanish identically for every ensemble, every code and every spectrum, contradicting the nonzero delta1-delta3 word measured in earlier work. The third-order deformation carries i^3, and restoring that factor removes the contradiction. That paper's own numerics evidently carried the factor, because it reports nonzero values of A_13 on two families that are not stabilizer codes; no value reported in any of the preceding papers is affected, and what requires correction is one definition as set. Two limitations are stated. Everything here is for the unitarily invariant ensemble, and none of the operator arguments survives for a structured mode family such as a Pauli basis on a stabilizer code. And a discrepancy with a published measurement at d_1 = 3, d_2 = 12 is located at a definite configuration but not adjudicated: the coefficient gives -9492 at the degenerate endpoint there, while the estimator used in this note cannot be carried to d_2 = 12 at the coupling used throughout, the Taylor control eps times the norm of W reaching 1.44. This note is posted here for the first time. It supplies the three missing channels of the five-channel decomposition of A Complete Fourth-Order Expansion of Reconstruction and Logical Errors for Arbitrary Gaussian Coherent Noise (Zenodo DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23644208), corrects one printed definition in it, and evaluates in closed form the delta1-delta3 word measured in A chi-squared divergence law for the fourth-order breakdown of entanglement wedge reconstruction in Gaussian holographic codes (Zenodo DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23621356). The degeneracy measurement it compares against is reported in Breakdown and Persistence of the Reconstruction-Error Hierarchy in Approximate Holographic Codes (DOI 10.13140/RG.2.2.19676.14723). The derivation note carrying the twenty-four case tables is deposited in this record as B2_derivation_note_2026-10-27.pdf. The scripts reproducing every number in the note are deposited as closed_forms_scripts.zip. They require Python 3.10+ and NumPy; no other dependencies, CPU only.
A pure encoded state of an approximate quantum code is perturbed by exp(i eps W) with W drawn from a centered Gaussian ensemble, and D(eps) denotes the relative-entropy disturbance of a reduced state. This paper derives the complete fourth-order coefficient of the mean disturbance in closed form, and identifies what that coefficient is made of. The derivation has two stages, and they assume different things. The first assumes nothing about the noise beyond that it is centered and Gaussian: the coefficient splits into five channels, one disconnected drift term and four connected ones, each a finite sum over pairs of Karhunen-Loeve modes of the covariance contracted with exact confluent divided differences of the logarithm. For any concrete noise model the whole quartic disturbance is then computable deterministically, with no sampling. The second stage adds one hypothesis, that the mode family is complete and orthonormal, and evaluates every channel. The device throughout is to substitute the integral representation of the divided differences before performing the index sums, which turns each Kronecker delta into a coincidence of resolvent labels, and then to integrate by parts in the ring Q[d_1][t, m_1, ..., m_4] of resolvent traces. No coefficient is fitted and no index contraction survives. What survives is four scalar functions of the Schmidt spectrum: Xi, chi, S_w and T. The assembled coefficient is a function of d_1, d_2 and those four alone, and four is the right number. The five functions 1, Xi, chi, T, S_w are proved linearly independent for every d_1 >= 3, analytically: a degeneration lemma confines the kernel to two dimensions and an expansion about the degenerate spectrum closes it, with discriminant d_1 (d_1 - 2)^2 / 4, which vanishes exactly at d_1 = 2, where the two relations that do make the set reducible are exhibited. The four are not a list that happens to close. Each is a contraction of the Kubo-Mori metric and the Amari-Chentsov skewness tensor on two operator directions, the identity and the maximal-coherence operator of the Schmidt eigenbasis; and those directions are not chosen but read off the mode two-point function, which the Gaussian ensemble fixes identically in the spectrum and for every d_1. The two are Kubo-Mori orthogonal, so chi is the squared classical Fisher length of the spectrum and S_w - chi the squared coherent length, bounded below sharply by d_1^2 (d_1 - 1). Every channel is a rational-weighted sum of metric and skewness contractions, with d_2 the only number entering from outside the geometry, and the skewness tensor enters the whole coefficient exactly once: at order d_2^0 and with weight -1/6, which is precisely the weight the relative-entropy expansion assigns to its own cubic term. The paper is explicit about scope. A dedicated section separates what is proved about the ensemble alone, which is everything, from what the code supplies, which is the Schmidt spectrum and the reading of log d_2 as an area term, and from where the gap lies. On a family of Pauli strings satisfying the Knill-Laflamme conditions on a stabilizer code the first-order mode objects vanish identically, so three of the five channels are not small but exactly zero, and the entire Amari-Chentsov contribution goes with them: the mechanism is a property of the ensemble, not of approximate codes in general. The step from the coefficient to a physical reconstruction-error floor requires fixing the backreaction at a chosen fraction of its Page value, a modelling decision that this paper does not make. The limitations section states four further points, including one archived measurement at d_1 = 3, d_2 = 12 which is located at a definite configuration, quantified, and left unadjudicated with the two reasons given. Every closed form is certified. The checks run from the defining index sums, from the raw five-channel sum built from the mode objects on an explicit orthonormal basis, from the geometric identifications, and, beyond the invariant ensemble, against direct simulation on structured families and stabilizer codes. Two of the latter are retrodictions: coefficients measured and archived earlier in this programme, before the present theory existed, are reproduced to +0.4 and 0.0 standard errors, with a previously unexplained connected excess given exactly by the connected-channel formula. The appendix evaluates the eighteen connected contractions on which the connected channel rests, and the deposited code derives all eighteen of them from the Wick rule and then checks symbolically that they sum to the closed form. This paper supersedes and absorbs three earlier preprints of this programme: 10.5281/zenodo.23644208, 10.5281/zenodo.23684111 and 10.5281/zenodo.23726789, together with the contraction appendix of 10.5281/zenodo.23621356. Those records remain available and are not withdrawn; readers should cite the present paper for any of their results, which are proved here in full and without reliance on unrefereed material. Version 3 corrects the presentation of the appendix table of eighteen connected contractions. Up to version 2 the nine word pairs were listed in five grouped rows, on the ground that the relations T_3 = T_1^dagger and conjugation with u <-> v relate the members of each row; those relations preserve a pair's d_2-degree but not its value, and for three pairs the grouped entry is therefore not the pair's own. The table is now listed pair by pair, the collected sum before the kernel contraction is displayed, and the deposited script derives all eighteen entries from the Wick rule rather than taking them as given. No result of the paper changes: the two matchings of a word pair are added together, and sum_uv w_uv p_u = sum_uv w_uv p_v by the symmetry of w, so the collected sum and everything downstream of it are unaffected. Version 3 also corrects the wording of the proof of the entropy-kernel lemma. The first-order term of the expansion of Tr f(sigma) is Tr[Delta log sigma_0] + Tr Delta, and it is removed by the second, linear term of the relative entropy rather than by Tr Delta = 0 as the earlier versions said; the conclusion of the lemma is unchanged and is verified in the deposited code. A fifth script, an independent review pass over the statements the other four do not cover, is added to the archive. The verification scripts that generate every entry of the certification table, together with the derivation and symbolic verification of the appendix table, are included in the attached archive under the MIT licence.
The fourth-order coefficient that controls the relative-entropy disturbance of a reduced quantum state under Gaussian coherent noise is identified here as one half of the quadratic form of the chi-squared divergence, evaluated not on a state but on the second-order mean drift of that state. The coefficient had appeared in an existing series of papers as a computed number attached to each noise family separately, with no statement of what kind of object it is. Naming it as a divergence norm on the drift is what makes the three results below possible, and each of them is a statement the series could not have reached while the coefficient remained a number. The first result is an identification, not a new computation. Five symbols are used for that coefficient across the series, carrying three different normalisations; they are shown to denote one quantity, and the conversion between them is recorded in a table. The normalisation that each symbol carries is stated explicitly, because the three differ by factors of the monitored dimension and of the total dimension, and a reader comparing two of the papers without that table would conclude that they disagree. The second result is a deformation. When the generating function of the expansion is replaced by the one-parameter family whose member at unit parameter is the logarithm, the coefficient becomes the quadratic form of the corresponding divergence of that family. The reason is local and explicit: the confluent value of the deformed kernel is the second derivative of the generator, so the kernel that the expansion produces is the Hessian of the generating function and nothing else. Closed forms follow for both noise families already studied, expressed in the power sums of the deformed theory. For unitarily invariant noise the coefficient is a single quadratic combination of three power sums. For Pauli-string noise on a stabilizer code only one power sum moves. The third result follows from the second. Because the only dependence on the deformation parameter sits in the diagonal of the kernel, whose sum over the spectrum is that single power sum, the counting law for stabilizer codes is invariant in form under the entire deformation, with the power sum read at the working parameter. The law is therefore not a feature of the relative entropy in particular; it is a feature of the whole family, and the choice of generating function changes one scalar in it and nothing of its structure. A structural correction to the series is also recorded, and it is the result with the clearest consequence for error correction. Protection at fourth order requires two independent conditions: the vanishing of every first-order amplitude, and the vanishing of the drift. The Knill-Laflamme condition supplies only the first. A code satisfying it may therefore carry a fourth-order error, and the residual is exactly the coefficient above together with the connected channel. That residual is thus the obstruction to full protection at this order, and a protection statement elsewhere in the series, which asserts the two conditions to be equivalent, is strictly weaker than it claims. A code and a noise family exhibiting the gap are given, and the residual is measured on them. The manuscript is self-contained. Three appendices derive, from the definitions, every ingredient that the results use: the two expansion coefficients and the quadratic form through the divided-difference Frechet derivative, the drift of each noise family from the completeness identities of the mode algebra, and the two vanishing arguments. No statement in the paper depends on work that is not yet published, and one appendix reproduces, from a convention-free law for the drift, the published coefficient of an earlier paper of the series, including the factor that the geometry of four tensor factors contributes to it. Every identity is certified numerically against the integral definitions of the deformed theory rather than against the closed forms used to derive it: the power sums are computed by quadrature in the substitution t = exp(u), with the interval split at the logarithm of every eigenvalue, at ninety working digits, and only then compared. Every statement of the appendices is checked separately on explicit matrices built from the definitions, with the perturbation applied by exact matrix exponentiation. Each check reports the discrepancy it attains rather than a verdict, so that the resolution of the test is visible; where a finite difference sets that resolution, the tolerance of the row is the resolution attained and not a wish. Three rational values reported as exactly verified in an earlier paper of the series are reproduced here from a single spectrum by a route not used when they were obtained. The archive deposited with this record carries the four self-contained checks, a README describing what each one measures, and the licence. Four further guards belong to the manuscript and are not in the archive, because none of them can run without files that are not part of it; they check the documents and the deposit rather than the mathematics, and all four are named in the README. The limitations of the work are stated in the manuscript as six paragraphs, among them the restriction of the drift to the diagonal case, the factor outside the weight hypothesis, and the extent of the prior-art search behind the disclaimer of novelty, which was two queries and the reading of two abstracts: the verdict recorded for the new statements is therefore "not found", which is weaker than "new". The use of an AI tool in the research and in the preparation of the manuscript is disclosed in the Acknowledgements, with the model and its version named, and described in the section on numerical certification.