Same quantum density, different hidden electron paths - diffusion-like (Nelson/MERW), smooth with velocity memory, Bohm, psMERW. Diffusion-like paths give imaginary-time correlations and kinetic energy from increments, no smooth path can (TRK slope) - but smooth paths are valid samplers of response via Dalgarno-Lewis. Larmor clock on tunnelling Rb atoms: residence of stochastic paths agrees with weak value and measured decrease at lower energy if velocity memory << traversal, longer memory goes continuously to Bohm, 12-64% too long. psMERW splittings -0.956 ω/Δ from E_n-(D/2Δ)<V''>, at Compton gap it is minus Darwin term - excluded by Lamb shift. Code and data included.
Same quantum density, different hidden electron paths - diffusion-like (Nelson/MERW), smooth with velocity memory, Bohm, psMERW. Diffusion-like paths give imaginary-time correlations and kinetic energy from increments, no smooth path can (TRK slope) - but smooth paths are valid samplers of response via Dalgarno-Lewis. Larmor clock on tunnelling Rb atoms: residence of stochastic paths agrees with weak value and measured decrease at lower energy if velocity memory << traversal, longer memory goes continuously to Bohm, 12-64% too long. psMERW splittings -0.956 ω/Δ from E_n-(D/2Δ)<V''>, at Compton gap it is minus Darwin term - excluded by Lamb shift. Code and data included.
As written by statistician George Box "All models are wrong, but some are useful", standard diffusion derivation or Feynman path ensembles use nonphysical infinite velocity/kinetic energy nowhere differentiable trajectories - what seems wrong, might be only our approximation to simplify mathematics. This article introduces some basic tools to investigate this issue. To consider ensembles of more physical finite velocity trajectories, we can work in (x,v) phase space like in Langevin equation with velocity controlling spatial steps, here also controlled with spatial potential V(x). There are derived and compared 4 approaches to predict stationary probability distributions: using Boltzmann ensemble of steps/points in space (GRW - generic random walk) or in phase space (psGRW), and analogously Boltzmann ensemble of paths in space (MERW - maximal entropy random walk) and in phase space (psMERW), also generalized to L{é}vy flights. Path ensembles generally have much stronger Anderson-like localization, MERW has stationary distribution exactly as quantum ground state. Proposed novel MERW in phase space has some slight differences, which might be distinguished experimentally. For example for 1D infinite potential well: ρ=1 stationary distribution for step ensemble, ρ∼sin2 for path ensemble (as in QM), and ρ∼sin for proposed smooth path ensembles - more frequently approaching the barriers due to randomly gained velocity.
Commonly held opinion is that particle trajectory descriptions are incompatible with quantum mechanics. Louis de Broglie (1926) first proposed a way to include trajectories in quantum mechanics, but the idea was abandoned until David Bohm (1952) re-invented and improved the theory. Bohm interprets the particle trajectories as physically real; for example, an electron actually is a particle moving on a well defined trajectory with a position and momentum at all times. By design, Bohm's trajectories never make predictions that differ from standard quantum mechanics, and their existence cannot be experimentally verified. \n \n \n \nThree new methods to obtain Bohm's particle trajectories are presented. The methods are non-dynamical, and utilize none of Bohm's equations of motion; in fact, two of the methods have no equations for a particle's trajectory. Instead, all three methods use only the evolving probability density ρ=ψ*ψ to extract the trajectories. The first two methods rest upon probability conservation and density sampling, while the third method employs the informational or geometrical construction of centroidal Voronoi tessellations. In one-dimension all three methods are proved to be equivalent to Bohm's particle trajectories. For higher dimensional configuration spaces, the first two methods can be used in limited situations, but the last method can be applied in all cases. Typically, the resulting higher dimensional non-dynamical trajectories are also identical to Bohm. \n \n \n \nTogether the three methods point to a new interpretation of Bohm's particle trajectories, namely, the Bohm trajectories are simply a kinematic portrayal of the evolution of the probability density. In addition, the new methods can be used to measure Schrödinger's wave function and Planck's constant.
How much time does a tunneling particle spend in a barrier? A Larmor clock, one proposal to answer this question, measures the interaction between the particle and the barrier region using an auxiliary degree of freedom of the particle to clock the dwell time inside the barrier. We report on precise Larmor time measurements of ultracold ^{87}Rb atoms tunneling through an optical barrier, which confirm longstanding predictions of tunneling times. We observe that atoms generally spend less time tunneling through higher barriers and that this time decreases for lower energy particles. For the lowest measured incident energy, at least 90% of transmitted atoms tunneled through the barrier, spending an average of 0.59±0.02 ms inside. This is 0.11±0.03 ms faster than atoms traversing the same barrier with energy close to the barrier's peak and 0.21±0.03 ms faster than when the atoms traverse a barrier with 23% less energy.
Abstract The Kinematics of Quantum Space: A Classical Proof of Orbital Stability and Trajectory Continuity (Part II) Building upon the dense, discrete, nonlocal medium defined in Part I (Quantum Space, density ratio ρ = 6.54×10¹²), we prove that the electron in a hydrogen atom follows a strictly deterministic, continuous, and classical trajectory. No probabilistic interpretation, wave function collapse, or irreducible uncertainty is required. 1. Orbital velocity – six independent derivations Starting from the Bohr radius (a₀ = 5.291772×10⁻¹¹ m) and the electron mass (mₑ = 9.109384×10⁻³¹ kg), we derive the ground state orbital velocity through six independent physical paths: Galilean kinematics (v = s/t) Bohr quantization condition (mₑ v a₀ = ħ) Fine‑structure constant (v = α c, α = 1/137.036) Kinetic energy (ionization energy 13.6 eV) Coulomb–centripetal force balance Direct experimental transit time (attosecond measurements) All six converge identically to: v=e22ϵ0h=αc≈2.188×106 m/sv=2ϵ0he2=αc≈2.188×106m/s The electron is a real satellite of the nucleus, not a probability cloud. 2. Orbital stability – zero radiation from destructive interference The classical objection (Larmor's formula predicts radiative collapse within ≈47 ps) assumes a point charge. For a standing wave charge distribution satisfying 2πr = nλ (Bohr condition), we compute the Liénard–Wiechert potentials and the far‑field Poynting vector explicitly: S=1μ0Erad×Brad=0,Ptotal=∮S⋅dA=0S=μ01Erad×Brad=0,Ptotal=∮S⋅dA=0 The ground state does not radiate. Energy is locked in the standing wave. Radiation occurs only during transitions (n→m), exactly as observed in atomic spectroscopy. 3. Quantum jump as a vertical ballistic throw – continuity proven The transition n=1 → n=2 (energy ΔE = 10.2 eV) is treated as a classical vertical throw in an effective constant acceleration field g_q: gq=FCoulomb(a0)me=kee2mea02≈9.043×1022 m/s2gq=meFCoulomb(a0)=mea02kee2≈9.043×1022m/s2 Jump height: h = r₂ - r₁ = 1.5875×10⁻¹⁰ mEffective initial velocity (constant‑g approximation): v₀ ≈ 5.36×10⁶ m/sTime of ascent: t_up = v₀/g_q ≈ 59 asTotal flight time: t_total = 118 as The position function y(t) = v₀ t - ½ g_q t² is continuous and differentiable (C¹ class). The illusion of an instantaneous "quantum jump" arises solely because t_total is shorter than the temporal resolution of most instruments (Δt_instr ≫ 118 as). The trajectory exists – we are simply not fast enough to see it. 4. Spin as toroidal vortex kinematics – no superluminal speed Spin (S_z = ±½ħ) is not a rigid sphere rotation. We model the electron as a toroidal charge distribution with major radius R. The no‑superluminal condition v = ωR < c yields a lower radius bound: Rmin=ℏ2mec≈1.93×10−13 mRmin=2mecℏ≈1.93×10−13m This is physically reasonable (≈300× smaller than the Bohr radius). Quantization to ±½ħ follows from resonance stability: only prograde (+) and retrograde (–) synchronous rotations are stable, analogous to the Moon (synchronous) and Venus (retrograde). 5. Measurement as ballistic collision – Heisenberg is technical, not fundamental A typical measurement photon (λ = 0.1 nm, E ≈ 12.4 keV) carries momentum: pphoton=hλ≈6.626×10−24 kg⋅m/spphoton=λh≈6.626×10−24kg⋅m/s The electron's orbital momentum is: pelectron=mev≈1.993×10−24 kg⋅m/spelectron=mev≈1.993×10−24kg⋅m/s Ratio: p_photon / p_electron ≈ 3.33. The photon delivers more momentum than the electron possesses in its orbit. Measurement is not passive observation – it is a ballistic collision (Compton scattering). The post‑collision electron momentum is fully determinable if both the energy and scattering angle of the outgoing photon are measured precisely. "Uncertainty" is a technical deficiency of incomplete measurement, not a law of nature. 6. Five falsifiable predictions Electron transit time across one Bohr diameter: 48.4 ± 5 as (testable with attosecond spectroscopy). n=1 → n=2 transition duration: 100–120 as (continuous, not instantaneous). Heisenberg product Δx·Δp → 0 as detector precision → ∞ (no fundamental lower bound). Bell inequality violations decrease as measurement impulse strength decreases (weak measurement regime). Residual "quantum randomness" equals unmodeled environmental force noise; full force accounting restores classical determinism. 7. Conclusion All calculations use only standard constants and classical equations (Newton, Maxwell, Coulomb, Compton). No new postulates are introduced. The electron's path exists, is continuous, and follows deterministic mechanics. Quantum mysticism – wave function collapse, irreducible uncertainty, non‑locality as magic – is replaced by scale‑inverted classical physics operating within the dense geometry of Quantum Space defined in Part I. Keywords: orbital stability, Larmor paradox, destructive interference, Poynting vector, quantum jump as ballistic throw, attosecond transit time, toroidal spin, Compton scattering measurement, Bell inequalities reinterpretation, classical determinism, falsifiable predictions, scale inversion. PACS: 03.65.Sq (Semiclassical theories), 03.65.Ta (Foundations), 31.15.xk (Classical treatments of atomic structure), 32.80.t (Atomic transitions), 42.50.Ct (Quantum optics, measurement).MSC: 81Q05 (Closed and approximate solutions), 70F05 (Two‑body problem, Kepler), 78A35 (Motion of charged particles), 83A05 (Special relativity).arXiv: quant-ph, physics.class-ph, physics.atom-ph.
A solution ψ to Schrödinger's equation needs some degree of regularity in order to allow the construction of a Bohmian mechanics from the integral curves of the velocity field ℏℑ(▽ψ/mψ). In the case of one specific non-differentiable weak solution Ψ we show how Bohmian trajectories can be obtained for Ψ from the trajectories of a sequence Ψn→Ψ. (For any real t the sequence $Ψ_{n}\left( t,\cdot \right) $ converges strongly.) The limiting trajectories no longer need to be differentiable. This suggests a way how Bohmian mechanics might work for arbitrary initial vectors Ψ in the Hilbert space on which the Schrödinger evolution acts.
This paper formulates the Schrödinger field path integral in Scretching–Planck (SP) density–phase variables, ψ=PeiS/ℏ. Substituting into the Schrödinger Lagrangian gives LSch=−LSP, so the real-time action weight in these variables is e−iSSP/ℏ. In the particle propagator, stationary phase recovers Hamilton’s principal function and the Van Vleck amplitude. The SP quantum potential is determined by the curvature of the propagator’s amplitude wherever that amplitude is regular and nonzero. In the time-sliced example, the error decreases quadratically with the time step. The SP Hamilton–Jacobi equation has an RMS residual of 1.6×10−4, compared with 1.365 when the quantum term is omitted. In imaginary time, the transfer matrix extracts the ground-state energy and density. The resulting density satisfies the stationary balance V+QSP[P0]=E0 in the benchmark calculations. For the double well, path-integral Monte Carlo gives E0=1.1458±0.0023, compared with the reference value 1.1439. A ground-state transformation converts the Euclidean evolution into a diffusion whose drift is the osmotic velocity u=(ℏ/2m)∂xlnP0. The simulated stationary density differs from P0 by 0.0033 in L1. For a ring threaded by magnetic flux, the SP circulation sum and the path-winding sum with Aharonov–Bohm phases agree to 2.5×10−16 in the numerical check. Eight solved problems are included.